Press "Enter" to skip to content

The Evolution of Our Stress Physiology | Zaneta Thayer | TEDxIndianapolis


[Applause]
Charlotte Heppell Meyer went into her
garage to check out her father when she
did she found that he was pinned
underneath the wheel of his truck
remarkably Charlotte was able to lift up
the truck prop it onto her hip and drag
her six-foot-three 280-pound father to
safety oh yeah did I mention the truck
was also on fire many of us are familiar
with stories such as these stories were
humans exhibit what seemed like
superhuman capacities in response to
extreme situations but of course what
Charlotte did wasn’t actually superhuman
at all and it wasn’t induced by anything
as fantastical as being bit by a
radioactive spider
instead Charlotte’s ability to save her
father was directly influenced by
activation of the stress response an
evolutionarily conserved system which
has evolved over great amounts of time
in order to allow organisms to respond
adaptively to stress exposure so when an
organism is exposed to stress such as
being chased down by a predator or
giving some sort of public talk stress
hormones are released and surged
throughout the body with a number of
different types of effects they allow us
to think more clearly enhances our
memory and blood travels quickly
throughout our body going to our muscles
in anticipation for their use but we
humans being the complicated creatures
that we are have found a way to actually
overburden this system so one of the
unique things about humans is that the
mere anticipation of stress is enough to
activate our stress hormone response so
what this means functionally is that all
the times that we stay up at night
thinking about that talk we need to give
our bills that we need to pay or how few
likes our most recent Facebook post got
all these things have the capacity to
activate the stress hormone response and
in doing so it can actually facilitate
the over activation of stress hormones
which in turn has really maladaptive
effects on our biology and so one of the
ways to visualize this is to think about
taking
game of operation and setting it atop a
pinball table so normally there might
just be one pinball going around in the
game but when we have too many stress
hormones surging throughout our body
it’s like having twenty pin balls and
they’re all surging around and running
amok with our innards leading to the
over stimulation of the different things
such as our arteries in our brain that
they’re meant to actually helpfully
stimulate so given the wide range of
effects of stress hormones in our body
it shouldn’t be surprising to know that
when we have too many stress hormones it
can lead to a broad range of health
effects everything from increasing risk
of developing anxiety depression
digestive problems heart disease sleep
problems weight gain and even memory and
concentration impairment so the first
point I want to leave with you all is
this and it is that chronic stress is
bad for your health but there’s more
stress can actually occur across the
life course and as it turns out when you
experience stress can actually have
really substantial impacts on how your
biology is affected so probably wouldn’t
surprise you to know that stress
experiences in adulthood and in
childhood impact adult health however we
now understand that stress experience is
an infancy and even prenatally that is
to say before you even born can actually
influence your adult health and as it
turns out these prenatal stress
exposures may have even greater impacts
on your health than those that occur
later so in my research I’ve been really
interested in trying to explore this
question of whether or how prenatal
stress experience may actually shape
offspring predisposition to developing
poor health and in order to do that I
went to Auckland New Zealand where I
recruited a group of socioeconomically
and ethnically diverse women to try to
understand how variation in maternal
stress experiences could relate to
maternal stress hormones and pregnancy
and offspring stress hormones after
birth so when you’re a stress researcher
something you realized pretty quickly is
that everyone experiences stress however
the types of stress that we experience
actually vary quite a bit so in order to
give you an example of how stress
experiences varied amongst my
participants I wanted to go ahead and
tell you three of their stories so one
day I start
in central Auckland in a relatively
affluent suburb interviewing the wife of
a pastor in terms of material situations
this woman was in a relatively well-off
position however her first birth had
actually been quite difficult and she
was worried about how this next birth
was going to go as a result she told me
she’d been youtubing caesarean section
videos and getting herself increasingly
worked up and worried about how her
birth experience was going to proceed
later that day I travel to South
Auckland where I interviewed a Samoan
immigrant this woman despite having to
earned a college degree in Samoa was
unable to work in New Zealand because
they wouldn’t recognize her degree there
so despite all the stress she felt
around not being able to work she said
that she wanted to remain in New Zealand
because she felt that her children would
have better educational opportunities
there than they went back in the islands
before going home that day I interviewed
a Tong and woman who told me that she
lived in a household of 24 and confess
then at mealtimes
the household size often swelled to 29
so again the point of sharing these
experiences is to highlight the fact
that stress experiences vary widely but
what’s interesting is that not all types
of stress experience impact physiology
in the same way so in my own study what
I found was that of all the different
types of stressors that women reported
those that were most strongly associated
with stress hormones or poverty and
racial discrimination and as it turned
out women who were poor and those who
experienced more racial discrimination
had significantly higher stress hormones
in pregnancy and gave birth to infants
who had significantly higher stress
hormones as well if we think about what
I talked about earlier about how higher
stress hormones are associated with the
development of poor health what these
findings suggest is that some
individuals may be predisposed to
developing poor health as early as birth
so the second point I want to leave you
with is this and it is that sensitivity
to stress begins prenatally in other
words the stress experienced by a mother
can actually have intergenerational
effects and interestingly there’s
actually an evolutionary basis for this
observation if we think about it
maternal environmental experience across
her life course shapes her biology and
pregnancy a maternal biology and
pregnancy in turn directly shapes
environment in which the babies growing
in developing and thus the babies result
of biology so we think about it maternal
biology and pregnancy acts as an
integrated signal linking maternal
environmental experience across her life
course with her children’s biology
what’s also interesting is that these
effects don’t appear to be limited to
humans and my favorite animal example
actually comes from the snowshoe hare so
for the snowshoe hare the most important
source of stress is in poverty but
instead predator density and what
scientists have found is that years
where there’s more predators
specifically Lynx’s hares who are
pregnant have higher stress hormones in
pregnancy and then give birth to
offspring who have higher stress
hormones after birth so again consistent
with these sorts of findings I talked
about before in New Zealand what’s more
if we actually take a step back and look
across different vertebrate species that
all share this common stress physiology
architecture so comparing humans
non-human mammals fish birds and
reptiles we see that there’s actual
general sensitivity of offspring to
prenatal stress across all these
different species where in organisms who
are exposed to stress prenatally tend to
have changes in their stress hormones
and altered behavior in response to the
stress experience and what this common
findings suggest is that this might have
actually been selected for an
evolutionary time that it might confer
some sort of adaptive benefit and that’s
why it’s shared across all these species
what I think is actually the most
illuminating comparison to make though
is to compare the types of stressors
that are studied in the human and
non-human animal literature so in the
nonhuman studies where their ecological
that is to say outside of the laboratory
the most common type of stressor that
studied is predation risk as I talked
about with the hair and in this case if
you’re exposed to a lot of predators
prenatally if you know that’s the type
of environment you’re going to be born
into it makes sense to have elevated
stress reactivity as it might allow you
to be more vigilant in the face of this
dangerous environment you’ll be living
in however if we look at the types of
stressors that that are studied in the
human studies things like poverty
discrimination 9/11 the Holocaust
these are stressors for which increased
stress reactivity doesn’t necessarily
increase
rival and so we’re left with is the
evolution of a stress physiology pathway
that evolved in the context of
qualitatively different stressors that’s
now being activated in response to these
very different types of exposures for
which elevated activity doesn’t
necessarily increase survival but
instead just increases our risk of
developing poor health so this leads me
to the final point I want to make for
you today in order to do that I need to
introduce one more concept and this
concept is what’s known as the social
gradient health and this is the
observation that both within and between
societies individuals who are socially
disadvantaged tend to have poor health
outcomes and shorter life expectancies
than individuals who are more socially
advantaged so this observation has been
made for many years and initially it was
thought that these differences might
reflect inherent genetic differences
between groups but if we think about
these results have been talking to you
about today the fact for example that
individuals who are born into poverty or
whose mothers experience racial
discrimination are more likely to have
higher stress hormones and those higher
stress hormones in turn predict the
development of chronic disease what the
suggests is that the social gradient
health may actually be shaped by this
differential exposure to stressors
across society so the final point I want
to leave you with is this and this is
that differential exposure to chronic
stress can shape patterns and of health
and disease in contemporary society
specifically the disproportionate
exposure to stressors among the most
socially disadvantaged individuals
within our society can shape the social
gradient health so now that I was
sufficiently depressed you all no one
said stress research is fun I do have
two practical points I want you to take
away from this the first is at an
individual level if we consider the
evolutionary context within which the
stress physiology system evolved it
suggests that when we get stressed we
get all this energy and therefore the
most productive thing we can do with
that energy is probably something like
exercise instead of perhaps assuming the
fetal position in binge watching Netflix
second has a societal level I think it’s
very important that we work to
understand the inter personal and
institutional pathways through which
differential exposure to stress occurs
and then we need to work to reduce the
exposure of stressors the most
vulnerable members of our society so
thank you very much for your time
you
Please follow and like us: