Press "Enter" to skip to content

The ethical dilemma we face on AI and autonomous tech | Christine Fox | TEDxMidAtlantic


[Music]
[Music] [Applause]
so I wanted to start today with that
so I wanted to start today with that video because I think it really captures
video because I think it really captures
video because I think it really captures the complexity surrounding technology
the complexity surrounding technology
the complexity surrounding technology today now I’ve looked at that video with
today now I’ve looked at that video with
today now I’ve looked at that video with a lot of colleagues and friends and I
a lot of colleagues and friends and I
a lot of colleagues and friends and I find that people’s reactions to that
find that people’s reactions to that
find that people’s reactions to that video follow along sort of three phases
video follow along sort of three phases
video follow along sort of three phases so let me describe them and you can ask
so let me describe them and you can ask
so let me describe them and you can ask if your reactions followed along these
if your reactions followed along these
if your reactions followed along these phases phase 1 Wow is that cool right I
phases phase 1 Wow is that cool right I
phases phase 1 Wow is that cool right I mean is that cool those guys are amazing
mean is that cool those guys are amazing
mean is that cool those guys are amazing then they start kicking it that’s kind
then they start kicking it that’s kind
then they start kicking it that’s kind of you know that’s kind of mean right I
of you know that’s kind of mean right I
of you know that’s kind of mean right I don’t know that they should be doing
don’t know that they should be doing
don’t know that they should be doing that I don’t think they should be
that I don’t think they should be
that I don’t think they should be allowed to kick them like that and then
allowed to kick them like that and then
allowed to kick them like that and then there’s phase 3 I kind of walking up the
there’s phase 3 I kind of walking up the
there’s phase 3 I kind of walking up the hill and looking around and that big guy
hill and looking around and that big guy
hill and looking around and that big guy starts going up the hill it’s kind of
starts going up the hill it’s kind of
starts going up the hill it’s kind of hmm
hmm
hmm you know they’re a little creepy
you know they’re a little creepy
you know they’re a little creepy I don’t know if I’d feel happy running
I don’t know if I’d feel happy running
I don’t know if I’d feel happy running into them walking in the woods you know
into them walking in the woods you know
into them walking in the woods you know what would they do I’m not sure we
what would they do I’m not sure we
what would they do I’m not sure we should be building those things I don’t
should be building those things I don’t
should be building those things I don’t think they should be allowed to build
think they should be allowed to build
think they should be allowed to build them so the question that I want to
them so the question that I want to
them so the question that I want to explore with you today is who decides
explore with you today is who decides
explore with you today is who decides should now I’ve spent a lifetime
should now I’ve spent a lifetime
should now I’ve spent a lifetime studying military operations as you
studying military operations as you
studying military operations as you heard I was even in the Defense
heard I was even in the Defense
heard I was even in the Defense Department for a while and I can tell
Department for a while and I can tell
Department for a while and I can tell you the answer to this question for
you the answer to this question for
you the answer to this question for military operations and Technology is
military operations and Technology is
military operations and Technology is very clear who decides should for
very clear who decides should for
very clear who decides should for military operations it’s the government
military operations it’s the government
military operations it’s the government its policy its Defense Department
its policy its Defense Department
its policy its Defense Department leadership one of the things we expect
leadership one of the things we expect
leadership one of the things we expect our military to be able to do is comply
our military to be able to do is comply
our military to be able to do is comply with something called the laws of armed
with something called the laws of armed
with something called the laws of armed conflict now the laws of armed conflicts
conflict now the laws of armed conflicts
conflict now the laws of armed conflicts say many important things but one of the
say many important things but one of the
say many important things but one of the things that says is that the military
things that says is that the military
things that says is that the military should do everything in its power to
should do everything in its power to
should do everything in its power to target combatants and protect civilians
target combatants and protect civilians
target combatants and protect civilians in conflict now I can tell you the
in conflict now I can tell you the
in conflict now I can tell you the military tries very very hard to do this
military tries very very hard to do this
military tries very very hard to do this I’ve studied operations for decades
I’ve studied operations for decades
I’ve studied operations for decades there are they perfect absolutely not do
there are they perfect absolutely not do
there are they perfect absolutely not do they make mistakes
they make mistakes
they make mistakes yes but they try very hard and they’ve
yes but they try very hard and they’ve
yes but they try very hard and they’ve gotten better and better and better at
gotten better and better and better at
gotten better and better and better at it as technology has improved one of the
it as technology has improved one of the
it as technology has improved one of the things that has improved our precision
things that has improved our precision
things that has improved our precision weapons precision weapons have made a
weapons precision weapons have made a
weapons precision weapons have made a big difference here in their ability to
big difference here in their ability to
big difference here in their ability to focus on combatants and protect
focus on combatants and protect
focus on combatants and protect civilians now more recently we’ve put
civilians now more recently we’ve put
civilians now more recently we’ve put precision weapons on something called
precision weapons on something called
precision weapons on something called remotely piloted vehicles drones now I
remotely piloted vehicles drones now I
remotely piloted vehicles drones now I know drones are controversial and I
know drones are controversial and I
know drones are controversial and I confess I’m not entirely sure I
confess I’m not entirely sure I
confess I’m not entirely sure I understand why they’re so controversial
understand why they’re so controversial
understand why they’re so controversial and I wonder if people have the
and I wonder if people have the
and I wonder if people have the perception or misperception that they’re
perception or misperception that they’re
perception or misperception that they’re actually autonomous they are remotely
actually autonomous they are remotely
actually autonomous they are remotely piloted the pilot is not in the aircraft
piloted the pilot is not in the aircraft
piloted the pilot is not in the aircraft but there is a pilot on the ground in a
but there is a pilot on the ground in a
but there is a pilot on the ground in a distant location but they have positive
distant location but they have positive
distant location but they have positive control of that aircraft from takeoff to
control of that aircraft from takeoff to
control of that aircraft from takeoff to landing and certainly for any employment
landing and certainly for any employment
landing and certainly for any employment of a weapon in fact today it is DoD
of a weapon in fact today it is DoD
of a weapon in fact today it is DoD policy that any employment of leaf
policy that any employment of leaf
policy that any employment of leaf capability have a human in the loop and
capability have a human in the loop and
capability have a human in the loop and when it comes to autonomous systems
when it comes to autonomous systems
when it comes to autonomous systems there’s a special directive governing
there’s a special directive governing
there’s a special directive governing autonomous systems that specifically
autonomous systems that specifically
autonomous systems that specifically says lethal autonomous capability is not
says lethal autonomous capability is not
says lethal autonomous capability is not allowed on the battlefield today and one
allowed on the battlefield today and one
allowed on the battlefield today and one of the reasons for that is a concern
of the reasons for that is a concern
of the reasons for that is a concern that lethal autonomous systems or
that lethal autonomous systems or
that lethal autonomous systems or technology is not able to discriminate
technology is not able to discriminate
technology is not able to discriminate between combatants and civilians and so
between combatants and civilians and so
between combatants and civilians and so therefore it would not be in compliance
therefore it would not be in compliance
therefore it would not be in compliance with the laws of armed conflict now let
with the laws of armed conflict now let
with the laws of armed conflict now let me tell you there are a lot of people
me tell you there are a lot of people
me tell you there are a lot of people who think that this policy is overly
who think that this policy is overly
who think that this policy is overly constraining I’ve heard a lot about it
constraining I’ve heard a lot about it
constraining I’ve heard a lot about it right it’s it’s holding us back it’s
right it’s it’s holding us back it’s
right it’s it’s holding us back it’s putting men and women in uniform in
putting men and women in uniform in
putting men and women in uniform in harm’s way needlessly our adversaries
harm’s way needlessly our adversaries
harm’s way needlessly our adversaries are going to get advanced ahead of us so
are going to get advanced ahead of us so
are going to get advanced ahead of us so it’s you know there’s a lot of pushback
it’s you know there’s a lot of pushback
it’s you know there’s a lot of pushback on this directive I’ve thought a lot
on this directive I’ve thought a lot
on this directive I’ve thought a lot about this directive I personally think
about this directive I personally think
about this directive I personally think it’s just right and I want to ask you to
it’s just right and I want to ask you to
it’s just right and I want to ask you to think along with me using the example of
think along with me using the example of
think along with me using the example of our friend spellchecker
our friend spellchecker
our friend spellchecker okay I don’t know about you but I often
okay I don’t know about you but I often
okay I don’t know about you but I often hit Send on a text just after I noticed
hit Send on a text just after I noticed
hit Send on a text just after I noticed that my helpful smartphone changed the
that my helpful smartphone changed the
that my helpful smartphone changed the spelling and the meaning of what I
spelling and the meaning of what I
spelling and the meaning of what I wanted to send I hope that happens to
wanted to send I hope that happens to
wanted to send I hope that happens to you and I’m not the only one right okay
you and I’m not the only one right okay
you and I’m not the only one right okay so let’s ask ourselves if technology
so let’s ask ourselves if technology
so let’s ask ourselves if technology today can’t understand the intent of a
today can’t understand the intent of a
today can’t understand the intent of a few simple lines of text how could we
few simple lines of text how could we
few simple lines of text how could we count on it to discriminate between a
count on it to discriminate between a
count on it to discriminate between a combatant and a civilian in environments
combatant and a civilian in environments
combatant and a civilian in environments so complex such as warfare so I
so complex such as warfare so I
so complex such as warfare so I personally think the policy has it right
personally think the policy has it right
personally think the policy has it right for now but the technology is evolving
for now but the technology is evolving
for now but the technology is evolving and I also think it will probably evolve
and I also think it will probably evolve
and I also think it will probably evolve to a point where it can discriminate and
to a point where it can discriminate and
to a point where it can discriminate and I am confident that the policy will
I am confident that the policy will
I am confident that the policy will evolve along with the technology and so
evolve along with the technology and so
evolve along with the technology and so I think this is a nice example of the
I think this is a nice example of the
I think this is a nice example of the relationship between technology and
relationship between technology and
relationship between technology and policy one involves the other revolves
policy one involves the other revolves
policy one involves the other revolves they stay together and that happens
they stay together and that happens
they stay together and that happens because technology that I’m talking
because technology that I’m talking
because technology that I’m talking about here is under the purview of the
about here is under the purview of the
about here is under the purview of the government now there was a time when
government now there was a time when
government now there was a time when advanced
advanced
advanced she was developed under the purview of
she was developed under the purview of
she was developed under the purview of the government in most cases that is not
the government in most cases that is not
the government in most cases that is not true today today advanced technology is
true today today advanced technology is
true today today advanced technology is developed in the commercial world far
developed in the commercial world far
developed in the commercial world far more than in government consider for a
more than in government consider for a
more than in government consider for a moment the fact that if you add up the
moment the fact that if you add up the
moment the fact that if you add up the research and development budgets of the
research and development budgets of the
research and development budgets of the top 5 defense contractors talking the
top 5 defense contractors talking the
top 5 defense contractors talking the big ones Lockheed Martin and Boeing etc
big ones Lockheed Martin and Boeing etc
big ones Lockheed Martin and Boeing etc the top 5 add them all up that comes to
the top 5 add them all up that comes to
the top 5 add them all up that comes to less than half of Microsoft’s research
less than half of Microsoft’s research
less than half of Microsoft’s research and development budget in the year less
and development budget in the year less
and development budget in the year less than half that doesn’t even begin to
than half that doesn’t even begin to
than half that doesn’t even begin to consider the R&D budgets of Apple and
consider the R&D budgets of Apple and
consider the R&D budgets of Apple and Google and so many others right so
Google and so many others right so
Google and so many others right so advanced technology is no longer the
advanced technology is no longer the
advanced technology is no longer the purview of the government it’s the
purview of the government it’s the
purview of the government it’s the purview of the commercial world and
purview of the commercial world and
purview of the commercial world and policy makers are not governing advanced
policy makers are not governing advanced
policy makers are not governing advanced technology in the commercial world I
technology in the commercial world I
technology in the commercial world I think that technology is amazing today
think that technology is amazing today
think that technology is amazing today and it is going so fast that
and it is going so fast that
and it is going so fast that policymakers have fallen behind and I
policymakers have fallen behind and I
policymakers have fallen behind and I personally am very dubious that they can
personally am very dubious that they can
personally am very dubious that they can catch up so where does that leave us I
catch up so where does that leave us I
catch up so where does that leave us I think it leaves us with a bit of a toxic
think it leaves us with a bit of a toxic
think it leaves us with a bit of a toxic brew where we have advanced powerful
brew where we have advanced powerful
brew where we have advanced powerful technologies that are available to
technologies that are available to
technologies that are available to anyone who wants to buy them with few if
anyone who wants to buy them with few if
anyone who wants to buy them with few if any constraints over their development
any constraints over their development
any constraints over their development and accessibility now technology is
and accessibility now technology is
and accessibility now technology is making our world better ok we do not
making our world better ok we do not
making our world better ok we do not want to regulate technology we want
want to regulate technology we want
want to regulate technology we want technology to continue going forward
technology to continue going forward
technology to continue going forward take for example this very simple but
take for example this very simple but
take for example this very simple but lovely application of technology today a
lovely application of technology today a
lovely application of technology today a non-profit foundation has developed this
non-profit foundation has developed this
non-profit foundation has developed this app it pairs people with CPR skills with
app it pairs people with CPR skills with
app it pairs people with CPR skills with people in need having acute cardiac
people in need having acute cardiac
people in need having acute cardiac arrest this simple application of
arrest this simple application of
arrest this simple application of technology is saving lives today
technology is saving lives today
technology is saving lives today awesome right that is awesome we don’t
awesome right that is awesome we don’t
awesome right that is awesome we don’t want to do anything to stop that but
want to do anything to stop that but
want to do anything to stop that but there are other applications of
there are other applications of
there are other applications of technology that we didn’t anticipate
technology that we didn’t anticipate
technology that we didn’t anticipate that aren’t making our world a better
that aren’t making our world a better
that aren’t making our world a better place
place
place and that we aren’t able to govern so I
and that we aren’t able to govern so I
and that we aren’t able to govern so I want to continue to explore this a
want to continue to explore this a
want to continue to explore this a little bit and I want to work through an
little bit and I want to work through an
little bit and I want to work through an example with you and I want to
example with you and I want to
example with you and I want to work through the example of the internet
work through the example of the internet
work through the example of the internet so I remember when the internet was
so I remember when the internet was
so I remember when the internet was first conceived of and introduced right
first conceived of and introduced right
first conceived of and introduced right was developed by DARPA the Defense
was developed by DARPA the Defense
was developed by DARPA the Defense Department but rapidly went out into the
Department but rapidly went out into the
Department but rapidly went out into the public and the promise was this amazing
public and the promise was this amazing
public and the promise was this amazing notion I still remember how I felt about
notion I still remember how I felt about
notion I still remember how I felt about it at the time that we would be able to
it at the time that we would be able to
it at the time that we would be able to instantly communicate with people all
instantly communicate with people all
instantly communicate with people all over the world and any information you
over the world and any information you
over the world and any information you wanted would be at your fingertips
wanted would be at your fingertips
wanted would be at your fingertips coming right up on your computer really
coming right up on your computer really
coming right up on your computer really really wow that’s amazing look what’s
really wow that’s amazing look what’s
really wow that’s amazing look what’s happened that promise has been realized
happened that promise has been realized
happened that promise has been realized it’s amazing right
it’s amazing right
it’s amazing right I think the promise of the Internet has
I think the promise of the Internet has
I think the promise of the Internet has really changed our lives forever there’s
really changed our lives forever there’s
really changed our lives forever there’s no going back I don’t know about you but
no going back I don’t know about you but
no going back I don’t know about you but I’m really cranky when my Wi-Fi is down
I’m really cranky when my Wi-Fi is down
I’m really cranky when my Wi-Fi is down for just a little bit right we expect it
for just a little bit right we expect it
for just a little bit right we expect it now it’s part of life but when the
now it’s part of life but when the
now it’s part of life but when the internet was first introduced I don’t
internet was first introduced I don’t
internet was first introduced I don’t think we really envisioned this future
think we really envisioned this future
think we really envisioned this future world of cyber or cyber warfare or the
world of cyber or cyber warfare or the
world of cyber or cyber warfare or the fact that the Defense Department would
fact that the Defense Department would
fact that the Defense Department would one day need a cyber command whose whole
one day need a cyber command whose whole
one day need a cyber command whose whole mission is to operate in cyberspace and
mission is to operate in cyberspace and
mission is to operate in cyberspace and defend it and defend our networks so
defend it and defend our networks so
defend it and defend our networks so that’s an unanticipated consequence of
that’s an unanticipated consequence of
that’s an unanticipated consequence of the internet the internet has introduced
the internet the internet has introduced
the internet the internet has introduced a whole set of vulnerabilities and those
a whole set of vulnerabilities and those
a whole set of vulnerabilities and those vulnerabilities are also impacting our
vulnerabilities are also impacting our
vulnerabilities are also impacting our lives take for example this um this
lives take for example this um this
lives take for example this um this group of people that worked at Sony so
group of people that worked at Sony so
group of people that worked at Sony so you’re at Sony you come to work you turn
you’re at Sony you come to work you turn
you’re at Sony you come to work you turn on your computer you expect your
on your computer you expect your
on your computer you expect your calendar and your email to come up and
calendar and your email to come up and
calendar and your email to come up and instead this is what you see that
instead this is what you see that
instead this is what you see that happened to every employee in Sony and
happened to every employee in Sony and
happened to every employee in Sony and November two years ago that was
November two years ago that was
November two years ago that was happening right before Sony was due to
happening right before Sony was due to
happening right before Sony was due to release a parody a movie about the North
release a parody a movie about the North
release a parody a movie about the North Korean leader Kim Jong on it was a
Korean leader Kim Jong on it was a
Korean leader Kim Jong on it was a terrible movie okay terrible was it was
terrible movie okay terrible was it was
terrible movie okay terrible was it was their biggest concerns at Sony before
their biggest concerns at Sony before
their biggest concerns at Sony before this happened was how big a flop it was
this happened was how big a flop it was
this happened was how big a flop it was going to be okay but North Korea didn’t
going to be okay but North Korea didn’t
going to be okay but North Korea didn’t think it was so funny they didn’t work
think it was so funny they didn’t work
think it was so funny they didn’t work they didn’t understand that it might be
they didn’t understand that it might be
they didn’t understand that it might be a flop they didn’t care and this is what
a flop they didn’t care and this is what
a flop they didn’t care and this is what happened to Sony they were hacked
happened to Sony they were hacked
happened to Sony they were hacked information was stolen embarrassing
information was stolen embarrassing
information was stolen embarrassing information and they got this threat and
information and they got this threat and
information and they got this threat and multiple threats for the next several
multiple threats for the next several
multiple threats for the next several weeks and it had a very devastating
weeks and it had a very devastating
weeks and it had a very devastating effect on Sony and the people who work
effect on Sony and the people who work
effect on Sony and the people who work there or perhaps consider that you’re
there or perhaps consider that you’re
there or perhaps consider that you’re one of the twenty one point nine million
one of the twenty one point nine million
one of the twenty one point nine million people I bet some of you here are I
people I bet some of you here are I
people I bet some of you here are I certainly a.m. who had their personal
certainly a.m. who had their personal
certainly a.m. who had their personal identifying information stolen out of
identifying information stolen out of
identifying information stolen out of the Office of Personnel management’s
the Office of Personnel management’s
the Office of Personnel management’s database okay stolen by a hacker they
database okay stolen by a hacker they
database okay stolen by a hacker they think in China well what’s that hacker
think in China well what’s that hacker
think in China well what’s that hacker going to do with my data I don’t know
going to do with my data I don’t know
going to do with my data I don’t know you know it’s unnerving it’s really
you know it’s unnerving it’s really
you know it’s unnerving it’s really unnerving and then take a much more
unnerving and then take a much more
unnerving and then take a much more recent example where we have a nation
recent example where we have a nation
recent example where we have a nation hacking into our political process the
hacking into our political process the
hacking into our political process the very foundation of our government a very
very foundation of our government a very
very foundation of our government a very big deal indeed so that’s where we’ve
big deal indeed so that’s where we’ve
big deal indeed so that’s where we’ve been that’s the story of the internet
been that’s the story of the internet
been that’s the story of the internet great promise all achieved even more so
great promise all achieved even more so
great promise all achieved even more so but also simultaneously introduced some
but also simultaneously introduced some
but also simultaneously introduced some vulnerabilities that we hadn’t
vulnerabilities that we hadn’t
vulnerabilities that we hadn’t envisioned hadn’t counted on and hadn’t
envisioned hadn’t counted on and hadn’t
envisioned hadn’t counted on and hadn’t prepared for all right so let’s stop and
prepared for all right so let’s stop and
prepared for all right so let’s stop and ask ourselves going forward what’s next
ask ourselves going forward what’s next
ask ourselves going forward what’s next where are we now and what do we see
where are we now and what do we see
where are we now and what do we see going forward where maybe we can
going forward where maybe we can
going forward where maybe we can anticipate a little better do a little
anticipate a little better do a little
anticipate a little better do a little bit better job so I want to talk a
bit better job so I want to talk a
bit better job so I want to talk a little bit about the Internet of Things
little bit about the Internet of Things
little bit about the Internet of Things now the Internet of Things it’s already
now the Internet of Things it’s already
now the Internet of Things it’s already here in some ways right you can already
here in some ways right you can already
here in some ways right you can already turn the lights on in your home before
turn the lights on in your home before
turn the lights on in your home before you get there so it’s nice and friendly
you get there so it’s nice and friendly
you get there so it’s nice and friendly when you arrive turn the heat up so it’s
when you arrive turn the heat up so it’s
when you arrive turn the heat up so it’s warm and toasty get your coffee done in
warm and toasty get your coffee done in
warm and toasty get your coffee done in the morning from just to click on your
the morning from just to click on your
the morning from just to click on your smartphone wonderful things all aimed at
smartphone wonderful things all aimed at
smartphone wonderful things all aimed at making our lives easier making our lives
making our lives easier making our lives
making our lives easier making our lives better Internet of Things manufacturers
better Internet of Things manufacturers
better Internet of Things manufacturers now are preparing to include something
now are preparing to include something
now are preparing to include something like this little guy into our homes this
like this little guy into our homes this
like this little guy into our homes this little guy is going to be your friendly
little guy is going to be your friendly
little guy is going to be your friendly household servant he’s going to help
household servant he’s going to help
household servant he’s going to help wake you up in the morning he’s going to
wake you up in the morning he’s going to
wake you up in the morning he’s going to get the kids ready for school he’s going
get the kids ready for school he’s going
get the kids ready for school he’s going to get breakfast ready he’s going to
to get breakfast ready he’s going to
to get breakfast ready he’s going to have your favorite news program on your
have your favorite news program on your
have your favorite news program on your radio who wouldn’t want him I’m guy I
radio who wouldn’t want him I’m guy I
radio who wouldn’t want him I’m guy I want him right my life is hard I really
want him right my life is hard I really
want him right my life is hard I really would love to have some help right I
would love to have some help right I
would love to have some help right I think we all feel the press of time
think we all feel the press of time
think we all feel the press of time today
today
today and we this is a very appealing concept
and we this is a very appealing concept
and we this is a very appealing concept it would make our lives better
it would make our lives better
it would make our lives better or would it who decides the cyber
or would it who decides the cyber
or would it who decides the cyber protection in our friend the robot who
protection in our friend the robot who
protection in our friend the robot who decides if you’re sitting out there
decides if you’re sitting out there
decides if you’re sitting out there thinking that there’s some government
thinking that there’s some government
thinking that there’s some government policy want somewhere that’s going to
policy want somewhere that’s going to
policy want somewhere that’s going to make this guy safe I’m afraid that
make this guy safe I’m afraid that
make this guy safe I’m afraid that you’re wrong there is no policy
you’re wrong there is no policy
you’re wrong there is no policy governing it there is no sense of what’s
governing it there is no sense of what’s
governing it there is no sense of what’s the appropriate cyber protection to have
the appropriate cyber protection to have
the appropriate cyber protection to have in this robot before it goes to market
in this robot before it goes to market
in this robot before it goes to market there’s nobody deciding when it’s ready
there’s nobody deciding when it’s ready
there’s nobody deciding when it’s ready to go to market this robot is going to
to go to market this robot is going to
to go to market this robot is going to come to market and we’re going to aside
come to market and we’re going to aside
come to market and we’re going to aside to buy it and so who decides we do and
to buy it and so who decides we do and
to buy it and so who decides we do and the company that builds it okay so I am
the company that builds it okay so I am
the company that builds it okay so I am concerned about this and I wish I had an
concerned about this and I wish I had an
concerned about this and I wish I had an answer because I really don’t think that
answer because I really don’t think that
answer because I really don’t think that policy makers are going to be able to
policy makers are going to be able to
policy makers are going to be able to keep up with this explosion of
keep up with this explosion of
keep up with this explosion of technology and you know this has been
technology and you know this has been
technology and you know this has been the study of academics for a long time
the study of academics for a long time
the study of academics for a long time morality affects legality of technical
morality affects legality of technical
morality affects legality of technical new technologies and the introduction of
new technologies and the introduction of
new technologies and the introduction of technology and I want to suggest to you
technology and I want to suggest to you
technology and I want to suggest to you today that the time for study is over
today that the time for study is over
today that the time for study is over these things are here today this
these things are here today this
these things are here today this technology is exploding today now you
technology is exploding today now you
technology is exploding today now you may think that that robot is way far off
may think that that robot is way far off
may think that that robot is way far off and we have a lot of time to get it
and we have a lot of time to get it
and we have a lot of time to get it right but the manufacturers are
right but the manufacturers are
right but the manufacturers are predicting that they’ll be ready for
predicting that they’ll be ready for
predicting that they’ll be ready for market in less than two years now you
market in less than two years now you
market in less than two years now you may be skeptical I can tell you I’m
may be skeptical I can tell you I’m
may be skeptical I can tell you I’m skeptical but I’m a terrible predictor
skeptical but I’m a terrible predictor
skeptical but I’m a terrible predictor of these things two years ago I said no
of these things two years ago I said no
of these things two years ago I said no way are we going to have autonomous cars
way are we going to have autonomous cars
way are we going to have autonomous cars on the road in any near time right
on the road in any near time right
on the road in any near time right there’s going to take a long time well
there’s going to take a long time well
there’s going to take a long time well if you’re driving on the Beltway today
if you’re driving on the Beltway today
if you’re driving on the Beltway today there’s a very good chance that there’s
there’s a very good chance that there’s
there’s a very good chance that there’s an autonomous vehicle driving somewhere
an autonomous vehicle driving somewhere
an autonomous vehicle driving somewhere in your midst right now today so you
in your midst right now today so you
in your midst right now today so you know autonomous cars is another really
know autonomous cars is another really
know autonomous cars is another really interesting thing right because
interesting thing right because
interesting thing right because autonomous cars are also going to have
autonomous cars are also going to have
autonomous cars are also going to have to make some difficult choices what if a
to make some difficult choices what if a
to make some difficult choices what if a car autonomous car gets into a situation
car autonomous car gets into a situation
car autonomous car gets into a situation where it has to
where it has to
where it has to Jews whether to protect the occupants of
Jews whether to protect the occupants of
Jews whether to protect the occupants of the car or the people outside the car
the car or the people outside the car
the car or the people outside the car does the car drive into the pedestrians
does the car drive into the pedestrians
does the car drive into the pedestrians or the brick wall it seems to me that’s
or the brick wall it seems to me that’s
or the brick wall it seems to me that’s a little bit like trying to choose
a little bit like trying to choose
a little bit like trying to choose between a combatant and a civilian yet
between a combatant and a civilian yet
between a combatant and a civilian yet the cars are on the road now and what
the cars are on the road now and what
the cars are on the road now and what about their hack ability if you don’t
about their hack ability if you don’t
about their hack ability if you don’t think you can hack these cars I
think you can hack these cars I
think you can hack these cars I encourage you to Google Jeep hack many
encourage you to Google Jeep hack many
encourage you to Google Jeep hack many of you have I can hear that you know
of you have I can hear that you know
of you have I can hear that you know it’s and that’s not even an autonomous
it’s and that’s not even an autonomous
it’s and that’s not even an autonomous car right she’s just driving down the
car right she’s just driving down the
car right she’s just driving down the road as radio goes craziest air
road as radio goes craziest air
road as radio goes craziest air conditioning goes crazy but his
conditioning goes crazy but his
conditioning goes crazy but his transmission is cut and he coasts to a
transmission is cut and he coasts to a
transmission is cut and he coasts to a stop in the midst of traffic a very
stop in the midst of traffic a very
stop in the midst of traffic a very dangerous situation
dangerous situation
dangerous situation so so these things are with us now and I
so so these things are with us now and I
so so these things are with us now and I think there’s a sense of urgency we have
think there’s a sense of urgency we have
think there’s a sense of urgency we have to start really grappling with this
to start really grappling with this
to start really grappling with this problem and I don’t think policymakers
problem and I don’t think policymakers
problem and I don’t think policymakers are going to solve it so I think that
are going to solve it so I think that
are going to solve it so I think that maybe it calls for some new form of
maybe it calls for some new form of
maybe it calls for some new form of corporate social responsibility I think
corporate social responsibility I think
corporate social responsibility I think companies need to take this on it’s a
companies need to take this on it’s a
companies need to take this on it’s a little different version of it but it
little different version of it but it
little different version of it but it you could see how it might apply where
you could see how it might apply where
you could see how it might apply where companies think about the
companies think about the
companies think about the vulnerabilities of their technology as
vulnerabilities of their technology as
vulnerabilities of their technology as well as the promise and the coolness of
well as the promise and the coolness of
well as the promise and the coolness of it and perhaps we could get companies to
it and perhaps we could get companies to
it and perhaps we could get companies to adopt something we do in the Defense
adopt something we do in the Defense
adopt something we do in the Defense Department called red teaming when the
Department called red teaming when the
Department called red teaming when the Defense Department comes up with new
Defense Department comes up with new
Defense Department comes up with new plans or new technologies that we want
plans or new technologies that we want
plans or new technologies that we want to introduce we bring people in who are
to introduce we bring people in who are
to introduce we bring people in who are very imaginative and expert on on what
very imaginative and expert on on what
very imaginative and expert on on what adversaries might do and we say okay
adversaries might do and we say okay
adversaries might do and we say okay have at it
have at it
have at it give us your all use your imaginations
give us your all use your imaginations
give us your all use your imaginations take our plans apart tell us how this
take our plans apart tell us how this
take our plans apart tell us how this technology can be turned against us and
technology can be turned against us and
technology can be turned against us and they do that and that gives us a chance
they do that and that gives us a chance
they do that and that gives us a chance to fix our plans and to change the way
to fix our plans and to change the way
to fix our plans and to change the way we use the technology so we have a much
we use the technology so we have a much
we use the technology so we have a much better chance of success when we need to
better chance of success when we need to
better chance of success when we need to use these things
use these things
use these things perhaps we could Red Team new
perhaps we could Red Team new
perhaps we could Red Team new technologies before they go on the
technologies before they go on the
technologies before they go on the street we could get somebody to use
street we could get somebody to use
street we could get somebody to use their imagination to ask how that robot
their imagination to ask how that robot
their imagination to ask how that robot might end up being used against us
might end up being used against us
might end up being used against us instead of helpfully helping us make our
instead of helpfully helping us make our
instead of helpfully helping us make our lives better now in order for a new form
lives better now in order for a new form
lives better now in order for a new form of corporate social responsibility to
of corporate social responsibility to
of corporate social responsibility to work there has to be a reward system
work there has to be a reward system
work there has to be a reward system right
right
right so they have to invest in more
so they have to invest in more
so they have to invest in more protection it’s going to take a more
protection it’s going to take a more
protection it’s going to take a more time cost a little more money so the
time cost a little more money so the
time cost a little more money so the reward is that you preferentially buy
reward is that you preferentially buy
reward is that you preferentially buy the products that come with security
the products that come with security
the products that come with security that means consumers need to be educated
that means consumers need to be educated
that means consumers need to be educated and they need to ask the hard questions
and they need to ask the hard questions
and they need to ask the hard questions before they just buy the device and so
before they just buy the device and so
before they just buy the device and so that means the answer to who decides
that means the answer to who decides
that means the answer to who decides should is us I really think all of us we
should is us I really think all of us we
should is us I really think all of us we have to decide should corporations need
have to decide should corporations need
have to decide should corporations need to decide should and consumers need to
to decide should and consumers need to
to decide should and consumers need to decide should now listen I don’t want to
decide should now listen I don’t want to
decide should now listen I don’t want to be debbie downer I love technology okay
be debbie downer I love technology okay
be debbie downer I love technology okay I work at the Applied Physics lab I am
I work at the Applied Physics lab I am
I work at the Applied Physics lab I am surrounded by cool technology every day
surrounded by cool technology every day
surrounded by cool technology every day and I love to buy it okay but I want a
and I love to buy it okay but I want a
and I love to buy it okay but I want a world where the technology is taking us
world where the technology is taking us
world where the technology is taking us to that great place that makes our lives
to that great place that makes our lives
to that great place that makes our lives better and I want to avoid a world where
better and I want to avoid a world where
better and I want to avoid a world where we’re surprised by unintended events and
we’re surprised by unintended events and
we’re surprised by unintended events and vulnerabilities that we just didn’t take
vulnerabilities that we just didn’t take
vulnerabilities that we just didn’t take a moment to anticipate but I’m confident
a moment to anticipate but I’m confident
a moment to anticipate but I’m confident that if we all pull together and we
that if we all pull together and we
that if we all pull together and we start asking the hard questions we can
start asking the hard questions we can
start asking the hard questions we can drive our world in that good direction
drive our world in that good direction
drive our world in that good direction not just for us today but for
not just for us today but for
not just for us today but for generations to come thank
Please follow and like us: