Press "Enter" to skip to content

The (Emerging) Science of Learning Organizations | Benjamin Riley | TEDxWilmingtonED


the first principle is do not fool
yourself
the problem is you are the easiest
person to fool that’s not an original
quote I stole that from the scientist
Richard Fineman and he was talking about
science itself and in a way I think it
frames nicely the story I’m going to
tell you because it involves a fool it
involves an awful lot of science and at
the conclusion I’ll offer hypothesis
that I hope we can test together so
let’s start with the fool you’re looking
at him I come from a family of public
educators and I’ve been advocating in
education for the last decade and when I
started that work I held an awful lot of
ideas about how I thought education
ought to take place and how I thought
students ought to learn you may have
heard some of these ideas in fact some
of them are still popular today they’re
ideas like the student should be in
charge of their own learning ideas like
we should match the style of delivery of
instruction to the preferred learning
style of the student I advocated for
these ideas because I believe then that
they sounded right and good even now
they do to me but interestingly enough
and the work that I did and the work
that I do I’ve had the opportunity to
see how they play out in practice it was
a day where I went to visit a school in
Washington DC where the students came in
every morning stared at a screen that
gave them their playlist of what they
were supposed to do that day hopefully
most of you are old enough to remember
iPods and playlists and they looked at
that screen and they were told Yasmine
you’re supposed to go read Joaquin
you’re supposed to go listen to this
online and what I watched that day
horrified me because most of them
weren’t learning and when I went over
and talked to the teacher and said well
what are you gonna do about this she
said there’s nothing I can do I can’t
give them feedback because I’m not in
charge anymore the people who design
that have all the best intentions of the
world
I know that because I’ve worked with
them the problem is is that the ideas
that they have are fooling themselves
into thinking that learnings taking
place at the same time that I was
witnessing this in person I just
happened to start reading a book written
by a teacher in the United Kingdom her
name is Daisy Christodoulou
and in that book Daisy describes how as
a teacher she was frustrated discover
long into her career that there was a
body of knowledge that would help her
understand how to teach and specifically
how students learn I’m gonna call it the
science of learning the technical term
for it is cognitive science the study of
how our minds work and she expressed
this deep frustration that no one had
ever bothered to tell her this when she
was being prepared to become a teacher
and I literally remember sitting on my
couch reading that and going we have got
so many challenges in our education
system but that we can address that’s
what led me to work with a number of
leaders around the United States of
America who want to improve the way we
prepare teachers the organization is
called Dean’s for impact the name is
really deceptive we work with Dean’s
schools of Education who want to have
impacts and it want to have impact in
the way that they prepare teachers once
they go in the classroom the very first
thing we did as an organization was to
put out a short publication we tried
again to make the title really deceptive
the science of learning it’s just six
pages long six questions about how
students learn about how they understand
new ideas about how they transfer their
ideas in new situations and importantly
we wrote this with a cognitive scientist
and a teacher working together so that
there would be actual practical
applications for educators I have to
tell you that this continues to be one
of the biggest drivers of interest in
the work that we do at Dean’s for impact
and it’s not just domestically it’s all
over the globe but in our work we were
very interested in trying to figure out
what would it take to spread these ideas
into the schools of Education that
prepare our future teachers
now one model of looking at that would
be just give them a course but
interestingly enough one of the powers
of cognitive science is that it says
just making people listen to things is
not necessarily the most effective way
to lead to learning
anybody who’s taught is nodding along so
we set out on a project at Dean’s for
impacts to see if we could get these
ideas understood and spread and we went
to look at 18 different programs that
prepare teachers in the United States
and in the course of doing that we saw
something interesting we found in many
cases that there were teachers who were
going into the classroom unprepared and
they would admit as much but in a few
instances we found programs that were
preparing teachers who seemed to be
lightyears ahead in their professional
confidence in their understanding of
what it was going to take once they
stepped into the classroom they were
professionals and when we looked at what
those programs were doing we were
surprised and in some ways gratified to
find that the individual principles that
apply in cognitive science to how
individuals learn seem to apply at the
organizational level of how you prepare
a future teacher we’ve synthesized those
findings in a publication called zand
it’s a little bit more unwieldy the
building blocks of effective educator
preparation and there are four of them
modeling feedback practice and alignment
I don’t have time to go in depth with
all of them but I’m going to go through
quickly a couple of the core components
we talked about modeling in the context
of preparing a future teacher we’re
saying that we want them to see an
excellent master mentor teacher modeling
the sort of pedagogy that we want to see
in the classroom but it’s not enough
just to give them the opportunity to see
it you have to be intentional and create
opportunities for those novice teachers
to have the opportunity to ask the
expert why did you do that what was
behind your decision-making when you
made that instructional move in your
classroom practice when we talk about
practice in the concept in the context
of preparing a future teacher all too
often we saw the idea that
take some coursework take some
coursework off you go into the classroom
and good luck the student teaching
experience was not designed
intentionally
in contrast the programs that were
preparing effective educators were
incredibly thoughtful about creating
opportunities to practice specific
skills with the opportunity to get
guidance from those master mentor
teachers about what they wanted to do
practice means actually getting
opportunities in no stakes situations
before you’re turned over to a classroom
which can be terrifying the programs
that integrate practice into every step
of the preparation of Future teacher’s
have teacher candidates who are getting
ready to go into their career who are
far more confident and ready than those
who just gave them a few weeks of
student teaching at the end of the
course of their experience feedback
feedback is vitally important to
learning but not all feedback is
equivalent when we were visiting
programs that prepare teachers in the
United States we saw a lot of feedback
that fell in the category of good job or
try harder that sort of feedback is not
actionable it doesn’t tell a future
teacher what it is they need to work on
and maybe most importantly it doesn’t
give them the opportunity to practice
and go back and do it again good
feedback has to be specific it has to be
task focused and there has to be an
opportunity to learn from the feedback
you’ve been provided this brings me to
the fourth and final building block and
it’s the most complicated one alignment
in the United States of America today we
have a tragedy going on and that tragedy
is that the preparation of future
teachers is not aligned between what’s
happening in the schools of Education
and in the elementary and secondary
schools where the practice based
teaching education is taking place over
and over again we would see a teacher
candidate a future teacher being told
one thing by their faculty in a school
of education and something completely
different by the teacher in the
classroom that they were doing their
student teaching in that’s almost worse
than getting no feedback at all because
you’re asking a novice to lead their own
learning and just like those students in
that classroom I saw that day in
Washington DC it is confusing if you are
getting conflicting feedback the good
news is is that in more than a handful
of programs there is intentionality and
thought about how to align what it is
that programs and schools are expecting
teachers to be able to do by the time
they go in the classroom the same way we
have those same expectations for medical
professionals we need to have those same
expectations for teaching professionals
and there are examples out there where
it’s happening and they are inspiring
they are exciting and we need to spread
them so how do we do that well if you’ll
forgive the self-serving nature of this
the science of learning document that I
mentioned is available in the dean’s for
impact website so too is the building
blocks of effective educator preparation
which will show you some of the examples
that I’m talking about in action where
it’s taking place but here’s my
hypothesis and it’s just a hypothesis
the principles of learning that take
place for individuals the principles of
learning that take place for future
educators they apply to all of us in the
context in which we live and work so my
charge to you today if you’re interested
is to think about what sort of behaviors
do you model in your personal and
professional experiences what sort of
intentionality do you have in the
feedback that you provide those who you
may be mentoring or caring about what
opportunities do you have for your kids
for your students for people you care
about to practice before they give
something in a high-stakes situation and
most of all how do you think about
aligning the goals that you have across
all of the activities in whatever you
may be participating in with your family
with wherever you work with those that
you care about
that’s the untested hypothesis of
learning science
I hope you’ll think about testing it
with me thank you
[Applause]
you
Please follow and like us: