
I would like to tell you a story and
like all good stories
it has heroes and villains treachery and
deceit good and evil towering Giants and
underdogs who are overwhelmed by
circumstances and maybe just maybe
there’s a little bit of hope and the
story I would like to tell you is the
death of the high street nothing like
being overdramatic my version of the
story is different from yours our all of
our visions of the story of different
mine begins in newcastle upon tyne where
i was born a little place called heatin
was an area of the city and right in
newcastle let’s get this straight
you don’t call your mother mother you
don’t call her mom you don’t call her
mom you call her mum just like the Queen
rhymes with ham ma’am and me mom would
take me shopping to our local high
stream best in the pram in the pushchair
and then holding hands and off we’d go
to our local high street
this is chilling him rude now my wife is
very fond of seeing that when I was born
back in 1832
[Laughter]
I’m not that old and this is a little
bit before my time but this is
Chillingham Road and it’s been a high
street for decades and this is it in 70s
this is what it was like when I was a
kid and it seemed to stretch on almost
endlessly full of tiny little shops
Baker’s greengrocers manas the butcher
for some reason I remember the names
even had sawdust on the floor a proper
old-fashioned butchers but there were
dozens of shops and we go from place to
place and get our groceries and at the
end if I was lucky and if I’d been
really good and not complained while
we’d gone through all the shops and
crawled up and down and by the way hats
like that were really popular at the
time
if I’d been really good I would get
taken for sweets at the end to an almost
mythical place called cloths this is
close
paint its sky blue on the outside and
sky blue on the inside with shelves
groaning with rainbow colored jars as
far as you could see off and cloths was
manned by mr. and mrs. cook but mr. and
mr. cook I never saw it was always mrs.
cough that is not me
but that’s all mrs. cook with her
stepladder because even to me is a four
or five year old boy she seemed like an
incredibly tiny old woman so whatever
you asked for she had to get a
stepladder out and if I was lucky I
would get a quarter of sweets and if IB
was being clever I would ask for
actually two two ounce bags some sweet
peanuts and some midget gems and then
we’d walk home and I’d eat them and I’d
sought the midget gems and the colors
because you know if you eat a black one
and this side you mouth you’ve got to
chew a black on that side that’s normal
right and off I’d go and it was a place
of almost unparalleled joy and we’ve all
got the memories of shopping trips like
that and that’s how the story always
starts there was a time when the high
street was full of tiny little shops and
then something came and killed it this
is the same street this is the fine fair
supermarket laughably small by the
standards of a supermarket today but the
damage is already done if you look at
that’s a brand new building back in the
70s a whole row of shops has been
demolished to accommodate a supermarkets
arrived in the 50s at first of all they
pushed out the grocer’s so the little
shops had sold
tins and dried goods they went first
because they couldn’t compete because
the supermarket’s model is simple and to
give them credit brilliant you buy in
bulk you stack it high and you sell it
cheaper and local independent grocers
cannot compete and they’re the first
ones to go but the supermarket’s
aren’t satisfied with just the grossest
the supermarket’s want to sell fresh
fruit and fresh vegetables so then the
green grocers gone and the supermarket’s
want to package meat and they do a deal
with the farms and the forced prices
down amongst the farmers and they sell
you packaged meat and then the butchers
and the supermarkets grow to dominance
with their simple model stack it high
sell it cheap people come in it’s
convenient they don’t have to wonder the
high street it’s one place we’ll have a
big but I’m a big car park people have
just come to us and people do and it’s
not just the supermarket’s the small
electrical retailers are forced out
because the same model is adopted by big
chains we will buy from the factory well
stick it in a box will ship it anywhere
we want in the country and we’ll sell it
and we’ll sell it cheaper than this
small electrical shops can and we’ll do
it in bulk and it’s not just electrical
shops it’s small independent clause
retailers is wrong and they go and
suddenly would get this idea that the
high street is the same kind of twenty
shops in every street in the country
everywhere everywhere has a double you
dismiss everywhere has a Marks and
Spencers and they’re all becoming the
same and the little independents are
forced out and then the big recession of
the eighties arrives and the traditional
industries get decimated and suddenly
there’s huge tracts of desolate land on
the other sides of cities nobody wants
it it’s dead cheaper hang on we don’t
just need to have expensive supermarkets
in the middle of towns now we can build
hypermarkets we can have vast warehouses
that will sell everything you could ever
possibly want electricals Klaus food
everything and the supermarkets move out
of town and not just the supermarket’s
the electrical chains and everybody else
follows we have huge out-of-town
developments and so the high street is
quietly kill the little independents
have gone and were left with raw after
raw of empty shop and we’re terrified
that our city centres will be these
and then the web comes and it’s not just
the little independent retailers brought
under anymore now it’s the big chains
the web you see what that thing for
geeks that has porn on it says the
chairman of CNA says the chairman of HMV
says the chairman of Woolworths what fit
is that to us where retail giants and
then the topple one by one and now there
are questions in Parliament
now there’s worry now there’s concern
because the retail giant’s we prolong
our lives
they’re starting to fall and then
there’s an injustice there who cared
when the family furniture business that
had been around for five generations
went under because MFI always had a sale
on but MFI goes bust and now the
Chancellor stands up and Paul the
Parliament and says something must be
done the High Street is dying
and that’s our story that the High
Street is dying that our city centres
are going to be desolate wastelands
think about stories is that they’re
important stories are the way we
understand the world and they’re just
they’re just as important as economic
models or scientific models and that
what they do is they take really complex
issues and they let us simplify them so
that we gain an understanding of them
the difficulty arises is if we simplify
the truth so much that so much of it is
lost that the story actually becomes
false so I’m thinking about this talk
and I’m thinking is it actually true our
high streets dying
so what questions can I ask what
fundamental questions can I ask to find
out this is true so the first question
I’m gonna ask are there actually fewer
unfortunately yes there are in the last
six years seventy one and a half
unbought it that translates to jobs as
well this year almost 47,000 retail jobs
have been lost in this country up until
the end of July this is not a prediction
these are jobs that have actually been
lost this year in retail okay so there’s
no glimmer of hope there alright let’s
say let’s move on from that then let’s
say from that we can find some hope
somewhere let’s ask the next question
why do we shop we shop the necessities
right we shop because we need to eat
meat it cools us close ourselves is that
the only reason we shop
I mean don’t about you but going out and
shopping for food bores me and I don’t
like to do it which is one of the reason
why so much growth in supermarket sales
is moving online because that’s much
more convenient than trolling around the
big supermarket so why do we shop why do
we go out why did we ever when shopping
was at the height of its popularity when
it seemed like it was the national hobby
and we all went to town on a Saturday
why did we do it good old maslul he’ll
give us a clue I want to look at the
esteem needs because this is interesting
maybe we shop so that we can show off to
our friends maybe we shop so we can see
a look what I found look what I’ve got
maybe we shop for the thrill and
excitement of finding something that you
haven’t seen before maybe that’s why we
do it which leads me to another thought
that maybe shopping isn’t actually about
the accumulation of things let’s have a
let’s have another question what kind of
well comet comet went under what was
comet comet was a box mover wasn’t it
really bought electrical goods out the
factories it shipped them around the
country and had put them into big rooms
where we all went and stared at them all
it really did was move with boxes
transport that’s not very exciting and
they went under because you know buying
the fridge is easier on the internet as
long as you know the measurements of the
fridge that you need and it does
everything you want well just order it
online don’t have to go to comment so
the box movers they’re on their way out
uninspired the uninteresting the things
that we’re young we do because we have
to but not because we get any joy out of
them those are the shops that are on
their way out but little shops little
interesting shops will specialist shops
little shops where people actually make
things where things are actually created
or where experiences are actually
created they’re not on their way out one
of my hobbies is wargaming do not laugh
I am a middle-aged man who collects pins
and plays with toy soldiers it’s
absolutely true yeah this is one of my
big battles I’m very proud I lost
unfortunately I don’t play this at home
nobody I know plays it at home we go to
a pub and we play the pub gives us two
nights a week in their big room and we
set up all the tables and 30 40 50
people turn off and play games are we
buy drinks at the bar we buy sandwiches
has anybody here heard of a company
called Games Workshop Games Workshop
tell Excel Toy Soldiers fantasy and
science fiction toy soldiers but still
toy soldiers and models the interesting
thing about the Games Workshop way of
working is if you go into one of their
shops it’s not just a shop
there are gaming tables where you can
play now mostly that’s so they thing can
give you an introductory game and get
you to try and buy something but most
games workshop’s stores if you go in and
you’re a regular gamer you can arrange
to use a table and just have a game with
your friends if there’s no else to play
you can play there and you don’t have to
buy anything obviously the idea is that
because you like playing do you like
this hobby and you’re gonna play you
will buy stuff but you don’t have to
that’s about experience that’s not about
the purchase there’s something
interesting going on there on the high
does the High Street have to be about
retail this is with thee
just up the cost this is the view out of
my wife’s holiday cottage top window of
the abbey across the roofs this is the
beach isn’t it lovely I want to tell you
one another story and this or the story
just quickly is about the death of the
seaside town this British seaside town
was massively popular in the thirties or
forties the fifties and sixties
tens of thousands of people would go
there on their holidays and then it died
package tours and cheap foreign holidays
kill the seaside town and now they’re
desolate places six are Italy to the
year they get some visitors in they’re
quite busy engine the summer but that’s
it I remember reading that story in the
newspapers over and over again just like
we’ve all read the story about the death
of the high street but Whitby isn’t like
that 20 years ago when I first moved to
the Yorkshire coast the bean bees would
be busy awesome and then they would when
the summer season was over they would
pack up they would do a clean down and
the owners would go off and their whole
days and come back and hunker down for
the winter it’s not like that there
something interesting is happening here
and I think it starts with fork week
it’s a nationwide famous festival a
whole week of folk music events this is
one of the morris dancing crews there is
a whole parade of morris dancing teams
who come and you can fall
in the town and they will all be dance
assume the dance with swords from the
dancing clogs it’s incredible some of
them end up doing their dance in the sea
I kid you know if you book a hotel if
you’re looking up during Fork week to
attend the events if you want the same
hotel or the same holy cottage for next
year you better book it now because if
you don’t you won’t get a place next
year the town is full and then there’s
goth week and goth week was so popular
that they made two of them there’s goth
week in April and it’s Halloween the
terror population of Whitby is roughly
thirty thousand people during goth week
on certain days the population of Whitby
is 55 thousand people it is so busy that
the police closed the roads in the
middle of town to vehicular traffic
because it’s dangerous because of how
many people there are and there’s not
just goth weekend there’s world war two
weekend there’s 1960s weekend there’s
1950s weekend and suddenly you have a
thriving tourist community there’s
something going on here because it’s not
just about ice cream and chips and
sitting on the beach it’s about your
experience all year round that’s what
would be showing us what if the high
street could be like that what if it’s
not just about retail what if it’s about
experience so what if that means the
space doesn’t have to be full of shops
what if it could be full of theatres and
art galleries and cinemas and shops what
if it’s about what we experience there
is that a little bit of hope for the
future regardless of all that I miss
clothes I wanted to go back and at least
find where it used to be the funny thing
is it’s still there there’s young mr.
cloth he was off doing something else
when I was a kid but he back and he runs
the shop now and it’s still sky blue and
it still has shelves that reach up to
the sky but
REME bulges and I think it’s still there
because he loves what he does and maybe
that’s what the high streets about maybe
it’s about creativity and consumers and
maybe mostly it’s about those who love
what they do
thank you for listening [Applause]
like all good stories
it has heroes and villains treachery and
deceit good and evil towering Giants and
underdogs who are overwhelmed by
circumstances and maybe just maybe
there’s a little bit of hope and the
story I would like to tell you is the
death of the high street nothing like
being overdramatic my version of the
story is different from yours our all of
our visions of the story of different
mine begins in newcastle upon tyne where
i was born a little place called heatin
was an area of the city and right in
newcastle let’s get this straight
you don’t call your mother mother you
don’t call her mom you don’t call her
mom you call her mum just like the Queen
rhymes with ham ma’am and me mom would
take me shopping to our local high
stream best in the pram in the pushchair
and then holding hands and off we’d go
to our local high street
this is chilling him rude now my wife is
very fond of seeing that when I was born
back in 1832
[Laughter]
I’m not that old and this is a little
bit before my time but this is
Chillingham Road and it’s been a high
street for decades and this is it in 70s
this is what it was like when I was a
kid and it seemed to stretch on almost
endlessly full of tiny little shops
Baker’s greengrocers manas the butcher
for some reason I remember the names
even had sawdust on the floor a proper
old-fashioned butchers but there were
dozens of shops and we go from place to
place and get our groceries and at the
end if I was lucky and if I’d been
really good and not complained while
we’d gone through all the shops and
crawled up and down and by the way hats
like that were really popular at the
time
if I’d been really good I would get
taken for sweets at the end to an almost
mythical place called cloths this is
close
paint its sky blue on the outside and
sky blue on the inside with shelves
groaning with rainbow colored jars as
far as you could see off and cloths was
manned by mr. and mrs. cook but mr. and
mr. cook I never saw it was always mrs.
cough that is not me
but that’s all mrs. cook with her
stepladder because even to me is a four
or five year old boy she seemed like an
incredibly tiny old woman so whatever
you asked for she had to get a
stepladder out and if I was lucky I
would get a quarter of sweets and if IB
was being clever I would ask for
actually two two ounce bags some sweet
peanuts and some midget gems and then
we’d walk home and I’d eat them and I’d
sought the midget gems and the colors
because you know if you eat a black one
and this side you mouth you’ve got to
chew a black on that side that’s normal
right and off I’d go and it was a place
of almost unparalleled joy and we’ve all
got the memories of shopping trips like
that and that’s how the story always
starts there was a time when the high
street was full of tiny little shops and
then something came and killed it this
is the same street this is the fine fair
supermarket laughably small by the
standards of a supermarket today but the
damage is already done if you look at
that’s a brand new building back in the
70s a whole row of shops has been
demolished to accommodate a supermarkets
arrived in the 50s at first of all they
pushed out the grocer’s so the little
shops had sold
tins and dried goods they went first
because they couldn’t compete because
the supermarket’s model is simple and to
give them credit brilliant you buy in
bulk you stack it high and you sell it
cheaper and local independent grocers
cannot compete and they’re the first
ones to go but the supermarket’s
aren’t satisfied with just the grossest
the supermarket’s want to sell fresh
fruit and fresh vegetables so then the
green grocers gone and the supermarket’s
want to package meat and they do a deal
with the farms and the forced prices
down amongst the farmers and they sell
you packaged meat and then the butchers
and the supermarkets grow to dominance
with their simple model stack it high
sell it cheap people come in it’s
convenient they don’t have to wonder the
high street it’s one place we’ll have a
big but I’m a big car park people have
just come to us and people do and it’s
not just the supermarket’s the small
electrical retailers are forced out
because the same model is adopted by big
chains we will buy from the factory well
stick it in a box will ship it anywhere
we want in the country and we’ll sell it
and we’ll sell it cheaper than this
small electrical shops can and we’ll do
it in bulk and it’s not just electrical
shops it’s small independent clause
retailers is wrong and they go and
suddenly would get this idea that the
high street is the same kind of twenty
shops in every street in the country
everywhere everywhere has a double you
dismiss everywhere has a Marks and
Spencers and they’re all becoming the
same and the little independents are
forced out and then the big recession of
the eighties arrives and the traditional
industries get decimated and suddenly
there’s huge tracts of desolate land on
the other sides of cities nobody wants
it it’s dead cheaper hang on we don’t
just need to have expensive supermarkets
in the middle of towns now we can build
hypermarkets we can have vast warehouses
that will sell everything you could ever
possibly want electricals Klaus food
everything and the supermarkets move out
of town and not just the supermarket’s
the electrical chains and everybody else
follows we have huge out-of-town
developments and so the high street is
quietly kill the little independents
have gone and were left with raw after
raw of empty shop and we’re terrified
that our city centres will be these
and then the web comes and it’s not just
the little independent retailers brought
under anymore now it’s the big chains
the web you see what that thing for
geeks that has porn on it says the
chairman of CNA says the chairman of HMV
says the chairman of Woolworths what fit
is that to us where retail giants and
then the topple one by one and now there
are questions in Parliament
now there’s worry now there’s concern
because the retail giant’s we prolong
our lives
they’re starting to fall and then
there’s an injustice there who cared
when the family furniture business that
had been around for five generations
went under because MFI always had a sale
on but MFI goes bust and now the
Chancellor stands up and Paul the
Parliament and says something must be
done the High Street is dying
and that’s our story that the High
Street is dying that our city centres
are going to be desolate wastelands
think about stories is that they’re
important stories are the way we
understand the world and they’re just
they’re just as important as economic
models or scientific models and that
what they do is they take really complex
issues and they let us simplify them so
that we gain an understanding of them
the difficulty arises is if we simplify
the truth so much that so much of it is
lost that the story actually becomes
false so I’m thinking about this talk
and I’m thinking is it actually true our
high streets dying
so what questions can I ask what
fundamental questions can I ask to find
out this is true so the first question
I’m gonna ask are there actually fewer
unfortunately yes there are in the last
six years seventy one and a half
unbought it that translates to jobs as
well this year almost 47,000 retail jobs
have been lost in this country up until
the end of July this is not a prediction
these are jobs that have actually been
lost this year in retail okay so there’s
no glimmer of hope there alright let’s
say let’s move on from that then let’s
say from that we can find some hope
somewhere let’s ask the next question
why do we shop we shop the necessities
right we shop because we need to eat
meat it cools us close ourselves is that
the only reason we shop
I mean don’t about you but going out and
shopping for food bores me and I don’t
like to do it which is one of the reason
why so much growth in supermarket sales
is moving online because that’s much
more convenient than trolling around the
big supermarket so why do we shop why do
we go out why did we ever when shopping
was at the height of its popularity when
it seemed like it was the national hobby
and we all went to town on a Saturday
why did we do it good old maslul he’ll
give us a clue I want to look at the
esteem needs because this is interesting
maybe we shop so that we can show off to
our friends maybe we shop so we can see
a look what I found look what I’ve got
maybe we shop for the thrill and
excitement of finding something that you
haven’t seen before maybe that’s why we
do it which leads me to another thought
that maybe shopping isn’t actually about
the accumulation of things let’s have a
let’s have another question what kind of
well comet comet went under what was
comet comet was a box mover wasn’t it
really bought electrical goods out the
factories it shipped them around the
country and had put them into big rooms
where we all went and stared at them all
it really did was move with boxes
transport that’s not very exciting and
they went under because you know buying
the fridge is easier on the internet as
long as you know the measurements of the
fridge that you need and it does
everything you want well just order it
online don’t have to go to comment so
the box movers they’re on their way out
uninspired the uninteresting the things
that we’re young we do because we have
to but not because we get any joy out of
them those are the shops that are on
their way out but little shops little
interesting shops will specialist shops
little shops where people actually make
things where things are actually created
or where experiences are actually
created they’re not on their way out one
of my hobbies is wargaming do not laugh
I am a middle-aged man who collects pins
and plays with toy soldiers it’s
absolutely true yeah this is one of my
big battles I’m very proud I lost
unfortunately I don’t play this at home
nobody I know plays it at home we go to
a pub and we play the pub gives us two
nights a week in their big room and we
set up all the tables and 30 40 50
people turn off and play games are we
buy drinks at the bar we buy sandwiches
has anybody here heard of a company
called Games Workshop Games Workshop
tell Excel Toy Soldiers fantasy and
science fiction toy soldiers but still
toy soldiers and models the interesting
thing about the Games Workshop way of
working is if you go into one of their
shops it’s not just a shop
there are gaming tables where you can
play now mostly that’s so they thing can
give you an introductory game and get
you to try and buy something but most
games workshop’s stores if you go in and
you’re a regular gamer you can arrange
to use a table and just have a game with
your friends if there’s no else to play
you can play there and you don’t have to
buy anything obviously the idea is that
because you like playing do you like
this hobby and you’re gonna play you
will buy stuff but you don’t have to
that’s about experience that’s not about
the purchase there’s something
interesting going on there on the high
does the High Street have to be about
retail this is with thee
just up the cost this is the view out of
my wife’s holiday cottage top window of
the abbey across the roofs this is the
beach isn’t it lovely I want to tell you
one another story and this or the story
just quickly is about the death of the
seaside town this British seaside town
was massively popular in the thirties or
forties the fifties and sixties
tens of thousands of people would go
there on their holidays and then it died
package tours and cheap foreign holidays
kill the seaside town and now they’re
desolate places six are Italy to the
year they get some visitors in they’re
quite busy engine the summer but that’s
it I remember reading that story in the
newspapers over and over again just like
we’ve all read the story about the death
of the high street but Whitby isn’t like
that 20 years ago when I first moved to
the Yorkshire coast the bean bees would
be busy awesome and then they would when
the summer season was over they would
pack up they would do a clean down and
the owners would go off and their whole
days and come back and hunker down for
the winter it’s not like that there
something interesting is happening here
and I think it starts with fork week
it’s a nationwide famous festival a
whole week of folk music events this is
one of the morris dancing crews there is
a whole parade of morris dancing teams
who come and you can fall
in the town and they will all be dance
assume the dance with swords from the
dancing clogs it’s incredible some of
them end up doing their dance in the sea
I kid you know if you book a hotel if
you’re looking up during Fork week to
attend the events if you want the same
hotel or the same holy cottage for next
year you better book it now because if
you don’t you won’t get a place next
year the town is full and then there’s
goth week and goth week was so popular
that they made two of them there’s goth
week in April and it’s Halloween the
terror population of Whitby is roughly
thirty thousand people during goth week
on certain days the population of Whitby
is 55 thousand people it is so busy that
the police closed the roads in the
middle of town to vehicular traffic
because it’s dangerous because of how
many people there are and there’s not
just goth weekend there’s world war two
weekend there’s 1960s weekend there’s
1950s weekend and suddenly you have a
thriving tourist community there’s
something going on here because it’s not
just about ice cream and chips and
sitting on the beach it’s about your
experience all year round that’s what
would be showing us what if the high
street could be like that what if it’s
not just about retail what if it’s about
experience so what if that means the
space doesn’t have to be full of shops
what if it could be full of theatres and
art galleries and cinemas and shops what
if it’s about what we experience there
is that a little bit of hope for the
future regardless of all that I miss
clothes I wanted to go back and at least
find where it used to be the funny thing
is it’s still there there’s young mr.
cloth he was off doing something else
when I was a kid but he back and he runs
the shop now and it’s still sky blue and
it still has shelves that reach up to
the sky but
REME bulges and I think it’s still there
because he loves what he does and maybe
that’s what the high streets about maybe
it’s about creativity and consumers and
maybe mostly it’s about those who love
what they do
thank you for listening [Applause]
Please follow and like us: