Press "Enter" to skip to content

The Cost of Complication | Robert Duff | TEDxCamarillo


[Music]

in August of 2014 I almost lost my wife

this was the final year of my training

before getting my doctorate in clinical

psychology what’s called the

pre-doctoral internship and my wife Jill

and I had moved into this little tiny

apartment in San Diego California and

not only was it tiny but it was so dark

it was like a cave sometimes we had to

go outside to tell if it was light or

dark out that’s how about it was I

didn’t realize though at the time that

that darkness was going to be a theme

for the year my wife Jill has always had

some difficulties with anxiety and

depression but the circumstances of our

life at this point made it more

difficult we were isolated from the

place that we had called home and our

support network and add to that I could

not be there for her as much as I’d like

because I was busy being overworked and

underpaid as all doctoral interns are

and this created the scenario where she

was having panic attacks more frequently

and they were becoming more severe but

she had been in to see the therapist and

the doctor trying to figure it out and

it was at one of these sessions it was

an emergency therapists session after a

particularly alarming panic attack that

Joelle revealed she had thoughts of

suicide she had thought about just

wanting to stop fighting taking a bunch

of pills going to sleep and letting it

go away

I remember the scenario pretty vividly

the therapist sitting over here calmly

excusing herself to use the phone call

and her supervisor they consulted at for

a moment talked to Joelle and I and then

the supervisor calmly explaining she’s

going to be held on a 5150 which is an

involuntary hold for psychiatric reasons

in other words she was going away to the

mental hospital for a few days now this

wasn’t the crazy scenario that you see

in the movies

no kicking and screaming and all of that

but it was Joelle sitting here with

silent tears running down her face

nodding and my hand on her shoulder

gripping tighter and tighter as if there

was some way I could anchor her there

and

stop all this from happening but there

wasn’t and she did go away for a few

days now the hospitalization process was

not like the movies but the hospital

itself kind of was we did not get the

best Hospital in the area and even as a

mental health professional when I

visited her it was shocking to me that

there were people screaming in the

hallways there was one person who

wouldn’t stop harassing us because they

were convinced that Joelle was a member

of the SWAT team planted there to kill

everybody and she told me she wasn’t

getting a lot of sleep because it seemed

like every few minutes they were shining

lights in her eyes to make sure she was

still there so I have no room to

complain here but this period of time

was also really hard for me I spent a

lot of time sitting in our little cave

alone by myself just thinking and

overwhelmingly I felt like a failure and

there’s a part of that that I think is

normal I think it’s understandable to

feel like a failure as a husband as a

spouse when your partner ends up in a

mental institution but there was

something else there too there is this

deeper sort of failure that was murky

and gross under the surface and it took

me a while to put my fingers on why

driving it was the sense that Joelle

shouldn’t have been there that something

went wrong along the way because she had

books and resources she had been in

therapy but for some reason the point

wasn’t sticking and she wasn’t able to

apply it and I came to realize as I

thought about it that sense of failure

under the surface was actually on behalf

of the mental health field that I

represented I thought we had failed her

by letting this happen and I think I was

right I think that we did fail her

because you see language comes at a cost

and the cost of the language that my

field was using came at the cost of

Joelle’s attention and ability to relate

to what they were saying it didn’t work

it didn’t hit the mark and so she was

somebody so strong and so resilient

feeling weak and helpless and that

didn’t sit well with me now after a few

days she was allowed to come back home

and we spent a lot of time talking about

this just going over what had happened

and how to move forward and during one

of these talks I reached over and

grabbed one of her books

this was basically the industry-standard

workbook for anxiety now for

professionals like me but for people

like her who are actively contending

with these symptoms so I flipped open to

a random page and read a paragraph and I

had to say to her sweetheart I have no

idea what the hell this is trying to say

here I was about to get my PhD in this

stuff so I could only imagine that for

somebody who’s exhausted from dealing

with these symptoms

day in and day out it must be so

demotivating to work up the courage and

energy and then get smacked in the face

by such a complicated language and it

was in that moment with that frustration

that I realized the reason we had failed

her as a field as we were guilty of

something that I’ve come to call

pedantic obfuscation I know that’s a

mouthful we can also call it P over

short but let me explain what it means

so pedantic just refers to being overly

obsessed with the details the

terminology their particulars of

something you might have had a professor

or a boss who was too pedantic and put

you to sleep as I drone on and on and on

about something obfuscation refers to

obscuring something making it unclear it

could even mean to bewilder someone so

putting those together pedantic

obfuscation pio this term that I kind of

just made up on my own refers to that

thing that people do that just grinds my

gears where they use jargon and

unnecessarily complicated language and

leave me feeling exhausted and unable to

actually relate to what they’re saying

when you don’t consider the cost of your

language you run the risk of alienating

people you separate them from the point

that you’re trying to make whether that

be in print or in a face-to-face

conversation and since as mental health

providers we were just peeing all over

the place

this made the scenario where Joelle and

probably countless others had a hard

time connecting to the resources

designed to help which pissed me off I

mean at this point in the scenario I’m

getting worked up about this after

reading that paragraph and I say

something to the effect of man when they

write misattribution of interoceptive

cues for anxiety basically they’re

trying to say that sometimes your brain

is an asshole

that sometimes you have this like little

heart flutter or a pain here or there

and instead of sitting back analyzing it

and thinking maybe this is normal let’s

wait it out and see your brain says that

feels like anxiety I think you know what

let’s have a panic attack just in case I

told her the whole book could probably

be condensed down into under a hundred

pages if they really wanted to so she

looked at me and said Robert you could

write that since she’s always right I

did and a month later I released my

first book now my serious is a self-help

series for people that typically hate

self-help it uses straightforward

language it’s spelled out has a healthy

dash of my own terrible humor in it and

I can’t tell you how amazing the

feedback has been people really

connected with my personal attempt to

cut the pedantic obfuscation and

understand the opportunity cost of my

language the reason I’m telling you this

is there’s an opportunity there there’s

an opportunity to reach people who might

not otherwise hear your message because

they can’t get through the words being

used this is really important in the

field of mental health we’re in the

business of reaching people and to make

our resources exhausting to get through

that shows we’re not truly empathizing

with people and I think it’s an issue in

a lot of other areas as well coming from

an academic background I wanted to dive

into the research a bit see is Pio an

issue in other areas and man it

definitely is there’s a lot of research

out there one line of research that

caught my eye though is in the medical

field

looking at the impact of unclarified

medical jargon so words or terms that

your doctor might use but they don’t

clear up for you there was one study

that blew my mind so these are people

that were about to be getting major

surgery and they had a preoperative

appointment where the doctor explains

everything to them beforehand now they

were tested after this session on their

comprehension of ten commonly used

medical terms that were thrown around

during the session 60% of the terms used

weren’t adequately understood by the

people studied so that means over half

of the terms used these common medical

terms used in this explanation session

were not understood by the people that

we’re trying to get that information

which blows my mind right but as I think

about it a lot of you have probably

the experience of being in with a doctor

or maybe even in a business meeting and

having some jargon or a certain term

thrown around that you don’t completely

understand but you don’t want to ask for

clarification because you don’t want to

sound stupid you are not stupid that

expectation to sit back and passively

accept the information without fully

understanding it that’s stupid

the impact of language in a medical or

mental health setting can be dangerous

in other situations the cost can be well

money I’ve definitely had the experience

of going to the mechanic for my car and

feeling like they intentionally throw me

off with a language that they’d use

because when you don’t fully understand

the language you can’t participate

completely in the conversation it

becomes a one-way street instead of a

transaction so in this situation I’m

left paralyzed unable to respond while

the mechanic reads this gigantic list of

things that apparently need fixing right

that moment and a huge price tag at the

end now this is not a new issue every

field of science information technology

news politics even sports these are all

fields that have had pedantic

obfuscation as an issue for a while

Albert Einstein even waited on the topic

he has a quote that says if you can’t

explain something simply you do not

understand it well enough I could not

agree more

I see reliance on jargon and

unnecessarily complicated explanations

as the easy answer it’s actually safer

than keeping things straight forward

because it allows you to keep it bullet

arm’s length it allows you to avoid

those people that might otherwise call

you out on any misunderstandings that

you have but I don’t think we should

settle for that I don’t think we should

settle for lofty confusing explanations

for things that could be distilled down

into succinct language with a little bit

of room for personality I mean at what

point in time do we have to stop being

real people when we talk or when we

write things so if you’re an expert or a

thought leader or even just passionate

in what you do ask yourself if you two

are differencing people through the

language that you use sometimes this is

on purpose in therapy or testing I might

use a jargon term like mal odorous

instead of saying that somebody stunk

really

that’s me distancing myself from that

point on purpose but often I don’t think

it’s on purpose I think it’s an

automatic process that we use to keep

ourselves safe from criticism so instead

of asking yourself if something sounds

smart or it sounds professional ask

yourself how you can reach people join

me in saying hell no to Pio and here’s

how you can start that here’s how you

can check where you fall on that Pio

meter

next time you have a meeting or you’re

writing an email before you dive into

your next written project ask yourself

three questions one do we already share

our language if you have a language of

vocabulary that you share with somebody

and it serves the purpose of actually

simplifying things by all means use that

in my professional work with my partner

I would much rather say that somebody

has executive functioning deficits and

blue and aphasia rather than saying well

they had a hard time paying attention

and when they were met with distractions

their productivity dropped and when they

talk to did it really make sense but if

you weren’t listening closely it sounds

like it should have made sense there’s

two phrases I mean the same thing so I

should use that the thing is you need to

be sure don’t assume ask the question of

whether you share that language question

– how can I say this to my best friend

or romantic partner over a beer or a

coffee or kale smoothie your beverage of

choice the best friend or romantic

partner is somebody who probably wants

to hear you out but they do not want the

overly complicated version so as you’re

picturing yourself saying something to

them or reading through something having

them read it if you see them crinkling

their brow clearly struggling through

your language or conveniently being

distracted by their phone as you’re

talking you might be veering off into

pio territory and need to reel it back

in a little bit the third question is a

simple one how would I like to receive

this information there’s no reason you

need to be putting out information or

resources that you would never want to

consume yourself

there’s no reason needs to be shipped

you should be saying things that you

would be bored to death by or that you

would be confused by so just flip the

script and imagine that you’re on the

receiving end how would you like to hear

it as I said before I think there’s an

opportunity here

some really interesting interesting

things can happen when we start to say

no to Pio and understand the cost of our

language for one the bar can raise so as

thought leaders and experts are

pressured to distill their ideas down

into relatable language they’re going to

have to be on their game just like that

Einstein quote implied you have to

understand something better in order to

simplify it so that’s going to be good

for everybody

and as that standard changes people on

the receiving end of information will

actually be empowered because they’ll be

allowed to ask questions and get

clarification really understanding

what’s going on rather than having that

one-way street most importantly you can

reach people every day there’s someone

out there just like my wife Joelle who’s

going through the worst year ever and

they’re desperate for that piece of

information that’s just so relatable and

clear that it can help them pull things

back together and you can be that voice

so please consider the cost of your

language avoid pedantic obfuscation

where you can focus on reaching people

and you can truly make a difference thank you

Please follow and like us: