Press "Enter" to skip to content

The Color Line: Black and White Aesthetic Values | Barbara-Shae Jackson | TEDxTuscaloosa


[Music]

growing up as a military child I was

afforded the opportunity that not many

get the chance to experience I grew up

in Naples Italy for 15 years my family

and I lived there and my parents because

they were from Montgomery Alabama made

sure that they provided their children

with the opportunity to see things that

we would not have otherwise been able to

see so we traveled all over Italy my

favorite thing to do was to travel up

and down the Amalfi Coast I love to go

to Venice to Florence to Pisa but my

most favorite thing to do was to spend

time in Rome at the Sistine Chapel at

the Sistine Chapel that’s where everyone

congregates from all around the world

people who appreciate and love fine art

and so while I’m standing there looking

up with my head tilted back at the

ceiling I’m surrounded by people of all

different nationalities all different

races all different ages and we’re all

looking at the frescoes that

Michelangelo painted in the early 1500s

in admiration but one thing that really

stood out to me was this feeling deep

down inside that while I’m looking at

something that I think is extremely

beautiful I don’t see myself reflected

in it so what does that mean what does

it mean to internalize something that

centuries and centuries of people have

exalted as extremely beautiful but you

don’t look like anything that’s

represented in it and so these are the

questions that I started to ask myself

as a child but I never thought to

verbalize them to anyone else because

what a sin is it to say that you have a

problem with Michelangelo’s Sistine

Chapel right but I had a real problem

with that

and so I grappled with that as a child

it wasn’t until I became older that I

finally realized that there was a lot of

things going around around the world

that were not what was happening in Rome

at the time while Michelangelo was

painting the Sistine Chapel Africans

were being transported from Africa to

the island of Hispaniola

which is now Haiti and the Dominican

Republic so while we saw this years

later if I’m reflecting back honestly

and I’m getting a full picture of

history Africans were being transported

somewhere to be used as slave labor

while in Europe white people were being

exalted and immortalized for centuries

and centuries to come and so this led me

on a track on a journey to really

understand what happens when you look at

a piece of art that reflects human

experience but your experience is not

reflected in that so I am a cognitive

psychologist well at least I’m studying

to be a cognitive psychologist hopefully

at the University of Alabama and what I

look at is cognition which is the study

of the mind and the processes that it

goes through the way that it stores

retrieves and codes information and I

also look at art this idea that whatever

is created is reflective of the human

experience and my journey is to look at

how those two things converge and what

those things can teach us now as

psychologists have to do I dug and dug

and dug in the research and I had to

come up with some kind of empirical

finding that happened which grounded my

research and what I was looking at I

found a groundswell of one article and

I’m running with that article

now that article was by a psychologist

named Ronald Knepper oude and he came up

with this idea to actually research how

blacks and whites viewed black visual

art and so Ronald Knepper conducted this

study in 1996 and what he found is that

in fact blacks and whites do not view

black visual art in the same way he said

that they actually view black that

whites actually view black visual art

less favorably now Ronald neferu posited

that this was probably so because blacks

and whites do not have the same shared

experiences and so just as art is

created out of out of a field

or an experience that the artist has had

the person that is looking at a piece of

artwork also brings their experiences to

the table in order to perceive and have

a moment with that piece of art so what

Ronald Knepper Root said basically was

that if white folks don’t have the same

historical understandings feelings

cognition collective memory belief

systems that are portrayed in black

visual art and created by black artists

they’re not going to effectively

resonate with that piece of art now I

doubt a little bit deeper because I

thought this was extremely fascinating

and I was extremely excited because what

I thought standing beneath

Michelangelo’s fresco in the Sistine

Chapel was finally turning out to have

some merit there is something different

there with the experiences that we bring

to a piece of art so I got to thinking

well what can I do with this and so I’m

still researching I’m digging I’m trying

to find something to hang my thoughts on

and I get a phone call from my cousin

who was a painter now my cousin is a

painter who lives in New York and he

paints the most beautiful images he’s he

get puts me in the mind of jean-michel

basquiat and so he takes these images

and he goes around New York and he does

different art shows but his favorite

thing to do is to just stand on the

street corner and show his art and so

what this does that invites people to

come and have difficult dialogues and

discussions around the certain things

that he portrays in his art one day my

cousin called me and he told me that he

had been arrested because a police

officer saw painting that he had in a

subway and he was offended by the

painting now the painting is this

painting behind me it’s called cops and

as you can see this this painting is

showing a police officer in an

aggressive stance and so the police

officer was not too happy with this

image because he felt that it painted

his brothers in blue in a very negative

light during this time it was at the

height of the black lives versus the

blue lives matter movement

and so this was kind of a rough topic at

the time so when my cousin called me and

told me this it really drove home this

idea that while he thought this painting

would bring some much-needed dialogue

and discussion around a particular issue

that was polarized in our country this

police officer saw the same painting and

had a completely different experience

from it

this also led me to believe that I might

be on the right track to something so I

kept digging a little bit deeper and a

little bit deeper and I came up with

another article a recent article that

just came out of Montclair State

University by a researcher named John

Paul Wilson now John Paul Wilson did a

study where he actually took images

there were superimposed of black folks

and images that were superimposed of

white folks who are of the same body

build mass and physical makeup the only

difference was their skin color

he found that overwhelmingly so white

participants in his study said that the

white folks who were superimposed were

more threatening than those who were

black simply because of their skin color

and nothing else I thought this was

extremely fascinating and it led me to

understand that this whole issue of a

value system that has been placed on the

black body it’s consistently being

perpetuated in our system in ways that

we don’t even recognize cognitively we

are responding to things and we don’t

necessarily realize that they are even

ingrained in us so this is the important

part of actually looking at visual

stimuli and taking a concerted effort to

figure out how we perceive things that

we look at these are the images that he

use or similar images like this he used

in a study as you can see the faces are

not shown but the body the body mass and

the body style is consistently different

throughout these three different people

now what John Paul Wilson did was that

he actually changed the skin color just

a little bit and had the participants

rate each of these images to say

which one they thought was more

threatening so why does this matter why

do we care that that images need to be

rated or that we have some type of issue

amongst the different races with

perception well it matters because

Philander Castile

it matters because of Mike Brown it

matters because of Trayvon Martin in

2015 the Huffington Post released a

startling startling article that said

2015 was the worst year in America for

the killing of the black man since the

worst year of lynching in America this

is a startling finding but it’s a

fighting that we need to be paying

attention to and my understanding and my

perception is that the best way to have

the difficult dialogues and

conversations is to come and meet at a

place where we all care about which is

art

everybody loves art everybody feels

something when they see a piece of art

so why not start the conversation there

William Edward Burghardt Du Bois who as

a sociologist would agree that that

might be the best place to start in 1908

and his souls of black folks he said

that the problem of the 20th century was

the problem of the color line in 1920 he

said that the only way to eradicate this

invisible color line was to use art I am

on the journey to figure out how we

might best be able to do that thank [Applause]

Please follow and like us: