Press "Enter" to skip to content

The Case for Empathy in Education | Stephanie Bai | TEDxBOVSchool


thank you I have a confession to make to

you only recently how I stopped feeling

like a complete fraud in my school as

far as confessions can usually go this

is a pretty good one the fact that I

feel like I belong in my own school

after being here for so many years is a

great thing however the reasons why I

felt like a fraud in the first place

matter not just for me but for students

everywhere I realized that the problems

that I faced as a younger student that

students have faced in the past and will

unfortunately still continue to face in

the present don’t have to stay that way

throughout my time here I’ve learned

that we must practice empathy in order

to do our best work but first what is

empathy

Teresa Weisman who has studied empathy

in many different professions where as

relevant such as nursing for example

found four main attributes the first is

perspective taking which means listening

and understanding that someone else’s

perspective is what they truly believe

avoiding judgment as difficult as that

can be recognizing emotion and

communicating that you have recognized

another person’s emotion as Rene Brown a

researcher storyteller who studies

courage and vulnerability says empathy

is making yourself vulnerable because

you have to put yourself in the other

person’s shoes you have to find that

sensation or experience within yourself

that is that reflects what the other

person is feeling you have to stay with

that person and let their pain be your

pain let their joy be your joy and let

your emotions be linked to theirs in an

incredibly intimate way so know that

we’re on the same page about empathy

let’s go back to 2012 or you could find

it insecure in logistics 7th grader

roaming these halls or me in back then

and I

succeeding in school with the occasional

silver balloon that had designated me as

an honorable student but something else

was at hand and the third or fourth

seating chart of the year in seven three

physics I was placed in a row that had

an East Asian student and a latina

student and in me it was an East Asian

student sandwich if you will and a kid

in the row behind us turn to that latina

student and said you’ll never have a

question in physics again it’s us Asian

one or Asian two and my little seventh

grade mind was blown wide open I was in

a world where I craved for identity I

just wanted to be part of something and

at that moment II dropped into my lap I

was Asian it took that kid in the back

route for me to realize this obviously

and now that I had this shiny brand-new

identity my actions had to fit it so if

anyone asked me a question about

schoolwork I had to answer to the best

of my ability because Asians you all

there was to know about schoolwork and

if I really didn’t know anything about

tenth grade economics graph making or

eighth grade rhetoric essay writing it

didn’t matter because my race clearly

ruled out these other insignificant

facts

deep down I knew I was a complete fraud

I knew it more than anything else in my

head but it wasn’t like a change my race

and escape what seemed to be that

ever-present expectations of others so

continued and continued through ninth

and tenth grade and I got angrier and

angrier but it couldn’t quite pin this

whole thing down then when I started the

college application and research process

in 12th grade I realized that my test

scores and my GPA

wellgood wouldn’t have not the same

if I wasn’t Asian my 34 on the acct

didn’t bear as much weight because I was

Asian and Asians just get nice ATT

scores anyways and my GPA similarly well

perfectly fine wouldn’t have looked the

same if I wasn’t Asian and I’m

definitely not the only Asian American

student who’s had these types of

frustrations with a college system just

half a year ago an article published in

the Atlantic detailed how multiple East

Asian groups made up of people mostly

from China Korea or Japan have had

frustrations with our college system

this picture shows people from the Asian

American Coalition for education

protesting about a permit of action

course affirmative action case in front

of the Supreme Court

what is affirmative action we have to

establish that before you move on

affirmative action is the set of

admissions policies that has a goal of

leveling the playing field for people

that have been underrepresented or

excluded in the past that could be

minority ethnicities women or other

marginalized groups as I’ve been beat

Johnson said if you do not take a person

who for years has been hobbled by Chains

and liberate him bring him up to the

starting line of a race and then say you

are free to compete with all the others

and still just believe you have been

completely completely fair this is the

justification for affirmative action

policies and out of all the topics in

this talk is probably the ones that you

already have some feelings about it’s

probably the one that I’ll leave you

with more feelings about but that’s good

because when we have feelings empathy

can come in and we need empathy when

discussing these situations because then

we can understand the weight of them for

the people that are working within them

in this case East Asian people and these

Asian American education groups so

despite these justifications for

affirmative action these East Asian

groups still have a statistics about

their discontent there are two big

factors in this discussion so the first

is that in Asian Americans are the

fastest growing minority in the

asian-americans are growing at a rate of

3.4%

vs. 2.2 percent for Hispanics according

to the 2015 census bureau and

asian-americans are also applying to

colleges more and more you can see that

in the age range of 18 to 21 from 1990

to 2011 that asian-american population

has more than doubled however a link to

college acceptance rates have

practically flatlined there’s been no

significant change let’s compare that to

the California Institute of Technology

or CIT it only takes into account

academics in its admissions process that

I’ve been your test scores on tests like

the SAT or the AC T as well as your GPA

that’s it they’re a student body

population proportion of asian-americans

in 1992 was 25 percent on-quarter

but in 2015 it had moved to 42 percent

if we look at Harvard however it’s in

that mesh of colleges whose lines are

all flat its acceptance rate of

asian-americans moved from 19 percent to

18 percent there’s been no change

despite the clear growth of Asian

American students and the higher rate of

applying to colleges so what can we

learn from this it seems clear that

Asian Americans have been discriminated

against in fact a famous Princeton study

done in 2005 showed that an Asian

American student needs a hundred and

forty more points on their SAT in order

to be compared on the equal level as a

white counterpart so the frustrations of

the East Asian American community seems

very justified we need a solution

addresses the fact that some students

are not being treated equal to their

classmates what can we do to find a

solution well throughout this talk so

far I’ve been referring to Asian

Americans as one single group or one

single entity and as it usually is

it’s more complicated than that

asian-americans are made up of a huge

amount of different groups of different

ethnicities and different nationalities

this table from the 2010 census details

some of them the P Research Center has

found that 83% of Asian Americans are

made up of six main groups that a

Chinese Vietnamese Filipino Korean

Japanese and Indian the other 17% has a

multitude of other groups sisters

Taiwanese Indonesian Malaysian Sri

Lankan time Biagio Cambodian Bangladeshi

and hammam and even more so we can’t

talk about the frustrations of one group

without thinking how does it impact

other people unfortunately according to

the Past White House’s initiative on

asian-americans and Pacific Islanders

the high school dropout rates for some

Southeast Asian groups are staggering

but 40% of hammam 38% of Cambodians and

34% of Russians not completing high

school in addition to those disturbing

facts it’s also clear that only 14% of

Native Hawaiians and Pacific Islanders

over the age of 25 hold a bachelor’s

degree compared to 27% of the general

population over the age of 25 known

proposed solution to one part of this

community can ignore the realities of

lives of so many others for these

Southeast Asian groups and Pacific

Islander groups it’s clear that

affirmative action can be a welcome part

of the admissions process and the roles

that can frequently be stacked against

them affirmative action can begin to

rectify some of those disadvantages it’s

also clear that according to the

testimonies and experiences of block

groups Native American groups and Latino

groups affirmative action can begin to

unravel those disadvantages felt through

an entire lifetime due to the color of

someone’s skin East Asian groups have

left empathy for their fellow citizens

and fellow students because they want to

see the end of something that could

um if ended have a potential to hurt

others so stepping back what can we do

when we do have empathy for our fellow

citizens and students what can happen

when we work for inclusivity and respect

and what can happen when we put our

efforts and her work into future

generations

all of those traits were brought

together in busing once there was a

movement connecting the 1970s to the

1980s and was spearheaded under the

lyndon b johnson presidency thought it

was a movement where lower-income black

kids were bused into different schools

that were mostly white or more affluent

and white students were sometimes bused

into lower income black neighborhoods to

attend those public schools i remember

distinctly going and seeing this display

at the Smithsonian Museum of American

history a cracked school bus window I

read a placard underneath that describe

how protests against a movement called

busing had often gotten violent and

protesters have thrown rocks at school

buses in order to show how displeased

they were with the movement now however

despite the many strong opinions that

swirls around busing in the past it’s

clear that it is one of the tested

positive ways to reduce the achievement

gap in America and to make sure that

education is a better place for all

lyndon b johnson started on busting

movement under his Great Society reform

era and he himself had worked as a

teacher and a low-income majority Latino

school in Texas he held up education as

the passport from poverty and made sure

that Congress knew it in a speech to

Congress in 1965 he said that but all I

knew it was to teach them the little

that I knew hoping that it might help

them against the heart if that lay ahead

somehow you can never forget a poverty

and hatred can do when you see his scars

on the face of a hopeful young child I

never thought then in 1928 that I was

standing here in 1965 and never even

occurred to me and the fondest dreams

that I might have the chance

help the sons and daughters of those

students and help people at them all

over this country the Johnson

administration required public schools

to integrate may need to have students

on multiple races or teachers at

multiple races in order to continue

receiving federal education funding and

in order to avoid federal lawsuits and

it seemed to have wondrous effects on

some schools with a particularly good

example involving North Carolina in the

1960s the first word Elementary School

was primarily all-black and had a

rundown playground with broken glass

littered on the ground with a poor

librarian however in the 1970s when

white children were bused into first

Ward the school quickly began improving

those facilities offense was put up

between the playground and the street in

order to protect kids from traffic

school the plans were bought for

teachers and for students and that

library was refurbished however

sometimes all black schools simply

closed down and what teachers found

themselves out of work the Johnson

administration did not respond to this

unfortunate development despite the

voices of black leaders arguing that

black tutors were needed in public

schools to maintain a more equal

education system despite these

unfortunate developments busing still

held great potential for those students

that were bused into more white more

affluent schools the National Assessment

of Educational Progress which is the

longest continuing assessment of

American students abilities began in the

1970s and at that point showed a 53

point gap between black students and

white students if in mathematics when

they’re 17 years old

however in 1988 after every area of the

country had moved towards integration

that 53 point gap moved to a 20-point

gap I say almost every area of the

country move towards integration because

every area did besides the Northeast

and this was because the Northeast

believed in many ways due to its more

progressive history didn’t really need

to integrate despite the fact that is

public schools were just as if not more

segregated than schools in the south

despite this it was clear that busting

was having wonderful effects all over

the country in 1968 about 78% of black

students attended and all minority

school but in 1988 only 24% of bottoms

did so this is also why we see not the

gap in mathematics was decreasing Batson

also have long term benefits for the

children that had been able to be bussed

and for the children of their children

that had been bussed Berkeley Economics

regressive Johnson performed a long-term

study on those students that have been

bused into more affluent schools and

also now on their children he found that

for that first generation of students

their graduation from high school and

college was higher their income was

greater their occupation when

prestigious their health better and the

lovely hood are going to deal was lower

wasn’t higher it was lower that’s what

we want and he studied siblings which

was uniquely insightful because siblings

grew up with the same parents who often

made the same income and also lived in

the same area despite these fundamental

demographic similarities they still show

significant differences in all of these

areas then he moved on to the second

generation meaning the descendants of

those who had lived during the busing

movement in the 1970s to 1980s for those

children he thought that the reading and

math scores were higher their chance in

repeating a grade was lower and their

graduation rates of high school and

college was higher it seemed clear that

busing had a profound effects on

bettering the lives of black families

what can we learn from all this

information it’s clear that when we work

for inclusivity and respect when we work

with

see it will go a lot further even

farther than you think it will they’ll

work with those in the Johnson

administration who knew as best they

could the struggles of those they were

trying to help they were able to bridge

those gaps that hurt students and hurt

people who are trying to get their

education it’s clear that we must have

empathy in order to find a solution for

all no matter what group is facing a

struggle what does that be in any racial

group or any community so parents when

you think about education and your

child’s future whether that be college

or their high school

make sure your pause and use that power

which empathy can give us and students

do the same when you think about your

own future in education no matter what

it may be make sure you’re listening to

the voices and experiences of those

around you in this way we will be able to do our best work together thank you

Please follow and like us: