Press "Enter" to skip to content

The Art of Good Political Discourse | Poon Singhatiraj | TEDxYouth@ISBangkok


[Applause]

an English writer and political

activists named Thomas Paine once said

to argue with the person who has

renounced the use of Reason is like

administering medicine to the dead

although he did die over 200 years ago

his message has never been more eleven

then today I remember that after the

2012 US election my fifth grade teacher

in Florida Gladys to talk about what had

happened the previous night coming from

an area where there was a diverse amount

of political opinions many of my

classmates were understandably either

very happy or very sad but we got

through our differences and we had a

fruitful political conversation or as

fruitful of a conversation as a

fifth-grade political talk could get but

it was what my teachers said after that

really stuck to me she went I like

talking to kids of all politics because

it’s the only group of people that don’t

yell each other at the time I thought to

myself

she must be wrong I thought that as

people grew up we will just learn to

respect each other even more and that we

will just live in this big utopia of

rainbows and happiness I was 10 years

old it’s so hard to argue that politics

divide people to use the United States

as an example over 40% of Americans

regardless of whether there are

Democrats or Republicans say that each

other’s party is a major threat to the

United States according to a poll dump

ever UK by Pew Research think about it

millions upon millions of Americans are

divided solely on party affiliation

alone the real question then is not if

politics to my people but why if we ever

want to mend this gap we have to look at

the root cause of the problem and

research by psychologist Jonathan gate

and Jesse Grahm may begin to provide

some insight into this issue their

research indicate that people tend to

endorse specific political policies

based on the moral values that they

already held wording I know but the

example of sex education in the United

States is a great example of this in the

United States many Democrats advocate

for a more comprehensive education

program as they believe that it will

reduce rates of teen pregnancy and stds

missions emphasizing the more liberal

values of avoiding harm or King for

others on the other side many

Republicans tend to endorse abstinence

only policies as it emphasizes the more

conservative value of maintaining purity

this reveals that political division may

not be a result of a difference in

opinion on specific policies per se but

rather a difference of opinion on moral

values and this just might be why

politics is so divisive you never

actually see people fighting over

whether Coke or Pepsi is better as

although copious obviously better

there’s just no moral conflicts that

play into this in the slightest I mean

if you’re really into soda that could be

but that’s just a little weird now that

we’ve established a main road root cause

of the problem it’s easier to discuss

solutions and for me it could be broken

down into three steps understand respect

and appeal number one understand their

moral values once you’ve begun to engage

in discussion really narrow out why they

believe the things that they do could it

be because of family up earnings

religion their environment if you only

try to present your side without trying

to understand theirs it is unlikely that

they will listen to anything you might

have to say if you sincerely show that

you are attempting to understand their

perspective no matter how much you

disagree if you do that then you will be

more this leads on to my next step which

is to respect them as a person respect

plays into the actual debate itself you

might consider attacking them with

personal unrelated remarks but this

achieves absolutely nothing try to

acknowledge that the other person is

also a living human with

thoughts and feelings crazy right but

how do I get someone to listen to me

actually and be persuaded by me you

might ask well appeal to their morals

this ties the last two steps together

you’ve established that you understand

them as a person and you’ve established

that you respect their opinions and

beliefs so it’s easier to appeal to what

they already believe in for example you

might know a Democrat who is opposed to

increase military spending you will be

more persuasive if you connect that with

if you connect that with their more

liberal values of maintaining avoiding

harm and caring for others by saying

that an increase in the military budget

will protect and aid those in other

countries that are vulnerable to

violence on the other hand on the other

hand you might also know a Republican

who is opposed to increased taxes

connect with their more conservative

value of Picher patriotism a more

conservative value by suggesting that

it’s their duty to help fellow citizens

through social programs that are funded

by their taxes now these are only two

examples but I find that this works in

most cases today I’m not trying to say

that these steps will get rid of

political order by sickness completely

it won’t but even if it events one

shouting match at the dinner table or

angry comment left on the Facebook post

I’d be happy a sharing of opinions

informs people and widens their mindset

on how their fellow citizens view the

world so when it comes to politics

understand and respect each other

because it’s the least we can do so

going back to our friend Thomas Paine

when he compared arguing with an

unreasonable person to giving dead

people medicine could be right but maybe

just maybe it’s time to bring the dead

back to life thank you [Applause]

Please follow and like us: