Press "Enter" to skip to content

The Acid Test for Biological Science | Cheryl Lancaster | TEDxDurhamUniversity


[Music]

hello everybody thank you very much for

that super welcome as Hamish very kindly

introduced me as I’m going to talk to

you today about fraud and his conduct in

biological sciences so fraud misconduct

aren’t you may be going on for a long

time for example in the 1970s there was

a chap named William Summerlin they said

that he was going to transplant the skin

from black mice onto white mice and

instead he just colored in the black the

white mice with a black marker pen very

good science this the subject i’m going

to talk to you about today and why it’s

called the acid test for Biological

Sciences is something called stop cells

st AP Stat cells and step cells were

cells that we were told about in january

2014 and these cells would apparently be

able to come from anywhere in the body

and we’ll be able to transfer them into

stem cells okay stem cells and all we’d

have to do is a very simple procedure

such as dipping them in acid but it

turns out that this wasn’t right this

wasn’t correct it was fraudulent and

that’s what we’re going to talk about

today am I going to examine it in two

ways we’re going to talk about it by a

replication so carrying out multiple

copies of the same experiment and

through trust as well the trust either

between scientists or between public and

the science so as I mentioned fraud

isn’t something you lots of people have

done studies on fraud as well for

example ferric Fang produce these nice

stats that we’ve got here in front of us

and between 1973 and 2012 there were

2047 articles published in the

biomedical sciences that were attracted

forty-three percent these are attracted

because of either fraud or suspected

fraud so in 2016

after the stat cell saga had come about

we thought it was important to have a

look at how this was affecting stem cell

sites in particular so we did a bit more

number crunching and this is what ferret

Quran came out with for this second

study between nineteen eighty nine and

twenty sixteen there were three thousand

two hundred and forty-four stem cell

articles retracted that’s around two and

a half times more than we would expect

for Biological Sciences as a whole 51%

we’re attracted because of either fraud

or suspected fraud so perhaps there is a

little bit more fraud going on in both

in stem cell science than in biomedical

science perhaps as them as public though

we are more aware of fraud in stem cell

science stem cell size is really

exciting really interesting its new is

cutting edge and a media like to tell us

about it when we have the drama of fraud

mixed into that we get you more excited

about it in the media jump on it so

we’re far more aware a stem cell fraud

so this is the article I wanted to talk

to you about today these are stuck cells

st AP stem cells and step stands for

stimulus triggered acquisition of

pluripotency what on earth does that

mean well it means that we can take

cells from anywhere in the body and

apply a stimulus for example exposure to

a strong acid and this would cause the

cells to revert back to a stem cell-like

state and what this means is that these

cells can then produce any other cell in

the body that’s what the pluripotency

means so that’s what we have we have

cells from anywhere in the body becoming

stem cells through a very quick very

simple very efficient technique and this

was the paper that was published on it

this work was carried out in Japan an

institute called the RIKEN Institute and

this is our lead author this is Heroku /

capita she became as I’ve said on the

slide there an overnight celebrity well

well first and foremost she wasn’t your

stereotypical middle-aged male scientist

she was something fresh and something

new she liked to wear her traditional

Japanese over garments in the lab

instead of her lab coat which we can see

on the image there she was hounded by

the paparazzi when this work came out

the clothes that she wore but the press

conferences sold out across Japan

because people wanted to be like her

truly an overnight celebrity based on

this work that she published so let’s

have a look at exactly what happened to

stop cells then initially the reaction

from the scientific community was great

excitement why well all of a sudden we

had the ability to produce stem cells in

the lab from any other cell very quickly

very easily and very efficiently why was

this important well there were two other

options that are available to scientists

who wanted stem cells capable of doing

this work the first are embryonic stem

cells very difficult to use we’re

talking with regards to ethics with

regards to morals and legally as well in

fact in some countries you can’t use

embryonic stem cells at all so it

completely blocked that line of research

the second option would be to use

induced pluripotent stem cells again

these were developed in Japan in the

early 2000s and in 2012 shinya yamanaka

who is one of the developers of induced

pluripotent stem cells won the Nobel

Prize on what this meant was with again

we could take cells from anywhere in the

body tweak their genetics so that they

would start using genes that they hadn’t

used since they were stem cells put

those back into action and again they

would start becoming stem cells but the

process was inefficient it was

technically difficult and it was long

winded at the moment it wasn’t really an

option for other loves to use this is

why people

excited about stop cells great for

developmental biologists they had a

reason to say that environment affected

our development as well as genetics and

for medicine as well imagine being able

to take a sample from anywhere in the

body of someone turning that sample into

stem cells and then regrowing it into

another organ skin or liver for example

really exciting but a few weeks later we

start to have some problems with these

publications first and foremost we start

to see that people were saying that the

some of the images used weren’t quite

right we had two images for example it

should have come from two separate

experiments but it was in fact the same

image the opposite also occurred where

in fact we had images whether it was

supposed to be from two separate

experiments put together to make it look

as though it was from one so had some

image manipulation problems there later

on we start have more problems where

people are trying to replicate the work

what people trying to replicate it

because it is so exciting they want to

use these stem cells in their lab but

they couldn’t do it and in a few weeks

following at the publication of the

article the one of the original authors

tried to replicate this work in a

different lab and he just couldn’t do it

again another few weeks later and the

some genetic tests were carried out to

see whether the stat cells that over

Carter said she produced were actually

step cells and it turns out that they

weren’t it looks as though they were

already stem cells this isn’t looking

good this isn’t looking good now so

whereas originally people started to try

and replicate this study because they

wanted to use this as a tool in the lab

now they were having to use it as a

challenge they wanted to see whether

over Carter finally agreed to retract

papers this was after people had accused

her of plagiarism in her previous work

and other manipulation problems in her

previous work so the papers were

attracted in the summer and by this time

more than 20 different laboratories had

tried to replicate the results

unsuccessfully so the question is was

over Carter guilty of fraud or

misconduct well let’s have a look at

both replication and Trust and see

whether she was or not so here’s trust

definition there for us to focus on so

we know what we’re talking about there

are two main issues of trust that we

have at the moment and that science

let’s re trust within science and trust

external to science so in science we

have informal and formal measures of

trust where scientists would talk to

each other informally in the coffee room

for example talk about experiments they

were thinking of doing or some

hypothesis that they were planning on

testing and they would expect other

researchers not to pinch those ideas and

go and do them first there’s also the

peer review process for example which is

a more formal method of trust where

researchers are sent for example funding

applications and again aren’t expected

to run off with those ideas and go and

do than themselves or their expects to

give honest critique and feedback

they’re not expected to sabotage someone

else’s work in this peer review process

so that’s trust replication replication

is seen as the cornerstone of scientific

research in theory it is one of the most

important things you can do in

experiments repeat your experiments to

see if you get the same results it’s

very important for confidence in your

results important for reliability

important to demonstrate quality for

example and pretty much every single

researcher on the planet would agree the

replication was important however in

practice not so simple and there are

four reasons for this

firstly if you look at any scientific

paper the method section is really quite

short in comparison to the rest of the

paper it’s not detailed there’s no

nuance on there and that makes anyone

trying to copy this method sorry leaves

anybody with trying to cut to copy this

method in some difficulty because they

don’t know exactly these fine details

and nuances the second problem is that

the resources might not be available for

example if you were testing a drug you

would perhaps test it on very specific

group of patients that’s type of patient

might not be available anymore so you

can’t replicate the test furthermore

another problem is that there might not

be funding available so lack of

resources again no scientists to do it

because you can’t pay them no money to

pay for the equipment so on and so forth

this brings us on to the third problem

with replication and that’s that there

is no motivation from scientists while

my other scientists motivated well

because they can’t get replication

studies published and they can’t get

funding for them funders do not want to

pay for research that has already been

done elsewhere but vacations do not want

to publish research that has already

been done elsewhere everything has to be

new and original and exciting and

cutting-edge there is no place for

replication the fourth reason the last

reason why replication falls down in

science in practical reality is that it

can be seen as a challenge to other

scientists it can be seen as a challenge

to another scientist replicator other

scientists integrity and skill we don’t

want to do that it’s going to cause

great animosity between scientists

between labs even between countries and

it really isn’t where ever want to go

with science we don’t want to create any

animosity in that respect so let’s have

a look at trust and replication in

specifically in the step sell

controversy

first of all the co-authors of a paper

would have had trust in the lead author

they would have carried out their

experiments and they would have had

trusted the lead author with their

results they trusted her not to

misinterpret them or to misrepresent

them in the publications likewise the

lead author would have expected to all

of her collaborators were carrying out

the results that carrying out the

experiments they said they were going to

do and give her those results they’re

also the same peer review trust issues

that I’ve mentioned earlier so trust

that nobody else was going to try and

sabotage for example the publication of

this work because they were doing

something similar what about replication

then well initially as I mentioned the

replication studies started to be

carried out because people wanted to use

this method in their labs they saw it as

really important and exciting in a great

tool but as time went on and we started

to lose trust in the lead researcher we

started to use replication as a

challenge had the author actually

carried out the experiment she said she

had well let’s try and replicate it and

see if we get the same results so the

question remains them was over Carter a

victim of trust and replication in

science and if she was if she was is

this a problem this is a bad thing

hopefully what I’ve managed to establish

here today is that trust in science acts

independently of replication trust

always has to be there trust between

Sciences between scientists and the

public all has to be their replication

though in some ways depends on trust so

what happens with replication is we only

tend to carry out if we want to use a

say

tools in the lab or we carry out as a

challenge to another scientists

integrity and skill signaling that we

don’t trust them so perhaps then we need

to think about this as whether there is

too much trust in science and not enough

replication thank you very much [Applause]

Please follow and like us: