
day morning and decided that you’re
going to learn something new today raise
your right hand please raise your right
hand if you decided to learn something
new now so your other right hand this
this other that’s that’s quite a few
okay that’s a lot I’m guessing the rest
of you came here for the coffee it’s
it’s good coffee so it’s I don’t blame
you so but there are my manners
let me introduce myself my name is Vinay
Menon
I am stand-up comedian and I teach
English to engineering students so most
of you might complain about having a
poorly paying job I have to I used to be
but that’s just the natural progression
right that’s like an evolution of an
Indian right now like you have that
chart of the evolutionary stages of an
Indian it will be like Australopithecus
Homo erectus software engineer Homo
sapiens this so but yeah the question
which I asked you is what I usually ask
my students as well when I go to a class
on an average I have a class length of
around 60 when I ask this question how
many of you woke up today to learn
something new the maximum I’ve gotten so
far is five five students who raised
their hands and in all naive optimism
said I am here to learn something new
now we are doing something really wrong
aren’t we
if people who are coming to an
institution of learning treat learning
as a sort of foreign concept which got
me to ask this one question what is the
point of the education system in India
it’s something which I have been asking
all throughout and now that I am part of
this I ask this once again now you could
be pragmatic and you could give the most
boring response and say that it’s to get
a job and getting educated so I can get
a job oh that’s great what happens if
you get a job or if I get a job I’ll
have financial security I’ll get a good
spouse
I’ll have genetically perfect children
I’ll put them into the education system
and the process continues so in short
the education system is to propagate our
species not very attractive when I say
it like that is it so but then this is
another word which I keep hearing when
people speak of education holistic I
keep seeing that in brochures for
schools and colleges education should be
holistic well at least those schools and
colleges which have a thesaurus use this
way but then what else is education good
for and I got an answer a lot of people
say this it is to create the best minds
in their respective fields so and I
think that’s not far from the truth I
had an opportunity to speak to dr. John
C James he is the former vice chancellor
of mahatma ghandi honesty she said and I
quote the best in India will always be
the best in the world when it comes to
education
now that’s something we can be really
proud about this means students teachers
educators facilitators you name it but
then think about it the best in India
the people who achieve things you have
Nobel laureates you have athletes even
in education they are the best
despite the education system and not
because of it so that’s why I come back
to the original question thank you
that’s I come back to the original
question what is the point of the
education system in India so I don’t
know the answer to this question it’s it
has bugged me for a while but then I can
give you many of you might have asked
the same question as well so I can give
you a fresh perspective which is why I
named this talk three myths of the
Indian education system why three
because it felt like an auspicious
number but these three myths are
supposed to are there so that I can
change your perspective on a few things
and maybe together we can all figure out
what is the point of the education
system in India so to understand the
Indian education system we must go way
back to its origins way back to the
early 1800s back in England when the
Industrial Revolution was in full swing
and the East India Company had just
started their business in India now they
were having the same problem a lot of
married couples do communication so at
that point they did not know how to
communicate with the Indians like
because our culture is so vast and there
are so many languages and so many
customs so they turned to this one man
thomas babington macaulay now my Kalle
they told him to go to India figure out
what’s going on there and to create an
education system so we can teach the
Indians now he was not too happy to come
to India because back then they did not
have Airlines or attractive stewardesses
in fact I believe this photo was taken
as Macaulay was being told he had to go
to India
this does not look happy does he yes
also my collar did come to India and he
wrote after that he went and he
circulated a memorandum which was called
the minute to Indian education and in it
he wrote and I quote it is I believe no
exaggeration to say that all the
historical information which has been
collected from all the books written in
the Sanskrit language is less valuable
than the most paltry abridgements found
in you preparatory schools in England
slight superiority complex in case you
didn’t notice it’s very subtle it’s you
have to look out for it so but then
there was a lot of debate about this few
people opposed this view but then in the
end my colleague got his way and we had
the English Education Act of 1835 this
was implemented primarily so that we can
bridge the gap between the British and
the Indians education was meant to be in
English while primary education and it
was supposed to facilitate one of
McCawley what he said was education
should be utilitarian you can be all
altruistic and say I am learning for the
sake of learning but that’s not what my
colleague wanted he wanted education to
have a purpose and he said it should be
utilitarian and back then the East India
Company needed clocks they needed people
to sit at a desk do as they’re told
without getting too creative sounds
familiar does it not so this brings us
to the first myth I’d like to disprove
the Almighty syllabus so I have a
confession to make I am NOT good with
mathematics I am NOT it’s I had a lot of
friends who are unfortunately good with
mathematics but then in mathematics
every class I sat through we had
teachers who came and told us you’re
going to need this in your real life
ladies and gentlemen let me introduce to
you calculus
I had no idea which aspect of my real
life required integration and
differentiation so but that’s the thing
I studied integration differentiation in
school in college and I did not know the
practical use of it until one month ago
when I was researching for this one talk
so as I was due I went to the place the
holy place of all answers Google and I
was trying to figure out the practical
use of differentiation all I had to do
was type in what is the practical and
the first autofill was what is the
practical use of differentiation this
they introduced me to two frightening
reality is one Google is getting
exceedingly well at reading my mind and
two this is a question a lot of people
ask why am i studying differentiation
why am i studying integration what is
the point of this so but that’s the
thing with our syllabus unless a teacher
tells you you are not going to find out
what it’s used for ask any student
whether they fully understand why they
are studying what they are studying they
really don’t know in most of them at
least unless like I said or and this is
a day and age when you can access
anything on the Internet as clearly
shown but then yes I am NOT don’t get me
wrong I do believe that memorizing a few
things is important because that’s what
our education system is about right
memorizing it’s not about understanding
it’s about how good you remember things
well then that has its disadvantages
well just memorizing and not fully
understanding so for this I have to tell
you about a bit about my college so I
teach in an engineering college and
engineering is a four-year undergraduate
degree so there’s a rule in our College
which goes that if you have caught using
your cell phone if a student is caught
using the cell phone within the college
building it will be confiscated from
them and kept in the principal’s office
and it will only be handed out to them
when they graduate pretty harsh I know
it’s but not that it frequently happens
but it’s the rule
so I went to Wikipedia and got this list
of Android updates and read the popular
mobile phone OS so let me give a
hypothetical scenario let’s assume in
2009 a student started his or her
engineering degree and for in 2009 the
Android version 1.6 was released as
highlighted so unfortunately this person
got their mobile phone news caught in
class because to all students out there
V teachers know you’re using overwhelm
the moment you turn our backs to the
class it’s something we know so it will
be kept in the principal’s office
until 2013 an android kitkat is out
version 4.4 now if you are teaching your
students based on a syllabus which is
all about retention of information
without fully appreciating understanding
and absorbing it they’re going to be as
outdated as that mobile phone sitting in
yeah so and also having a syllabus based
kind of thing revolving around that has
its issues as well what is being taught
which brings us to our second myth art
is not important
so again let me set up a hypothetical
scenario let’s go back thousands of
years back to the era of Stone Age of
cavemen and two mothers are meeting to
Stone Age mothers are meeting and
they’re talking about the subject which
most mothers are interested in their
children so one mother asked the other
so what does your son do oh my son he’s
a hunter and he usually hunts deer but
this month he got a promotion next month
on was he’s going to start hunting
elephant and I’m such a proud mother so
what does your mom son do oh my son he
is completely useless
he says he wants to be an artist does
nothing but sit in the cave and draw on
the walls all day I mean it’s not like
this is going to become a defining
moment in human civilization the
so whether we like to appreciate it or
not art is an integral part of what
makes us human
but remember what I told you what my
colleague said education should be
utilitarian and the use with the east
near company had of the Indians back
then was similar to the use which they
had back in England the Industrial
Revolution was in full swing they needed
people in factories which is why the
syllabus and the education system got
focused on what is known as the STEM
subjects that science technology
engineering and mathematics everything
else got pushed to the side I mean they
didn’t require a poet running around in
factories
so because of this we have a clear
hierarchy when it comes to education it
starts with stem followed closely in
second by humanities those are your
languages history geography economics
etc and way in the bottom you have art
now art is a field which we don’t teach
our kids because you don’t fully
understand it we don’t fully understand
creativity now I’d like to consider
myself an artist lot of real artists out
there are cringing right now but I like
to consider myself an artist and from my
experience I can tell you what
creativity is it’s not about what most
people think it is it’s not about chaos
and instability and drugs
well I asked about the drugs apparently
it’s illegal so it’s about making a
mistake and then learning from it and
making another mistake and then learning
from that and so on and so forth until
maybe if you get it right without any
formal education in arts the kids won’t
have anywhere to go in fact I have a
student I have a student who in order to
impress a girl in his class learned a
song in the shortest duration of time
that is how creative kids can get
depending on rewards of course so but
that’s the thing it’s like I said
creativity is not an important part in
our education system so kids don’t know
whether they are creative they don’t
know what creativity is they don’t know
what they can be creative in and of
course they are not allowed to make
mistakes in our education system brings
us to myth number three discipline
requires punishment so now let me tell
you about this man Wendell Johnson now
Wendell Johnson Wendell Johnson was a
psychologist and he conducted in back in
1939 in u.s. he conducted a study which
was later called the monster study what
he did was he took 22 orphans and he
divided them into two groups of 11 each
one group he gave them positive
reinforcement
in speech therapy he gave them
compliments he praised them and rewarded
them for having made effort the other
group the other 11 he gave them negative
reinforcement he belittled them he made
fun of them the group which got negative
reinforcement not only did not improve
on their speech impediments they started
developing new speech impediments some
which lasted their entire lives hence
the term wants to study so this is the
thing this is how our education system
treats our kids they are not allowed to
make a mistake and therefore they are
afraid too when I walked in here and I
asked you a question whether you are how
many of you are ready to learn most of
you started squirming in your seats and
looking next to the side as in like this
was not part of the brochure what’s he
talking about because you are afraid to
make a mistake same with my kids they
are afraid to make mistakes because I
have to go back to the philosophy of
Socrates Socrates was a man who said
that we should always question
everything inwardly and outwardly and
for his trouble he was imprisoned and
executed because authority doesn’t like
too many questions refer East India
Company so Socrates were someone who
said that we should always question
everything and I agree I do not believe
that there is such a thing known as a
silly question
there are silly intentions yes but there
is no such thing as a silly question
which brings me back to my original
question what is the point of the
education system in India again like I
said I don’t know the answer maybe I
could have helped you come closer to the
answer but now I told you what it
doesn’t do
it doesn’t help our children in order to
change the education system there’s
going to be a lot of effort from all of
us someone else is not going to do it we
eat it’s up to us
I know what you are going to say it’s a
lot of effort it’s a lot of you know
things which you have to put from our
side but isn’t that what we expect from
our kids isn’t that what we extra mile
kids in an education system which is
actively holding them at bay because I
don’t know about you I would like to
live in a
future a future that I walk into a class
and I ask them so how many of you woke
up today morning I decided to learn
something new and instead of five hands
going up I’d like to have at least six
hands going up thank you [Applause]