Press "Enter" to skip to content

The 3 Myths of the Indian Education System | Vinay Menon | TEDxThiruvananthapuram


how many of you walk

day morning and decided that you’re

going to learn something new today raise

your right hand please raise your right

hand if you decided to learn something

new now so your other right hand this

this other that’s that’s quite a few

okay that’s a lot I’m guessing the rest

of you came here for the coffee it’s

it’s good coffee so it’s I don’t blame

you so but there are my manners

let me introduce myself my name is Vinay

Menon

I am stand-up comedian and I teach

English to engineering students so most

of you might complain about having a

poorly paying job I have to I used to be

but that’s just the natural progression

right that’s like an evolution of an

Indian right now like you have that

chart of the evolutionary stages of an

Indian it will be like Australopithecus

Homo erectus software engineer Homo

sapiens this so but yeah the question

which I asked you is what I usually ask

my students as well when I go to a class

on an average I have a class length of

around 60 when I ask this question how

many of you woke up today to learn

something new the maximum I’ve gotten so

far is five five students who raised

their hands and in all naive optimism

said I am here to learn something new

now we are doing something really wrong

aren’t we

if people who are coming to an

institution of learning treat learning

as a sort of foreign concept which got

me to ask this one question what is the

point of the education system in India

it’s something which I have been asking

all throughout and now that I am part of

this I ask this once again now you could

be pragmatic and you could give the most

boring response and say that it’s to get

a job and getting educated so I can get

a job oh that’s great what happens if

you get a job or if I get a job I’ll

have financial security I’ll get a good

spouse

I’ll have genetically perfect children

I’ll put them into the education system

and the process continues so in short

the education system is to propagate our

species not very attractive when I say

it like that is it so but then this is

another word which I keep hearing when

people speak of education holistic I

keep seeing that in brochures for

schools and colleges education should be

holistic well at least those schools and

colleges which have a thesaurus use this

way but then what else is education good

for and I got an answer a lot of people

say this it is to create the best minds

in their respective fields so and I

think that’s not far from the truth I

had an opportunity to speak to dr. John

C James he is the former vice chancellor

of mahatma ghandi honesty she said and I

quote the best in India will always be

the best in the world when it comes to

education

now that’s something we can be really

proud about this means students teachers

educators facilitators you name it but

then think about it the best in India

the people who achieve things you have

Nobel laureates you have athletes even

in education they are the best

despite the education system and not

because of it so that’s why I come back

to the original question thank you

that’s I come back to the original

question what is the point of the

education system in India so I don’t

know the answer to this question it’s it

has bugged me for a while but then I can

give you many of you might have asked

the same question as well so I can give

you a fresh perspective which is why I

named this talk three myths of the

Indian education system why three

because it felt like an auspicious

number but these three myths are

supposed to are there so that I can

change your perspective on a few things

and maybe together we can all figure out

what is the point of the education

system in India so to understand the

Indian education system we must go way

back to its origins way back to the

early 1800s back in England when the

Industrial Revolution was in full swing

and the East India Company had just

started their business in India now they

were having the same problem a lot of

married couples do communication so at

that point they did not know how to

communicate with the Indians like

because our culture is so vast and there

are so many languages and so many

customs so they turned to this one man

thomas babington macaulay now my Kalle

they told him to go to India figure out

what’s going on there and to create an

education system so we can teach the

Indians now he was not too happy to come

to India because back then they did not

have Airlines or attractive stewardesses

in fact I believe this photo was taken

as Macaulay was being told he had to go

to India

this does not look happy does he yes

also my collar did come to India and he

wrote after that he went and he

circulated a memorandum which was called

the minute to Indian education and in it

he wrote and I quote it is I believe no

exaggeration to say that all the

historical information which has been

collected from all the books written in

the Sanskrit language is less valuable

than the most paltry abridgements found

in you preparatory schools in England

slight superiority complex in case you

didn’t notice it’s very subtle it’s you

have to look out for it so but then

there was a lot of debate about this few

people opposed this view but then in the

end my colleague got his way and we had

the English Education Act of 1835 this

was implemented primarily so that we can

bridge the gap between the British and

the Indians education was meant to be in

English while primary education and it

was supposed to facilitate one of

McCawley what he said was education

should be utilitarian you can be all

altruistic and say I am learning for the

sake of learning but that’s not what my

colleague wanted he wanted education to

have a purpose and he said it should be

utilitarian and back then the East India

Company needed clocks they needed people

to sit at a desk do as they’re told

without getting too creative sounds

familiar does it not so this brings us

to the first myth I’d like to disprove

the Almighty syllabus so I have a

confession to make I am NOT good with

mathematics I am NOT it’s I had a lot of

friends who are unfortunately good with

mathematics but then in mathematics

every class I sat through we had

teachers who came and told us you’re

going to need this in your real life

ladies and gentlemen let me introduce to

you calculus

I had no idea which aspect of my real

life required integration and

differentiation so but that’s the thing

I studied integration differentiation in

school in college and I did not know the

practical use of it until one month ago

when I was researching for this one talk

so as I was due I went to the place the

holy place of all answers Google and I

was trying to figure out the practical

use of differentiation all I had to do

was type in what is the practical and

the first autofill was what is the

practical use of differentiation this

they introduced me to two frightening

reality is one Google is getting

exceedingly well at reading my mind and

two this is a question a lot of people

ask why am i studying differentiation

why am i studying integration what is

the point of this so but that’s the

thing with our syllabus unless a teacher

tells you you are not going to find out

what it’s used for ask any student

whether they fully understand why they

are studying what they are studying they

really don’t know in most of them at

least unless like I said or and this is

a day and age when you can access

anything on the Internet as clearly

shown but then yes I am NOT don’t get me

wrong I do believe that memorizing a few

things is important because that’s what

our education system is about right

memorizing it’s not about understanding

it’s about how good you remember things

well then that has its disadvantages

well just memorizing and not fully

understanding so for this I have to tell

you about a bit about my college so I

teach in an engineering college and

engineering is a four-year undergraduate

degree so there’s a rule in our College

which goes that if you have caught using

your cell phone if a student is caught

using the cell phone within the college

building it will be confiscated from

them and kept in the principal’s office

and it will only be handed out to them

when they graduate pretty harsh I know

it’s but not that it frequently happens

but it’s the rule

so I went to Wikipedia and got this list

of Android updates and read the popular

mobile phone OS so let me give a

hypothetical scenario let’s assume in

2009 a student started his or her

engineering degree and for in 2009 the

Android version 1.6 was released as

highlighted so unfortunately this person

got their mobile phone news caught in

class because to all students out there

V teachers know you’re using overwhelm

the moment you turn our backs to the

class it’s something we know so it will

be kept in the principal’s office

until 2013 an android kitkat is out

version 4.4 now if you are teaching your

students based on a syllabus which is

all about retention of information

without fully appreciating understanding

and absorbing it they’re going to be as

outdated as that mobile phone sitting in

yeah so and also having a syllabus based

kind of thing revolving around that has

its issues as well what is being taught

which brings us to our second myth art

is not important

so again let me set up a hypothetical

scenario let’s go back thousands of

years back to the era of Stone Age of

cavemen and two mothers are meeting to

Stone Age mothers are meeting and

they’re talking about the subject which

most mothers are interested in their

children so one mother asked the other

so what does your son do oh my son he’s

a hunter and he usually hunts deer but

this month he got a promotion next month

on was he’s going to start hunting

elephant and I’m such a proud mother so

what does your mom son do oh my son he

is completely useless

he says he wants to be an artist does

nothing but sit in the cave and draw on

the walls all day I mean it’s not like

this is going to become a defining

moment in human civilization the

so whether we like to appreciate it or

not art is an integral part of what

makes us human

but remember what I told you what my

colleague said education should be

utilitarian and the use with the east

near company had of the Indians back

then was similar to the use which they

had back in England the Industrial

Revolution was in full swing they needed

people in factories which is why the

syllabus and the education system got

focused on what is known as the STEM

subjects that science technology

engineering and mathematics everything

else got pushed to the side I mean they

didn’t require a poet running around in

factories

so because of this we have a clear

hierarchy when it comes to education it

starts with stem followed closely in

second by humanities those are your

languages history geography economics

etc and way in the bottom you have art

now art is a field which we don’t teach

our kids because you don’t fully

understand it we don’t fully understand

creativity now I’d like to consider

myself an artist lot of real artists out

there are cringing right now but I like

to consider myself an artist and from my

experience I can tell you what

creativity is it’s not about what most

people think it is it’s not about chaos

and instability and drugs

well I asked about the drugs apparently

it’s illegal so it’s about making a

mistake and then learning from it and

making another mistake and then learning

from that and so on and so forth until

maybe if you get it right without any

formal education in arts the kids won’t

have anywhere to go in fact I have a

student I have a student who in order to

impress a girl in his class learned a

song in the shortest duration of time

that is how creative kids can get

depending on rewards of course so but

that’s the thing it’s like I said

creativity is not an important part in

our education system so kids don’t know

whether they are creative they don’t

know what creativity is they don’t know

what they can be creative in and of

course they are not allowed to make

mistakes in our education system brings

us to myth number three discipline

requires punishment so now let me tell

you about this man Wendell Johnson now

Wendell Johnson Wendell Johnson was a

psychologist and he conducted in back in

1939 in u.s. he conducted a study which

was later called the monster study what

he did was he took 22 orphans and he

divided them into two groups of 11 each

one group he gave them positive

reinforcement

in speech therapy he gave them

compliments he praised them and rewarded

them for having made effort the other

group the other 11 he gave them negative

reinforcement he belittled them he made

fun of them the group which got negative

reinforcement not only did not improve

on their speech impediments they started

developing new speech impediments some

which lasted their entire lives hence

the term wants to study so this is the

thing this is how our education system

treats our kids they are not allowed to

make a mistake and therefore they are

afraid too when I walked in here and I

asked you a question whether you are how

many of you are ready to learn most of

you started squirming in your seats and

looking next to the side as in like this

was not part of the brochure what’s he

talking about because you are afraid to

make a mistake same with my kids they

are afraid to make mistakes because I

have to go back to the philosophy of

Socrates Socrates was a man who said

that we should always question

everything inwardly and outwardly and

for his trouble he was imprisoned and

executed because authority doesn’t like

too many questions refer East India

Company so Socrates were someone who

said that we should always question

everything and I agree I do not believe

that there is such a thing known as a

silly question

there are silly intentions yes but there

is no such thing as a silly question

which brings me back to my original

question what is the point of the

education system in India again like I

said I don’t know the answer maybe I

could have helped you come closer to the

answer but now I told you what it

doesn’t do

it doesn’t help our children in order to

change the education system there’s

going to be a lot of effort from all of

us someone else is not going to do it we

eat it’s up to us

I know what you are going to say it’s a

lot of effort it’s a lot of you know

things which you have to put from our

side but isn’t that what we expect from

our kids isn’t that what we extra mile

kids in an education system which is

actively holding them at bay because I

don’t know about you I would like to

live in a

future a future that I walk into a class

and I ask them so how many of you woke

up today morning I decided to learn

something new and instead of five hands

going up I’d like to have at least six

hands going up thank you [Applause]

Please follow and like us: