Press "Enter" to skip to content

TEDxWhitehallWomen Dan Susman | Dan Susman | TEDxWhitehallWomen


is it possible to make an anti-war film
I first asked myself that question many
years ago talking to the great film
editor Walter Murch about a scene in a
film here edited called jarhead the US
Marines are psyching themselves up for
battle by watching Apocalypse Now
specifically they’re watching the
sequence where the helicopters bomb a
village to the thrilling music of
vogner’s ride of the Valkyrie now Walter
Murch found it peculiar to edit this
scene because he had also been the
editor of the original Apocalypse Now
but what was even more peculiar was that
Apocalypse Now is obviously intended to
be an anti-war film if it’s about
anything it’s about the horror and the
chaos of war yet the jarhead scene was
inspired by real events sometimes US
Marines really did watch Apocalypse Now
before going into battle how could a
film with such a blatant message end up
being used for precisely the opposite
purpose for which it was intended how
could a deafening wake-up call against
war end up being heard as a call to arms
this is the question I’d like to explore
today I have some experience of it
myself in 2015 which in terms of
politics filled about a hundred years
ago now but in 2015 one of the big
issues was should Britain leave the
European Convention on Human Rights now
I was making films for the Guardian as I
still am and as there were so many
obvious benefits to the European
Convention I had the idea of adapting
the sketch from Monty Python’s Life of
Brian what have the Romans ever done for
us what has the European Convention on
Human Rights ever done for us apart from
freedom from slavery freedom from
torture peace in Northern Ireland but
apart from that
Patrick Stewart is a passionate defender
of the European Convention and he very
kindly agreed to star in it and the film
culminates in the revelation that the
European Convention wasn’t foisted on
the British by Europe on the contrary
Britain more or less wrote the European
Convention on Human Rights to protect
Europe
this is Britain the land of Magna Carta
we invented human rights for God’s sake
we should be writing our own Bill of
Rights and posting it on the Europeans
ah let’s see how they like it then we’ve
already done that actually what well
after we won the war British legal
experts did draft a bill of Human Rights
to help Europe sort itself out you know
protect people from abuses of state
power that kind of thing oh yeah you
sure oh yeah oh that’s good what’s it
called the European Convention on Human
Rights
oh off the film was a great success
with over 35 million views and it felt
that seemed as if we had found a bridge
a way to connect a really important
message to millions of people but had we
really got the message across or where
we only preaching to the converted so it
was interesting to read the online
comments roughly half said that they
loved it but the other half said over
and over again this is rubbish Britain
is the land of Magna Carta we invented
human rights for Christ’s sake which was
frustrating they didn’t disagree with
the argument which would have been fine
they were completely oblivious to the
argument now clearly some of the people
hadn’t watched the film to the end but
others complained over and over again
about love ease and elite lefties
telling people what to think so it
seemed that for people who had already
made up their mind a film whose message
was to support the European Convention
on Human Rights was further evidence for
its disavowal how could a film produced
the opposite of its intention how could
the Marines come away from Apocalypse
Now feeling ready for battle according
to Dan kahan professor of psychology and
law at Yale audiences are affected more
by emotion and by feelings of group
identity than they are by rational
argument the film made the argument that
people who wanted to leave the European
Convention were being ridiculous
so perhaps those people felt the sting
of ridicule and tuned out of the
argument just as the Marines latched on
to the most emotionally resonant aspect
of Apocalypse Now the thrill and the
spectacle while completely missing the
point so where does that leave us with
an anti-war film always insidiously
promote war because it’s it will always
have spectacle and thrill well
fortunately the answer is no there are
exceptions and a great recent example
timbuktu hisako’s masterpiece about the
tragedy of violent fundamentalism coming
to Mali the the topic is brutal but the
film itself is not full of explosions
and violence instead it’s incredibly
serene a football match plays out in
balletic slow-motion and because the
fundamentalists have banned footballs
the game has to be a potent they’re
playing without a ball but imagine how
how differently origins how differently
the audience would feel if if instead
they played with a ball and suddenly
were moaned down horrific ly by a
machine-gun
so in this way we can see that the
medium itself is the message or at least
the style the tone the genre becomes the
message as Nietzsche once said and as
Luke Skywalker discovered fighting Darth
Vader he who fights monsters should be
careful lest he thereby become a monster
why as Jedi put it even better your
focus determines your reality watching
the beautiful dystopia of Blade Runner
2049 I had the eerie sensation that by
experiencing it so viscerally we were
unwittingly willing ourselves closer to
that possible future reality
practitioners of CBT and visualization
techniques tell us that I must give up
smoking is a bad mantra because you’re
still ultimately focused on smoking
better instead to imagine how healthy
you feel having already given up what
you see is what you get so if we apply
that to the human rights film perhaps if
we actually want to persuade people to
embrace the European Convention on Human
Rights maybe we need to promote it and
portray it in a positive and heroic
light rather than ridiculing its
detractors however rational that may be
or then again maybe we’re asking too
much from film maybe Susan Sontag got it
right in her 1966 essay against
interpretation if you have a message if
you have something to say
just go ahead and say it art is not for
messages it’s for exploring it’s not for
rational argument is for exposing deep
human truths if we had just said if we
just written the sentence Britain wrote
the European Convention on Human Rights
so let’s be proudly British and
continued to be bound by our own
invention then we probably would have
had less ambiguity but then again we
probably would have had probably
wouldn’t have been able to persuade 35
million people to read that sentence so
I don’t pretend to have all the answers
but I am thinking about the question in
my film about segregation in Northern
Ireland 90% of children in Northern
Ireland are still educated in what are
effectively segregated schools Catholic
and Protestant but I don’t want to focus
on the the segregation and the
alienation instead I’m setting the film
in one of the forward-looking integrated
schools the bridge that I want the
audience to cross is one that directs
their focus their attention less on the
pain of the problem and more on their
the hope and the possibility of
achieving the solution
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: