Press "Enter" to skip to content

Technology and Control | Bart Preneel | TEDxPatras


[Music]
[Music]
candy maker says signo me then velour
indica so my talk will be in English and
I want to speak to you about technology
and control our society is being changed
by technology and I would say for many
aspects for the better things are much
more convenient information is
accessible everywhere we don’t get lost
and our smartphones have become our
friends today I want to talk about the
flip side of the metal is that we
believe we are controlling technology
but to some extent technology is
controlling us and let’s just go back to
a mystery I grew up in the 60s in the
60s Europe had an Iron Curtain and it
was nowhere as visible as in Berlin
where there was a wall separating East
and West and in school I was thought we
are the good guys and they’re the bad
guys because we are free and they’re not
free to travel they’re being surveilled
all the time in East Berlin there was
Stassi and Stasi was a police who kept
files on everybody and was watching
everybody’s lives and they were using
friends and family members colleagues to
watch and everybody was suspicious and
if you want to see what it means in
practice I recommend you watch the movie
the life of others where this is
explained in full detail and you can
feel it better
we’ll come back to this later so every
moment you search something on the
internet or you said a message to
whatsapp or iMessage or Skype or for the
paranoid among you to a signal or you
upload information in social media all
this data ends up in the cloud and the
cloud this is a large number of
computers controlled by large implant
corporations where they collect all your
data and they do this to give you
services
but of course they also do other things
with this data and the cloud is seen as
something very positive and convenient
but I’d like you to take the view of
which is Salman the father of the free
software movement and he said the cloud
is somebody else’s a computer so your
data is not on your computers it’s
somebody else’s computers and somebody
else is in control
there is massive amounts of data we are
producing today and I will not have time
to go to all the details in the slides
but just in one minute 240 thousand
photos are uploaded on Facebook 350
thousand tweets are being sent 400 hours
per minute are uploaded on YouTube so
even if 700 thousand hours I watched
every minute we’ll never be able in our
lives to watch everything on YouTube so
there is a massive amount of data being
processed in this magic cloud and of
course we’re going further because we
creating smart cities and I wrote that
also Patras is going this way many
cities try to put sensors everywhere to
detect weather information
traffic information where people are
what is happening in town where there is
big events and of course it can be very
convenient to organize things but of
course it can also be very intrusive and
in general we are watching a deployment
of technology called the Internet of
Things where every object will be on the
Internet
some people say in a few years there
will be 20 billion devices obviously 200
billion but it’s many more than today
because today only 4 or 5 billion
devices are on the Internet
and they will be in our cities in our
cars in our homes and I think in 10
years also in our bodies we will all be
on the internet all the time and you can
decide not to have a smartphone or to
give your smartphone at home or you can
decide not to have a Facebook account
but the IOT will be unavoidable very
intrusive and stealthy so the legal ID
of you can opt out if you don’t like it
will be gone because the
we went to opt out will be not to go to
the city or not to enter a car and of
course the IOT will produce lots of data
this is known already for many years as
the Big Data revolution more and more
data is being collected at very high
speed high variety and enormous volumes
as I showed you and people believe that
by analyzing this data we can make a
society better we can improve health we
can improve traffic we can improve
government so there is many positive
sides to this do I want to show is that
there is also negative sides to this one
of the big data systems you’ve been part
of already for a while at least if
you’re on the Internet is the
advertising ecosystem and I will just
use here record by Andrew Levis if
you’re not paying for it
you’re not the customer you’re the
product being sold and in fact all
services on the internet or most are for
free but in fact what you do is you pay
with your data and this data is used to
generate advertising revenue in the tens
of billions of dollars all based on your
data and the slide behind me show is a
very complex ecosystem because you may
think only of the big companies but also
hundreds and thousands of small
companies are processing your data every
time you visit the website every time
you post a tweet every time you upload
the photo and this ecosystem goes from
advertisers companies who want to sell
things to publishers like newspapers or
companies with websites and process your
data to show you the optimal
advertisement and this is how money is
being made today on the Internet
so there is a first problem with this
and it has been identified as the filter
bubble you have the impression in the
internet that you can see and find
everything but in fact what you see and
find is very confined Google only finds
a very small fraction of the Internet or
what you see in your news feeds is very
much bias and has narrows you view on
the world and so this is down because of
the way companies do it this way they
will get more clicks and mortar
and more attention they try to optimize
their revenue at the costs of narrowing
your view and so while you think the
internet would be people together what
we see is that we see more polarization
as a consequence of this filter bubble
problem there is more problems because
as humans we should know by now if we
build big systems they go wrong and you
see here behind me an oil disaster we
also have seen unfortunately the nuclear
disaster in Japan so as humans we always
believe that our systems will be good
but turns out that the bigger the
systems the bigger they fail and if you
have time I invite you to go and look at
this website you’ll get the slides
information is beautiful and then you
see all the biggest breaches of the last
year in a very visual way
the bigger the breach the bigger the
bubble and it’s always about tens and
hundreds of millions of data items so in
the last week’s in the news was Equifax
in the US we’ve also seen anthem a
health care provider we’ve seen MySpace
the old social network we’ve seen Yahoo
we’ve also seen dating sites or sites
for people wanting an affair and they
all lose their data by the tens of
millions I’m an engineer I don’t
understand this if we can’t protect data
why do we allow people to collect it
because eventually if we collect data it
will be end up in the wild that seems to
be what we are seeing and maybe step
back and think about this as pollution
when I grew up the rivers were polluted
and the sky was black like we now see in
big cities in China and India and
apparently pollution now is less visible
but it’s still there there’s just
different pollution but pollution is the
consequence of individual benefits I
give car I get some product but
everybody else suffers for my individual
benefits and I gave this talk last week
and somebody made a very nice cartoon
which is actually much better than my
picture which actually shows how all our
data we produce in our social networks
and our
IOT systems actually it’s polluting the
environment and so maybe we should think
more about data as pollution and
actually reduce data we spread and avoid
abuse of this data there is not an actor
and this is the government and to be
honest most people didn’t know too much
about this but thanks to this guy most
of us have someone heard of what’s
happening at the government side I guess
you all heard of Edward Snowden
so he actually leads many documents
showing what governments are often Adame
the US government but also the UK
government and many other governments
and more or less he civilized their
slogan as collected all collect all
information you can get know-it-all and
exploit it all who has an iPhone here so
it’s very nice because the NSA makes
slides about iPhones it saves me time to
make my own slides I can do more
productive things in life
this is slides don’t buy the NSA and
they say who knew in 1984 that this
would be Big Brother and the zombies
would be paying customers let me repeat
that the NSA calls the iPhone users
public zombies who pay for their own
surveillance and is the same for Android
users by the way there is no difference
you’re also public zombies who pay for
your own surveillance so I think if you
look at the privacy debate in globally
what we see we have three major players
because so far I told mostly about
industry with them is also government
and in Europe we tend to trust our
governments most of us do at least or
trust them more we tend to distress the
companies but actually in the u.s. it’s
the other way around now what we see
with technology is that it was switch
collecting big data in the streets
collecting IOT data and imagery is
creating advertise with ecosystems what
we learned from this node
is that the government’s go to industry
and ask for this information and this is
one of the programs is the prison
program it’s very well named
it shows the government has a few and
what’s happening in all the data in the
cloud and so the government has now lost
the incentive to stop companies from
collecting data because the more data
companies collect the more data
government has as well and so think now
back up my story what we built now is
something which was called by the
apologist Jeremy Bentham the panopticon
he designed a long time ago at the end
of the 18th century a prison where the
guards would be watching the prisoners
all the time and the idea was if people
I watched all the time they will behave
properly in the 19th century these
prisons were built two of them in the UK
and guess what people didn’t like them
because we don’t like to be watched all
the time and it can be abused by
governments for discrimination being
watched all the time instills fear being
watched all the time makes you behave
properly because if you don’t behave
properly maybe your kids will not be
allowed to go to a certain university or
maybe you will not get insurance anymore
or maybe you will not get the job you
wanted and so it can be abused heavily
by government so it has shifted the
power from individual to government and
if you think of Stasi
the Stasi could only have dreamt of such
a system so it’s very strange in the 70s
I’m told that the Stasi is terrible and
I wake up 40 years later and in fact we
see that our governments and industry
have built exactly the system the Stasi
could only dream of isn’t that bizarre
so what we told the citizens is that to
get security we have to give up your
privacy and I could give a lot of talk
about this but I don’t have the time but
I think this cartoon shows that
transforming privacy the security is not
a very pleasant experience
I don’t think this family will be very
happy in their home afterwards so this
sounds all very gloomy and doomy
[Music]
Karl Popper said optimism is a moral
duty we should believe we can do
something about this and I think the
first point I use actually the palace of
knossos as an example architecture is
politics the way the Internet is
architected and organized with
everything going to central places in
the cloud it’s political decision and we
can actually build an internet where
data stays local and a good example is a
Skype Skype was a European company
offering telephony services with no
central servers but what happened to
Skype it was bought by a US company it
was made centralized so by having such
centralized systems you become
vulnerable to failure by hacks by other
nation states and by data breaches so
what we should do is rethink the
internet and stop putting all our data
in the cloud it’s not very smart to do
this and it’s actually possible to do it
differently so think of the smart phone
here this has 50 times more power than a
great computer from the 80s
yet the smartphone industry tries to
convince me that this phone is too
stupid to actually tell somebody which
advertisement I want to see but I want
to see something for a trip or for a car
or for some other service no this has to
be done in the cloud why can’t my phone
decide that and tell the cloud show this
guy this kind of advertisement so we
should keep data local those machines
are powerful enough to keep our data
under our control in our devices
sometimes you have to pull data and it’s
a bit technical but I’m a cryptographer
and we’ve invented in the last decades
of magic where you can encrypt your data
protect your data in the cloud and still
get value out of it’s still compute on
the data without showing your data to
any mode so this is something which was
science fiction 20 or 30 years ago but
it’s actually reality today
and finally I think we have to have open
systems we should really
think of the Internet as an open
infrastructure is the basis of our
society it should not be based on
secrets and if you think what Internet
has done in fact on the Internet
the powerful ro page you don’t know what
the big companies and governments are
doing it’s a secret
it happens in their big computers and
they can’t tell you or they don’t want
to tell you
well you as a user you’re completely
transparent because everything you do is
being traced and followed and if you
think about this it should be the other
way around
the powerful should be transparent and
the user should have some privacy that’s
the kind of society we want to build
that’s the kind of society I think we
invented in the Enlightenment and we
worked very hard to develop this and
with technology we kind of turned the
tables in a few decades time I think the
main message is we can actually turn
this around so my generation witnessed
the Internet as a fantastic big machine
developing with billions of devices in
the cloud but somehow we mess up we did
it and bet the society values of Europe
in the internet we let other countries
other continents put their values in our
social infrastructure in our networks so
the next generation and I’m happy to
help you we should rethink things build
new IT infrastructures which are
distributed they will be hanged less and
they will protect our data more and at
the Euro object I delete there to
actually create open systems where the
powerful are transparent and we get our
privacy thank you very much for your
attention
[Music]
you
[Music]
Please follow and like us: