Press "Enter" to skip to content

Taxes. You may have missed that but the rules have changed. | Galina Akchurina | TEDxMoscow


[applause]
isn’t it strange
only doctors are not important for curious
you do not know the phrase inevitable death
taxes and I think you all learned a fragment
from the movie
meet joe black where beautiful brad
pitt who played the role of death came for
successful entrepreneur anthony hopkins
and decided to linger on this land for
in order to understand what we have here
there is this piece of advice
Directors in an American company are very
Well shows what are the base
factors that determine our rules
games but above all this is of course death
because our earthly life course and
we need to have time to understand ourselves and
realize all your abilities to
creativity and here you have to be unexpected
be able to be creative to be able to overcome
some kind of taboo barriers and then in general
then everything will work out but you need to remember
that is, those rules are in
Generally it can not break it is legal
those rules that are set and
coercive force provided
states and we are with you today
let’s talk about taxes i think that many
of you watching this video so about yourself
thought well, we of course heard that there
them death taxes this thing is inevitable
but we don’t have the usual phrase
they say what we say
the law is that the pole well you know how to twist
do you want as much as the state politely
saying don’t take
without legal grounds, its not
come back and it defines some rules
games when we live in enough
aggressive society where we are trying to
general there do not abide by the basic rules i
I want to tell you that in the Russian
federations are also taxes and this is inevitable
and the rules of the game for the last few
years have changed a lot let’s
let’s start with a boring story like
statistics in 2010 decision which
taken on a dispute between
taxpayers and tax
bodies were
40 43 percent in all other cases
taxpayers won now by
official statistics published for
first quarter of the 18th year 83 percent in
tax authorities favor
why does this happen well let’s first
let’s deal with what is really
the rules of the game have changed and in general
why shy away from paying taxes
such a story is the worst case you lose
money can be for your business
financial death will come worst
it will end up in jail and in
in some situations it is inevitable for
all like this sometimes people somehow up
so far it seems unobvious at all my
work to protect
taxpayer I speak in courts
protecting them in the tax authorities
but I understand very well that the best
protection is informing because
when you know the rules of the game there we are
all adults you yourself take
open-eyed solution let’s
let’s see what typical thinks
entrepreneur when it comes
about taxes
even if everything goes bad, well I
I will do well, I will leave the company and in the end
I’ll start again in the fourteenth year
the first bell rang
royal water when venture in
checkout time, I understand that they will not pay
those taxes that accrued food created
near the same company with another
legal form perry
entered into a contract and legal friend
other tax payer tax
body applying article 45 nkr came in
this is a new legal entity and sought
through court those taxes
who were not paid abandoned
companies you quit company with us
considered to be almost normal
entrepreneurial practice were
other cases when during tax
checks people understand that these taxes are not
will pay too much burden and
passed on
no property and do not withdraw money
just the staff went to another
the company
perry contracts were made and no
formal grounds for applying
here is this 45 article and coming into this new
the company seemed not to have happened
doing bargaining growth of experience no matter what
name is a fait accompli to it
can be treated differently even lawyers
to this in different ways but it refers to this
the companies that this
perry staff has concluded
treaties and it was established that it was
done at the initiative of the person who
in general, went bankrupt
and don’t forget his taxes on him all
charged further what he thinks
entrepreneur ok
if so everything happens but at the end
I’m risking only
property of the company my property no one
touches well here is this illusion in many ways
dispelled
conditioned court of the russian federation in
December seventeenth year by so
called the Ahmadiyev case and this is the main one
accountant
I found it possible in the case of
impossibility of an enterprise to recover
taxes and it is recognized that the person is guilty of
that taxes are not paid to the state
only from the head but from the main
accountant and in some cases financial
directors
of those who will be recognized as controlling
face to collect these taxes by
to certain rules but to claim what
entrepreneurs think
we live there we understand the rules of the game we
now we put the nominal director and
then in general, well, contact him
There is such experience year through three
well known classics you
also all remember what is the position
if you opened
Well, God forbid, horns and hooves but it
no matter there is december 17 very much so
we had a fruitful end of the year plenum
supreme court responsibility
controlling persons in case of this
enterprises go bankrupt and not only
if this nominee director
even if you hold no position
nowhere to glow will testify that on
actually managed by management
decisions were made by others and will call
their surnames will be proportionally
decrease the size of his personalized
responsibility including due to
personal property property beyond
property limits of a legal entity
which can be levied
how else do people think that in principle
Of course , this little world is big
where people like to keep their savings
anywhere in the british virgin
islands somewhere else in some familiar
all jurisdictions so he is at the end
all you can bring something beyond
Russian Federation
here, too, is not so simple Russian
the federation has joined the international
conventions from the eighteenth to
automatically exchange information with
number of countries in the world 83 countries in this world
will provide information on all
hits
open to Russian citizens remnants
on accounts and companies that
controlled by Russian citizens a
point requests Russian tax
organs get a lot of volume
information including enough
intimate who controls how who
appoints and stuff why because
the whole world is concerned with the problem of fighting
tax declination is
international plan to fight against
erosion
tax base erosion is a common problem
everyone here helps each other therefore
here, too, does not really work
if something else still works then
these are just a few years and while checking
we are held backdating 3 years
back a criminal
up to 10 years depth checking like everything
people think but in the end they won’t see
Well, I can conclude maybe my contractor
it will be normal somewhere there is a lot
operations a bunch of participants won’t see it
also the illusion of science and technology has not passed
only global companies
but also to the tax authorities, I think that everything
heard about such an information complex
how ahiska vat 2
it is on the information system
which is in automatic mode
shows essentially all your operations
if someone bought immediately mirrored
should relate to what someone sold if
there is a gap someone showed revenue
expense did not show revenue immediately
automatically generated request for
control procedure begins to break
and the control procedure is serious if
appointed check queen
evidence for what became
interrogations are actually interrogating everyone
starting simply with a cleaner literally
This word drivers popular subjects
for interrogations and generally according to the instructions
jointly issued federal tax
service and investigative committee
begin to interrogate
laid-off employees who may
to be some kind of resentment and other
it is necessary to part with people well but
This is not the case. There is also expertise.
there are inspections and a request for information from you and
your counterparty
what i am talking about is that thought
our information society with
the development of technology that something is not
you can see it is an illusion and you can see it
business about all and now very much
developed such a procedure as a pretrial
before verification tax preparation
bodies generally shy away from paying
taxes in general, it becomes more and more
and more is impossible but when i talk about
This percentage of 83 percent is not in favor
taxpayers deal with
Moreover, almost all checks productive I
I do not see the joy you have but it’s the same
well when we fight declension from
payment of taxes with the withdrawal of money in offshore
using both anal anal
okay but there is no joy why let’s
let’s figure it out
what is the basic tax claim
bodies to all entrepreneurs
she is called so bad faith
getting unreasonable tax
benefits and exceeding limits
enjoyment of rights actually up
seventeenth year none of these words
you would not find the tax code for the first time
this is the norm 54 1 it seems to me and will know everything
entrepreneurs appeared only in
seventeenth year
what is it all about is very simple I
buy some goods
Well, I want to buy fish, I have her visa from the far
East pick up in the port I know who her
catch i agree with people give me
constituent documents certificate
registration certificate of statement
on account of counterparty invoice me
I bring fish to try it all good
I pay only after delivery and
I sell I get the proceeds I live in peace but
in three years comes to me
tax authority to check and says
you know what ‘s this company
who bought the fish did not pay taxes
and it was used to evade
paying taxes means there is a question
when they come to you for taxes which
did not pay your counterparty or
second level counterparty or counterparty
the third link and here the rules are very
seriously changed and they concern everyone
if before it was so it was not
Your tied dependent person you go on
what signs are not visible that have identified
these anal money you in
Generally did not touch but the rules
changed because so state is not
can fight so huge
the amount of magna that happens
occurred earlier now only
desperate to do this in our country
and such a rule was established you must
show due diligence
caution when choosing a counterparty
the same criterion of responsibility as
if you work in a commercial
activities
why what does this mean you should not
just check that he put you this
fish and the fact that this is a real subject
business activities with him
and the staff he has property
he has competence and if
questioning the CEO of the company
don’t understand at all what a single fish is
different from the other what is spawning and
in general, where in what pools is it
It grows and is harvested it all
it will be recognized as an unreal subject
business activities and
there used to be such rules for you
refuse deduct vat
and on income tax if you
The market price bought and in this chain is not
greatly increased the cost you
recognize in the costs and if not then
here you will lose everything
but these criteria were developed as
you understand not the rules of the law on judicial
practice and the problem is that often
counterparty criterion
backdated well then
have you make a deal in some
conditions
ok come to check you in three years
tell you how you should have checked
counterparty problem is that new
the rule was to eliminate this situation
what are we talking about and
right now it is written in the law that
prohibited
distort the facts of economic life
the second
make transactions the main purpose of which
is tax evasion and
the third
you can reduce your tax
liabilities only if
the deal that you made executes
your counterparty or whose face
obligations transferred by agreement well then
there is a subcontractor for nothing if not
so actually you will be denied
recognition of the relevant well, that is
taxes will charge you there
had to pay others
tax authorities interpret it now as
new counterparty verification standard and
we could have understood him if not
one thing but this rate will apply to
tax checks that are assigned
after July 19th of the seventeenth year that is
all transactions were made under their conditions
there in the sixteenth or fifteenth
year and it turns out that depending on
tax authority decisions when
assign check rule
requirements may be different therefore
probably our first massage to the state
no first massage yourself
evade tax not
it turns out taxes apply to all
but in order for us to live in normal
society in a normal social system
where people respect each other and honor
regulations
the state also needs to be made a rule
that can not be distributed
rule worsening situation
taxpayers in hindsight it
very important criterion
and the second point that arises and about
which I want to inform you
due to the adoption of this new norm I am not
agrees with that but the tax authorities are so
interprets that in case
taxpayer does work with
such counterparties or in distortion
facts of economic life that is when
we design as it really is
to save on taxes
it will be recovered not only that which is not
budget has been stolen
from budget plus penny plus fine and how
Now and taxes will be taken VAT and
profits are just already with turnover they are with
profit and not value added and this
The problem I think is that it can not be done
but
this is our rather such a massage to the state
what do you have to be reasonable
The question is whether you can do business in Russia
if the rules change so much if they often
unwritten my answer is possible and necessary
but you must understand that taxes are not
that theme which you can now not
be interested they concern you your
personal property and a list of persons who are for
their answers are constantly expanding that
do especially small and medium
business needs support and in fact
such a project is created it is called
support is created by people whom i
infinitely respect you know we have before
would be the highest arbitration court which was by
our with you can be no guesswork
liquidated were made
relevant constitutional changes
we let it happen so it happened but
the man who led the tax
composition in this court
he was not taken by the Supreme Court
man the supreme court he created very
important project cuda support
joined and the scientific community
sees there St. Petersburg
university leading lawyers leading
counsel leading counselors what are they
did they did this project in order
to engage in educational
tax activity
there you can get training programs 12
day to dive deep
what happens in the field
taxation is important and the second
people created such a discussion
independent platform where can
meet business representative
state science representatives
judicial community where in normal
non-aggressive no attempts to fool a friend
friend mode you can discuss those problems
who have and develop solutions
so I want to tell you
success of your business actually
taxes it’s not so scary just by them
need to be interested they need to know
because in fact it concerns
all of us
thank
[applause]
Please follow and like us: