Press "Enter" to skip to content

Stumbling Toward A More Just World | Julie Garcia | TEDxSanLuisObispo


I want to start with a little thought
experiment I want you to imagine an
astrophysicist think about what a
typical day for that person might be
like maybe they’re sitting at their desk
coming up with a formula to better
understand black holes or the origins of
the universe when you were thinking of
that person what did that person look
like if you’re like me this is probably
the most immediate image that comes to
mind right and I know some of you are
thinking is she reading my mind no it’s
not a talked about yes P I’m sorry to
disappoint but what does this mean that
this was a typical image that many of us
came up with in our head it could be an
example of an implicit bias we might
hold an automatic association with
science as both white and male and
that’s not a judgment it’s just the way
our brain works it’s a function of us
seeing science paired with white and
male repeatedly in our textbooks in our
films and on TV if we see these concepts
paired enough times we automatically
link them in our head see you might
wonder what does it matter if I have
this automatic association between
science as in white and male it matters
for a lot of reasons it matters because
our biases affect our behaviors without
awareness if you’re a student in a
science class and your professor assigns
a group project do you avert your eyes
when a woman or person of color looks to
you to join your group if you’re a
parent maybe you don’t prove maybe that
the types of toys you provide your
daughter’s aren’t science focused that
allow her to develop her science skills
if you’re a teacher a science teacher
maybe give a little bit more encourage
to the boys in your class than the girls
and if you’re an employer and someone
misses something science-related on the
interview maybe you give that person to
pass if they’re white but you scrutinize
those errors when a Latina makes them
these examples show there are biases
affect our attitudes our perceptions our
memory and these behaviors are often
unintentional without any malicious
intent but we can begin to see the
negative consequences to those behaviors
women and people of color don’t feel
like they belong in science classes
little girls don’t learn that science is
something they should do or can do
differential encouragement from teachers
translates to higher grades for boys and
girls and white people more than Latinas
are hired for science jobs and while I
focus on my example so far on science of
course our biases aren’t limited to this
context imagine meeting someone and you
learn something about maybe their
religious affiliation or sexual
orientation does that automatically
trigger feelings of inclusion or
exclusion our biases can affect day to
day interactions let me give you one
example from my life my cell phone broke
so I went with my brother to buy a new
one and immediately as soon as we enter
that store that sales person started
treating us like a couple and he started
I know the women in room were like I I
know that where this is going
and immediately directs all the
information about the costs and specs of
the phone to him and not me I was
invisible and I was the one buying the
phone I was mad but more than being mad
I left without purchasing a cell phone
our biases have interpersonal costs but
they have financial ones
– in that moment that salesperson
assumed a lot of things about me that we
were a heterosexual couple and as my
husband or boyfriend he was going to be
making about purchasing a decision not
me I’m sure we can all think of an
example where we were misread or me we
misread someone else but in addition to
our biases affecting these mundane
interactions they can have more severe
consequences people have been killed
merely for wearing a hoodie so if we can
agree that a biases lead to poor
decisions and ultimately a less fair and
just world what can we do about them
we’re not at the mercy of these biases
we can choose to do something else I’m
going to suggest three things we all can
do to create a more equitable world a
world where everyone has the best shot
to thrive as a first step we need to
acknowledge that we all have biases and
this is hard because when we imagine
someone who’s biased we imagine someone
who looks like that alright and we think
to ourselves I’m not like that
I’m a good person with good intentions
I’m not like that guy we need to step
away from ik waiting biases as stemming
from evil hearts and minds biases our
product of being human of learning that
to quickly navigate my world I’m going
to lump people into categories and then
assume I know some something about an
individual if I know something about
their category and while that helps me
make decisions more quickly they’re not
better decisions so here’s another
tricky part of this step as I mentioned
we’re often unaware of our biases so how
do I know if I have no one to begin with
one thing we can to do is take a test
design to matter measure these automatic
links in our head it’s called the
implicit associations test or IIT you
can Gugu
project implicit or go to the website
implicit Harvard et you and you can take
a test designed to measure your implicit
biases as am I relate to a whole host of
things like mental health or careers
it’s a computerized test it just takes a
few minutes to do and when you take this
test your first inclination might be to
just regard it especially if it runs
counter to what you feel your explicit
beliefs are don’t do that I want to
reassure you that this test was
developed nearly 20 years ago by two
social psychologists dr. mahzarin banaji
dr. Anthony Greenwald it’s been found to
reliably predict behavior so instead of
disregarding it sit with it a little bit
and maybe it do an audit of your
behaviors if you’re a student maybe you
think about your science groups and
they’re if they’re diverse if you’re a
parent maybe you think about the toys
and books you provide your children are
they science and math focus for your
boys but cooking in relationship focus
for your girls as teachers maybe you ask
a peer to come into your class to
observe your teaching to see if you call
on boys and girls equally in class and
if you’re an employer maybe you do an
assessment if see if your procedures are
as equitable and objective as fossum
possible do you set clear standards from
the onset and by doing these things we
can begin to see our blind spots and we
can take the second step which is to
challenge our biases our biases are like
a smog it’s icky
we don’t want to be exposed to it but we
all breathe in that toxic air all of us
regardless of our identities and if we
act in line with our biases we can
actually make them true let me give you
one concrete example of this there was a
study done by Rosenthal and Jacobson
where they told elementary school
teachers that on the basis of an IQ test
20% of their students showed unusual
potential for growth and then they were
provided with those students names in
actuality those students were selected
at random with no relation to actual
performance and then they took an IQ
test eight months later how do teachers
expectations affect actual performance
those students who were thought to be
smarter performed better what likely
happened in those eight months those
teachers provided those kids that they
thought were smarter with more time more
attention that led to greater confidence
on the students part which translated
higher grades in this case bias was
based on supposed performance on an IQ
test the biases could have been based on
maybe perceptions of wealth physical
ability size who do we automatically
assume will fail or succeed our biases
well this experiment powerfully shows
that our biases can actually we can
actually make our biases true while we
like to think of our successes and our
failures as purely the product of our
effort or our abilities biases affect
outcomes so how can we begin to
challenge them as I started this talk I
gave the example that we may have an
automatic association with science as
both white and male we don’t come out of
the womb with that association we learn
them we learn them as a product of our
culture and our environment if we learn
them we can unlearn them but how do we
unlearn them one thing we can do is we
can be more deliberate about what we
feed our brains
well we expose ourselves to we can offer
ourselves opportunities perhaps to read
a book from someone who comes from a
different background than ourselves it
allows us to see a different perspective
on the world and see someone in alter
for Humanity author si Hayakawa captures
a sediment best when he says it’s not
true that we have only one life to live
if we can read we can live as many more
lives in as many kind of lives as we
wish in addition to that helping us gain
perspective and seeing someone in all
their humanity and also allows us to see
a different future for ourselves
especially if we’ve seen negative
imagery for our own groups when a little
girl reads a story and that female
protagonist is a scientist she learns
that she too can be a scientist imagine
if our textbooks equally celebrated the
contributions of diverse scientists if
our movies similarly captured the
experience whether they’d be fiction or
nonfiction of a diversity of scientists
and that was also true in our TV shows
we see the automatic association between
science and white and male go away
because of these diverse exemplars and I
want to note it was really hard for me
to capture the slide as you can see with
my TV examples I couldn’t think of
anybody of people of color for that exam
for those examples we still have a long
way to go in thinking about whose
stories we tell but these images matter
research is found on the IAT that if
someone had an automatic association
with black and bad based on that test
but immediately before taking another
IAT they’re showing positive exemplars
of black people people like Oprah colon
Powell Obama that negative association
weakens or goes away in addition to what
we expose our brain to via media we can
also think about meeting people who are
different from ourselves and not just
one person but many people how often
have we where someone say I’m not a
racist
my best friend is black well I’m sorry
it doesn’t work that way and it doesn’t
work that way because one person can’t
represent the experience of an entire
group of people knowing one person is a
start but just a start to challenging
our biases
so his last step I want to encourage us
to all have compassion as we take these
steps towards creating a more inclusive
world when we start challenging our
biases we’re gonna make mistakes that’s
inevitable but without compassion for
ourselves
we’ll give up look say it’s just too
hard and I think what makes it hard to
think about our failures is because of
how we catch couch success and failure
broadly psychologist Carol Dweck talks
about how we frame our abilities as
coming from one of two different camps
either they’re a product of innate or
natural ability what she calls a fixed
mindset or they’re a product of learning
and growth what she calls a growth
mindset and our successes and our
failures means something different
depending on which lens we use to view
them from with a fixed mindset our
successes are easy they confirm my
belief that I’m naturally gifted my
failures on the other hand mean that I’m
not naturally gifted and more than that
I will never be good at something with
the growth mindset our failures means
something more hopeful was enough time
and energy and effort I can be better
let’s relate that back to bias if we
approach this from a fixed mindset
perspective when we make mistakes we’ll
say it’s just who I am but with a growth
mindset perspective I can leverage those
mistakes to make better decisions in the
future and just as it’s important to
view my own behaviors with a growth
mindset it’s important for how I view
others behaviors as well research by dr.
Anita Ratan and Carol Dweck has found
that when I have a growth mindset I’m
more likely to step in when someone
makes a biased response and that in turn
has found to lead to a reduction of
biased behaviors in the future have you
ever called someone a racist or sexist
how does that work out for you
I guess I’ll buy laughs not very well
you’re approaching that from a fixed
mindset perspective you’re just saying
that’s who they are
but if you approach it from a growth
mindset perspective and talk about the
behavior that they can change maybe say
something something like when you said
this I heard or I felt or ki explain a
little bit more what you meant by its
approaching it from a growth mindset
perspective perspective and I guarantee
you they’re gonna hear that a lot better
I know that talking about our prejudices
and biases is difficult I’ve been
researching and teaching on this topic
for nearly 20 years but what I hope my
talk today has accomplished three things
one help me just acknowledge that we all
have biases so we can begin to be on the
path of creating a more equitable world
and to providing you with some tangible
tools so you know what to do once you’re
on that path and three encouraging you
to have a growth mindset which will will
allow us to have more compassion for
ourselves and others when we and they
inevitably make mistakes that will allow
us to stay committed to that path I know
our biases can seem insurmountable a
product of a lifetime of being inundated
with media and and images but once we
begin to see the powerful negative
consequences our biases have for
ourselves for others for the world we
are left with no other choice but to
challenge them and we can challenge them
if they are learned that can be
unlearned and we may make mistakes along
the way but we can’t afford to give up
it’s simply too important we all have
our spheres of influence places where we
can make tangible differences today and
that might be our social circles our
family our classrooms our boardrooms
our universities I want to share with
you one of my Spears of influence this
is a picture of my little girl and she
may choose to be an astronaut one day or
an astrophysicist or she may choose to
be a dancer
and I have a feeling in a couple of days
from now she might be both a little
astronaut in a tutu but I want to open
as many doors and possibilities for her
as possible we cannot afford to let our
biases limit someone’s potential or lead
to poor decisions in our classrooms our
board rooms or day-to-day lives I hope
you’ll join me as we work together and
work however imperfectly towards the
goal of creating a more inclusive world
the child’s hoping to be a scientist the
person just wanting a fair shot on the
interview the person needing to be seen
in all their full humanity is depending
on it thank you
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: