Press "Enter" to skip to content

Storytelling and Ecology | Mark Borthwick | TEDxUniversityofEdinburghSalon


so honest mark I’m a storyteller and I’m

going to tell you why stories are going

to save the world I’m going to do this

to begin with through the medium of

story and this story like all stories

begins with silence it happened here for

the touching of the ankles and a

swelling of the belly a baby was born

and it was beautiful and healthy in

every single way and normal in every

single wave of one instead of a belly

button

a little silver cross at the top of a

screw and he was fine his mom Esther

loved in the same when he was getting

changed for PE you know he he faced the

wall so no one saw his little silver

belly button or anyone swimming he will

one those long blue and white striped

swimming costumes we show this to just

above the knees you know his then with

the times and cuz them with the times

when he met a girl he looked at her she

looked away she looked at him he looked

away maybe some you know what love is

like when they’re gonna get married they

never saw each other naked until the

wedding night or prim and proper

Presbyterian values and a guest of the

day before the wedding and this boy is

so nervous so he goes to his mama like

all sensible nervous boys he says mama

I’m so afraid that she’s going to see my

Ilsa the bellybutton and think I’m a

freak he’s gonna leave me on the night

of our wedding his mama looks at him

with a crinkled wisdom of age she says

my darling boy you’ve got to talk to the

woman you’re gonna marry you’ve got to

communicate with your partner for the

rest of your life or else or else what

do you have and if she sweats this small

stuff

she was never right for you anyway it’s

nice right

and he knows deep down that this is the

right advice but he also is for this

deep-seated fear and he says mama I

recognized that that’s the right thing

to do because there anything else I can

do to avoid this confrontation she says

well you know my advice but if you won’t

take it you could always go down to the

woods see what the she will do for you

that she as I’m sure you know are the

garlic fairies and these people aren’t

Tinkerbell they live in a world just

parallel to ours millimeters beneath and

their advice sometimes goes awry because

they don’t know

what it’s like to be a human being but

he decides he’s going to risk it and it

goes down to the woods finds a nice

clearing strips naked so is a good bet

when you’re dealing with the she he lies

down that clearing pretends to be asleep

as the Sun sets and the moon rises he

peeks through his eye and he sees

beating down upon him is a beautiful

silver moon being as he watches down

that Moonbeam floats a beautiful elegant

slender silver spelt and Sybil and she

holding a beautiful long elegant slender

silver belt and civil and Phillips

screwdriver and she kneels on the heath

beside him and slots that into his

bellybutton and twists and out from his

belly comes a beautiful long elegant

slender silver cross headed screw I with

a screw in one hand and a screwdriver in

the other hand that she drifts back off

up that Moonbeam when she’s gone at

least his feet I’m normally says I’m

healed then his bum falls off thanks

thank you there’s no time so 20 years

ago John McInnis spoke at this

university and he said the fairy world

is a metaphor for the imagination and in

this story despite it being clearly

modern phallus written by Patrick

Rothfuss I’m led to believe it involves

a hero stepping out into the world

facing or shouldering the burden of an

inadequacy encountering the other in a

natural liminal space struggling and

returning having changed and this is

true of most stories in the Celtic cycle

people meet the other in a natural space

where the two worlds meet and return

haven’t been humbled I’d like to know if

you’ve ever stepped out into nature and

fealty or I’ve been around you the

tremendous other you felt very small but

connected to the deep linear to the

place that you’re standing this is our

friend cat Mallos in a farm in Spain and

this is John Muir who famously walked

through the Yosemite Valley and

converted to a Cathedral he says these

mountains are God’s words writ large

he felt connected to a wider creation

you can see in his face having an

experience this is me having an

experience in a liminal rhododendron

bush this is the Berwick stone circle

which is near oh I grew up these stones

have been there for thousands of years

and if you look there’s a second circle

of stones around the ones that still

survived and this is a very heavy place

when you stand there you can feel the

two worlds meeting the Coniston fells

look like a pregnant woman lying on her

back and they supposes why they built

the stones there and when you come here

it’s very hard to feel like you’re king

of the world the landscape is wild and

there’s this sense of the other

encouraging enough because of this sense

of the other this has become a site of

preservation people don’t build their

and imagining the fairies that realm of

imagination has led to an actual

conservation through laissez-faire

conservation ethics so these are the

characteristics of the Celtic myth as

you can see our story wither with the

bum screw despite being modern fit every

one of them I like to draw attention

particular to the numinous which is what

is encountered in the liminal space CS

Lewis who popularized this term

describes a numinous like this instead

of one believed there was a mighty

spirit in the next room the disturbance

should be profound one would feel wonder

and a certain shrinking a sense of

inadequacy to cope with such a visit on

this feeling may be described as all and

the object which excites it is the

numinous so newness is a transformative

power we encounter in natural spaces in

Celtic mythology again the newness is a

transformative power which is

encountered in natural spaces in every

story in the Celtic mythology you may be

asking why this is important why is it

important that we have this sense of

ourselves that’s generated by exposure

to the natural world I argue that it’s

very important because our place in the

world determines how we understand the

world or how we view ourselves in the

planet will affect how we contextualize

ourselves in the planet this is somewhat

ruined by Izzy’s fantastic talk because

it of course

a creep by Donald Trump which would be

good you can move this line on hard to

believe if we hadn’t just just analyzed

it so this is obviously a certain

narrative about the environment

obviously he’s denying the environment

on the on the highest level but he’s

also making other narratives about it

the first is that the climate is a

comparable or a laterally coherent

priority with US production it’s an

economic object but not a moral

necessity so even by denying climate

change he’s making all these other

narratives and assumptions about the

climate and putting into a conceptual

scheme was not a viable thanks this is

what seems to be an opposite view this

is a solution to solve climate change a

man named David Keith he wants to use

jets and rockets to put sulfuric acid

into the atmosphere and this is his plan

to cheaply and easily stop global

warming and while he’s well-intentioned

I’d argued that he has the same

destructive narratives that the current

president has he views humanity is

floating above a mechanistic world which

can be controlled and manipulated in a

way which suits the human interest

without regard for other other beings or

other life fortunately he was never

allowed to do this yet and I think that

that might be something to be grateful

for because while this would solve one

human problem it is another form of

pollutant with uncertain consequences I

think that both these people Trump and

Keith are going naked into the woods and

they’re waiting to see what the reaction

would be from nature and I wish I could

take them both and make them feel the

numinous either through story or taking

them up to Berkeley comment because when

you contextualize yourself in that way

when you imagine yourself going into the

woods and meeting the great other or

when you listen to the story of Jemima

Puddleduck and imagine yourself as a

duck with duck friends and duck things

to do it becomes very hard to hold on to

that image of humans as a be land

end-all of experience and when you

decentralize yourself from the human

story and

look at yourself as part of a rich

family of life you’re doing Deep Ecology

before you even know that you can doing

it and we can trick people almost or

guide people into bringing things that

were otherwise distant very close to the

power of story this chart I think shows

how we normally understand reality as

objective facts which then filter out

and become myths and legends but if you

move to the next slide actually I think

that there’s a lot more of the other way

around so if any of you have studied

philosophy of science here at the

university lacketh or shun-kun a few

knots you might know that our

observations about the world are laden

with our theories about the world and

what we choose to look for

scientifically it’s not arrived at

scientifically that’s a product of our

culture and importance of other forces

and pressures so what we believe in the

collective unconscious for instance if

we believe that we need a mechanistic

solution to climate change or if we

believe X Y then these will lead us to

certain conclusions there wouldn’t be

possible to get a different vision of

our place in the world and I think

storytellers have a very unique position

with one step in the collective

consciousness as held by the myth the

poetic with all its environmental

information and one step in forming

people’s conceptions of themselves in

the world and realities document

anywhere it doesn’t heed any equipment

it can be done for free I think it’s a

very good tool and if you doubt me take

a look at these fine men on the right is

John Muir you may recognize him from

earlier he was born pretty close to here

in Dunbar moved to America and he’s

broadly credited with inventing the

modern National Park project he wasn’t a

politician his own political career

failed its Hensel Lobby broadly failed

instead he was famous at the time for

his nature writing mostly fictional or

quasi biographical talks about his

travels in nature and his poems and on

the left is Theodore Roosevelt who in

his life did create five national parks

18 national monuments and 53 wildlife

reserves and quoted Muir’s language all

the time and Roosevelt obituary of John

Muir which he wrote after he was death

he says no man

was more able to influence contemporary

thought in action and John Muir say that

again there was powerful man on the

planet said that no man was more able to

impose contemporary thought and action

than this poet and storyteller

thanks to conclude I say the

storytelling is a unique capacity to

bring what is otherwise distant into a

realm of understanding through metaphor

and through fable when we imagine

ourselves as other creatures and these

centrioles are socially human experience

we are able to empathize with that which

is otherwise refined out of our sphere

of understanding through a reductive

language and I think that if everybody

listened to one Celtic myth a day or

went into nature to experience in

numinous once a day we were living in a

very different planet thank you very

much [Applause]

Please follow and like us: