Press "Enter" to skip to content

Stop being so nice! The key to global economic growth | Amy Karam | TEDxKanata


[Applause]

what if I told you that the world as we

know it is no more and that there’s one

word that would secure a better future

for all of us but before I get into that

let me tell you a few stories I’m gonna

tell you three stories in fact I’m gonna

tell you a personal story a corporate

story and a global story let’s start

with the personal story so over 15 years

ago I was recruited from Canada to

Silicon Valley by a high-tech

multinational and one thing that struck

me when I met Americans for the first

time was the sympathetic tone that they

would give me and the look and they

would kind of tilt their head to the

side and they say oh you’re Canadian

babies they’re so nice I leave a

conversation a bit perplexed like what

do they mean by that was I not a worthy

contender was I so exceptionally

unthreatening by being a Canadian and so

I give this more thought and I realized

for me to be successful in the US I had

to change and so I became a hybrid of

practices I learned from the Americans

and I adapted to an adopted some of

their more assertive American ways along

with being the Canadian who I was in

order for me to continue on and to be

somewhat successful there now let me

shift gears and get into the second

story I’m gonna tell you about that

terrific high-tech multinational that I

went to Silicon Valley to work for now

they were a world-class company and I

was so proud to work for them in fact

they were an leader in the industry they

were innovators they had market share

dominance they had major brand equity

because their product superiority so

essentially they were the best then

things started to change a little bit

and we would be

being challenged by emerging competitors

and we weren’t winning business in

certain markets as easily as we were

used to so what had changed what

happened as it turns out we did such a

good job at being the best that foreign

companies were emulating our business

strategy from product development right

down to marketing approaches and I know

this firsthand because I was tasked with

monitoring and addressing some of these

new sales dynamics and so they say that

imitation is the finest form of flattery

but it doesn’t protect revenues and

market share and so we quickly learned

that we needed to adjust we needed to

adjust our business strategy in certain

markets in order to stay ahead and so

secure hold our position of strength now

you’re probably thinking okay great

great stories but what does that have to

do with me

let me get into the global story and

let’s take a look at how it was how it’s

been and how it has become so the West

which includes Canada the US Western

European countries etc have had pretty

good economies in the last few decades

don’t you think right the prosperity has

allowed us to have very strong buying

power and a great standard of living in

fact shopping has become a favorite

pastime for many of us and the

additional spending powers allowed us to

upgrade our homes etc life has been

pretty good then in 1976

with the joining of Canada to the g7 the

International Monetary Fund said that

these countries were the most advanced

economies in the world and they

represented more than 50 percent of the

net global wealth and they would get

together occasionally and talk about

macroeconomics and international trade

and relations with developing countries

now because of this concentration of

power

in a few in the hands of a few countries

that share some similar views and values

they were able to direct the global

economy and they were able to decide to

be nice they decided that they were

gonna help the emerging countries grow

right by being cooperative by

establishing partners partnerships by

you know contributing funds and

knowledge transfer and Martin you know

special allowances and market access etc

and then they did such a good job at

being nice I’ve been giving and

cooperative that it fueled the growth of

the emerging countries and so this power

gap is closing right to the point where

these emerging countries wealth became

so strong they got it voice at the table

and so the g20 was formed with developed

countries and developing countries

coming together and giving everybody a

more power in determining how the global

economy was going to be run right so as

you see your countries like China like

India like Brazil came into the mix and

so now there’s a power shift and the

West has to adjust to this power shift

and the thing is these new players don’t

necessarily play by the same rules

right so we hear a lot of complaints

about unfair trade practices or

infringement of intellectual property

laws etc so again the influence and the

power of the West has been marginalized

and we need to shift and adjust to

accept this power shift alright so again

so why do you care she’s talking

economics this is way beyond me let’s

bring it down to your concerns the

Western economies are suffering we are

not growing like we used to grow take a

look at this chart and look at Canada’s

GDP decline over the last five years

pretty aggressive isn’t it alright and

if you even compare Canada and the US

u.s. is growth at under two percent

compared to China at six point five to

seven percent of course that’s always

debatable but it’s still larger and then

unemployment rates are exceptionally

high seven percent in Canada and we see

in in the u.s. they’re clamoring for

their jobs their manufacturing jobs to

come back home they’ve lost too many

jobs overseas what are you gonna do

about it politicians and of course the

cost of living has has gone up

significantly real estate costs so

because these emerging countries are

wealthier they’re coming over and

they’re buying your real estate and a

top dollar to the point where your local

economies are placing fifteen percent

taxes on foreign purchasers just to try

to contain the high skyrocketing real

estate prices and then we’re gonna get

into this a little more later but our

competitive advantage is also threatened

so why should you care your standard of

living your quality of life is at stake

all right so more than ever right the

West needs to shift gears and wake up we

really need to just wake up and do

things differently we no longer can

afford to be nice or at least not in the

same way that we have been we need to

look within and change easy enough to

say so what did this do all of these

economic downturns and threats provoked

they provoked a reaction of let’s

protect let’s protect and grow just on

the inside right right within our own

borders and just like in the airline

industry when they say make sure you put

your oxygen mask on first before you

help others that’s the same reaction

that politicians are having we and we’ve

seen this right insulate protect the

home front

let’s get competitive if we don’t take

care of number one who’s gonna take care

of number one by the way there is only

one number one it’s gonna be us right

and then we get into the import taxes

and tariffs and we get into

manufacturing and bringing home etc and

so in other words the the whole idea the

SEPTA’s let’s play hardball and let’s be

less nice and this isn’t just rhetoric

right we’ve seen this with brexit and

we’ve seen it with the recent USA

protectionist movement now I do believe

that we we do need to take better care

of the homefront times have changed and

we can no longer operate under the same

rules and and procedures that we have in

the past but the question is so what do

we do so what I had just described is

you know with the whole protectionist

movement is running sprints when the

race really is a marathon it’s not

sustainable right so if we do take the

protectionist approach and bring jobs

home it really only has a short-run

reaction right or reward but it really

is only damaging to our economy in the

long run so let’s take a specific

example if say we did it apply import

tariffs and taxes to foreign goods

coming into our country well it would

create more jobs that actually causes us

to have more costs higher costs equals

inflation inflation causes in higher

interest rates higher interest rates

means reduced investment right and less

spending thus further stagnation of our

economy and let’s let’s also not forget

this is going to cause retaliation by

other countries on our goods they’re not

gonna let us in either and we need

global trade for us to grow and based on

the charts that I showed you before we

really need to grow so now what

so clearly either extreme is is not a

viable option

we can’t be super cooperative and

extremely nice and giving and partner

and have the giving to be one way nor

can we be hyper competitive or super

protectionist because at the end of the

day they both have not very strong

outcomes in the long run so the new way

what we need to do is

change and adapt the wist needs to shift

gears by accepting this new world order

we need to accept that there’s a power

shift and that there’s new players in

the mix and that they play by different

rules and that we maybe need to learn

from them and adopt some of their

practices in order for us to become more

successful going forward we need to

shift from this comfort zone of being

the best it’s been it’s been a great

ride all right last few decades we’ve

set the global standard everyone looked

to us being the best is a pretty

comfortable place at a certain point but

being the best is a little bit on the

static side we need to shift to a

philosophy of becoming better and by

better we need to learn we need to

evolve we need to shift the way we do

business in order to stay ahead

so like the two stories that I mentioned

at the beginning right when I had to

shift gears and become a little bit more

American to succeed in a new culture and

just like the American multi-national

that had to change its business approach

in order to be a little bit more

successful within new market dynamics so

to do we all have to change in certain

ways let’s talk a little bit about

innovation now and what I call the

innovation advantage which has been our

competitive differentiator on the

international scene the West especially

Canada the US has been known to be

innovators and emerging countries have

looked to us for for innovation and by

looking towards us they have grown and

they’ve learned and they’ve taken on

their own innovation models China for

example is a great example they’re

becoming innovative on their own but

they’ve done that by sending droves of

delegations over here into Silicon

Valley to learn how to become innovative

when’s the last time we sent delegations

to China to learn about maybe supply

chain efficiencies or new business

models and by the way we really need to

get smarter about commercializing or

monetizing our innovation

we’re very proud of being clever and

innovative and smart but are we really

making that much money from them

couldn’t we make a little bit more but

that’s another topic for another day now

the real kicker for me was when I

discovered that China thinks that

they’re more innovative than Canada in

their national innovation index report

they actually ranked Canada at number 20

and ranked themselves at number 18 so

even the perception of Canada as an

innovator is weakening with emerging

markets a little bit alarming so at the

end of the day what I’m suggesting is

that we need to be more innovative at

innovation we need to recreate our

competitive advantage all right so I’m

not suggesting at the end of the day

that you give up on being nice I’m

simply suggesting that you take on a new

flavor of nice so instead of good old

vanilla nice maybe it’s a tutti fruiti

kind of nice right a mix of different

practices we need to take care of our

own interests while we are cooperating

and collaborating with other nations

right mutual interests are important but

that’s the key is two-way exchange

making sure that those exchanges are

mutual and taking on a philosophy of

being better and adapting and learning

this win-win attitude also has to be two

ways fair trade is key and reciprocity

from all parties involved is really

important for this to work and it’s not

just one nation or two nations it’s all

nations so the one word that I promised

you at the beginning of our talk it’s

really not either one of these practices

look are the world has become bigger and

smaller at the same time our economies

are too intertwined and 200

interdependent and gone are the days of

global DOM

by one player or even a few players we

need each other’s differentiated

benefits and our economies to grow we

can no longer just grow within our own

Nations and so we need to foster this

collaborative attitude and so we can’t

just be cooperative and nor can we be

purely competitive that one word that

will secure our future success is the

combination of the two that one word is coopertition thank you

Please follow and like us: