Press "Enter" to skip to content

Startup: The mysteries of organizational emergence | Jerome Katz | TEDxSaintLouisUniversityMadrid


so glad to be here today on this stage I

loved TED talks how many of you watched

TED Talks it’s unanimous all right great

and it’s I’m honored to be able to

contribute one if you might guess I am

fascinated by the ones done by

entrepreneurs and since 1984 when Ted

talk started there have been over 2000

talks given by entrepreneurs founders

and owners you’d watch those and you

watch how many more there are now than

1984 and you would draw the conclusion

that startups are happening more and

more often more people are becoming

entrepreneurs than ever before let me

show you a diagram in 1949 in America 18

percent of people were self-employed by

2015 only six point four percent so at a

time when we would think it’s growing

and it’s more popular than ever the

reality of it is it’s less popular than

it’s been for more than 40 years so let

me tell you aspersa kn’l story to help

you understand part of this this is my

family now this picture is 18 years old

it was the last photo we took when my

parents were both healthy and we could

get all the families together let’s

start with my parents it may not be

obvious you look at me and say ah well

that’s an American no I’m a grandson of

Europe my parents were born in Europe in

western Poland in 1925 and in 1939 the

Nazis rolled in put my parents in

concentration camps

they were the fortunate few they

survived they came to America as

immigrants in 1949 when 18 percent of

Americans were self-employed over the

course of their lives my father started

four I’m sorry my father started seven

for-profit businesses my mother started

for charity nonprofit businesses three

of which are still operating today

my parents died years ago so this was

the first generation steeped

entrepreneurs let’s talk about what

happened after that oh by the way just

yes my parents really did that is 1947

immigrant dress in Europe by that time

they were actually immigrants now living

in a DP camp in Germany so let’s go back

so the parents had kids as my sister her

husband my wife who’s here today and me

obviously much younger so among with us

each of us has been self-employed a part

of the time and employed by other people

part of the time so where my parents

were pretty much lifelong entrepreneurs

my sister my wife my brother-in-law our

only part-time entrepreneurs over the

course of our lives and we had children

my sister had two girls and we had a boy

and a girl between them three of the

four have never ever been self-employed

remember they’re 18 years older in the

photo here one of them was self-employed

only briefly so we went from having

people who were totally self-employed

for almost all their working life to

being people who were part-time

self-employed to even less part-time

self-employed that is one of the ways

that we see more fewer and fewer people

becoming self-employed the other thing

is take a look at me note my age

especially the young people you have to

look a long time because you don’t like

to look at old people so the thing is

that there are a lot of old people who

started businesses there the baby boomer

generation and they’re now my age and

what all my friends doing retiring or

talking about retirement so what do the

entrepreneurs do if they can’t find

someone to buy the business they close

it and go retire so I see more and more

and more of this kind of retirement so

we see that again reason why there’s

less self-employment you might be saying

is self-employment important and it’s

vitally important first off

self-employment these entrepreneurs with

their passionate cool ideas are the

source of most of our new products and

services whether you’re looking for the

next product that’s being funded on

Kickstarter whether you are involved in

the gig account economy and you’ve used

Airbnb or uber or you work for them if

you are interested in hybrid

organizations TOMS shoes sells us shoes

for profit but then takes a large part

of the profit and gives shoes to people

in third-world countries when they need

them hybrid organization entrepreneur

behind it

all of these are possible because

entrepreneurs go out with their

wonderful ideas and dreams and make it

into reality other entrepreneurs go out

into our communities and give us that

those things we couldn’t get otherwise

this is the dattari refugee camp in

Jordan most of the refugees there are

Syrian when they first came to this camp

fleeing the turmoil in Syria there was

no food there was no water there’s

nothing for them to do and nothing for

them to buy and so the first people who

settled there started trading what they

had with them and what skills they could

sell to one another and so it was a tiny

little market that would occur once a

week and then twice a week and then

every day and more people came some

people went to the city farther behind

and bought bought products and brought

it to the camp and sold it to the

refugees but these people created this

and literally built a market this road

is actually the main street of the

current marketplace at the za’tari camp

you’re probably now saying why is this

crazy American raising the issue about a

refugee camp a thousand miles away just

to give you an idea of a kind of

important situation we would all

recognize but let me give you one if you

go two hours outside of Madrid or if you

want to hours outside of my hometown of

st. Louis you would discover people in

Primark Cara fors Walmart don’t go to

these small towns how do these people

get their goods how do they buy new

clothes how do they get their food they

get it when an entrepreneur says I will

start a business and get get this in

here and sell it to you so people

entrepreneurs give people

the missing products and services they

need to live there are other reasons to

start a business if something is

important to you something you’re

passionate about the only way to make

sure it gets done is do it yourself

start an organization to achieve it if

you want to leave a legacy if there’s

something that you think is important to

be done for another group start a

business and one other which fits in as

if you think about my parents story

the fact is for immigrants very often

the best way to become part of the

society and part of the economy is to

become self-employed and we’ll come back

to look at that so I showed you the

picture of the decline do we know what

causes it well it turns out we do it’s

worse in countries like ours the US and

Spain let me explain that every year

there is a study called the Global

Entrepreneurship monitor it’s a

worldwide study last year it took place

in over 60 countries where they survey

the entire population a sample the

people and ask them about their interest

in entrepreneurship and they discovered

over the years that there are three

kinds of economies the ones that have

the highest level of entrepreneurship in

the blue bar are not the countries you

would normally expect that to be Iran

Egypt Peru belives Burkina Faso in all

of those countries people make a living

through what’s called a factor driven

economy they make their living by

farming by hurting by fishing by

forestry by mining very labor-intensive

lots of small family farms and herders

and folks like that so high levels of

self-employment as we move to

mechanization and industrialization now

we’re talking about countries like

Bulgaria South Africa Indonesia Turkey

and Brazil these are called efficiency

driven countries or it efficiency driven

economies and in those where you now

have plants that you have factories

people move from the farms and the rural

areas to take jobs in the city and work

in the factories fewer and fewer people

are self employed what happens when you

move from an industrial economy to an

idea economy and this is where we live

in Spain in the rest of the EU in the

United States

Taiwan Israel in these idea

innovation driven economies we have even

the lowest level of self-employment

anywhere in the world why is that well

the researchers have discovered there

are four major issues to watch one do

people see a lot of opportunities and

more opportunities they see the better

if they see opportunities do they feel

capable of pursuing that opportunity and

if they do feel capable do they let

themselves do it or do they have a fear

of failure that holds them back and if

you have all three of those you get

through all three of those then do you

have an intention to start that

organization of your own so Spain the US

how do we do we do terribly we have the

lowest level of we see fewer

opportunities than other people

we feel less capable to exploit those

opportunities than people these other

kinds of economies we have the greatest

fear of failure and in the end we have

the fewest people who talk about

starting an organization another reason

why the numbers are going down so I’m

not going to leave you without some

solutions first off me as an American

entrepreneurship professor want to

congratulate all of you

I believe you’re all pretty much here at

members of the EU your country your

joint country your Confederation that

beats my country in entrepreneurship in

particularly you beat us an

entrepreneurship education and I applaud

you for that you’ve done a wonderful job

how did it happen in 2006 there was a

you gathering as there is every day of

the year somewhere in the EU but this

one was focused on entrepreneurship

education and the group in 2006 passed

the Oslo Accords which mandated in the

EU lifelong entrepreneurship education

and as a true of all the EU initiatives

over the past ten years some countries

have done better and some countries have

done not as well but the fact is

the countries in the EU that have made

the most progress of the Oslo agenda

have done a tremendous job of teaching

young people about entrepreneurship and

teaching them the skills to master

entrepreneurship the opportunity the

capability decreasing their fear of

failure and increasing their desire and

intention to start entrepreneurship and

you’ve actually done a wonderful job of

measuring this and the EU leads the

world in its ability to consistently get

young people to want to start small

businesses so my hats off to you that’s

what your governments doing now what can

you do

keeping with all those two thousand

TEDTalks let me one more time the 2004

sensative keep dreaming and keep

pursuing your dreams keep trying to find

a way to start a business a way to do

things that’s better or way things to do

something important that isn’t being

done now the funny thing is now you

could at the break walk out with your

credit card you could use the Ted of

Wi-Fi login you’ve got ten minutes you

could start a business you could buy

product from a wholesaler you can open a

store on eBay or Amazon and start

reselling it and have the the material

you bought from the wholesaler either

drop shipped or sent to Amazon and

they’ll ship it for you you’ll never see

them you’ll never see the equipment of

the material that you bought you’ll just

see the money if you’re not a product

Court of person maybe you’re an artist

maybe you’re can do caricatures maybe

you’re an accountant you can do books

alright there are websites for that like

Fiverr or up work and for either of

these you can always start your own

e-commerce site but it takes more than

ten minutes to do that but you certainly

could and if you’re a programmer getting

an app into the Google Play Store the

Apple Store is very easy very and very

cheap so like Nike says just do it it’s

never been faster it’s never been easier

you can always also do a pop-up business

this old man is selling his artwork by

the ocean which actually looks to me

like a perfect way to spend the day

uh you know and the thing is that you

don’t have to have a lot involved it’s a

temporary sort of thing you do it when

you want to or when you think there’s a

crowd there having been in Madrid now

for two days I am amazed how about the

crowds day and night that’s it’s

glorious

you know I’m sitting but I’m sitting

here it’s like oh this would be a great

place to put up a shop you know this is

with my wife so looking at me can you

please give it up so but it really if

you’re doing a part-time you know

weekend sort of thing it’s really a very

easy thing to do very open sort of thing

the other thing is to buy a business and

how is this possible well look at this

guy to be honest he’s about my age

although I think I came out better on

the hair deal but here’s the deal the

amazing thing is that two elderly the

baby boom generation that yes I am a

part of actually had started more

businesses than anywhere these are the

us numbers but it’s virtually the same

in in the EU so in the u.s. one out of

six businesses are owned by people my

age or his his age how much longer are

we going to work my friends are thinking

about retirement I’m beginning to think

about it so you look at this guy

and he like every entrepreneur I’ve ever

met he wants 1 million euros for his

business you go to him the first day he

thinks about retirement you say I want

to buy your business 1 million euros

said why this is 1 million euros take it

or leave it

ok good leave it because here’s a

psychological trick he gets closer to

retirement he’s going to reach a point

where he has a young worker has worked

for him for like like six eight years

and the kids just getting married and

they’re going to start a family he’s

going to have to tell this kid I want

you to find a job somewhere else because

you need a stable income to raise your

children and I can’t guarantee you that

any more and when that kid is walking

out the door for the last time his

heart’s going to break that kid is not

just an employee that kid is family and

when he takes one of his oldest

customers and the customer is talking

about plans for two and three years

ahead he says you know maybe you should

talk to

not that my competitor across the street

he’ll be able to take care of you I

might not be here all that time it’s

going to kill him and the million

dollars will go down and down and down

and if you a bright passionate person

come up to him and say I want to buy

your business and I can’t pay for it

right now but I’ll come in you teach me

to work you retire I will send you a

check every month and if you die I’ll

send your wife a check every month and

if she dies I’ll send your estate the

check every month until I bought your

business I bet you he’ll go for Less a

lot less than a million dollars ten

percent sorry sixteen percent of your

businesses are going to close or get

bought in the next ten years the

opportunity is unprecedented last I saw

this photo in a newsfeed and it said

that seems I just emotionally I

connected with this photo and it was

because it reminded me of a photo there

are my parents again this was a train in

Germany outside the DP this place

persons camp they were in and this was

their stock the start of their trip to

America a train that took him to

Bremerhaven Germany where they took a

boat and eventually got to Memphis

Tennessee where I grew up so why are

immigrants important immigrants are

important because they start businesses

they go self employed more than

native-born people in the US it’s

actually 20 percent higher in EU

countries that’s low in many of the EU

countries is 25 30 33 40 % as high as 40

percent and that’s that’s a significant

difference in the number of businesses

people are starting they often start

selling to other immigrants like in this

atari camp but a lot of them start

selling not just immigrants but to the

native-born in a few this list are

famous American companies and you know

all of them you all have craft food in

your freezer Procter & Gamble cleaning

products AT&T eBay Yahoo Instagram Intel

Intel Inside right every one of those

companies was founded or co-founded by

an immigrant

and we show the countries so realize

those immigrants can make an enormous

difference in every level of your

society so let me go back and tell you

the lessons my immigrant parents gave me

like they started with nearly nothing

but if you seek prepare pursue and

persevere you can make a difference on

your own I encourage you take the chance

and give a not another chance to our own

immigrants thank you [Applause]

Please follow and like us: