
[Music]
gachaaan in most philosophers do not
live in big ceramic barrels in their
local supermarket but there was one just
down the road from here actually not so
very long ago his name was Diogenes of
Sinope a and he was probably the closest
thing philosophy has ever produced to a
troll he was rude outrageous impulsive
offensive but he was deeply admired by
Alexander the Great who was arguably the
most powerful person in the world at the
time it said that one day Alexander went
to visit Diogenes in his big barrel in
the marketplace and went up to him and
said Diogenes I will grant any one wish
that you have just tell me what you want
Diogenes was lying in the Sun at the
time and true to his form he looked up
at Alexander and replied stand out of my
light and I love this story because it
has lessons for us about how we should
be responding to the alexander’s of our
time our digital technologies and the
people who create them because like
Alexander they’ve come into our lives
and offered to fill all sorts of needs
and wishes that we have and in many ways
they’ve done so extremely well but we’re
beginning to realize now that in doing
so they like Alexander have also been
standing in our lion in a sense and in
one light in particular that is so
precious and so essential for human
flourishing there without this light the
other benefits of technology might not
do us very much good the light that I
mean is the light of our attention
there’s something profound and
potentially irreversible happening to
human attention in the digital age it’s
more than just distraction it’s more
than just addiction or manipulation
in fact I think that the way we respond
to this challenge could be the defining
moral and political issue of our time
I’d like to tell you why I think so and
what I think we can do about it in the
1970s Herbert Simon pointed out that in
an environment of information abundance
attention becomes the scarce resource
there’s a kind of figure ground
inversion that takes place and this
inversion has happened so quickly and so
recently that we’re still just beginning
to come to terms with what it means for
human life but because attention is the
scarce resource it is now the object of
competition among most of the
technologies we use every day
the total environment of competition for
our attention is often called the
attention economy and in the attention
economy there are no truly free products
you pay with your attentional labor
every time you look or tap or scroll or
click and this is exactly what they’re
designed to try to get you to do and
they use the your attentional labor to
advance their goals not yours because
there is a difference between their
goals and yours if you think about the
goals that you have for yourself today
this year and even beyond they’re
probably things like I want to spend
more time with family or I want to learn
how to play the piano or what it take
that trip that I’ve been thinking about
for a while you know these are real
human goals this stuff that when we’re
on our deathbed if we don’t do we’ll
probably regret it but if you look at
what the technologies of the attention
economy are designed to promote in our
lives if you don’t see these goals what
you see are things like maximize the
amount of time I spend using it or the
amount of clicks did I make or the
number of pages or ads that I view now I
don’t know anybody who has these goals
for themselves
does anybody wake up in the morning and
think how much time can I possibly spend
on Facebook today I certainly don’t if
there’s someone out there like that I’d
love to meet though
but what this means is that there’s a
deep gap between our goals and theirs
and at the technologies of the attention
economy are not on our side their goals
are not our goals these are distractions
petty distractions from the goals of
life and this seems to me to be a really
big deal even more so because the
creators of these technologies know that
this is the case Steve Jobs did not let
his children use the iPad the CEO of
Netflix a little while back said that in
addition to snapchat and YouTube one of
their biggest competitors asleep this
seems to me a crisis of design ethics
the crisis of self-regulation
that design is actually amplifying and
making even worse in the last couple of
decades psychology and behavioral
economics research has catalogued an
enormous number of vulnerabilities in
our brands little buttons that can be
pushed to get us to think or do certain
things in parallel with this the
advertising industry has effectively
colonized the internet and turned it
into a large-scale system of industrial
persuasion of measurement of
optimization of message delivery what’s
more this power this persuasive power is
more centralized than at any time in
human history never before in history
have a few people at a few companies in
one state in one country been able to
shape the attentional habits of billions
of human beings Alexander could have
never even dreamed of that sort of power
so I think it’s no hyperbole to say that
the digital attention economy is the
largest system and most effective system
for human attitudinal and behavioral
manipulation the world has ever seen and
again this seems to me an enormous
question I think what’s happened is that
as Aldous Huxley said of the defenders
of freedom in his time that they had
failed to take into account man’s almost
infinite appetite for distractions I
think that in the design of digital
technologies we have made exactly the
same mistake and I think that it is
for us to start taking those into
account so how can we start to do that
well I think what it would require
essentially is to start asserting and
defending our freedom of attention now
this is a type of freedom we have always
had but never needed to seriously assert
or defend because there wasn’t a whole
lot in our world that could seriously
threaten it but I think we can find good
precedent on the great writers on a
subject for instance John Stuart Mill
who said that the appropriate region of
human Liberty comprises the inward
domain of consciousness freedom of mind
is the first sort of freedom he adds
that the principle of Liberty Liberty of
tastes and pursuits of framing the plan
of our life to suit our own character so
what this suggests to me is that we need
to start thinking more broadly about
what we mean by the concept of attention
in order to take into account the full
spectrum of distractions that are now
being unleashed in our world because
when we hear the term attention what we
normally think of is the spotlight of
attention kind of the immediate way we
shape our awareness within the task
domain so the attention that you know
you’re all giving to me right now in
this moment attention for which by the
way I’m very grateful but and so when
this when the spotlight of our attention
gets obscured it sort of interferes with
our ability to act so let’s say I’m
trying to read a book but I see on my
phone that Donald Trump has unleashed
another outrageous tweet and so I
stopped reading my book and don’t finish
reading it until later but over time
actions become habits and the things we
do become the people we are and we don’t
have a way of talking about attention in
this longer-term view with respect to
our higher goals and our values so I
think that we could maybe think of
another light of attention beyond this
spotlight of attention we could think of
the Starlite of attention so the way we
navigate our lives by the stars of our
higher values so it’s technology if a
technology obscures the Starlight of our
attention we could
we can see this especially in infinite
scrolling news feeds like on Facebook or
Twitter and when you pull down to
refresh the same psychological mechanism
as a play that is it play in the design
of slot machines
so does intermittent variable rewards
when you randomize the reward you give
somebody they’re more likely to do the
behavior you want them to do and when
the attention economy stands in the
light of our art the star light of our
attention it shapes our lives and its
image our values become its values we
become more petty or narcissistic more
impulsive and I think this is perfectly
represented by the CBS CEOs comment from
February of last year when he said that
Donald Trump’s candidacy may not be good
for America but it’s damn good for CBS
the attention economy doesn’t just shape
our lives in its image it shapes our
politics in its image again I think this
is an urgent moral question that is
being talked about virtually by no one
but I think we could find one more light
of our attention to talk about it’s when
we it’s with it the technology doesn’t
just make it harder to do what we want
to do or to be who we want to be but in
a sense to want what we want to want to
define our goals and values in the first
place we can think of this as the
daylight of our attention the light by
which we’re able to do everything else
so when technology undermines the
daylight of our attention it erodes our
fundamental capacities like reason
reflection intelligence metacognition
one way we see this very clearly is in
the proliferation of outrage in our
societies and in our world outrage the
impulse to judge and punish was
extremely valuable at earlier stages of
human evolution in small foraging groups
have promoted moral clarity social
solidarity it was a way of signaling to
other people that you could be trusted
but when we amplify this on a societal
scale it results in large-scale social
division and rampant retaliation to give
you one exam
I don’t know how many of you remember
this there’s a dentist from Minnesota a
little while back that went to the
Zimbabwe and killed a lion named Cecil
it was a stupid thing to do he probably
shouldn’t have done it it might have
been illegal I don’t know but what
happened as a result of that is the
entire internet came down on this man
for a bad decision it was this whole
sort of festival of public shaming
people showed up at his place of work
putting signs on it saying rot in hell
they showed up to his home and
spray-painted it with children do this
sort of thing we call it cyberbullying
that when adults do it
it is mob rule plain and simple and mob
rule is precisely what Socrates held was
the main route democracies take when
they burn into tyrannies so we can think
beyond the spotlight of our attention we
can think not just in terms of doing
what we want to do but being we want to
be and ultimately wanting what we want
to want this is an intolerable situation
this should not persist as Aristotle
said it is disgraceful
to be unable to use our goods things we
should not have to settle for a
relationship with technology that is
adversarial we should demand that they
be on our side isn’t that what
technology is for so how would we do
that
well in the past we’ve typically put it
back on people themselves to deal with
distraction to deal with the effects of
technology to say work harder but in the
digital age the persuasion is just too
powerful and too ubiquitous and this
will not work but neither can we blame
the people who make these technologies
these are by and large good people and I
count many of them as my friends they’re
just players in a game called the
attention economy the problem is that
game ultimately this is not a problem of
the ethics of individual actors it’s a
problem of the ethics of the system to
the infrastructure what philosopher
luciano floridi at oxford calls the
infra affix so how can we change the
situation well go back to what I said a
little bit earlier about how what we’re
doing is attentional labor
using these technologies and paying for
them with our time and our attention in
this light we can frame the problem in
two ways
one is that we’re getting poor value for
our attentional labor the other problem
is that the conditions of that
attentional labor are extremely poor now
throughout history when people have been
faced with this situation what they’ve
done is to organize to create mechanisms
of collective representation so that
they can collectively negotiate with
those in power with those alexander’s of
their time so what I think is needed is
something that will give us a voice a
direct voice in the design of our
technologies and now no mechanism like
this existence today so what I’m calling
for and what is needed is a labor union
or something like it for the attention
economy and there’s a community of
people who are passionate and thinking
about these issues going under the name
time well spent so that you can know
when you spend time with your
technologies that it won’t just be time
spent it will be time well spent so
we’re thinking about how to change the
attention economy coming up with better
metrics better principles processes
business models and if you’re passionate
about this we would love to engage with
you because the thing is we need your
help to make this to make this a reality
and to change the system because at the
end of the day your attention is the
most precious resource that you have
it’s the ultimate scarce and finite
resource and the challenges that are
facing humanity right now so many big
and important challenges before anything
else what they require of us is that we
be able to give attention to the things
that matter on individual levels and at
the collective level and this is
precisely what the technologies of the
attention economy are undermining and
ultimately this this relates to the very
goals of life because you know nobody on
their death bed ever looked back and
said I wish I had spent more time on
Facebook you know what we what we regret
are those real goals the human goals
those things that make
life worth living and so from here you
know I think it will take some time to
reform the attention economy big
projects usually take time but in the
mean time I think what we need to do is
organize so that we can have a voice
directly a direct voice to these those
who create our technologies and we
should continue to reap the benefits of
our technologies and continue to affirm
and support the people who create them
because they carry that flame of
innovation and creativity that is so
core to the human project but before
anything else we need to organize and
ask them for their attention so that we
can tell them what we want them to do
with ours before anything else we need
to ask them to stand out of our light
thank you for your attention
[Applause]
[Music]
you
[Music]
gachaaan in most philosophers do not
live in big ceramic barrels in their
local supermarket but there was one just
down the road from here actually not so
very long ago his name was Diogenes of
Sinope a and he was probably the closest
thing philosophy has ever produced to a
troll he was rude outrageous impulsive
offensive but he was deeply admired by
Alexander the Great who was arguably the
most powerful person in the world at the
time it said that one day Alexander went
to visit Diogenes in his big barrel in
the marketplace and went up to him and
said Diogenes I will grant any one wish
that you have just tell me what you want
Diogenes was lying in the Sun at the
time and true to his form he looked up
at Alexander and replied stand out of my
light and I love this story because it
has lessons for us about how we should
be responding to the alexander’s of our
time our digital technologies and the
people who create them because like
Alexander they’ve come into our lives
and offered to fill all sorts of needs
and wishes that we have and in many ways
they’ve done so extremely well but we’re
beginning to realize now that in doing
so they like Alexander have also been
standing in our lion in a sense and in
one light in particular that is so
precious and so essential for human
flourishing there without this light the
other benefits of technology might not
do us very much good the light that I
mean is the light of our attention
there’s something profound and
potentially irreversible happening to
human attention in the digital age it’s
more than just distraction it’s more
than just addiction or manipulation
in fact I think that the way we respond
to this challenge could be the defining
moral and political issue of our time
I’d like to tell you why I think so and
what I think we can do about it in the
1970s Herbert Simon pointed out that in
an environment of information abundance
attention becomes the scarce resource
there’s a kind of figure ground
inversion that takes place and this
inversion has happened so quickly and so
recently that we’re still just beginning
to come to terms with what it means for
human life but because attention is the
scarce resource it is now the object of
competition among most of the
technologies we use every day
the total environment of competition for
our attention is often called the
attention economy and in the attention
economy there are no truly free products
you pay with your attentional labor
every time you look or tap or scroll or
click and this is exactly what they’re
designed to try to get you to do and
they use the your attentional labor to
advance their goals not yours because
there is a difference between their
goals and yours if you think about the
goals that you have for yourself today
this year and even beyond they’re
probably things like I want to spend
more time with family or I want to learn
how to play the piano or what it take
that trip that I’ve been thinking about
for a while you know these are real
human goals this stuff that when we’re
on our deathbed if we don’t do we’ll
probably regret it but if you look at
what the technologies of the attention
economy are designed to promote in our
lives if you don’t see these goals what
you see are things like maximize the
amount of time I spend using it or the
amount of clicks did I make or the
number of pages or ads that I view now I
don’t know anybody who has these goals
for themselves
does anybody wake up in the morning and
think how much time can I possibly spend
on Facebook today I certainly don’t if
there’s someone out there like that I’d
love to meet though
but what this means is that there’s a
deep gap between our goals and theirs
and at the technologies of the attention
economy are not on our side their goals
are not our goals these are distractions
petty distractions from the goals of
life and this seems to me to be a really
big deal even more so because the
creators of these technologies know that
this is the case Steve Jobs did not let
his children use the iPad the CEO of
Netflix a little while back said that in
addition to snapchat and YouTube one of
their biggest competitors asleep this
seems to me a crisis of design ethics
the crisis of self-regulation
that design is actually amplifying and
making even worse in the last couple of
decades psychology and behavioral
economics research has catalogued an
enormous number of vulnerabilities in
our brands little buttons that can be
pushed to get us to think or do certain
things in parallel with this the
advertising industry has effectively
colonized the internet and turned it
into a large-scale system of industrial
persuasion of measurement of
optimization of message delivery what’s
more this power this persuasive power is
more centralized than at any time in
human history never before in history
have a few people at a few companies in
one state in one country been able to
shape the attentional habits of billions
of human beings Alexander could have
never even dreamed of that sort of power
so I think it’s no hyperbole to say that
the digital attention economy is the
largest system and most effective system
for human attitudinal and behavioral
manipulation the world has ever seen and
again this seems to me an enormous
question I think what’s happened is that
as Aldous Huxley said of the defenders
of freedom in his time that they had
failed to take into account man’s almost
infinite appetite for distractions I
think that in the design of digital
technologies we have made exactly the
same mistake and I think that it is
for us to start taking those into
account so how can we start to do that
well I think what it would require
essentially is to start asserting and
defending our freedom of attention now
this is a type of freedom we have always
had but never needed to seriously assert
or defend because there wasn’t a whole
lot in our world that could seriously
threaten it but I think we can find good
precedent on the great writers on a
subject for instance John Stuart Mill
who said that the appropriate region of
human Liberty comprises the inward
domain of consciousness freedom of mind
is the first sort of freedom he adds
that the principle of Liberty Liberty of
tastes and pursuits of framing the plan
of our life to suit our own character so
what this suggests to me is that we need
to start thinking more broadly about
what we mean by the concept of attention
in order to take into account the full
spectrum of distractions that are now
being unleashed in our world because
when we hear the term attention what we
normally think of is the spotlight of
attention kind of the immediate way we
shape our awareness within the task
domain so the attention that you know
you’re all giving to me right now in
this moment attention for which by the
way I’m very grateful but and so when
this when the spotlight of our attention
gets obscured it sort of interferes with
our ability to act so let’s say I’m
trying to read a book but I see on my
phone that Donald Trump has unleashed
another outrageous tweet and so I
stopped reading my book and don’t finish
reading it until later but over time
actions become habits and the things we
do become the people we are and we don’t
have a way of talking about attention in
this longer-term view with respect to
our higher goals and our values so I
think that we could maybe think of
another light of attention beyond this
spotlight of attention we could think of
the Starlite of attention so the way we
navigate our lives by the stars of our
higher values so it’s technology if a
technology obscures the Starlight of our
attention we could
we can see this especially in infinite
scrolling news feeds like on Facebook or
Twitter and when you pull down to
refresh the same psychological mechanism
as a play that is it play in the design
of slot machines
so does intermittent variable rewards
when you randomize the reward you give
somebody they’re more likely to do the
behavior you want them to do and when
the attention economy stands in the
light of our art the star light of our
attention it shapes our lives and its
image our values become its values we
become more petty or narcissistic more
impulsive and I think this is perfectly
represented by the CBS CEOs comment from
February of last year when he said that
Donald Trump’s candidacy may not be good
for America but it’s damn good for CBS
the attention economy doesn’t just shape
our lives in its image it shapes our
politics in its image again I think this
is an urgent moral question that is
being talked about virtually by no one
but I think we could find one more light
of our attention to talk about it’s when
we it’s with it the technology doesn’t
just make it harder to do what we want
to do or to be who we want to be but in
a sense to want what we want to want to
define our goals and values in the first
place we can think of this as the
daylight of our attention the light by
which we’re able to do everything else
so when technology undermines the
daylight of our attention it erodes our
fundamental capacities like reason
reflection intelligence metacognition
one way we see this very clearly is in
the proliferation of outrage in our
societies and in our world outrage the
impulse to judge and punish was
extremely valuable at earlier stages of
human evolution in small foraging groups
have promoted moral clarity social
solidarity it was a way of signaling to
other people that you could be trusted
but when we amplify this on a societal
scale it results in large-scale social
division and rampant retaliation to give
you one exam
I don’t know how many of you remember
this there’s a dentist from Minnesota a
little while back that went to the
Zimbabwe and killed a lion named Cecil
it was a stupid thing to do he probably
shouldn’t have done it it might have
been illegal I don’t know but what
happened as a result of that is the
entire internet came down on this man
for a bad decision it was this whole
sort of festival of public shaming
people showed up at his place of work
putting signs on it saying rot in hell
they showed up to his home and
spray-painted it with children do this
sort of thing we call it cyberbullying
that when adults do it
it is mob rule plain and simple and mob
rule is precisely what Socrates held was
the main route democracies take when
they burn into tyrannies so we can think
beyond the spotlight of our attention we
can think not just in terms of doing
what we want to do but being we want to
be and ultimately wanting what we want
to want this is an intolerable situation
this should not persist as Aristotle
said it is disgraceful
to be unable to use our goods things we
should not have to settle for a
relationship with technology that is
adversarial we should demand that they
be on our side isn’t that what
technology is for so how would we do
that
well in the past we’ve typically put it
back on people themselves to deal with
distraction to deal with the effects of
technology to say work harder but in the
digital age the persuasion is just too
powerful and too ubiquitous and this
will not work but neither can we blame
the people who make these technologies
these are by and large good people and I
count many of them as my friends they’re
just players in a game called the
attention economy the problem is that
game ultimately this is not a problem of
the ethics of individual actors it’s a
problem of the ethics of the system to
the infrastructure what philosopher
luciano floridi at oxford calls the
infra affix so how can we change the
situation well go back to what I said a
little bit earlier about how what we’re
doing is attentional labor
using these technologies and paying for
them with our time and our attention in
this light we can frame the problem in
two ways
one is that we’re getting poor value for
our attentional labor the other problem
is that the conditions of that
attentional labor are extremely poor now
throughout history when people have been
faced with this situation what they’ve
done is to organize to create mechanisms
of collective representation so that
they can collectively negotiate with
those in power with those alexander’s of
their time so what I think is needed is
something that will give us a voice a
direct voice in the design of our
technologies and now no mechanism like
this existence today so what I’m calling
for and what is needed is a labor union
or something like it for the attention
economy and there’s a community of
people who are passionate and thinking
about these issues going under the name
time well spent so that you can know
when you spend time with your
technologies that it won’t just be time
spent it will be time well spent so
we’re thinking about how to change the
attention economy coming up with better
metrics better principles processes
business models and if you’re passionate
about this we would love to engage with
you because the thing is we need your
help to make this to make this a reality
and to change the system because at the
end of the day your attention is the
most precious resource that you have
it’s the ultimate scarce and finite
resource and the challenges that are
facing humanity right now so many big
and important challenges before anything
else what they require of us is that we
be able to give attention to the things
that matter on individual levels and at
the collective level and this is
precisely what the technologies of the
attention economy are undermining and
ultimately this this relates to the very
goals of life because you know nobody on
their death bed ever looked back and
said I wish I had spent more time on
Facebook you know what we what we regret
are those real goals the human goals
those things that make
life worth living and so from here you
know I think it will take some time to
reform the attention economy big
projects usually take time but in the
mean time I think what we need to do is
organize so that we can have a voice
directly a direct voice to these those
who create our technologies and we
should continue to reap the benefits of
our technologies and continue to affirm
and support the people who create them
because they carry that flame of
innovation and creativity that is so
core to the human project but before
anything else we need to organize and
ask them for their attention so that we
can tell them what we want them to do
with ours before anything else we need
to ask them to stand out of our light
thank you for your attention
[Applause]
[Music]
you
[Music]
Please follow and like us: