
a show of hands how many think that
there is an alligator that makes this
sound not so many now take a second to
think about this picture how does it
make you feel bothersome right it’s it’s
a realistic it’s very difficult for us
to accept such image when I studied
quantum mechanics I came about this
picture it made me uncomfortable just
the same way as the previous picture
made you uncomfortable what does this
picture mean it says and according to
physics that it is accepted that light
can be both particle and a wave at the
same time how is that possible you know
an ocean wave is a wave anorak is a hug
how can a wave be a rock and a rock be a
wave at the same time not only that it
you know what quantum mechanics says
that you know a wave sometimes can
behave like a rock and sometimes can
behave like a wave and sometimes it
could be a third option imagine you’re
at the beach and an approaching wave all
of a sudden turns into a hug that’s
crazy
or if somebody throws a rock at you and
then just before hitting you is splash
into water you know there’s no way this
could happen we don’t experience that as
humans unless you know you see it in the
Matrix movies or something so why
scientists have accepted such crazy idea
or concept in such field of science well
maybe to find an answer to this is to
look into history for a long time
people felt that light is made of
particles and then all a sudden
Descartes showed that light can be
modelled as a wave propagating through a
medium which he thought it was a
universal medium and he called it plenum
I’ll come back to this plenum stuff
later on but then Newton came along and
you probably heard he spent a lot of
time studying light he spent over 30
years just studying light and the nature
of light and then he concluded that
light must be particles that light beams
are made out of particles at the same
time Huygens was also investigating
light but he showed that light is made
out of waves so it behaves like a wave
is not a particle but back then Newton
has a much stronger position Newton was
a very respected will established
scientists we have made so many
accomplishments so that the way the wave
view of light was was ignored because
you know Newton said light is a particle
so we cannot dispute that and imagine it
took 200 years after Newton died to make
people comfortable to say that he was
incorrect you know 200 years was wasted
just because people trusted what Newton
say without question of that but luckily
over time the a lot of evidence surface
that light behaves like a wave and that
was in the mid 19th century and then
comes M Stein I call him the
troublemaker
Einstein said sorry guys
light is made of particles and knowledge
I am calling them photons but then he
was faced the dilemma
how can he justify
that in all the evidences over the past
hundred years that showed or all the
experiments that showed that light
behaves like a wave all a sudden now
he’s saying that it’s a particle and he
has experimental evidences shows that
light is a particle he said guys let’s
compromise and I have a clever idea he
was very creative and he said well let’s
call it both let’s just say light behave
like a wave and a particle at the same
time and this is where the concept of
particle wave duality was born it was
born from managed time and his creative
thinking of what light could be now
duality is not new it is deeply rooted
in human cultures we have many examples
that shows duality throughout history if
we take centers as an example in this
belief that the idea of centers was a
reaction to people who never saw a human
riding a horse
so horse riders from far away and
because they didn’t understand what that
meant they thought was a creature that
is half human half animal but then of
course when the rider came closer they
realized it’s just two creatures on top
of each other
well quantum mechanics is telling us
right now is to accept that light is
like a center it’s both wave and a
particle at the same time now light or
theories about light were not the only
ones that faced such drama there are
other theories that have similar or face
similar pattern if we take for example
either since the beginning of human
thinking either what was proposed as a
medium that fills empty space throughout
our universe they thought it can be
vacuum there has to be something that
fills all the empty space in our
universe and they give it a name and
they call it either now
in the 19th century the view of light as
a wave became strong but for that to be
supported there was a need for a medium
for the for the light waves to propagate
in and this has to be a strange medium
it has to be invisible and it has to be
infinite and it has to be something that
does not interact with physical objects
so now we’re faced with other dilemmas
how can you even imagine such material
in existence so there was a long debate
throughout history whether either exists
or not some people said yes it does
exist some people say no way that’s not
possible it’s not realistic well then
comes mekansm Mendelson took it upon
himself once for all to settle this
debate so he came up with a very clever
experiment to measure or detect ether
and he tried tirelessly to measure
either but he couldn’t so at the end he
said well I give up and you know I’m
saying that there’s no ether it does not
exist well then at the same time
Lawrence said well just because we
couldn’t measure it it does not mean it
doesn’t exist maybe there’s something
wrong with the experiment and then he
came up with some explanation to justify
why either could not be detected through
this specific experiment well most
people did not believe that so what what
most of the scientists decide to is to
look for alternatives to how can light
travels without such medium and then
comes the troublemaker again and Stein
and he finds a very convincing way using
his relativity to explain why Michelson
could not measure
he also said is not needed now what does
that mean he meant or what he said
guys look you know we’ve been crazy
enough to accept the concept of light
duality so when I just accept that light
just travel in vacuum at constant speed
and this one the speed of light came
about so he just proposed that another
solution another crazy solution to the
problem now what does that tell us it
tells us that science is always in
progress you know we should not take
[Music]
scientific theories for granted
you have witness how scientists went
back and forth between different
theories throughout history what if what
if you know new ideas come up what what
can we do you know even understand
himself when he said that we don’t need
to either and this is doing his when we
was working out his special relativity
theory later on when he developed his
generality theory he realized well we
need something similar to either so even
Einstein changed his mind later on about
some medium that should be in an empty
space so could either be the space-time
continuum that Einstein talked about
could either be dark energy that now
other people talked about we don’t know
and I hope maybe someday somebody in a
TED talk would tell us what either’s all
about
now scientific theories are you know the
best possible or best available
explanation to things as we know them
now we should not take them for granted
sign you know scientific theory
does not provide absolute truth it’s
just telling us what we know so far so
and I hope that that that message you
know gets across to a lot of people
because our people just think just
because an accepted theory is there we
think it’s that’s the absolute truth
well that’s now that that’s not the case
now I should also clarify that such that
the term or the expression
scientifically proven is a contradiction
in terms
there is nothing scientifically proven
you know what what what we know is
basically what you know whatever
experiments on toughness but that does
not mean that that’s the absolute truth
now in traditional schools students are
focusing on learning or understanding
accepted theories it is very rare that
students are being taught how to
challenge these theories and models you
know we should not teach students what
to think we should teach them how to
think and you know when when examining
any theory whether it’s physical or
biological or chemical theory you should
always consider or question the
assumptions what were the assumptions
when they were discussing this theory
also you should always question the way
the test was done not only that also the
way data was collected
remember mackelson experiment initially
he thought that his experiment proved is
still what they turned out it was wrong
and this experiment have been repeated
so many times you know he tried in the
mountains he charged in a cave it turned
the desert he tried
everywhere in different dimensions
different spaces even others not only
himself others have tried it just to
make sure that the test is correct and
this experiment is famous or known to be
the most famous failed experiment in
history so even though he failed he
still was recognized also we should look
into or we should always question
interpretations just like anything else
observations and data are open to
different interpretations just to give
you an example quantum mechanics and
quantum against there are ten
interpretations from quantum mechanics
what does that mean well to be frank
with you it means we don’t understand
quantum mechanics otherwise we wouldn’t
have ten interpretations for quantum
mechanics so don’t feel bad if you don’t
understand quantum mechanics some of the
smartest people have said they don’t
understand quantum mechanics I can give
you an example fireman he’s a Nobel
Prize winner in physics and he said it
he didn’t he does not understand quantum
mechanics duality does exist it’s not
just in our imagination an object such
as this cylinder this picture can
produce two forms of shadow at the same
time we can have a circle and a square
and in one setting what does that mean
it means it does exist but there are
also other alternatives the picture of
particle wave duality does not make me
comfortable and I would like to share
with you an alternative view or
alternative theory to which instead of
having a center you know a fake figure
we can have a particle surfing on a wave
and this this deal is known as the pilot
wave theory which was proposed initially
by debroglie in nineteen
twenty-seven and then restart again by
boom in 1952 what this theory tells us
that there is both a real particle and a
real wave but the wave actually
influenced that how the particle
behavior this concept has been recently
demonstrated experimentally by a group
at MIT and this is a video to show you
how this happens basically a group at
MIT managed to produce a droplet that
bounced on a surface of liquid and as as
this droplet bounced on that surface it
creates waves and then they were able to
demonstrate that these waves actually
guide their particle as it moves or as
it hovers over that that wave so after
all you know it is possible to have an
alligator that makes bird sound only if
we think that the bird is actually just
on top of the alligator it’s now
actually have alligator have bird I hope
I have sparked dance time in you to
think about the nature of flight because
we don’t know what we don’t fully
understand what light is and maybe one
of you someday will come up with an
alternative theory to explain the
behavior of light thank you very much
there is an alligator that makes this
sound not so many now take a second to
think about this picture how does it
make you feel bothersome right it’s it’s
a realistic it’s very difficult for us
to accept such image when I studied
quantum mechanics I came about this
picture it made me uncomfortable just
the same way as the previous picture
made you uncomfortable what does this
picture mean it says and according to
physics that it is accepted that light
can be both particle and a wave at the
same time how is that possible you know
an ocean wave is a wave anorak is a hug
how can a wave be a rock and a rock be a
wave at the same time not only that it
you know what quantum mechanics says
that you know a wave sometimes can
behave like a rock and sometimes can
behave like a wave and sometimes it
could be a third option imagine you’re
at the beach and an approaching wave all
of a sudden turns into a hug that’s
crazy
or if somebody throws a rock at you and
then just before hitting you is splash
into water you know there’s no way this
could happen we don’t experience that as
humans unless you know you see it in the
Matrix movies or something so why
scientists have accepted such crazy idea
or concept in such field of science well
maybe to find an answer to this is to
look into history for a long time
people felt that light is made of
particles and then all a sudden
Descartes showed that light can be
modelled as a wave propagating through a
medium which he thought it was a
universal medium and he called it plenum
I’ll come back to this plenum stuff
later on but then Newton came along and
you probably heard he spent a lot of
time studying light he spent over 30
years just studying light and the nature
of light and then he concluded that
light must be particles that light beams
are made out of particles at the same
time Huygens was also investigating
light but he showed that light is made
out of waves so it behaves like a wave
is not a particle but back then Newton
has a much stronger position Newton was
a very respected will established
scientists we have made so many
accomplishments so that the way the wave
view of light was was ignored because
you know Newton said light is a particle
so we cannot dispute that and imagine it
took 200 years after Newton died to make
people comfortable to say that he was
incorrect you know 200 years was wasted
just because people trusted what Newton
say without question of that but luckily
over time the a lot of evidence surface
that light behaves like a wave and that
was in the mid 19th century and then
comes M Stein I call him the
troublemaker
Einstein said sorry guys
light is made of particles and knowledge
I am calling them photons but then he
was faced the dilemma
how can he justify
that in all the evidences over the past
hundred years that showed or all the
experiments that showed that light
behaves like a wave all a sudden now
he’s saying that it’s a particle and he
has experimental evidences shows that
light is a particle he said guys let’s
compromise and I have a clever idea he
was very creative and he said well let’s
call it both let’s just say light behave
like a wave and a particle at the same
time and this is where the concept of
particle wave duality was born it was
born from managed time and his creative
thinking of what light could be now
duality is not new it is deeply rooted
in human cultures we have many examples
that shows duality throughout history if
we take centers as an example in this
belief that the idea of centers was a
reaction to people who never saw a human
riding a horse
so horse riders from far away and
because they didn’t understand what that
meant they thought was a creature that
is half human half animal but then of
course when the rider came closer they
realized it’s just two creatures on top
of each other
well quantum mechanics is telling us
right now is to accept that light is
like a center it’s both wave and a
particle at the same time now light or
theories about light were not the only
ones that faced such drama there are
other theories that have similar or face
similar pattern if we take for example
either since the beginning of human
thinking either what was proposed as a
medium that fills empty space throughout
our universe they thought it can be
vacuum there has to be something that
fills all the empty space in our
universe and they give it a name and
they call it either now
in the 19th century the view of light as
a wave became strong but for that to be
supported there was a need for a medium
for the for the light waves to propagate
in and this has to be a strange medium
it has to be invisible and it has to be
infinite and it has to be something that
does not interact with physical objects
so now we’re faced with other dilemmas
how can you even imagine such material
in existence so there was a long debate
throughout history whether either exists
or not some people said yes it does
exist some people say no way that’s not
possible it’s not realistic well then
comes mekansm Mendelson took it upon
himself once for all to settle this
debate so he came up with a very clever
experiment to measure or detect ether
and he tried tirelessly to measure
either but he couldn’t so at the end he
said well I give up and you know I’m
saying that there’s no ether it does not
exist well then at the same time
Lawrence said well just because we
couldn’t measure it it does not mean it
doesn’t exist maybe there’s something
wrong with the experiment and then he
came up with some explanation to justify
why either could not be detected through
this specific experiment well most
people did not believe that so what what
most of the scientists decide to is to
look for alternatives to how can light
travels without such medium and then
comes the troublemaker again and Stein
and he finds a very convincing way using
his relativity to explain why Michelson
could not measure
he also said is not needed now what does
that mean he meant or what he said
guys look you know we’ve been crazy
enough to accept the concept of light
duality so when I just accept that light
just travel in vacuum at constant speed
and this one the speed of light came
about so he just proposed that another
solution another crazy solution to the
problem now what does that tell us it
tells us that science is always in
progress you know we should not take
[Music]
scientific theories for granted
you have witness how scientists went
back and forth between different
theories throughout history what if what
if you know new ideas come up what what
can we do you know even understand
himself when he said that we don’t need
to either and this is doing his when we
was working out his special relativity
theory later on when he developed his
generality theory he realized well we
need something similar to either so even
Einstein changed his mind later on about
some medium that should be in an empty
space so could either be the space-time
continuum that Einstein talked about
could either be dark energy that now
other people talked about we don’t know
and I hope maybe someday somebody in a
TED talk would tell us what either’s all
about
now scientific theories are you know the
best possible or best available
explanation to things as we know them
now we should not take them for granted
sign you know scientific theory
does not provide absolute truth it’s
just telling us what we know so far so
and I hope that that that message you
know gets across to a lot of people
because our people just think just
because an accepted theory is there we
think it’s that’s the absolute truth
well that’s now that that’s not the case
now I should also clarify that such that
the term or the expression
scientifically proven is a contradiction
in terms
there is nothing scientifically proven
you know what what what we know is
basically what you know whatever
experiments on toughness but that does
not mean that that’s the absolute truth
now in traditional schools students are
focusing on learning or understanding
accepted theories it is very rare that
students are being taught how to
challenge these theories and models you
know we should not teach students what
to think we should teach them how to
think and you know when when examining
any theory whether it’s physical or
biological or chemical theory you should
always consider or question the
assumptions what were the assumptions
when they were discussing this theory
also you should always question the way
the test was done not only that also the
way data was collected
remember mackelson experiment initially
he thought that his experiment proved is
still what they turned out it was wrong
and this experiment have been repeated
so many times you know he tried in the
mountains he charged in a cave it turned
the desert he tried
everywhere in different dimensions
different spaces even others not only
himself others have tried it just to
make sure that the test is correct and
this experiment is famous or known to be
the most famous failed experiment in
history so even though he failed he
still was recognized also we should look
into or we should always question
interpretations just like anything else
observations and data are open to
different interpretations just to give
you an example quantum mechanics and
quantum against there are ten
interpretations from quantum mechanics
what does that mean well to be frank
with you it means we don’t understand
quantum mechanics otherwise we wouldn’t
have ten interpretations for quantum
mechanics so don’t feel bad if you don’t
understand quantum mechanics some of the
smartest people have said they don’t
understand quantum mechanics I can give
you an example fireman he’s a Nobel
Prize winner in physics and he said it
he didn’t he does not understand quantum
mechanics duality does exist it’s not
just in our imagination an object such
as this cylinder this picture can
produce two forms of shadow at the same
time we can have a circle and a square
and in one setting what does that mean
it means it does exist but there are
also other alternatives the picture of
particle wave duality does not make me
comfortable and I would like to share
with you an alternative view or
alternative theory to which instead of
having a center you know a fake figure
we can have a particle surfing on a wave
and this this deal is known as the pilot
wave theory which was proposed initially
by debroglie in nineteen
twenty-seven and then restart again by
boom in 1952 what this theory tells us
that there is both a real particle and a
real wave but the wave actually
influenced that how the particle
behavior this concept has been recently
demonstrated experimentally by a group
at MIT and this is a video to show you
how this happens basically a group at
MIT managed to produce a droplet that
bounced on a surface of liquid and as as
this droplet bounced on that surface it
creates waves and then they were able to
demonstrate that these waves actually
guide their particle as it moves or as
it hovers over that that wave so after
all you know it is possible to have an
alligator that makes bird sound only if
we think that the bird is actually just
on top of the alligator it’s now
actually have alligator have bird I hope
I have sparked dance time in you to
think about the nature of flight because
we don’t know what we don’t fully
understand what light is and maybe one
of you someday will come up with an
alternative theory to explain the
behavior of light thank you very much
Please follow and like us: