Press "Enter" to skip to content

Sense and Sensibility | Pamela Dow | TEDxLeicesterSalon


[Music]
and yes my name is Pamela day I was
director strategy the Ministry of
Justice and I’m now working on something
called the new futures Network which is
trying to boost and prison reform and
basically think-tank the RSA and what I
want to talk today about is and some of
the principles underpinning the prison
reform agenda and Jane Austen the great
novelist and author of Pride and
Prejudice who gave us our title today
and died 200 years ago in 1817 and I
want to talk about Sense and Sensibility
which is the title of another of her
great novels and the case I want to make
is that the criminal justice system has
swung between Sense and Sensibility over
the years and actually where we blend
the two and find the balance between the
two is where real success lies so it’s
like please call some of you might
recognize the lady on the left that’s
Jane Austen soon to be gracing a
ten-pound note near you soon and I
imagine few of you recognize a lady on
the right that’s Jane Lee parrot and
Jane Austen’s aunt her mother’s wealthy
sister-in-law and on the 8th of August
1799 this Jane was accused of stealing
lace worth one pound from a hat shop in
bath and one pound was four times the
amount and that was the five five
shillings they meant that carried the
death penalty and James aunt said the
lace was in her bag by mistake the
shopkeeper said it wasn’t and she was
arrested on a charge of grand theft and
refused bail and committed to prison
Jane Lee Perrault was a rich respectable
woman it’s very unlikely had she been
found guilty she would have been
sentenced to death the alternatives
weren’t great either she could be in
brandied she could have been deported to
Australia for forced labour because of
her social standing and while awaiting
trials she was allowed to stay in the
house of the prison keeper and
jaelyn so in Somerset and her beloved
husband James was allowed to stay with
her and despite these concessions to her
status she wrote that she suffered
vulgarity dirt and noise from morning
till night and at her trial the jury
took 10 minutes to find her not guilty
based on her own and testimony and the
character references of her friends I
think we can all imagine what might have
happened to somebody who has less
refined than Jane Austen’s aunt and in
practice criminal justice in 1799 had
much more to do with sensibility than
sense and much more to do with the end
you know whims of individuals the
prejudices the social and norms of the
day community values and personal
experience or the lack of it and that
was rational at the time apart from the
Bow Street Runners in London there was
no organized police force and capture
and prosecution depended much more on
you know vigilantes the victims local
volunteer constables maintenance of law
and order depended much more on
deterrence than on apprehension so the
harshest of punishment went with them
went with the smallest of crimes and in
1799 200 fantasies carried the death
penalty and but in reality local judges
and juries had a huge amount of latitude
and juries could apparently and down
value the sum of stolen goods so it went
below that five shilling threshold that
carried the death penalty a judge might
look at the person in front of them and
say whether a barbaric punishment was
suitable appeal was very common and so
between 1770 and 1830 and 35,000
death sentences were handed down but
only 7,000 executions were carried about
sorry only 7,000 and so that’s a victory
for central office office over cents a
victory for individual context and
compassion but not a victory for
progressive values like equality before
the law not a not a victory for national
kin
assistance II or evidence-based
policymaking or good use of data this
was sensibility over stance so hold that
thought for me historians in the room
will know that that period separately
the late seventeen hundreds too early
eighteen hundreds was notable for a
reason other than them Jane Austen annex
minor celebrity lace collar crime and in
1779 the penitentiary Act was was passed
that was written by the reformer John
Howard and introduced a policy of state
prisons for the first time sixty new
prisons were built polluting this one
and in that period 1772 eighteen hundred
the prison population doubled fewer
people executed fewer people sent to
Australia fewer people brandy to put
more people sent to prison so pop quiz
and do we know and other and period when
the prison population doubled you can
see from that graph that’s the prison
population of this century we spiked
after the Second World War
conjecture has taught the reason for
that was but the really big leap was
from the mid nineties until now and the
explanation for that is very complex in
a nutshell better detection longer
sentences longer time in prison one in
three sentence crimes in prison today
are accounted for by violence against a
person drugs and sex offenses these are
all crimes over which Crown Prosecution
Service the police courts have very very
little latitude so we can chart and
criminal justice a progression over the
century as the application and triumph
of sense over sensibility of objectivity
of consistent national training and
standards of sentencing guidelines of
predictive analytics of forensic science
and this approach means that the
outliers can be identified the hanging
judges versus the lenient ones the rate
and the racial and social groups for
whom the systems manifestly unfair they
can be corrected and by the national
laws and policies and you know which can
be codified and rigidly applied I think
we can all agree that that’s you know
we’re pretty happy about that in
principle postcode lotteries are pretty
terrible in schools and hospitals but
very very bad in criminal
the idea that you could commit a crime
in Dorset and Yorkshire or not commit a
crime and have a different outcome seems
abhorrent to us and we’re all quite
happy forum senses a sense to triumph
over the potential vagaries of an
individual prison officer or the CPS or
are we haven’t we all felt the
frustration of the inerts
unthinking bureaucracy that this stopped
something happening not because it’s the
wrong thing to do but because the system
says no and the system wouldn’t let them
do otherwise so let’s go back to 1799 as
I described and the Jane Austen ants
crying to you we probably all had some
of the same thoughts let’s imagine the
2017 version of Jane Lee Poirot was
quite well-to-do maybe bored depressed
maybe a kleptomaniac maybe have some
sort of substance abuse problem there
was that was linked to her antisocial
behavior even if she was guilty we
probably all think that prison might not
be the right place for her and not
because she’s posh but because the bet
is you know her spending some time in
prison might not be the best way to keep
society safe and fair and to make her
pay for her crime we know now about the
success of restorative justice programs
or community sentences maybe she could
be forced to work in that hat shop for a
few months and you know close
supervision that has the value of being
a visible punishment but also helps her
make a local contribution restore social
capital excuse the jargon justice being
done being seen to be done and being
done well but too often at the moment
people needing these sort of initiatives
these sort of innovative local
approaches and we’re doing so in spite
of the system not because of it how
often have we all heard the term ask
forgiveness not permission when you’re
trying to do something a bit different a
bit full of you is used it in relation
to today
shouldn’t have to do either our goal
should be to blend Sense and Sensibility
to achieve a balance we don’t want to
dilute or diminish the blindness of
justice or the fairness of law but we do
want human beings to take context into
account and be allowed to do so and we
do want the criminal justice process to
work and it be effective we want people
all levels in the system to feel like
reducing harm to societies their
responsibility the police officer to ask
the right questions the CPS to know what
sort of sentences might be effective and
there to pass that information on to the
judges and we want to devote these
people to work with with the information
data and evidence at their fingertips so
what factors define assist what what
factors have to be present in a system
defined by Sense and Sensibility
that’s a next slide and happily we know
a lot of what works in public service
improvement from other sectors from
education from health and I you know
this isn’t me making this up I stand on
the shoulder of giants like Michael
Barbour and professor Julian the Grand
Andreas Schleicher
and the before necessary factors I’m
sorry you probably can’t read all this
I’ve done through it you can hopefully
read the brain the heart and the data
which is my very crude clipart formula
and you need to devolve decision-making
as closer to the frontline
decision-makers as possible you need to
empower the people closest to the
decisions being made and to choose how
to lead their organizations to allow
that to be successful you have to
properly invest in them and not just
salary although that that helps but at
the recruitment retention training
invest in your workforce to make sure
those two things are effective at the
same time as having some kind of
national consistency in standards you
need to have absolute transparency and
to make people accountable and that
isn’t about league tables and naming and
shaming it’s too untested to make a
system that’s in this intellectually
curious enough to understand why things
are happening not just what’s happening
and that allows you to set a higher
aspirations why shouldn’t we set our
standards against the performance of the
best and the only one of those things
that wasn’t present in 1799 and actually
it wasn’t present until very recently is
that third one really sophisticated
accessible transparent data and
information and it said with the sort of
system that allows us to be
intellectually curious as I described
exhibits a and I’m sorry this is a
horrible slide and I’m not going to talk
through it it’s the crown court
information tool I share it with you
here to ask you to go and explore it is
an online database is available at
justice gov dot uk’ it can it is a hold
comparative data for every single crown
court in the country you can tell why
Dobby has fewer fix trials and
Birmingham you can tell why volume crime
is seems to be better dealt with in the
Northeast than the northwest
it’s an amazing bit of kit and I’m
desperate for some data scientist to
just delve into it and find something
that public policymakers haven’t found
yet that understands why things are
successful in one place than the other
imagine if we had something like that
for the prison system prison and
probation again not to name and shame
but to just try and understand why
things are happening not what’s
happening and finally then let’s look at
this quite pleasing graph that shows
again you can’t really read it properly
but that’s the red liner female
offenders in the system and the blue
line it’s a prison population that we
saw earlier so you can see that as a
proportion woman in the system the trend
has been downwards and they’re about
4,000 women incarcerated at the moment
of a population of about 85,000 there
are many many reasons for this decrease
but my conjecture is that the N
a large part of this story is that we
better understand that some of the
better recognize that some of the crimes
women commit are linked to abuse
addiction and we treat those as well as
the criminality and because of the
relatively small numbers involved we
have good data and professional networks
police courts and prison officers were
trained to manage women in the system
there are very good examples of problem
solving courts disproportionately
working well with women family drug and
alcohol courts the police and rotation
services trained together so they’re
able to learn from the best we know the
impact of mothers being separated from
their children and in terms of
intergenerational tribe and we do
something about it it’s very very far
from perfect and I don’t want to sound
complacent up try not to catch CJ’s eye
because to be the first to accuse me of
complacency there’s so much more to do
and but I think the scenario we imagined
for a modern day janely Perrault was
what might be getting a bit closer
thanks in no small part to people I
could wiener Grosvenor and Sarah Payne
who is a prison Prison Service and lead
we have a national framework for
managing women in the system but we also
have a really empowered and intelligent
informed and network of people working
with them sense + Sensibility
I’ll give the last word to two heroes of
mine the first is Woodrow Wilson
American president and in that essay
which I recommend to all of you had and
slightly know the followers of civil
service reform like me and he captures a
fundamental challenge of trying to make
government better but if he appears to
be setting up a sort of mutually
exclusive choice for us between and you
know sense or Sensibility my version of
that would be strive for public services
that are just moderate and simple well
ordered and effective why should we
choose and but let’s give the last words
to Jane herself who gave us a title
today systems and policies and public
services are really just the combined
act of millions of individual people and
all of us are complicated bond
of Sense and Sensibility it doesn’t
really like do things as long as we do
the right things
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: