Press "Enter" to skip to content

Seeing through the complexity. On Earth’s ecosystem | Barbara Pietrzak | TEDxUniversityofWarsaw


back in December I wrote the quote
introducing Pavo garlic stock and I
thought hey we are going to talk about
the same quest the quest to understand
complexity like geneticists strive to
understand how the interactions of
thousands of genes make us who we are
ecologists strive to understand how
interactions of thousands of species
make ecosystems forests wetlands rivers
oceans what they are humans included
here is one of the many species but in
the pre present epoch one of centinall
influence on all the others and after
all this is what I will focus on today
because today it is high time we
acknowledged the effects of our own
actions the web of interactions in the
global ecosystem is complex yet I am
convinced that if we keep in mind the
very basics of how the nature functions
this will help us guide our everyday
actions to make my point that we need to
see the big picture and act responsibly
I need to answer two notorious questions
first why do we have to bother with
planetary processes and second is there
anything each of us could possibly
individually do to impact them before I
continue to answering these two
questions let me invite you to join in
solving two puzzles as ecology has
something to do with economics both deal
with our dwelling place or household the
puzzles are a simple calculation to do
which you can enjoy are you mines
radicular puzzle here they come a small
avocado and a big apple have together
190 calories the avocado has 100
calories more than the Apple the
question is how many calories does the
apple have take the very first number
that comes to your mind and share it
with your neighbor so that it sounds
ready okay here is the other one and
here they are again
costing together
one euro 90 the avocado costs one euro
more than the Apple the question is how
much does the apple cost again share
hope many of you unsaid 92 the first
puzzle though the answer is not 90 and I
hope you were reluctant to answer 90 in
the second puzzle that is to say an
apple cost almost as much as an avocado
it doesn’t here though the two though
mathematically the two are the same
puzzle the first one was a little bit
more abstract to most of us we know
something about energy in foods but
those who are not on a particular diet
to not count calories everyday
confronted with an abstract problem our
brain simplifies the task omitting the
more than part in the second puzzle most
of us already had some expectations for
the answer and our brains did not go
that easily into the wrong products I
show you this to point out to our
natural shortsightedness our brains did
not evolve to solve logical puzzles or
to uncover processes like global issues
but to acquire and distribute resources
to evaluate social context to decide
whether to cheat or cooperate that is to
solve everyday dilemmas of a social
primate those early humans who solve
these every day to name as well survived
and were produced passing on their genes
to us with such inheritance it is still
today not really hard for us to see to
accept and to react to problems like
global issues here comes my first
question why then bother with planetary
processes in our day lives at all
that is why geologists say that for some
decades we’ve been living in the new
geological epoch the intrapersonal this
is the time when these are us humans
that
shaped the surface of the planet if
Jurassic means dinosaurs to you
Anthropocene is humans squared and I
bring the name Anthropocene here not as
something for us to be afraid of but as
something to help us see and admit the
fact the time has come that these are
not just the glaciers or tectonic
movements but a single species Homo
sapiens ever more numerous is ever
faster changing the surface of the globe
to feed the growing population humans
transform the surface of the planet to
cropland you turn a virtual globe and
see the green and bears thinking forests
and deserts but when you start zooming
in vast territories start showing you
regular patterns of either wetter or
drier but still farmlands humans take a
quarter of all productivity of the
continents and the most productive lands
are already taken and those still
productive are disappearing ever faster
anytime you see a graph of this shape it
tells you about acceleration which is
one of the characteristic features of
Anthropocene to maintain productivity of
the soil humans supply oldest cropland
with elements essential for plants
growth at the scale of changing global
flows of these elements for producing
fertilizers we drew from the atmosphere
more nitrogen than all other life on
Earth has in its old history nitrogen no
leaks from the legs and fertilizes the
seeds enhancing processes like toxic
algal and bacterial blooms in waters
phosphorus also leaks from the fields
and some researchers say the case of
phosphorus even bigger as land deposits
of this element are almost exhausted
phosphorus shortage is something we need
to find solution for as it is a key
building element of energy transfer
molecules in all living things intensive
agriculture demands high energy inputs
and we still get almost 90
cent of energy we use from burning
organic remains
this results in enormous carbon dioxide
emissions today there is over 40% more
of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere then
it was some 200 years ago and possibly
much more than ever has for the last 400
thousand years this does affect the
climate and this all affect other
inhabitants of the planet their wild
populations shrink and disappear your
car windscreen is the first place to
observe that two or three decades ago
driving a car on the longer route ended
with a windscreen full of dead insects
said but strangely said er this is a
rare sight today and this is not because
we drive more slowly a study conducted
in Europe showed the overall biomass of
flying insects is now a quarter of what
it was just three decades ago these are
the pollinators of flowering plants
crops included that are gone gone are
the decomposers of the dead gone is the
food for bigger animals which do not do
much better themselves the global number
of all wild vertebrates or fish
amphibians reptiles birds and mammals is
now one third of what it was in the 70s
this means in some locations in some
ecosystems their populations disappeared
already in other locations they are too
few to play their ecological roles and
with the numbers the diversity
disappears the estimates say at least
100 species go extinct each year this
means some three species lost today how
many species can we take out so that the
global ecosystem as we know it still
functions and does not collapse what is
left then something that opened my eyes
a few years ago an illustration to
publish data found in a geek comic
series visualization of the global
biomass of all mammals present on land
which shows a
third or fourth morale kilogram on land
is us humans dark gray hair then our
animals most of all animals grown as our
food cows pigs goat sheep more than
double us in mass finally wild mammals
here in green make less than 3% this is
not how I imagined the planet I live in
the city ok but out there I thought dar
these deers antelopes elephants
carnivores rodents they all make less
than 3%
now imagine extraterrestrials coming to
earth and what they see cows and humans
rarely something else and human
influence reaches beyond land small
animals living ten kilometer down deep
in the ocean in the Mariana Trench have
their stomachs filled with plastic now
we will be not surprised to hear plastic
nanoparticles are found much closer in
lakes rivers drinking water the many new
substances were introduced into the air
so water does so many of them and in so
small concentrations that only now we
learn how to detect them in the
environment hormones antibiotics
antidepressants and many other things we
ever more often use and excrete are not
saved out by water treatment plants fish
do not die of tiny amounts of
antidepressants they just care less if
it’s day or night if it’s safe or not if
there will be preyed upon or not frogs
do not die of tiny omnipresent amounts
of hormones they just change sex subtil
effects and we do not see them all yet
yet they translate into how the
ecosystems function I claim we need to
face it all do you remember the puzzle
and the Apple we need to do the mass and
acknowledge our impact on the planet
even though our brains might be wired by
evolution for different tasks we need to
make this effort in order to fight
global probe
as complex as they might be this pays
off we have already stopped a
detrimental global process which we
first triggered the decline in the ozone
layer we understood the chemical chain
reaction behind the phenomenon we
introduced international laws cut freon
emissions and it helped indeed it
demanded a concerted international
effort can we as individuals make an
impact to answer the second question I
refer you back to the basics of the
economy of nature to the flows of the
very hard currency energy and this is
very important remind yourselves of the
very first classes in physics and in
ecology or maybe you saw it somewhere
else first energy cannot be created out
of nothing for life on Earth the Sun is
the main source of energy energy can be
changed but at each transformation from
one phone to another some energy is lost
there is no purpose to mobula so yes
energy is currency
acquire energy and transform it into our
bodies into a work into a offspring this
is all way living things do I want to
show you this currency flows in more
detail an animal gets energy by
consuming other organisms but usually it
does not eat them whole the arrows here
represent the flows of energy then part
of the consumed energy is excreted with
feces and urine before it is used only a
part is assimilated yet again
transformation of energy is costly and
as an animal grows and maintains its
body moves rep reduces some energy is
dissipated as what we call heat is lost
in the process of respiration an animal
exhales a great deal of carbon oxygen
instead of building them into its body a
fraction of the consumed energy is built
into tissues which
and we preyed upon by other animals and
so it goes from one level in the food
chain to another and each time some 90
percent of energy is lost from the chain
herbivore
gets some 10% of what plants acquired
the first carnival in the row gets some
10% of the 10% which is one and so on
and all we do to recoup the lost energy
to reuse the waste material to minimize
the loss is secondary and is energy
consuming by itself the simplest thing
to do is do what the Bison does eat
plants and get even an order of
magnitude more energy indeed there are
problems that need to be solved in a
systemic and synchronized manner but
this shows us there are things each of
us can do and the they are again and
again our everyday individual choices
and I claim along with many others the
single simple thing with greatest impact
you can do is cut your meat consumption
just keep in mind these calculations
whatever we do to feed our growing
population we need to engage an order of
magnitude more energy and naturally
other resources area of land amount of
freshwater fertilizers fossil fuels when
we produce meat that when we produce
plant food hypothetically what if we all
turned vegan consuming the same amount
of calories just replacing meat and
dairy with vegetable protein and oils we
would lower greenhouse gas emissions in
the next decade despite population
growth animal food production is simply
so much more energy consuming and more
waste producing carbon dioxide and
methane included anytime you cut your
animal food consumption a little you
make a big impact for another example
let’s take the avocado from our puzzle
and a meatball of a similar energy
content and compare the energetic costs
of obtaining them if you put these foods
equivalent in their energy content on
plates where the size of each plate
reflects the amounts of resources that
were used to produce the food the meat
comes on a very big plate plate being
again the amount of water fossil fuels
and so on can we afford the luxury of
the big plate and we’re short-sighted
minds will be fooling us to answer yes
we can’t afford that but we need to see
beyond the edge of our own plate see the
big picture see what is not easily seen
we haven’t seen the free on particle
reactant were breaking down into your
zone Oh sphere either this time there is
just a few links more to understand
links between our plate and the amount
of fossil fuels burned to understand the
whole process then we can start a chain
reaction ourselves take this knowledge
and act take your steak every second
time you otherwise would maybe one
portion of any meat a week would be
enough joyfully replace meat with
lentils Indian Dao dal or your local
traditional lentil dish they are
forgotten but plenty and explained
someone the basics of energy flows
through the system and why this matters
someone who will react and keep the
chain reaction going Copernicus
once showed us the earth is just a
planet in a planetary system Darwin
showed us humans are just a species
among others pieces these are very good
reasons not to feel that special nor
that responsible but want it or not
today in the Anthropocene the world is
back in our hands thank you you
Please follow and like us: