
today is a math education in fact I’m
going to start with math education and
I’m going to end my talk without math
education and it’s really important to
understand why I chose this title seeing
the way to succeed in school mathematics
because the key word here is seeing
because currently in our math classrooms
we do a lot of watching have you seen
the movie arrival yes if you haven’t you
should go see it and you’re probably
wondering why I’m asking you if you’ve
seen the movie arrival if you sit in a
theater and you watch a movie and you
really like it sometimes you go see it a
second time at third time in four times
some of us go see it 20 times does that
make me capable of making that movie not
at all I can sit in that movie over and
over and over again watch it very
carefully and really at best all I can
do is learn the script by heart but I
will never be able to see how to make
that movie and that’s exactly what we do
in mathematics classrooms is that we sit
children in mathematics theatres and ask
them to watch mathematics movies for
example the multiplication table over
and over and over again and then expect
them to know multiplication or know how
we built that table in the first place
so what they do in effect for those who
succeed in memorizing the multiplication
facts is that they’ve learned the script
at best they haven’t been behind the
scenes to know how to make a
multiplication table so that’s the
problem that’s the main problem with our
education right now in mathematics is
that we get the children to watch and so
they don’t see behind the scenes so
let’s see how that works what’s this
number I can’t hear you thank you what
about this one 123 what about this big
one
and in fact I can keep throwing numbers
are you and you will know them or at
least I hope so and that’s because
you’ve learnt or you’ve sat in that
mathematics theatre and you’ve learned
what we call the whole number decimal
enumeration chart that’s the script so
they put the script in front of you
you’ve memorized this so the first
number on the right is going to be your
your ones and then the tens and then the
hundreds and then the thousands and so
forth and you’ve learnt this quite well
but you didn’t learn how this chart was
created again this is the movie and not
the behind the scenes so what we’ll do
is we will go behind the scenes to see
why that is not working in fact that’s
what’s making a math education not
working so we’re going to write a script
because when you ghost watch a movie the
script is not just didn’t just appear
there somebody actually wrote the script
so I’m going to do a little activity my
earrings are clicking and take a lot
okay it’s also a strip show so we’re
going to use the numbers you know i’m
not going to do something crazy because
most people I know are not comfortable
with mathematics so we’re going to
choose the numbers one two three four
five six seven eight nine and we’ll use
t410 and notice there’s no zero right
we’ll get rid of 0 in fact historically
zero came really late late 16th century
so we’re just going to use these
numerals now and I want you to write or
think in your head how you would write
the numbers 8 2 22 with these numerals
all I’ve changes to remove is 0 and put
in a t410 well you’re probably thinking
this is how we write eight this is how
we write nine this is how we write ten
now because we have a symbol for that
which is called T and then you probably
sell it goes pretty easy let’s go on t1
because 10 plus one makes 11 t 2 for 12
t 3 for 13 all the way to 19 which you
probably think of t nine
team makes sense then you get to 20 then
it’s TG 1010 you know that makes 2010 10
14 21 10 10 24 22 when I asked this
question to my student teachers they
always give me these answers because
that’s what they learnt is that they
learned the script but they don’t really
learn how to write a script in effect
this is what is truly what we should be
writing so 848 949 t410 11 now why is it
I’m writing 11 this way not with a tee
well if you look at the T in the t1 the
t is in which column is in the tens
column so in effect that t1 represents a
hundred and one not 11 when you look at
11 with just 11 you don’t say 1+1 you’re
not adding the digits together you
realize that the first one on your left
is telling you how many tens so I have
110 and then I have a 11 so that makes
11 so 12 13 14 all the way to 19 so how
do we represent 20 without a zero well
it’s simply won t because i can put 10
ones in one column and then after that i
put sorry I’m going backwards 10 ones
and one column and then I simply need
one more 10 to account for the 20
objects and then 21 would simply be 21
to tens and 11 and 22 will be 2 to the
bottom line here is how we write a
script we learn what’s what’s the system
behind it and in fact we should be
creating those systems so how do we
write a hundred have two zeros to
contend with here so all I’m going to do
then is simply use my t410 so if I have
10 in my ones column how many more do I
need I need nine more tends to make a
hundred and so it writes 90 so what is
going on here is that I’m working behind
the scenes so instead of telling them
here’s the chart
results how it’s built and this is how
you place numbers in it we need to
engage the students in building that
chart so understanding how we build that
charge so we start with ones so let’s
say we use popsicle sticks then after I
have one’s counting by one is very
tedious especially that have a large
amount of things and so I’m going to
group them and then count the group’s so
I’m gonna make a bunch of popsicle
sticks here I chose five so I bunch my
five popsicle stick then I can simply
count bunches of five because it’s much
more quick to do that and then I will
regroup because even if I have a large
amount of popsicle sticks grouping them
by 5 i’m going to end up with the same
problem of having many groups of five to
call 22 count and so therefore it’s not
efficient so I’m so k so when I have
five bunches of five popsicle sticks
I’ll stick up in a bag and they can just
count the bags so what we’ve done
cleverly is develop this system of
counting that is so efficient it’s
become so efficient that we don’t
remember how we created that system then
we have to use symbols to code it either
verbally or in writing so if I’m
counting popsicle sticks by bunches of
five only 0 1 2 3 4 i’ll never see a 5
because the minute i have five things it
becomes one bigger object and then we’ve
introduced place value so in here we
have sticks then we have bunches then we
have bags and then we’d have boxes
crates and so forth right so this is
what our system is built on this idea of
these these points here this is how
we’ve developed this whole chart in the
first place so when we present children
with simply this chart already made up
they don’t get to see behind the scenes
they get to watch so it is a time for
change we know for over a hundred years
now that we’re not we’re failing to
children in school in mathematics and in
fact a lot of adults end up not liking
mathematics and choosing careers that
EGNOS make sure that they don’t have to
have any
Madison so it has a large impact and
really it’s just a change in the way we
do things are the way we approach the
teaching of mathematics now the results
and methods of mathematics or its
artifacts there the movie that we that
we go sit to watch in the theater the
actual mathematics lies in the thinking
that creates those artifacts so again
it’s behind the scenes of the movie that
the mathematics is actually occurring
and those artifacts are indeed
surprising just like arrival is a
beautiful movie to watch but that’s not
we want we don’t want kids to be become
really good at watching movies or
watching mathematical results we want
them to become mathematical thinkers so
some of those artifacts are surprising
sometimes we discovered with our
creative thinking that there are
irrational numbers now those numbers
were accepted only about 150 years ago
so it’s not unusual for learners to have
struggles to understand these particular
kinds of numbers no one here doubts that
even if they hate math it is practical
it serves practical purposes for example
the Pythagorean theorem is used in
construction to paint your wall in your
room you need to take some measurements
and know how much paint you’re going to
need so mathematics is practical but if
you speak to most mathematicians they’ll
tell you mathematics is beautiful how
many of you think mathematics is
beautiful very good well I do I find it
surprising and it’s practical but it’s
also beautiful here’s my favorite
formulas that a Laplace transform how
many of you are familiar with this one
how are you okay the level of class
transform is is a formula that takes a
very complex problem and converts it
into a simple problem to solve so very
powerful it’s a very powerful formula
and that’s what makes it beautiful so
I’m talking about mathematical thinking
so well how do we do that and what is it
so mathematical thinking is a whole way
of looking at things of stripping them
down to their numerical structural or
logical essentials and of analyzing the
underlying patterns it’s a way of
looking at the world seeing the world in
ways that you can size things you can
time things you can measure things you
can see the patterns what’s the same
what’s not the same the relationships
among things that’s what mathematical
thinking is all about but if we teach a
script in other words we keep plopping
these kids in the mathematics theater
instead of having them work behind the
scenes then we get the results we get
for that right I was in grade one
working with grade 1 kids this year and
I asked him a very simple problem 3 I
gave him sequences of numbers 3 4 what
number six seven eight I also put the
box at the beginning what number comes
before four five six seven and I even
put the box at the end through two three
four or five what number comes after
that well I wasn’t surprised with the
teacher surgery was this is what they
answered they put one in all the boxes
and that’s because the script is you
count one two three four five six so for
them no matter where it was you have to
start the script at one and I have lots
and lots of examples of this of children
who watch mathematics instead of being
interactive with the mathematics they
give you these kinds of results but can
we get kids to think that’s a good
question there’s a lot of debate right
now about thinking skills cognitive
ability executive functions and so forth
and I’ve been working closely with
children all my career and I can tell
you that yes it’s actually easier to get
them to think than my adults so
absolutely we can get them to learn to
think and once we get them to learn to
think then we know that they can develop
mathematical thinking so we need to get
sure to be sure that they can think
first I’ll give you an example at the
beginning of
year I gave them these figures very
simple shaped squares circles and
triangles and I asked them to look
carefully with their eyes to see what is
different one of them is very different
from the others and they responded
immediately some of them said a some of
them said these some of them said see
and then when I asked them why they
chose I want they said why not I said
but look just look very carefully with
you guys see what’s the same what’s not
the same you know they just looked at me
with blank looks ok well let’s be then
no no no I don’t want you just to give
me an answer I want you to look
carefully at this and there was they
didn’t seem to understand what I was
asking them to do so we did some more
activities where they had to observe and
discern what’s the same and what’s not
the same and so for then they got better
at it they got so good at it that they
surprised me after about four sessions I
gave them another similar problem but
this time I threw in some noise in grade
one there’s they’re learning language so
they’re learning how to read and how to
write so I presented them with letters
which had nothing to do with the the the
task but it was just to add some noise
to see how well they would do and I
asked them which one of these doesn’t
belong I’m math person so I know it’s w
because W has four lines and all of the
other letters have three lines most of
the children pick 2w and I was quite
happy but then I asked of wine and they
said because it starts with adi and i
went ok can you explain that to me go
Wow a F and H wd4 w of it oh my goodness
that is so smart I was thinking dude
simple numbers of lines and instead they
came up with something a lot deeper
using their language knowledge in order
to look and see what’s going on with
these letters so absolute
we can change from not having a clue
what to do with the task to actually
coming up with something that surprised
me as a researcher and that brings me to
my conclusion and the idea that I’m
trying to push that I’ve been trying to
push for great many number of years is
that instead of teaching mathematics
what we should be doing is teaching
mathematical thinking which in of course
it requires thinking so we need to go
away walk away from mathematics
education and start looking at
educational mathematics so that the kids
are using mathematics really to learn
about seeing the world and we’re back to
my movie arrival so I thank you very
much [Applause]