Press "Enter" to skip to content

Science and Morality | Michael Lynch | TEDxKU


after years of pestering and annoying my
family friends really anybody I could
corner into having a philosophical
debate with me I finally have a captive
audience so it should be great
as the title suggests we’re gonna be
talking about science we’re gonna be
talking about morality more specifically
we’re gonna be talking about the link
between the two could it be possible
that science has something to say about
what we should believe in and how we
should have in our daily lives hopefully
about the end of this talk you’ll be
convinced that there is but as it is
said in the title of this event tonight
that the theme is reflections and so I
will be talking a little bit about
myself although unfortunately compared
to the source material or the material
we’re gonna be covering in the rest of
this talk it’s exceedingly boring my
life but we’ll get through it as quickly
as we can when I was young I was
obsessed with science I was obsessed
with science and I still am I would play
with my toy dinosaurs and I would know
everything about them where they lived
when they died why they died and where
where they went how they acted how they
behaved what their names were I knew
everything and I carry that that the
thirst for knowledge with me today and I
carried it through my entire life so far
I wanted to know everything and as I
started to get into high school and then
higher levels of education I started to
learn incredible things like me you the
chair you’re sitting in the car you
drove here the planet you live on
they’re all made of exactly the same
stuff which is incredible to me they’re
all made in the exact same place in the
bellies of stars which i think is
unbelievable really almost magical but
not quite and you know the fact that
every single one of us here has almost
exactly the same DNA and in fact you and
me share 60% of our DNA with a banana so
you are 60% banana or a banana at 60%
you however you want to take that all
these things I learn it and eventually I
started looking up into the Stars and I
realized that we are just one small
insect
to give planet in one decently sized
solar system in one a ver aside galaxy
that’s where we are by the way and that
is just one in trillions of galaxies in
the universe by the way we can’t
actually see the whole universe that’s
why we call it the observable universe
it might be infinite there might be an
infinite amount of galaxies with an
infinite amount of planets that’s
incredible
and if you think about it all those
things are made of the same stuff –
exactly the same stuff as well
unbelievable really and you know what I
would look up into the Stars well
actually it’d probably look more like
that cuz you know light pollution but
you know I look up into the Stars and I
wonder you know is there morality in the
universe and I don’t think it’ll be
controversial to say that the universe
itself is a moral not immoral but a
moral Jupiter does not give a damn
whether you live or die regardless of
what your horoscope says you know the
galaxies are not making are not having
moral quandary about destroying each
other and running into each other
destroying billions of years of hard
work on account of the atoms that made
them they don’t care and that kind of
struck something in me because I looked
up and I saw these things and then I
would look down and I think well we’re
all made of the same stuff mean the
galaxies the whole universe so if
morality doesn’t apply to the universe
then what is morality does it apply to
me is it just something that we tell
ourselves to help us sleep soundly
enough and I really started to get into
a moral crisis about the universe oh
yeah I mean it’s like what is the point
is there a point to being moral is there
a point of me existing and this is high
school at the time guys so I was kind of
freaking out yeah I had enough to worry
about it was barely cats passing my
chemistry exams let alone thinking about
the existential problem with the truth
free but you know one thing I didn’t
lose yeah I lost a lot of things you
know my faith my my hope I lost a lot of
things but one thing I didn’t lose was
my thirst for knowledge I kept that with
me I kept trying to learn as much as I
possibly could about the world we live
in regardless of what it taught me
regardless of how it made me feel that
is one good thing about science is that
it doesn’t care how you feel about it it
exists regardless and so the more I
learned the more I realized even though
we I in the universe are also similar it
also helped me learn about how different
we are
it helped me learn about how unique
Humanity is I mean cosmic cosmologically
speaking life you don’t see it every day
in fact it is possible although
hopefully not true that we might be the
only habitable planet in the universe
now but far as we know that’s the case
but what does that mean does that mean
we’re special we unique well let’s find
out let’s start simple okay so how about
we just have a working definition of
morality now some might say well the
golden rule would be a good way to sum
up morality and I’m talking secular
morality not associative one particular
creature or another so the Golden Rule
do unto others as you would do to
yourself now that’s a good start but
what about the rhinoceroses what about
the giraffes what about the bug then you
step on every day you don’t know this I
mean are they part of the moral
community too I think that a good
working definition of what it means to
be moral is to whenever and wherever and
however possible try to increase the
flourishing or promote the flourishing
of autonomous and sentient creatures
in at the same time we have to do our
best to obstruct and cast out the
beliefs of people whatever that try to
impede on that and what it what does it
mean to be sentient well that just
basically the ability to think and feel
and not just feel like oh that hurts but
I’m in love or I’m very angry when I’m
very nervous as I am right now now this
wasn’t my idea actually this is with
other speakers and other people much
more intelligent than I am like Sam
Harris well and I agree with it well so
with that with that said with a working
definition of morality in place let’s
talk about football there are objective
things about football and this is how we
can tie in science now if in any pursuit
in life if you are not up-to-date on the
scientific advancement of the time and
not just football I mean everything
literally everything in the entire world
we couldn’t have without the advances of
modern science made in transportation
agriculture modern psychology
communication industry what-have-you and
this is an exhaustive but by no means a
complete list of everything that science
makes possible well so how does that
kind of football if I dress like this in
modern day football and I go up against
someone like this regardless of how how
tough I am regardless of how well I
understand the plays regardless of how
much natural talent I have if I’m not
wearing the right equipment I will get
destroyed by this man regardless of what
I do the same can be said with really
any pursuit if I’m a doctor and I don’t
believe in antiseptic I don’t think I’ll
get a lot of patients if I am a lawyer
and I don’t know how to use a computer
to communicate with people and so they
can help me help them I probably won’t
get a lot of clients it’s the it’s the
truth in every single pursuit in in
human history since the dawn of time if
you’re not up to date then you’re you’re
behind the time and in some ways
irrelevant
well how does this apply to morality
morality is in the exact same boat if I
don’t understand the world I live in
both scientifically bla philosophically
what-have-you culturally then I can’t
make good moral decisions so if I don’t
understand the world I live in
how can I truly be moral well maybe
there we go now you might think I’ll
talk about deforestation or polluting
the water or nuclear waste but these are
not issues of ignorance the size this is
an issue necklace I mean that no one’s
going into these pursuits innocently
anymore no one is pouring nuclear waste
into the ocean be like what what
happened you know no one’s saying that
anymore we know what we’re doing in
these situations I could talk about
climate change but as I’m sure my dad
could attest I probably couldn’t
convince you that it actually exists so
we won’t talk about that what I do want
to talk about is a particular species of
frog the Panamanian frog and it lives or
rather lived in Central America no
longer exists in the wild it’s now by
all by all definitions extinct there’s a
few hundred individuals that live in
captivity but this frog used to be one
of the most popular animals like almost
like a mascot of Central America they
had statues little trinkets toys
what-have-you of the Frog and a few
decades ago it just disappear and we
have no idea why I had no idea it wasn’t
because we were poisoning the water
supply it wasn’t that we were doing
anything that we knew would be harmful
we were ignorant to what we were doing
to this frog and this wasn’t hundreds of
years mind.you disappearance this was
this is two decades and this thing is
gone millions of sentient creatures died
painfully in droves you could find piles
of frog bodies all over and so you know
well it turns out that we started
looking at other frogs for answer
some of them started having fungi grow
inside of the dead bodies of these frogs
where was this coming from I mean we
traced it all the way back to Europe and
it turns out there’s a species of Toad
that can grow this fungus and it’s
immune to the effect that it has on the
frogs that died off in Central America
and people ignorant to the fact that
this fungus can be harmful brought that
toad over to United States and then it
eventually migrated down to Central
America
spreading the fungus wherever it went
and because of our ignorance we allowed
millions of intelligence feeling
creatures die painfully now just because
we didn’t know what we were doing does
that mean we’re not at fault morally I
don’t think it does I think that we are
to blame for this because we weren’t
educated enough to make a good decision
so that’s how science can help us
practically in morality but I want to
move this talk to a little bit of a
different direction I’m going to propose
something to you hypothesis take or
leave it that I think might help us find
objective moral truth now what I mean by
objective moral truth is something that
you can carry with you no matter where
or when you go in time and space and you
can still believe in those things and
they are objectively true the issue with
faith based or ideology based morality
is that it’s culturally based and I
won’t single out any religion yeah
actually I will I’ll use ancient Greek
religion because I don’t think there’s
any worshippers of Zeus in that audience
right and if you are I apologize I will
not be sacrificing a goat to your God to
appease him but let’s look at ancient
Greece everything about the ancient
Greek gods was Greek they did the exact
same thing the Greeks did they laid
around and drank wine and had wonder its
battles and and you know and so on and
so forth it was exactly like Greek
culture the God and the same can be said
with every religion and ideology based
faith in the world so what’s the issue
with that cultures don’t usually like to
agree with one another and they usually
like to believe that
right and so when two people think
they’re right or two cultures think
they’re right usually good things do not
happen usually bad things and the
problem with that is that if you’re
looking for objective moral truths and
you use faith to justify them you’re
actually breeding moral relativism and
well moral relativism is
counterproductive to having morality
that can span time and space it’s an
issue now science on the other hand
deals in objectivity there’s no Japanese
chemistry
there’s no Brazilian physics if I went
to a physics talk and I said well this
whole gravity deal it’s a good idea but
I think that things should move away
from each other rather than towards each
other I’d be laughed out of that
conference these are objective truths
the laws of physics and laws of
chemistry are objective no matter which
way you look at it you can’t say that
water is made out of special oxygen and
special hydrogen hydrogen so if we can
if we can get moral values from the
scientific method it is possible to find
that these moral values would be
objective no matter where you go because
that’s what science deals it so I want
to focus on biology to propose this this
new type of morality in the pinnacle of
biology is of course evolution now the
problem most people have with a secular
Darwinistic type of finding a way to be
moral is that a lot of people think that
the famous line survival of the fittest
they kind of don’t understand what
Fitness means in the natural world they
think that if we resort to Darwinism to
get our moral values then everyone will
be killing each other in the streets
because they’re the biggest they’re the
strongest and I’m weaker so Byard the
right of nature they should kill me but
that’s not what it’s not what Fitness
means Fitness is not brute force its
adaptability and in my opinion nothing
makes you more adaptable
then apply to telogen not just
intelligence cuz I’m sure you know
someone who’s very intelligent but also
very dumb but applied intelligence makes
you the most adaptable creature on the
planet in fact we’re so adaptable we’re
so intelligent and I like to think the
humans are intelligent despite some
political yeah you might look at
political figures and think that maybe
they’re not that intelligent but I’d
like to think we’re pretty smart and in
fact we’re so smart that we don’t even
have to genetically grow for a cotan to
live in the Arctic although I’m growing
my fur coat right now we don’t have to
do that
they live in cold places anymore it
doesn’t take millions of years of
evolution to live all across the globe
we don’t have to grow gills to live near
the coast it’s because we’re smart
enough to adapt just the way we are so
nothing makes you more adaptable than
applied intelligence and in my opinion
there’s nothing more intelligent than
having mutual responsibility for one
another there’s always it’s always a
good idea to have someone watching your
back and to expend a little bit of
energy to watch their back in the hopes
that together you’ll be able to survive
this whole deal because I’m not going to
be able to take the world on by myself
and neither are you and neither is
anything or anybody and so the more
people that you have mutual
responsibility for the easier it will be
to survive in this thing we call life
and it’s really hard to be responsible
for something if you’re not concerned
for it for instance it’s extremely hard
for someone to do their math homework if
they don’t give a damn about it I’m
sorry mom but it’s extremely boring I’m
not concerned about it at all and so it
would make evolutionary sense to have
biological foundations for caring about
one another it makes sense if I don’t
care about you I’m probably not gonna
take responsibility for you and you need
my help and vice versa and so if we can
start caring about each other it’ll be
much easier for both of us to survive
and have children and our families will
get bigger and we’ll all be able to
survive and with happy lives what does
this mean for morality I don’t think
it’s a very big step
from in CERN to carry and from carrying
to morality in again using the working
definition we had early in earlier in
the presentation caring for all sentient
creatures not just ourselves because the
more we learn the more we begin to
understand that without all the other
creatures appear we’d all be dead I mean
for God’s sakes products from bees if
the bees died a lot of people are gonna
die
seriously look it up but the more we
start to understand the world we live in
the more moral or allowed to be and so
I’d like to leave you today by asking
you a question what do you think I mean
if there’s anything that you can take
from this talk I don’t want you to think
that I’m telling me what to believe the
good thing about science is that it
teaches you how to think it doesn’t tell
you what to think and I think that it
would be a good idea for us to think
critically to understand the world we
live in the only way we’re gonna be
truly moral is to understand what we’re
doing you can’t be moral in a vacuum if
I don’t understand the rules of football
then I’m not gonna play good football
you know if I go to if I go to Argentina
or whatever I say let’s play football
and they start kicking it around with
their feet that’s not football
it’s so objectively just because
morality might be an accident of
evolution that doesn’t mean that it
can’t have objectivity football is an
accident of American culture and it does
have objective rules and values so don’t
be afraid of morality being something
that was an accident because it does
exist but it might not be missing a
metaphysical so if there’s one thing you
can take it should be that the
scientific process and the scientific
method can make you more moral and if I
can submit to you if you want
objectivity in your moral values you can
have that we can only have it through
the one objective based process that we
currently have access
and that’s the scientific method thanks
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: