Press "Enter" to skip to content

Say No to Piracy! | Muthoni Garland | TEDxKilimani


I want to tell you about my first
experience with piracy it was in the mid
1980s and I just joined the advertising
industry and yes I’m older than I look
and we went on a raid piracy rate in
Madera Valley and in this very humble
Shack in the middle of the slum we found
a little homemade factory in which some
young men were busy wrapping soap in the
wrapper of our best-selling clients
brand and and then obviously they were
going to sell this and this was my first
experience and I felt I knew it was
wrong what they were doing but I feel
slightly amused partly sorry for them
you know I thought these are hustlers
trying to make a living and amuse
because the word piracy at that time had
this swashbuckling Hollywood sort of
vibe you know
piracy high seas Miletus O’Malley’s you
know and it was hard to take seriously
fast-forward 30 years and I’m here at
story moja and we get the unbelievable
news we’re such a small publishing
company and we get the unbelievable news
that we’ve won a government tender to be
the suppliers of a textbook that is used
in secondary schools it’s a very big
deal and we win the tender at the end of
December we send a book off for printing
after you finish the artwork and all
that we send it for printing and January
the very first week of January barely
days after we send it out I get a call
from one of our sales people saying
Milani our book is on the street it’s
being sold the book is called Kiko go
okay go goes on the street and I said
that can’t be we haven’t received it
from the printer and so we report it add
to the Kenya copyright board
and the anti-counterfeit police and we
go and we read this hawker who is
selling it on the adrenaline side of
nairobi and and there we find our books
and what had happened is somebody had
stolen them from the printer and was
selling them there and we thought ok
problem but problem solved
they’ve just stolen books it’s just a
cartoon they will you know that’s
contained wrong within days I get
another call another place this time not
even adrenaline side we’re talking you
know leafy suburb side and there are
books again being sold this time in a
bookshop and when we find out is that
what actually happened is somebody went
took the stolen copies and they have
gone and reproduced scanned and
reproduced relatively poor quality
copies but nevertheless they were
selling them and again I repeat this is
before we at story moja have received
the books from our printer our book is
on sale we’re in a panic what’s going on
and perhaps I should take this
opportunity to tell you what piracy is
maybe some of you are still unclear
piracy according to dictionary.com is
there unauthorized reproduction sale or
use of somebody’s copyrighted material
material that is illegally obtained now
what does that mean it means and some of
you here I am sure University students
it means when you’ve invited me to your
university and this is a true story
and at the end of my talk you have come
to me as fans very excited
motherly we love your work you know sign
our sign your book for us and the book
you are presenting for me to sign is a
photocopy that is piracy right so I
started thinking is piracy happening
only because people are innocent maybe
they don’t know what piracy is and why
don’t they know or is there something
else going on
and then I thought you know after I’ve
talked to enough people I realized a lot
of people think publishing equals
printing so therefore we are doing no
more than they are you know they
photocopy what’s the difference right so
why are you making such a big deal I
mean we’ve had this conversation even
with police that you are going on a raid
with you know where they ask you know
did they jump over the fence and steal
did they break down your barriers you
know what is this they just have copies
that they’ve copied what does that mean
but publishing is not just printing
printing is at the end of a lot of other
work the major investments in publishing
is in content creation we create
original content that means we run
workshops we work closely with authors
to develop the books it means we invest
in warehouses we invest in distribution
we invest in printing we invest in
marketing we invest in finance
administration legal or other things
that are real business it’s a huge
investment to get into publishing in
this market and yet I love publishing
the scale of piracy is huge and it’s
making nonsense of a lot of this
investment because just within that
month I’m telling you the book we
launched in and in fact the book was
published kay gogo was published and
printed by the end of by the end of
January we started distributing it in
February we’re now in just beginning of
April so when we started distributing in
February between February and March
we’ve had 10 major cases of piracy that
we are actively pursuing through the
court system just that period including
the one that was in the papers and we
got a lot of coverage thank you very
much Kenyan media that doesn’t always
happen because we’re not politicians but
it did make it did make the news that
that the kenya copyright board had led a
raid in which ten in which 5.5 million
shillings worth of books had been found
in the middle of gong in the middle of
gong town
and amongst those 5.5 million shillings
worth of books were our little humble
offering or not so humble
it’s very good skulky go go anyway there
were over a thousand copies of key gogo
and during that very same press
conference in which we were displaying
this array of books that have been
pirated we then discovered there’s yet
another raid that is that was that had
just been conducted where they’d found
10 million shillings worth of books a
whole container load that clearly had
come from outside the country they had
printed the books in India and had
brought them so it is not thing it is a
vast criminal enterprise at work it is
well funded they have good distribution
they know what they’re doing now the
main players who are involved in this
anti-piracy campaign it’s not just the
publishers who have major losses and
just so you understand the scale I’m
talking about the kind of Publishers
Association as estimates that roughly
50% of all textbooks are pirated roughly
50% long horn if you remember went
public they’re one of the largest if not
the largest publisher in our parts of
the world they went public I think in
2013 or 2014 and last year they made a
public declaration that they lost in
2016 four point five million shillings
and sorry
I repeat four point five million dollars
u.s. dollars 450 million shillings lost
to pirates lots to lost to piracy
so piracy is not small the other players
who are involved apart from Kenya
Publishers Association is the Kenya
copyright board the anti-counterfeit
police we have obviously the Ministry of
Education in fact the Ministry of
Education has now declared that all our
books have to have a special sticker and
this special sticker is our technology
the industries technology attempts to
combat
the Pirates so we put a sticker on the
top you know on the front cover of the
book and if you scratch the sticker it
has a unique 16 digit code and on that
if you text in that 16 digit code to the
number provided it’s a pretext you’ll
immediately get a response that tells
you this is a genuine book and hopefully
that will give you a lot of comfort why
because when these books are pirated
let’s just talk about the damage that
first of all let’s talk about what
happens to the students so the student
buys pirated books wherever it is they
buy them on the street in book shops or
wherever it is that they buy books
oftentimes you can’t even tell it is
pirated oftentimes you can so let’s
start with the ones which came out very
quickly because you can these two books
are pirated now you can see the
variation in terms of color and all that
but more than that if you look at these
two books more closely and I’m sorry
that you can’t see them closely enough
you will see that the printing is very
uneven
it is squib if you go through it you see
that the binding is very poor if you go
through it some pages are actually
missing if you go through some of the
pirated books you find you know the
pages are upside down you think you know
it’s been cut off at the top so that you
can’t even read the book properly and
this is the book on you know based on
which students are going to do their
final year que si se exam so imagine you
as a parents are paying for that but you
as a parent you know you don’t even
realize what that happened is by buying
these books illicitly on the street
thinking and it’s not even to save money
cause pirates Ella the same price since
the government mandates the price you
know Manuel says you must sell it there
at that particular price then what
happens is you enable the very people
who are going into the schools to steal
the books to come and sell on the
streets
so beyond piracy it is also enabling
direct theft that schools complain
bitterly about
in fact it’s come as a shock to me late
in my life you know that’s people
actually is in school they actually have
strong rooms to to lock up to lock up
books and discourage the use of
libraries because libraries they’re too
free you know people can come in and
steal the books and I’m wondering no we
did libraries but no duh that’s a story
for another day
there’s damage done to the quality of
the brand so when people to me and they
say but only you guys honestly we like
to support African publishers but you
guys can’t even print straight you know
it’s a damage to our brand
why are you chopping off logos what’s
you know damage to our brand but it’s
more than that
it is damage in terms of you think about
16 percent of the book price is v80 you
think the Pirates are handing over their
v80 no they are not now there’s no you
can answer there’s damage done there’s
it’s done in terms of loss of income but
it’s not just loss of income a t2
Madonna’s pocket its loss of income to
authors so the authors who are sweating
hard to try and create good materials
exciting African narratives etc I mean
that’s they’re not getting the royalties
they deserve and what’s happening is a
lot of authors will then come back to
the publisher and they’ll say how can
you say my royalties are like this when
I’m seeing my book everywhere I go to
school my book is there everybody’s got
a copy of it what do you mean that I’m
not earning more royalties than this and
they don’t realize you know half the
sales actually coming through there
right for publisher so the loss of
income is to authors it’s to the
industry itself it is also an incredible
distraction we’re a small publisher but
already months into this game and we’ve
got two full time people we’ve hired
just to deal with piracy I am frankly
tired of going on raids it’s sounding I
mean it’s in fact I need to write a knob
out of this it’s it it’s unbelievable
the stuff that goes on there’s the cost
you know you think about the cost you
know you have to come up with this new
technology have to
take it manually at the moment because
we’re just frantically you know trying
to deal with the issue that you know
that exists that you are coming into but
it’s worth Matt I’m a writer I’ve spent
ten years and a very passionate reader
and I’ve spent the last ten years of my
life advocating reading for pleasure
preaching the gospel of reading wherever
I can
starting story much a festival we’ve got
the National leading the National read
aloud where over 400,000 kids read from
the same book on the same day in fact
you have the world record on that by the
way and there’s so many things that we
have done a story about the starting
libraries in primary schools all sorts
of things that many many many many
people have joined hands with us to
achieve and yes African readership is
growing which is fantastic so where the
books to feed this growing industry well
that’s a question many authors ask me
why aren’t you investing more in non you
know in in non educational materials in
fiction in exciting nonfiction in
biographies in other areas in topic
books about topical Affairs for God’s
sake there’s so much to write about so
that we can shape the world according to
our African you know to AH let the world
see us through our eyes rather than
there let us write the African books
from here not just from there and what
has happened is that we who believe that
we can do it we have the brains we have
the the ambition we want to do it
what’s hampered us for a long time is
the finances so when we get a win like a
Go Go and we’re celebrating we’re
celebrating not just because that you
will make money but because we’ll make
the money to really go and do the things
we’ve been want to say secretly but you
know the things that we’ve been really
wanting to do then we are hampered
because half the revenue goes to the
Pirates and then it and then a
significant portion of the rest is just
fighting those pirates so suddenly we
don’t have the financial muscle to go
out there and encourage you the readers
you the writers to work with you to
create the
African narrative and I find that you
know it’s like killing the big B know
the literature baby in the womb before
it’s born that’s what Pirates are doing
and it’s wrong wrong wrong so what I
want to appeal to you to do it’s not
many things before before we kill
stillborn the next Ben Oh Chris the next
Ellen van doos the next page of monkeys
the next Charlene cashout jeez
can we just say no to piracy can we just
end this story before we ruin children’s
education before we make it impossible
to nurture the production of new books
then please let’s say no to piracy it’s
not that difficult with this technology
all it is is if you find a sticker don’t
just look at it and admire it and say
wow no scratch it first of all look for
it don’t buy one without a sticker
scratch it and please call in and verify
it’s not difficult honestly it’s a
pretext text actually it’s not even a
call it’s a free text and we’ll verify
and if we verify then you know you’ve
got the real deal and you’re helping us
fight piracy they know to piracy if you
have any information about piracy anyone
selling illegally without stickers even
if it look like the real deal like I
said sometimes they print in India or
other places and they produce really
good books even if it doesn’t have as
well doesn’t have the sticker it’s not a
bona fide book from story moja or indeed
from any of the other textbooks or set
book manufacturer publishers if you know
please whistle blow if you know please
please please if you know any technology
any solutions please write to us at info
at africa at info at story mode africa
don’t co dot ke please write to us and
let us know we really need your help to
fight piracy help me say no to piracy
[Applause]
you
Please follow and like us: