Press "Enter" to skip to content

Saving Private Mind: Madness, Privacy, Consciousness | Howard Hendrix | TEDxUCR


changes in privacy affect consciousness
can the sense of a loss of privacy be
connected to be linked to a loss of
sanity itself I would prefer not to have
dealt with these questions but I had no
choice
36 years ago my younger brother Vincent
John J Hendrix started to manifest
symptoms that are generally defined as
schizoaffective or paranoid
schizophrenic my experience with him
though did show me it made me think
about the would to learn a discussion of
privacy and consciousness the point that
I feel that discussion vastly
underestimates the importance of privacy
to consciousness I would have preferred
to leave it to the philosophers the
psychologists the neuroscientists the
lawyers and it is heavy lifting just
looking at the various types of privacy
just a small sampling shows you that
privacy is a philosophical concept
privacy is a psychological space privacy
is a neuro physical state privacy is an
a matter of social etiquette privacy is
a recurrent issue in internet and
information technology policy privacy is
an amendment is a right implicit in the
first third fourth and fifth amendments
to the Constitution privacy is asserted
as a fundamental human right in article
12 of the United Nations Universal
Declaration of Human Rights and that’s
just a sampling of privacy this is a
sampling of all the many many many
theories of mechanisms for consciousness
over the last couple of decades don’t
stare at it too long it’ll suck your
brain into an alternate universe okay
but that’s a good thing for me because
the science of consciousness remains
very much speculative research that live
leaves a space for someone like me to
make a connection between something to
do with what happened to my brother and
something to do with the way
we live now during the 1980s in his
early 20s my younger brother came to
believe that the private channel of his
stream of consciousness was being
intercepted compromised today we might
say hacked in such a way that he felt
all his inmost feelings and experiences
all his intimacy’s were being leaked
into the public sphere by DJs on the
radio stations he listened to this is
the last picture we have of him
it is a photo copy taken from his
University of Wyoming at Laramie student
ID he was a PhD candidate there in
Native American history was also used in
this have you seen me poster from late
October 1988 my distant cousin John
Keenan was posting that up all around
Laramie but that was only to serve the
tail end of a larger craziness he had
felt for many years that although he was
nobody there was a vast conspiracy of
nuns and priests focused on him would
this filled icky indifference he wasn’t
sure they were human he thought they
might be robotic flesh automata I say
Phil dick Ian is a reference to a
science fiction writer fellow science
fiction writer philip k dick and also
someone who was purportedly like my
brother they suffer from mental health
problems let’s get to effective or
paranoid you know him even if you don’t
know his name his story do Androids
Dream of Electric Sheep was made into
Blade Runner Minority Report was based
on a story by him called Minority Report
paycheque based on a Phil dick story
Adjustment Bureau based on a Phil ok
dick story inception based on folk a
there’s a lot of them and the recurring
questions in Phil chaotix work are what
is private what is human what is real my
brother after his first episodes became
obsessed with the works of philip k dick
he felt that philip k dick was a kindred
spirit Philip
KFOR kindred that is his middle name and
the reason he felt that was many of the
characters in Phil dicks work had that
similar experience of a sense of loss of
privacy contributing to a feeling that
they were becoming like all you zombies
like flesh automata Phil dick wasn’t the
first one to address this relationship
between privacy and consciousness the
19th century Danish philosopher Soren
Kierkegaard wrote at length about what
he called social chatter the endless
talk of private matters in public until
we lose a sense of the private that it
sort of evaporates away and the
distinctions between us as individuals
get lost now the last thing I would want
to do is to have my brother’s private
story become more mere chatter fodder
but I am reminded that Kierkegaard also
wrote that authentic impassioned speech
can be an antidote to chatter when I
tell you that my brother in his last
mania was so until intellectually
incandescent it was like speaking with a
supernova
I had to avert my eyes and too soon
thereafter that light his light
collapsed beyond the event horizon of
his eyes down to some singularity of
madness from which that light could
never again escape to infinity when I
say that I hope you don’t think I’m just
contributing to chatter my experience
with my brother and is interested in
philip k dick made me see helped me see
that my brother’s robotic clergy and
philip k dicks androids were very much
like conscious theorists call
philosophical zombies that is in fact
they cover from a magazine yes there is
a magazine called philosophy now the
head on that zombie is a noted
consciousness theorist David Chalmers
who has written extensively about what’s
called the hard problem of consciousness
the hard problem of consciousness is
this why aren’t we just input/output
device
all our depth on the surface like
machines why is it that our waking
experience is accompanied by this
virtual reality multi-sensory
consciousness movie always running in
our heads my angle on it’s a little bit
different not so much why is this
consciousness movie that runs alongside
physical existence why is it there not
so much of that is why is that
consciousness movie always such a very
private screening an auteur project of
the individual primarily by the
individual for the individual why
traditionally philosophers have assumed
that consciousness is a prerequisite for
privacy
I hold the opposite that privacy is a
pre-wet prerequisite for consciousness
and it makes possible something
wonderful in consciousness consciousness
you see is a world that names the world
but that world that names the world the
opposite of that kind of consciousness
is not unconsciousness the opposite of
that kind of consciousness is oppression
oppression proceeds most powerfully
degrades consciousness most powerfully
by attacking privacy but I want to
address this not only functionally in
the present but evolutionarily it’s
often today speculated that waking
consciousness has arisen from REM the
REM sleep dream consciousness I hold
that privacy emerges from that high
arousal threshold state that surrounds
REM sleep that state in which we’re very
almost immune to external stimuli when
our brains focus inward on what are
called their default mode networks but
just as privacy is a descendant of that
high arousal state threshold so too is
that that high arousal state itself a
descendant of something much older
descendant it’s an evolutionary
transformation of something extremely
old a very old defense mechanism called
tonic immobility
also known as Thanatos as’ also known as
playing possum or playing dead and the
role of that was to get rid of unwanted
attention primarily from predators that
is a living spider playing a dead spider
it’s an arthropod they go back 300
million years the Carboniferous that is
a living frog playing a dead frog that
is a living snake playing a dead snake
that is a possum playing possible the
deeper state of privacy then is the
realization that it itself can be
considered a highly evolved highly
refined mechanism over 300 million years
old for being left alone privacy itself
can be analogized to many things it’s
part matrix part chamber of secrets
Concha it’s privacy is the place to
stand consciousness the lever with which
we move the world just as silent spaces
in between the notes make music possible
so to private space between thoughts
makes consciousness possible privacy is
neither simply conscious or simply
unconscious the boundary property rather
like the fact that snowflakes are
neither merely ice nor merely wind but
it’s something more than that privacy is
the emptiness that makes fullness
possible privacy is that latent potency
that potent latency that eventuates in
conscious experience it’s like the
mushrooms mycelium spawn bed but you
don’t really usually see at all it’s
virtually invisible
but given rain it eventuates in
mushrooms privacy is the nothing to hide
in without which we have everything to
fear in the 35 years since philip k dick
died our world has in many ways seemed
to become more and more like the world
he prophesied the world he feared the
threat of big data and predictive
analytics to free will see Phil dicks
Minority Report again
the dangers of mass and niche social
chatter see the three stigmata of Palmer
eldritch which also takes place on a
climate changed world the dangers posed
by an Orwellian overt surveillance or a
Kafka esque covert information gathering
see book and movie of A Scanner Darkly
the dangers posed by machine autonomy
and artificial intelligence see Do
Androids Dream of Electric Sheep also
known as Blade Runner in the movie and
the dangers of an authoritarian fascist
alternate history alternate facts post
truth world the funhouse mirror mine 2
philip k dick has affected and really
reflects what we see the advent of
ubiquitous digital social media has made
our world look more like his now I’m not
saying that just because I’m not saying
we’re all going to turn into paranoid
schizophrenics or philosophical zombies
because we over share on social media
but I do think we are conducting a vast
unregulated experiment on human
consciousness
there are even certain attacks on human
consciousness even see when you look at
them there’s a sort of brute force
invasion of privacy knocking doors down
wiretapping at my brother so feared
there’s the monetization of privacy
usually by corporations making money off
of privacy the inundation of privacy the
flooding of it with social chatter the
sublimation of privacy the almost
unconscious giving away of personal
information to the public sphere and
finally the trivialization of privacy
which usually runs like this on the net
everybody knows everything about
everyone forever
so privacy is dead get over it I don’t
think that’s a good idea what that tends
to do is drive that depth of human
beings that unpredictable unprogrammed
non machine like
thing upward making it more shallow
making it more predictable making it
more machine-like making it in many ways
to shared the result is a leveling and a
shallowness when all the depth is on the
surface not only is there no more depth
but superficial begins to look like a
superpower and the result of that is
this that the two modes of oppression
the two definitions the personal
definition of oppression mental pressure
or distress and the political definition
of oppression unjust treatment or
control tend to merge together now we
tried to do some good things in response
to this already we’ve seen open letters
advocating strong guidelines for the
production of strong AI we’ve seen the
development of lex informatica the law
of information technologies which
includes not only recognizing the
responsibility of data collectors but
also the rights of data subjects
including the right to be forgotten by
silicon we’ve made some mistakes this is
an actual list of descriptors from the
tsa z– pre terror behavior detection
program it has turned out to be a
tremendous flop but in many law
enforcement agencies and organizations
across the United States we have these
risk assessment algorithms which are
supposed to be in a very fill Dickian
sense about pre-crime its consciousness
profiling information there needs to be
protection or consciousness a model we
might look at is the genetic information
non-discrimination Act of 2008 which
provides a limited protected status for
the individuals genetic information
including the prohibition of the use of
that information that genetic
disposition predisposition for disease
for instance the prohibition of that use
of that information if in employment or
insurance decisions and lastly there’s
us that’s st. Mary of Egypt she was a
mystic the Mystics the shamans the
meditators have long told us that if we
wish to strengthen consciousness
we must emphasize chatter las’ mind over
mindless chatter mr. Togo me who’s a
character in both the TV series and the
book man in the high castle knows that
he is that sort of person but at a
deeper level we need to look at the fact
that the public and the private only
gain their fullest meaning in reference
to each other loss of subjectivity is
loss of objectivity no one has the whole
truth and nothing but the truth but
distinct private conscience
consciousness means unique consciousness
means we can share and compare our
pieces of the truth that is crucial to
the survival of societies society is not
a prerequisite for the existence of
privacy privacy is a prerequisite for
the existence of society diving deep can
be dangerous
perhaps a mystic is a diver who can swim
and a schizophrenic is a diver who cans
my brother did not end well he drowned
in beauty untimely shrouded in myriad
fine cold pieces of lace called
snowflakes that is he froze to death in
a late season snowstorm in the Laramie
Mountains of Wyoming a private act so
private that we’ll never know whether it
was a suicidal accident or an accidental
suicide the forces arrayed against
individual human consciousness are
powerful they’re pervasive they’re
persistent and they’re largely of our
own making we have our work cut out for
us
trying to save private mind from the
things my brother feared and that philip
k dick prophesied our great challenge is
to keep pace in our understanding and
response to those that array of forces
which is moving at the accelerating pace
of technology itself never since
tomorrow as today seeing
so yesterday we have our work cut out
for us but it’s a work always already
begun always yet to be done and always
worth the doing thank you very much
[Applause]
you
Please follow and like us: