
[Music]
[Music]
a lake is a very beautiful thing and as
we all know Minnesota has well over
10,000 but it’s beautiful and precious
as they are and economically valuable
and despite the many tens to hundreds of
millions of dollars who spend annually
attempting to take care of them and save
them our lakes are in great deal of
difficulty almost 50% of Minnesota’s
lakes are now impaired and almost 10%
have an aquatic invasive species so as a
scientist I ask myself what are we doing
wrong and what might we do better the
problem I believe after having spent
several decades trying to understand
this problem is that we fundamentally
failed to recognize the biological
principles that underlie healthy lakes
and their fish we’ve had trouble as
visual beings focusing on the water
surface and not what’s underneath it
where all the action actually occurs
because the below the surface of a lake
you’ll find a dynamic and complex web of
hundreds of species of microbes plants
algae fish that are all highly
interconnected and interacting dying
living eating each other and growing and
this web is constantly shifting in ways
that we frankly don’t totally understand
but as it shifts it changes and if you
can end up in a situation very easily
where it gets out of balance too many
plants for instance or too few large
fish but the connections change and they
lead to new alternative stable States
new balance points and once they shift
and the lake changes it can get stuck in
the stable state it’s once they get
stuck it’s a common alternative state
that lakes end up in is having too many
floating microscopic algae then shield
out submerse plants and then you can’t
have habitat for fish and you enter a
stable state you can’t get back from so
for those of us who want to save lakes
or study them and understand them we
really have to look at the dynamics of
what underlies these stable States so
I’ll just take a moment and talk about
what we understand about that but
science after about 50 years of work now
has basically identified five factors
that drive stable states and lakes the
first factors nutrients nutrients such
as phosphorus and other chemicals
traditionally came from the lake itself
and its waters but now they’re coming
from runoff Lake Shore homes agriculture
roadbeds all kinds of sources and this
is particularly insidious because they
build up in sediments in ways that they
cannot wash out people spend entire
careers chemists trying to understand
how the nutrients bind to sediments and
how to get them out the point is they’re
there for decades and once it shifts you
end up with an interconnected
alternative state the second major
factor is temperature changing
temperature and loss of thermal refuges
and lakes can have dramatic effects on
fish and water quality this is not
always intuitive to people because we’re
visual and were warm-blooded but fish
are cold-blooded everything living in
lakes is cold-blooded they’ve evolved to
do well in certain temperature ranges
and these ranges are now shifting so
they can’t do as well in this figure
from a paper by Gretchen Hansen you can
see how that green bar at the top which
represents why a cool water fish unless
something happens in our neighbors state
of Wisconsin the walleye will be lost at
the expense of largemouth bass over the
next few decades solely because of
warming waters the third major factor
that you have to keep in mind is habitat
this is much more intuitive to people
because usually we can see it lakeshore
development the lakes are experiencing
wholesale changes in their shorelines
and the plants and animals that live
along the edges of course this means
that things are losing the places where
they live and this leads to unhealthy
balances and changes in habitat which of
course facilitate the arrival invasive
species the fourth major factor I wanted
to talk about today briefly was large
predators fish in particular
historically our lakes since the last
glaciation have been dominated by large
old fish this is how and why these
systems work the way they do it’s what
we treasure about them but in the last
century
another large predator has arrived
ourselves fish that our grandparents
used to catch are now mostly gone and
stalking small fish has just not kept up
this is a pervasive problem because the
continual removal of large fish results
in new evolutionary trajectories that
favor smaller meeker less fish so
it blades to another kind of alternative
stable state and finally the one that
people are most concerned about now and
rightly so is aquatic invasive species
we’re changing the species compositions
of our lakes and we’re doing so partly
because of our movements and partly
because their habitats are changing
what’s insidious about this is that
aquatic invasive species are often
what’s known as environmental engineers
they remake the entire ecosystems to
their own desire thereby creating
another alternative state that in which
natives maybe don’t do well and this is
a picture of common carp which arrived
in our water some 140 years ago which
totally turn ecosystems upside down and
just now a hundred and forty years later
we’re starting to get a grasp on our
lakes and their health and their
fisheries are pretty much determined by
five major factors these factors are
highly interconnected and work as webs
within these systems where they
influence each other and the influence
themselves and they drive primarily the
things that we really care about water
clarity and fisheries and all these
factors are driven by ourselves as well
in rather complicated ways but everybody
is involved with this and when you look
at it a little more closely as a
biologist it gets particularly daunting
because you realize that normally more
than one factor is being disturbed in
most lakes in this figure I’ve sort of
symbolized here a lake in which aquatic
invasive species a is temperature and a
predator population would be impacted
and you can see by the red arrows how
they all influence each other in a
web-like effect and even though the
fisheries may be managed properly there
will be a resulting impact on fisheries
and of course each Lake will have a
different set of scenarios this
overwhelming problem has typically led
understandably to a focus on one or two
factors in a lake at most an extremely
piecemeal approach this means that it
can’t work controlling one factor alone
just can’t work it’s all interconnected
it’s all part of a whole successful Lake
management will have to evolve to
something new that addresses all five
factors simultaneously in a holistic
fashion so how might we do that I think
there’s only two possible options one
would be more and better technology this
is where people such putting scientists
myself typically gravitate to but if you
look at the history of this and the and
the challenge in front of us it’s a
little bit daunting this is where we’ve
already heavily invested we’re spending
tens of millions of dollars a year
already in new sewage treatment plants
alum treatments habitat restoration fish
stocking programs boat inspections plant
eradication programs it goes on and on
and there’s no question it’s helping but
to be honest if you really look at it is
it doing the job out of almost 4,000
impaired lakes in Minnesota only 35 in
the last 20 or so years have been taken
off the impaired species list and not
one lake has been eradicated for aquatic
invasive species this is an unfortunate
reality we just simply do not have the
science time or money to keep up with
the continual avalanche of pressures
being put on these lakes we have to look
for something new the other option might
be conservation if we could identify
through new conservation science and
policies particular segments of lakes
that were particularly valuable and can
serve them the lake and those pieces of
areas might preserve themselves in a
holistic fashion which all five factors
are automatically addressed in a way
that makes sense and allows nature to
work for itself furthermore if we could
identify key areas that were anchored
into the entire ecosystem they might
benefit the
entire system well I’d like to say this
was my great idea but it’s not at all
because 50 years ago marine scientists
came to exactly the same conclusion in
1960s marine managers whose systems are
really not that different by the way
than freshwater it’s just that you can
see through them so people rise what was
going on a lot earlier realized that
these same five factors were the ones
that were destroying coral reefs
fisheries wetlands etc and they came to
the conclusion that the only reasonable
solution the only real hope in the short
term anyway was to establish a set of
marine protected areas these areas can
take many forms and they basically
involve reserving certain pieces of
water in certain ways to protect them in
some fashion and they’re always locally
managed to meet local needs and local
ecosystem needs well it’s been a huge
success there’s almost 14,000 marine
protected areas across the globe almost
five percent of the world’s oceans are
now protected with them and there’s a
target to increase this to almost ten
thousand importantly not only have these
marine protected areas improved entire
ecosystems but they’ve greatly improved
many fisheries and the reasons are
pretty simple there what I said before
basically if you allow fish and other
organisms to survive and thrive and
reproduce their way they originally
evolved guess what they tend to do
pretty well in this little example I’ll
show you here a small area a banana
Creek Reserve it’s called just outside
Cape Canaveral was set aside in the
early 70s and within a decade that
entire system extending all the way down
to Cape Canaveral not only had much
higher quality water in ecosystems but
the fisheries recovered considerably
with tenfold increases and key game fish
and world-record captures of also the
black drum another major fish in that
area they were spilling out of these
areas they were reproducing them they
spill out and they benefit the entire
area but I’ve asked myself is why not
apply these principles of conserving key
selected areas to
fresh water they’re equally valuable
they’re equally delicate they’re equally
important why not apply that I’m
proposing to establish fresh water
conservation areas in the state of
Minnesota and hopefully beyond that
these areas would conserve key parts of
lakes and rivers and maybe entire lakes
in certain cases and holistic and
relatively inexpensive way that would
get the job done and give Giants a
chance to catch up maybe to restore some
of these areas because it’s going to
take a lot of work we’ll need new
science to do this to identify the
important factors and some new policies
but it’s a fairly straightforward
process we already have a good start on
many of these these freshwater
conservation areas would include things
like easements to deal with nutrients
habitat protection in the water itself
they would play key roles saving our
lakes beauty and value protect our
heritage for future generation I really
believe it’s time for a new approach and
that this is a very realistic and needed
facet there are lakes there are
resources
we’re the ones through all those five
factors that I’ve described that have
that have really driven things to where
they are now I believe it’s time to
realize the reality of it and take it
back and start to bring this situation
under control with these freshwater
conservation areas and a foundation has
been established to take that step
forward because there’s no agency that
can deal with this holistic approach at
this time and if you’re interested I
would refer you to that website listed
at the end there thank you for your time
you
[Music]
[Music]
a lake is a very beautiful thing and as
we all know Minnesota has well over
10,000 but it’s beautiful and precious
as they are and economically valuable
and despite the many tens to hundreds of
millions of dollars who spend annually
attempting to take care of them and save
them our lakes are in great deal of
difficulty almost 50% of Minnesota’s
lakes are now impaired and almost 10%
have an aquatic invasive species so as a
scientist I ask myself what are we doing
wrong and what might we do better the
problem I believe after having spent
several decades trying to understand
this problem is that we fundamentally
failed to recognize the biological
principles that underlie healthy lakes
and their fish we’ve had trouble as
visual beings focusing on the water
surface and not what’s underneath it
where all the action actually occurs
because the below the surface of a lake
you’ll find a dynamic and complex web of
hundreds of species of microbes plants
algae fish that are all highly
interconnected and interacting dying
living eating each other and growing and
this web is constantly shifting in ways
that we frankly don’t totally understand
but as it shifts it changes and if you
can end up in a situation very easily
where it gets out of balance too many
plants for instance or too few large
fish but the connections change and they
lead to new alternative stable States
new balance points and once they shift
and the lake changes it can get stuck in
the stable state it’s once they get
stuck it’s a common alternative state
that lakes end up in is having too many
floating microscopic algae then shield
out submerse plants and then you can’t
have habitat for fish and you enter a
stable state you can’t get back from so
for those of us who want to save lakes
or study them and understand them we
really have to look at the dynamics of
what underlies these stable States so
I’ll just take a moment and talk about
what we understand about that but
science after about 50 years of work now
has basically identified five factors
that drive stable states and lakes the
first factors nutrients nutrients such
as phosphorus and other chemicals
traditionally came from the lake itself
and its waters but now they’re coming
from runoff Lake Shore homes agriculture
roadbeds all kinds of sources and this
is particularly insidious because they
build up in sediments in ways that they
cannot wash out people spend entire
careers chemists trying to understand
how the nutrients bind to sediments and
how to get them out the point is they’re
there for decades and once it shifts you
end up with an interconnected
alternative state the second major
factor is temperature changing
temperature and loss of thermal refuges
and lakes can have dramatic effects on
fish and water quality this is not
always intuitive to people because we’re
visual and were warm-blooded but fish
are cold-blooded everything living in
lakes is cold-blooded they’ve evolved to
do well in certain temperature ranges
and these ranges are now shifting so
they can’t do as well in this figure
from a paper by Gretchen Hansen you can
see how that green bar at the top which
represents why a cool water fish unless
something happens in our neighbors state
of Wisconsin the walleye will be lost at
the expense of largemouth bass over the
next few decades solely because of
warming waters the third major factor
that you have to keep in mind is habitat
this is much more intuitive to people
because usually we can see it lakeshore
development the lakes are experiencing
wholesale changes in their shorelines
and the plants and animals that live
along the edges of course this means
that things are losing the places where
they live and this leads to unhealthy
balances and changes in habitat which of
course facilitate the arrival invasive
species the fourth major factor I wanted
to talk about today briefly was large
predators fish in particular
historically our lakes since the last
glaciation have been dominated by large
old fish this is how and why these
systems work the way they do it’s what
we treasure about them but in the last
century
another large predator has arrived
ourselves fish that our grandparents
used to catch are now mostly gone and
stalking small fish has just not kept up
this is a pervasive problem because the
continual removal of large fish results
in new evolutionary trajectories that
favor smaller meeker less fish so
it blades to another kind of alternative
stable state and finally the one that
people are most concerned about now and
rightly so is aquatic invasive species
we’re changing the species compositions
of our lakes and we’re doing so partly
because of our movements and partly
because their habitats are changing
what’s insidious about this is that
aquatic invasive species are often
what’s known as environmental engineers
they remake the entire ecosystems to
their own desire thereby creating
another alternative state that in which
natives maybe don’t do well and this is
a picture of common carp which arrived
in our water some 140 years ago which
totally turn ecosystems upside down and
just now a hundred and forty years later
we’re starting to get a grasp on our
lakes and their health and their
fisheries are pretty much determined by
five major factors these factors are
highly interconnected and work as webs
within these systems where they
influence each other and the influence
themselves and they drive primarily the
things that we really care about water
clarity and fisheries and all these
factors are driven by ourselves as well
in rather complicated ways but everybody
is involved with this and when you look
at it a little more closely as a
biologist it gets particularly daunting
because you realize that normally more
than one factor is being disturbed in
most lakes in this figure I’ve sort of
symbolized here a lake in which aquatic
invasive species a is temperature and a
predator population would be impacted
and you can see by the red arrows how
they all influence each other in a
web-like effect and even though the
fisheries may be managed properly there
will be a resulting impact on fisheries
and of course each Lake will have a
different set of scenarios this
overwhelming problem has typically led
understandably to a focus on one or two
factors in a lake at most an extremely
piecemeal approach this means that it
can’t work controlling one factor alone
just can’t work it’s all interconnected
it’s all part of a whole successful Lake
management will have to evolve to
something new that addresses all five
factors simultaneously in a holistic
fashion so how might we do that I think
there’s only two possible options one
would be more and better technology this
is where people such putting scientists
myself typically gravitate to but if you
look at the history of this and the and
the challenge in front of us it’s a
little bit daunting this is where we’ve
already heavily invested we’re spending
tens of millions of dollars a year
already in new sewage treatment plants
alum treatments habitat restoration fish
stocking programs boat inspections plant
eradication programs it goes on and on
and there’s no question it’s helping but
to be honest if you really look at it is
it doing the job out of almost 4,000
impaired lakes in Minnesota only 35 in
the last 20 or so years have been taken
off the impaired species list and not
one lake has been eradicated for aquatic
invasive species this is an unfortunate
reality we just simply do not have the
science time or money to keep up with
the continual avalanche of pressures
being put on these lakes we have to look
for something new the other option might
be conservation if we could identify
through new conservation science and
policies particular segments of lakes
that were particularly valuable and can
serve them the lake and those pieces of
areas might preserve themselves in a
holistic fashion which all five factors
are automatically addressed in a way
that makes sense and allows nature to
work for itself furthermore if we could
identify key areas that were anchored
into the entire ecosystem they might
benefit the
entire system well I’d like to say this
was my great idea but it’s not at all
because 50 years ago marine scientists
came to exactly the same conclusion in
1960s marine managers whose systems are
really not that different by the way
than freshwater it’s just that you can
see through them so people rise what was
going on a lot earlier realized that
these same five factors were the ones
that were destroying coral reefs
fisheries wetlands etc and they came to
the conclusion that the only reasonable
solution the only real hope in the short
term anyway was to establish a set of
marine protected areas these areas can
take many forms and they basically
involve reserving certain pieces of
water in certain ways to protect them in
some fashion and they’re always locally
managed to meet local needs and local
ecosystem needs well it’s been a huge
success there’s almost 14,000 marine
protected areas across the globe almost
five percent of the world’s oceans are
now protected with them and there’s a
target to increase this to almost ten
thousand importantly not only have these
marine protected areas improved entire
ecosystems but they’ve greatly improved
many fisheries and the reasons are
pretty simple there what I said before
basically if you allow fish and other
organisms to survive and thrive and
reproduce their way they originally
evolved guess what they tend to do
pretty well in this little example I’ll
show you here a small area a banana
Creek Reserve it’s called just outside
Cape Canaveral was set aside in the
early 70s and within a decade that
entire system extending all the way down
to Cape Canaveral not only had much
higher quality water in ecosystems but
the fisheries recovered considerably
with tenfold increases and key game fish
and world-record captures of also the
black drum another major fish in that
area they were spilling out of these
areas they were reproducing them they
spill out and they benefit the entire
area but I’ve asked myself is why not
apply these principles of conserving key
selected areas to
fresh water they’re equally valuable
they’re equally delicate they’re equally
important why not apply that I’m
proposing to establish fresh water
conservation areas in the state of
Minnesota and hopefully beyond that
these areas would conserve key parts of
lakes and rivers and maybe entire lakes
in certain cases and holistic and
relatively inexpensive way that would
get the job done and give Giants a
chance to catch up maybe to restore some
of these areas because it’s going to
take a lot of work we’ll need new
science to do this to identify the
important factors and some new policies
but it’s a fairly straightforward
process we already have a good start on
many of these these freshwater
conservation areas would include things
like easements to deal with nutrients
habitat protection in the water itself
they would play key roles saving our
lakes beauty and value protect our
heritage for future generation I really
believe it’s time for a new approach and
that this is a very realistic and needed
facet there are lakes there are
resources
we’re the ones through all those five
factors that I’ve described that have
that have really driven things to where
they are now I believe it’s time to
realize the reality of it and take it
back and start to bring this situation
under control with these freshwater
conservation areas and a foundation has
been established to take that step
forward because there’s no agency that
can deal with this holistic approach at
this time and if you’re interested I
would refer you to that website listed
at the end there thank you for your time
you
[Music]
Please follow and like us: