
health in the sense
common is probably considered the
most important dimension of well-being
on which policies must be measured
public, but it is also public in the
way people interpret it
common
he tells us to the cartoon character
but the Venetian character tells us this
even with a somewhat fatalistic tone like
to say disparities of health happen a little
by chance and the story I tell you is
that these disparities for health do not
they happen by chance, they are unjust
blacks are avoidable and can fall back
under the responsibility of specifications
policies this is as fifth as there is
I’ll try to prove and I’ll do it with you
some data trying to trace a
po the identikit of the inequalities of
health to understand if it actually is
true that something can be done
we start from turin we go as in all
the great cities of Turin
if you try to tell it in terms of
income distribution you see that there is
a strong disparity between the high hill
bourgeois with a very high income and
in the areas of workers’ barriers
north and south with low income in the areas
petty bourgeois and middle class one
intermediate income but the one who wants or
tell the health history
story an animation did not work
very good for which he had to resort to
a situation a little less effective between
you will excuse this health story there
speak for example of life expectancy
you try to take the tram 3 which
it starts from the hill and goes from the side
opposite of the city to the north towards the
Valletta district are as you see i
your neighborhoods are a bit opposed
for income levels and see that i
characters that climb on this tram
every kilometer they lose about 4 5 months
of life expectancy at the extreme between
two
between the two neighborhoods on average and looking for gods
34 years of life expectancy but i
the richer the distance between them
richer isolates to use more
poor comes up to seven years of
life expectancy
the health stories behind
these differences are really a lot
very curious because who is in this
pia neighborhood practically in terms of
life expectancy is already at the time
of the expo to the right
who instead is in the neighborhood on the left
it is practically at the hope of life and
so and share the experience of
health that those who were in the hills
had already experienced 30 years before i
times of the abduction of the dark this is a bit
the size of the differences that
we find ourselves in our city because
because in that neighborhood you should in
that neighborhood those who live there
they have a home food they have doctor
etc. because they should be like this
worse, they should be so worse
get sick more a question of
luck or and a pressure of styles
life a matter of pollution and gods
work risks a matter of
access to doctors or a question of
genius oo is a question instead of
social position this is la la
question we face in this
presentation and indeed if we move on to
Italian level let’s see what
it happens by way of study
on the right there are the graduates and gradually
you grow going down the ladder of
education we get to people with
elementary for the same age
the risk of dying grows
progressively until you get to one
excess of eighty percent among them
men a little less among women
this is a fairly specific picture
and shows us a feature
constant of these phenomena
if from mortality we jump to one
subjective health indicator proven
to interview Italians
13 thousand with psychometric scales for
ask how is their health a
equality
if compared with peers you see
that the average that is more or less in
the center of these differences sees them
low education people have about
double the probability of reporting of
stay less than good compared to ai
But graduates see that these
differences between the different levels of
education at age parity see some
regions on the left much more
complex in the gap is that some
regions of the right with a gap
extremely grateful so there is someone
who can do better than someone else in
this story
returning to mortality the same thing
it happens on a European scale here are 21
European populations where again
we have mortality rates at parity
age among people with the title of
study of compulsory education in
high in the middle of the middle is at the bottom
graduates and see that systematically
in all countries there are differences
of the same sign of the same
direction but there are countries on the left
who has been able to do much better are i
15- country countries and right-wing countries
that instead they know year
an explosion in the intensity of the
inequalities then inequalities
of the same direction everywhere to have
few individual resources hurts to
all however of different intensity if
we had to summarize these
introductory features in terms
of a kind of identikit of the
inequalities we could say that the name
they are health inequalities because
they are inequalities in health because
they always hit more disadvantaged
they could be different could
hit a little a little disadvantaged the
instead I’m always a
disadvantage of the most disadvantaged
when the nanny are practically always
we know them from when we measure them
so since we can measure them
we know where they happen when they have
the place of birth and residence in
truth we have seen that in each
context in which we measure however the
context can make the difference the
context can change
the intensity of this one
inequalities and connotations the signs
details are that we see them linked to
all forms of resource poverty
individual that can be those
of this ability in skills
expressed by the instruction those of the
power relations expressed by
class and material indicators
expressed by income and wealth e
finally the last feature of these
particular connotations is that they are in
scale and non -threshold relationship
there is a threshold below which not
inequalities are bad but a
any level of position of the
scale corresponds to a level of health
better than those below are worse than
who is on it
the set of these identikit makes sure that
This thing is sought after and put on
safe in jail and to be condemned, however
since we are of those who
we prefer harm reduction and the
rehabilitation of the guilty we want
ask ourselves why these are born because
if we understand the mechanisms by which these
they are obviously born we are also capable
to identify the entry points from
which may draw political inspiration
or solution interventions and then i
main generation mechanisms
they are of three categories the first is that if
compare
the high position the manager the manager
on the left and the low worker
qualification right on the basis of
characteristics that the master of this
field of investigation that michael marmot
of the university college of london
suggests that I am able to
imbalance between what it is
demands from a person and what degree of
autonomy
is allowed in doing this task to
person as a degree of remuneration
what degree of help is offered to him
we see that obviously on one side there
are the other social positions from which
maybe you ask a lot but you give
so much autonomy so much remuneration e
a lot of help, vice versa, there are the low ones
social positions of which not always yes
he asks a lot sometimes yes sometimes not though
the level of control and remuneration
it helps extremely low this is
the origin of what we could
define below by summarizing it
concept of social position read in
key to health basically
the social position is scarce
ability to control on your own
destiny on the things that happen to us
in life next week the
next month in twenty years and there
we ask this first mechanism that is
the poor ability to control that
they have people of low position
social as it can act on health and
it can act with four mechanisms
direct intermediate action on health
the first is what is well studied in
neuroendocrinology and that is that this
situation of poor control over the
life triggers of the neuroendocrine chains
which lead to high rates of those
hormones like free cortisol that
explain the increase in the long term
risk of heart attack and the increase of
risk of depression of diabetes mellitus
back of the system falls
immune and defense capabilities e
of repair, now this
this risk factor this stress
chronic that is triggered by this thing
how it is distributed socially and if it is
you see and the workers on the left have three
more times the probability of having
this risk compared to gods
already employed so this is a
mechanism that intermediate this effect
a second mechanism is what is it
poor control that has the low
social position
and also
harmful to health because it generates one
greater dependence on substances e
to the lifestyles and unhealthy that they are
those who then generate problems of
health and see the differences on the left
by educational qualification in Italy in smoking
among the poorly educated and highly educated and
right the differences in overweight in
both cases less educated people
at the same age they are more likely to
be smoking to be heavy smokers
to be overweight and share
all lifestyles at risk for the
health as unprotected sex e
incorrect feeding, etc.
etc. this is the second mechanism of
mediation of the social position
always the social position as poverty
of control and therefore of conditions of
subordination obviously leads to life
in places or to work in situations that
I’m at risk for health in this
case let’s see what is the probability of
being to reside in a neighboring municipality
at a polluted site and it’s about twice as high
among the municipalities among those residing in the municipalities
less private than right on
who resides in the wealthiest municipalities a
left fourth mechanism of
intermediation is that the poor
control over one’s destiny on the
own life that characterizes the low
social position can threaten the
probability and ability to benefit from
appropriate and effective treatment
let’s go back to turin and see the case
of the infarct on the left there is a heart attack
mapped on the city of turin and sees
review the things we saw on the
life expectancy of the red zones
workers barriers and north to south are
those in which one gets sick more a
infarct the second map on the right there
describes how it is
revascularized revascularization
coronary is the effective answer
appropriate or a heart attack and see that the
two maps coincide on the contrary are
totally dissociate each one
level of access to a problem of
to cure a diagnosis solution e
care and at risk of showing this
mismatching where there is the most need there is
less ability to use care
appropriate and this is a quarter
mechanism that can generate this
finally there is a mechanism still final
live in truth because here you see i
first two reconstructed see on the left
the bottom bar the low control on the
life at the low social position that
generates an increase in exposure to
these risk factors stress styles
of life environmental risks access to
cure all this causes a problem of
health distributed this equally as
we have seen but you see this
health problem can fall on
capacity of the sick individual who does
disease experience to progress
on the social scale so there is another one
mechanism this case a case of
inverse causation that causes this
effect
these three mechanisms fall back
in order to left these three scales
great mechanisms the position with the
low position as poor control i
intermediate mechanisms these factors
risk this is this fall in the
descending social mobility that is
related to the experience of illness are
each one an entry point for some
possible policies if you look at the first one
the mechanism of stratification
social control of the poor control is well
expressed by the example on the left
back to Italy we know that i
unemployed in Italy in 2013 had
double the risk of presenting one
bad mental health indices
measured with psychometric scales if we
we actually had if we were in
able to report the mental health of the
unemployed at the same risk as the
mental health of the employed in 2013
we would have saved more than 380 thousand
mental health cases
compromised if on these 380 thousand cases
with a first shot of a magic wand
the policies of law enforcement aid
to poverty in unemployment
they worked we would have avoided it
about 80,000 if not only this but the
policies of political mobility
active work and development
cheap they had reported the
2013 unemployment to the pre-unemployment
crisis in 2005 we would have avoided it around
250,000 this gives you the idea of how much
the answer from the can be important
redistributive policies those of which
this is discussed in this ted
conference in changing the level of
control over life which then affects
on the health that is determined by
different social position
the second group of mechanisms that is
that linked to social distribution
of risk factors see
basically the need for
distribute allocate the interventions of
prevention that avoid these factors
risk proportionate to the
exposure distribution if they are
the risks are more exposed to lifestyles
environmental issues with poor access to treatment
people of low social position
it is necessary to make interventions of universalism
proportionate to accommodate more resources
in this circumstance it is what it is
success in screening
mammographic that actually
the number of cases decreases
diagnosed advanced stage and al
improves survival
substantially on the little women
educated that they are the ones they had
less effects is the last example that
on descending and well mobility
demonstrated by this case these are the
differences in life expectancy at 65
between managers and laboratories
unskilled manuals if you think of the
review of benefits for the pre
he sees there that he discusses the council
to the presidency of the council of the
Ministers
to adapt them to life expectancy
media is clearly understandable that it is
what happens is that using the
average life expectancy
practically the workers who die three
years before they receive pension three
fewer years in giving away their own
pension to managers who instead live
three more years
this is the example of the fact that we can
let’s make known explanations
solutions and call delle
responsibility there are some things that
we still have to find out in this field
and we can not stop but come back
at the beginning and we actually conclude
health is important it is important for
all as a criterion of well-being
but we can also remove this
resignation this fatalism
of our cipputi on duty because
we actually know many things that
they call the responsibility of the decision makers
up to our parliament and someone not
let’s say nothing new someone already two
centuries ago
this great pathologist that founders
of modern medicine already reminded us
that medicine is a social science e
politics is nothing but medicine
on a large scale this is a bit
the teaching we call for
learn more about this book that was
been recalled
thank you so much
common is probably considered the
most important dimension of well-being
on which policies must be measured
public, but it is also public in the
way people interpret it
common
he tells us to the cartoon character
but the Venetian character tells us this
even with a somewhat fatalistic tone like
to say disparities of health happen a little
by chance and the story I tell you is
that these disparities for health do not
they happen by chance, they are unjust
blacks are avoidable and can fall back
under the responsibility of specifications
policies this is as fifth as there is
I’ll try to prove and I’ll do it with you
some data trying to trace a
po the identikit of the inequalities of
health to understand if it actually is
true that something can be done
we start from turin we go as in all
the great cities of Turin
if you try to tell it in terms of
income distribution you see that there is
a strong disparity between the high hill
bourgeois with a very high income and
in the areas of workers’ barriers
north and south with low income in the areas
petty bourgeois and middle class one
intermediate income but the one who wants or
tell the health history
story an animation did not work
very good for which he had to resort to
a situation a little less effective between
you will excuse this health story there
speak for example of life expectancy
you try to take the tram 3 which
it starts from the hill and goes from the side
opposite of the city to the north towards the
Valletta district are as you see i
your neighborhoods are a bit opposed
for income levels and see that i
characters that climb on this tram
every kilometer they lose about 4 5 months
of life expectancy at the extreme between
two
between the two neighborhoods on average and looking for gods
34 years of life expectancy but i
the richer the distance between them
richer isolates to use more
poor comes up to seven years of
life expectancy
the health stories behind
these differences are really a lot
very curious because who is in this
pia neighborhood practically in terms of
life expectancy is already at the time
of the expo to the right
who instead is in the neighborhood on the left
it is practically at the hope of life and
so and share the experience of
health that those who were in the hills
had already experienced 30 years before i
times of the abduction of the dark this is a bit
the size of the differences that
we find ourselves in our city because
because in that neighborhood you should in
that neighborhood those who live there
they have a home food they have doctor
etc. because they should be like this
worse, they should be so worse
get sick more a question of
luck or and a pressure of styles
life a matter of pollution and gods
work risks a matter of
access to doctors or a question of
genius oo is a question instead of
social position this is la la
question we face in this
presentation and indeed if we move on to
Italian level let’s see what
it happens by way of study
on the right there are the graduates and gradually
you grow going down the ladder of
education we get to people with
elementary for the same age
the risk of dying grows
progressively until you get to one
excess of eighty percent among them
men a little less among women
this is a fairly specific picture
and shows us a feature
constant of these phenomena
if from mortality we jump to one
subjective health indicator proven
to interview Italians
13 thousand with psychometric scales for
ask how is their health a
equality
if compared with peers you see
that the average that is more or less in
the center of these differences sees them
low education people have about
double the probability of reporting of
stay less than good compared to ai
But graduates see that these
differences between the different levels of
education at age parity see some
regions on the left much more
complex in the gap is that some
regions of the right with a gap
extremely grateful so there is someone
who can do better than someone else in
this story
returning to mortality the same thing
it happens on a European scale here are 21
European populations where again
we have mortality rates at parity
age among people with the title of
study of compulsory education in
high in the middle of the middle is at the bottom
graduates and see that systematically
in all countries there are differences
of the same sign of the same
direction but there are countries on the left
who has been able to do much better are i
15- country countries and right-wing countries
that instead they know year
an explosion in the intensity of the
inequalities then inequalities
of the same direction everywhere to have
few individual resources hurts to
all however of different intensity if
we had to summarize these
introductory features in terms
of a kind of identikit of the
inequalities we could say that the name
they are health inequalities because
they are inequalities in health because
they always hit more disadvantaged
they could be different could
hit a little a little disadvantaged the
instead I’m always a
disadvantage of the most disadvantaged
when the nanny are practically always
we know them from when we measure them
so since we can measure them
we know where they happen when they have
the place of birth and residence in
truth we have seen that in each
context in which we measure however the
context can make the difference the
context can change
the intensity of this one
inequalities and connotations the signs
details are that we see them linked to
all forms of resource poverty
individual that can be those
of this ability in skills
expressed by the instruction those of the
power relations expressed by
class and material indicators
expressed by income and wealth e
finally the last feature of these
particular connotations is that they are in
scale and non -threshold relationship
there is a threshold below which not
inequalities are bad but a
any level of position of the
scale corresponds to a level of health
better than those below are worse than
who is on it
the set of these identikit makes sure that
This thing is sought after and put on
safe in jail and to be condemned, however
since we are of those who
we prefer harm reduction and the
rehabilitation of the guilty we want
ask ourselves why these are born because
if we understand the mechanisms by which these
they are obviously born we are also capable
to identify the entry points from
which may draw political inspiration
or solution interventions and then i
main generation mechanisms
they are of three categories the first is that if
compare
the high position the manager the manager
on the left and the low worker
qualification right on the basis of
characteristics that the master of this
field of investigation that michael marmot
of the university college of london
suggests that I am able to
imbalance between what it is
demands from a person and what degree of
autonomy
is allowed in doing this task to
person as a degree of remuneration
what degree of help is offered to him
we see that obviously on one side there
are the other social positions from which
maybe you ask a lot but you give
so much autonomy so much remuneration e
a lot of help, vice versa, there are the low ones
social positions of which not always yes
he asks a lot sometimes yes sometimes not though
the level of control and remuneration
it helps extremely low this is
the origin of what we could
define below by summarizing it
concept of social position read in
key to health basically
the social position is scarce
ability to control on your own
destiny on the things that happen to us
in life next week the
next month in twenty years and there
we ask this first mechanism that is
the poor ability to control that
they have people of low position
social as it can act on health and
it can act with four mechanisms
direct intermediate action on health
the first is what is well studied in
neuroendocrinology and that is that this
situation of poor control over the
life triggers of the neuroendocrine chains
which lead to high rates of those
hormones like free cortisol that
explain the increase in the long term
risk of heart attack and the increase of
risk of depression of diabetes mellitus
back of the system falls
immune and defense capabilities e
of repair, now this
this risk factor this stress
chronic that is triggered by this thing
how it is distributed socially and if it is
you see and the workers on the left have three
more times the probability of having
this risk compared to gods
already employed so this is a
mechanism that intermediate this effect
a second mechanism is what is it
poor control that has the low
social position
and also
harmful to health because it generates one
greater dependence on substances e
to the lifestyles and unhealthy that they are
those who then generate problems of
health and see the differences on the left
by educational qualification in Italy in smoking
among the poorly educated and highly educated and
right the differences in overweight in
both cases less educated people
at the same age they are more likely to
be smoking to be heavy smokers
to be overweight and share
all lifestyles at risk for the
health as unprotected sex e
incorrect feeding, etc.
etc. this is the second mechanism of
mediation of the social position
always the social position as poverty
of control and therefore of conditions of
subordination obviously leads to life
in places or to work in situations that
I’m at risk for health in this
case let’s see what is the probability of
being to reside in a neighboring municipality
at a polluted site and it’s about twice as high
among the municipalities among those residing in the municipalities
less private than right on
who resides in the wealthiest municipalities a
left fourth mechanism of
intermediation is that the poor
control over one’s destiny on the
own life that characterizes the low
social position can threaten the
probability and ability to benefit from
appropriate and effective treatment
let’s go back to turin and see the case
of the infarct on the left there is a heart attack
mapped on the city of turin and sees
review the things we saw on the
life expectancy of the red zones
workers barriers and north to south are
those in which one gets sick more a
infarct the second map on the right there
describes how it is
revascularized revascularization
coronary is the effective answer
appropriate or a heart attack and see that the
two maps coincide on the contrary are
totally dissociate each one
level of access to a problem of
to cure a diagnosis solution e
care and at risk of showing this
mismatching where there is the most need there is
less ability to use care
appropriate and this is a quarter
mechanism that can generate this
finally there is a mechanism still final
live in truth because here you see i
first two reconstructed see on the left
the bottom bar the low control on the
life at the low social position that
generates an increase in exposure to
these risk factors stress styles
of life environmental risks access to
cure all this causes a problem of
health distributed this equally as
we have seen but you see this
health problem can fall on
capacity of the sick individual who does
disease experience to progress
on the social scale so there is another one
mechanism this case a case of
inverse causation that causes this
effect
these three mechanisms fall back
in order to left these three scales
great mechanisms the position with the
low position as poor control i
intermediate mechanisms these factors
risk this is this fall in the
descending social mobility that is
related to the experience of illness are
each one an entry point for some
possible policies if you look at the first one
the mechanism of stratification
social control of the poor control is well
expressed by the example on the left
back to Italy we know that i
unemployed in Italy in 2013 had
double the risk of presenting one
bad mental health indices
measured with psychometric scales if we
we actually had if we were in
able to report the mental health of the
unemployed at the same risk as the
mental health of the employed in 2013
we would have saved more than 380 thousand
mental health cases
compromised if on these 380 thousand cases
with a first shot of a magic wand
the policies of law enforcement aid
to poverty in unemployment
they worked we would have avoided it
about 80,000 if not only this but the
policies of political mobility
active work and development
cheap they had reported the
2013 unemployment to the pre-unemployment
crisis in 2005 we would have avoided it around
250,000 this gives you the idea of how much
the answer from the can be important
redistributive policies those of which
this is discussed in this ted
conference in changing the level of
control over life which then affects
on the health that is determined by
different social position
the second group of mechanisms that is
that linked to social distribution
of risk factors see
basically the need for
distribute allocate the interventions of
prevention that avoid these factors
risk proportionate to the
exposure distribution if they are
the risks are more exposed to lifestyles
environmental issues with poor access to treatment
people of low social position
it is necessary to make interventions of universalism
proportionate to accommodate more resources
in this circumstance it is what it is
success in screening
mammographic that actually
the number of cases decreases
diagnosed advanced stage and al
improves survival
substantially on the little women
educated that they are the ones they had
less effects is the last example that
on descending and well mobility
demonstrated by this case these are the
differences in life expectancy at 65
between managers and laboratories
unskilled manuals if you think of the
review of benefits for the pre
he sees there that he discusses the council
to the presidency of the council of the
Ministers
to adapt them to life expectancy
media is clearly understandable that it is
what happens is that using the
average life expectancy
practically the workers who die three
years before they receive pension three
fewer years in giving away their own
pension to managers who instead live
three more years
this is the example of the fact that we can
let’s make known explanations
solutions and call delle
responsibility there are some things that
we still have to find out in this field
and we can not stop but come back
at the beginning and we actually conclude
health is important it is important for
all as a criterion of well-being
but we can also remove this
resignation this fatalism
of our cipputi on duty because
we actually know many things that
they call the responsibility of the decision makers
up to our parliament and someone not
let’s say nothing new someone already two
centuries ago
this great pathologist that founders
of modern medicine already reminded us
that medicine is a social science e
politics is nothing but medicine
on a large scale this is a bit
the teaching we call for
learn more about this book that was
been recalled
thank you so much
Please follow and like us: