Press "Enter" to skip to content

Rethinking Trauma: What Youth From Domestic Violence Have to Teach Us | Tracey Pyscher | TEDxWWU


82% of women incarcerated in our prisons
today our survivors of domestic violence
in fact domestic violence is the most
common denominator even more than race
or poverty for incarcerated adults in
America and so what do these stark
realities have to do with kids from
domestic violence in school well we know
that kids from domestic violence make up
a bulk of the kids in the American
foster care system and we also know that
these same kids represent the vast
majority of kids being labeled
emotionally behaviorally disordered in
our public schools and so you may wonder
what does that a beedi label emotionally
behaviorally disordered have to do with
youth incarceration EBD youth are 13
times more likely to be arrested
compared to in school compared to other
kids who’ve been labeled with
disabilities now compare that to kids
who have no labeled disabilities at all
and so what we know is that we can trace
the practices in schools and how they
set up conditions for kids from domestic
violence to later end up in our prisons
so we know there is a direct connection
between being a kid from domestic
violence and being labeled EBD in the
school to Prison Pipeline oops so I am a
childhood and adolescent survivor of
domestic violence and I like many of the
kids with my background well we were
labeled emotionally broken kids from a
very young age and so today I’m here to
offer a different way to think about
kids like me kids from domestic violence
and so I’m going to talk about
mastic violence from a social justice
perspective and I’m also going to
directly challenge the popular medical
and mental health research on kids from
domestic violence and trauma and so I
want you to know that when I was six
years old I was permanently kicked out
of my neighborhood brownies true and I
was kicked out because I resisted a
violating interaction directed at me by
my local neighborhood brownies troop
leader and the truth is is I became
almost an instant outcast in this
woman’s presence I talked too much I
didn’t get into line and frankly I
resisted her often when I felt socially
violated by her now on one particular
afternoon this brownies troop leader
decided to socially shun me my six year
old self surviving domestic violence in
the worst way that a kid could be
shunned she separated me from the rest
of the girls in the brownies troop as
she shuffled them along to an adjacent
room to sing songs in preparation for a
holiday concert and I never reached that
room she banished me to sit alone only
sharing space with partially completed
styrofoam Santa Clauses that we had
built earlier in the afternoon and so my
punishment was severe and my response
was equally uncompromising
and in a frenzy I destroyed every single
one of those Santa Clauses in this space
now I resisted just slide missing I
resisted that brownies troop leader like
I resisted most of my teachers and my
k-12 schools when I felt like they were
violating me and I want to be clear that
on this day my six year old self was
being violated
you know I collapsed further honor the
way of an adult educator who couldn’t
either hear me or treat me more humanely
and so my resistance to miss – Miss
Brown this brownies troop leader and my
destruction of those Santa Clauses was
not some part of my traumatized and
individualized self it was not because
my brain is disordered it was because I
was resisting this educator who was
violating me finally we get to this
slide so this is me this is my young
self I’m the one up front and I’m
circled by my brothers and sisters what
you can’t see in this photo is that I
was already being labeled and
emotionally broken kid and this is my
mother and now she was a fierce woman
and she often showed worried facial
expressions like you see here in this
photo because you see she tried her best
to protect us from the violence of my
father while she also carried that
silence of being from and living under
domestic violence to the larger
community and this is a picture of my
mother and father and what seemed to be
a normal-looking young couple starting a
family what you can’t tell from these
photos though is that we were living
under domestic violence at the hands of
my father and his mental illness and
so what I’m suggesting to you is that
these experiences of domestic violence
not only shape me then but shape me who
I am today and how I respond when I feel
violated by others and so I see these as
my cultural ways of walking through the
world and especially domestic violence
has shaped Who I am even more so than
being from Flint Michigan growing up to
be a queer girl in a queer woman today
and living under Livy
living under working-class conditions so
I think that all of those social and
justices but especially domestic
violence set me up to be a fierce
six-year-old who was not going to give
in when she was feeling violated and as
I learned to resist the battles of my
parents I too equally if not more so
resisted the violation pointed at me
from teachers and educators be vey
informal or formal throughout my k-12
school years and it seemed to me over
those years that most of these teachers
that’s not true some of them were
amazingly loving but for most of those
teachers they could not or would not
understand my resistance or have empathy
for my violent home life and so during
my k-12 school years I was labeled that
emotionally broken kid I was frequently
suspended and often truant and today I
actually believed it would be a more
dangerous time for me because today I
argue that I would have been labeled
that EBD kid and that I want all of you
to challenge yourselves to imagine what
the impact on the life trajectory of a
kid from domestic violence already is
but especially if their schools label
them emotionally behaviorally disordered
so in my brownies story what this meant
is that my six year old self was kicked
out of a community-based organization
that I needed so badly considering my
violent home life and so I make the
argument that experiencing domestic
violence is not so different than
experiencing other social
marginalization like being raised or
classed or gendered or queered in fact
it is one part a major part of my
identities in this world and so what I
mean by this is when you walk through
the world in this way in these ways you
read that world differently than
somebody who does not have to walk
through in a marginalized way you know
how to read social spaces differently
and more closely and more keenly and so
for an example if a teacher stares down
a kid from domestic violence I don’t
care if that teacher is behind them
hovering or ten feet away that kid will
almost always read that experience is
violating and how about we not
underestimate that anyone in this
theater today would not experience that
situation as violating so our
institutions and the people who work in
those institutions need to be very
careful when trying to label and name
these kids resistances as something
broken in fact the impact of labeling
kids from domestic violence is
disordered is a metaphorical monster for
their lives the impact is staggering and
the impact on their life trajectories
becomes quite clear and so I would ask
you to imagine what our schools
might look like for kids from domestic
violence and how could schools think
differently about the way they treat
these kids and so I’m suggesting if they
choose to do that and they should to be
more humane they first should listen to
what these kids are trying to teach us
about being more humane to each other
and so an example of this would have
been if that brownies troop leader would
have talked to me differently would not
have socially shunned me in front of all
the other little girls would have
perhaps bent down and said you know
Tracy and can you try something
different here but instead the result
was that I was kicked out of this
organization and what I’ll say is that
we should never shut down this precious
knowledge this beautiful ability the
strength and kids to be able to tell us
when we are being socially violating to
others in fact I would encourage schools
to help these kids to mentor them to
name when they are feeling socially
violated and then to respond differently
to them and not expect that these kids
will respond to the school this is a
precious knowledge and I can imagine
that if schools do this we can change
the current trajectories of these kids
lives now we know we cannot on race or
on class or on gender or unclear a
marginalized person’s experience this is
also true for people from domestic
violence and you know I really challenge
educators to consider how to relevantly
respond to the cultural ways of these
kids because if we don’t the results are
profound educators will stay in states
of ignorance and the life trajectory
for kids from domestic violence will
remain severe so the next time you see a
kid acting out be it a kid who’s
destroying styrofoam Santa Clauses or
resisting in all kinds of ways try not
to throw them into the damaged bin try
to respond to them differently and see
what they need from you I put a
challenge out there for my fellow
educators I was a teacher for 15 years
in the inner city of Minneapolis and we
need to imagine our role in dismantling
the school-to-prison pipeline in fact if
we go back to the statistics I started
with it demands that teach that schools
and teachers do something very different
than what they’ve been doing with kids
from domestic violence these kids do not
need to be fixed they do not need their
brains to be ordered again they are not
disordered even though these are popular
beliefs in our society today rather we
need to flip the script understanding
the resistance of kids who have survived
domestic violence actually offers us a
more humane way forward [Applause]
Please follow and like us: