Press "Enter" to skip to content

Rethinking the Purpose of Business | Christian Idicula | TEDxUAlberta


[Music]
what is the purpose of business is it to
make money for the owners or is it to
create opportunity and prosperity this
question has been on my mind for a while
now when we see the headlines of
corporate scandals layoffs poor labor
conditions that question of purpose cuts
to the heart of the matter and I think
it’s a question we need really need to
grapple with because the globalization
of business has had a profound impact on
us it’s certainly get opened the door to
opportunities but it has also put
enormous pressure on our environment and
our communities according to the latest
Trust Barometer by Adelman trust in CEOs
is at an all-time low and the support
for anti business policies is
overwhelming and yet there is an
expectation that businesses take a
leadership role in improving the
conditions of our social and environment
environmental conditions in our
communities populist movements have been
on the uprise and they’re taking aim at
the business elite who they see as the
cause of job losses stagnating wages
environmental harms just last week the
Prime Minister spoke about this in
Hamburg and he said we need to take this
frustration seriously and we do what I
believe underlies this is really a
debate between two worldviews the
stakeholder theory and the shareholder
theory and those two have been largely
confined to the pages of business
journals in the corners of boardrooms
but I want to talk to you about both of
them the shareholder theory
as can be summed up into three words
maximize shareholder value and that idea
has dominated the North American economy
since the 1970s and they really got
going when Milton Friedman wrote an
article in The New York Times saying
that the social responsibility of
business is to increase profit and the
idea here was really that the owners
would take the money and they would
apply it in society as they saw fit and
so that gave birth to this idea that you
know what the shareholders wanted was
most important what the shareholders
valued was most important and therefore
we took value and profit and we put them
together our stock markets our economy
they’re all driven by quarterly
financial results and that’s driven a
culture of short-term thinking when you
hear about things like layoffs R&D
spending being slashed product recalls
labor strife even consumer backlash
that’s where it comes from the
stakeholder theory on the other hand is
far more nuanced in 1984 Edward Freeman
really talked about this idea of
rethinking the purpose of business as a
vehicle to coordinate stakeholder
interests that really means that when we
come up with a strategy for business
we’re not just thinking about the
shareholders we’re also thinking about
the other stakeholders employees
consumers suppliers the government and
communities that’s a complex undertaking
though now there are pieces of this
already in place we have things like
talent development we have corporate
donation programs we have you know
ethical sourcing and social
environmental standards but we still
tacitly subscribe to this idea that the
shareholder is dominant
so where does that leave us well the
desire for change is absolutely here
there’s a whole generation of talented
young people stating very clearly
they’re seeking more from their
workplace than just the pursuit of
profit there is greater demand for
accountability and transparency from
consumers and advocacy groups and there
are companies who are actually taking a
leadership role so take for example the
Tata Group they are a multinational
conglomerate based in India they do
about a hundred billion dollars of
revenue a year they have been investing
in their communities and they’ve been
doing this through healthcare services
job skills training and education and
they’ve been doing that for 150 years it
is built into their DNA they aren’t just
investing in the prosperity of today
they are investing in the people who
will one day want to buy their products
Schneider Electric is another example
they’re an energy management and
automation company in Europe and they
have committed 50% of their executive
and shareholder compensating the SEC you
t’v and senior management compensation
to achievement of their environmental
social and governance goals or take
Unilever at the core of Unilever
strategy is a simple idea sustainable
living and to that end they have
invested in 800,000 farmers in their
sustainable practices and those farmers
supply Unilever they have invested in
reducing their energy consumption by 20%
and most interestingly they have
eliminated waste that they send to
landfills in 70 countries
so of course Unilever makes money but in
34 countries there
considered an employer of choice because
people are looking for purpose in their
work this kind of long-term thinking
actually produces greater value
investing in the strength and
sustainability of a supply chain
investing in the development of
communities investing in efficiency and
the elimination of waste those are all
good business decisions but those things
also create and sustain jobs they create
greater well-being in our society and
they reduce the burdens on our
environment because when we invest for
the future we ensure there is something
there for us in the future so what is
the purpose of business I believe that
business is a platform for ingenuity
creativity and prosperity it gives us a
way to focus our resources on solving a
problem it gives us a means to aligning
a complex set of stakeholder interests
and it compels us to invest today for a
benefit tomorrow and that kind of bigger
picture longer-term thinking is why I
think the stakeholder model will
ultimately win the debate because how we
answer the question of purpose is a
reflection of what matters to us what we
value
now of course profit is an important
measure don’t get me wrong but it is not
and I believe it cannot be the only
measure of value what if we measured
value through other things like economic
impact or wage growth
what about quality of life happiness
what about life expectancy maybe poverty
reduction or reduced carbon footprint
what if we committed those kinds of
measures to the core of our business to
the core of our strategy I believe that
if we can take a broader view of what
value is we will land at the doorstep of
so
thing called purpose-driven strategy and
that’s where I’ve committed myself to
put more time and energy because I
believe it is at the heart of what will
transform our economy and our society so
I want to leave you with something to
think about
whether you’re in a business or a
non-profit or you’re in a volunteer
group whatever it might be how does your
organization define value and therefore
purpose it will take thoughtful
resourceful leadership to tackle the
complex challenges of creating value the
challenges that are ahead of us but in
doing so we’re going to give ourselves
permission to move away from short-term
reactive thinking and towards long-term
value creation that will have a greater
impact on our shared prosperity and the
sooner we get down to that hard work of
figuring out what it is we truly value
the sooner we can actually get down to
the business of creating that value and
we can get companies to take that
leadership role and make a real
difference in our communities in our
environment and in our shared prosperity
thank you
[Applause]
[Music]
Please follow and like us: