Press "Enter" to skip to content

Restoration through Incarceration | Aaron Kinzel | TEDxUMDearborn


[Music]
I want to really challenge you on some
different notions about the criminal
justice system just quickly a show of
hands curious how many you have heard
how the criminal justice system is
broken okay so it’s something that’s
kind of out there in the media suppose
you that showed your hands though how
many you actually believe that that the
criminal justice system is actually
broken okay so most of you I think raise
your hand again so what I want to tell
you is that from my personal
professional experience I feel the
criminal justice system was not broken
and in fact it’s actually doing exactly
what it was intended to do which is to
oppress and marginalize certain
communities so I’m going to show you
some graphs and some information that
kind of back that up so my presentation
is restoration through incarceration and
we are living in the era which is now
commonly known as mass incarceration
where we have currently over 2.2 million
people incarcerated in this country we
have less than 5% of the world’s
population and yet we hold more than 25%
of the world’s prisoners we leave the
country in incarceration that is kind of
like our claim to fame here in the
United States and how we are allegedly
better than other countries we are the
leaders in incarceration and we spend
vast amounts of money on an annual basis
if you look at this graph you can see
there’s been an exponential increase
from 1985 where we spent approximately
6.7 billion to nah more present-day over
50 billion in 2015 and present-day bring
it up now we’ve spent over 80 billion
dollars annually on incarceration that’s
across the nation which is just a
phenomenal amount of money that is going
to marginalizing people protecting
society to an extent but also keeping
people away from their families and
being able to become productive citizens
so Bryan Stevenson talks about how our
criminal justice system is able to treat
people better if you are rich and guilty
than you a few are porn innocent and
that is just a Travis
of justice so wealth not culpability is
a driver in our criminal justice system
today so people who have money and can
afford lawyers are able to navigate the
system in a much better way even if they
are guilty but so many people who are
living in poverty who cannot afford an
attorney and also our cash bail system
that we have here in the United States
where people are just put into county
jails and can stay there for several
years without even being found guilty of
a crime is also a travesty just because
they cannot have the financial means to
post bail and get out of the system so
this is a problem this is something that
should not be going on in an advanced
civilization that we have here in the US
Michelle Alexander talks about the
collateral consequences of conviction
where people who have been involved in
the criminal justice system when they
actually end up coming home they have
been put into a second-class citizenship
so a lot of states you are not able to
vote when you come home from prison you
are not able to give certain types of
licensure you have difficulty finding
employment because there’s something
where you very often have to check a box
many of you I’m sure is filled out a job
application
where this little box that asks have you
been convicted of a crime and lots of
research also demonstrates where a vast
majority of these what people do check
the box and they have a misdemeanor or
felony conviction these are just getting
thrown away in the trash people not even
getting an opportunity to kind of prove
themselves that they have worked them
that they want to contribute to society
there are over 40,000 collateral
consequences of conviction in the United
States which are basically legal
sanctions that allow for people who are
firmly incarcerated to be discriminated
against and this is something that we
allow in this country we have I believe
it’s over 70 million people in the
United States that have had some contact
at some point with the criminal justice
system whether that be an arrest a
conviction probation parole etc many
people have been touched by
incarceration and my assumption is a lot
of you in this room hopefully not have
you been incarcerated but my assumption
as many of you know someone who’s been
jail maybe you have a family member
that’s been to prison or you know
someone who’s been pulled over and
arrested maybe they were let out later
but this is something that touches all
of us it’s not something that is
isolated many people and the community
is also indirectly affected by
incarceration in many communities so a
problem with people coming in from the
penitentiary is they’re very as I
mentioned with these collateral
consequences they are set up for failure
so they have all these restrictions when
they come home if they’re on probation
or parole it is very difficult for them
to acclimate back into society get a job
have financial means even having a form
of identification is difficult to get so
you are kind of like in this endless
cycle where you are just going back in
and out of the penitentiary
recidivism rates according to the Bureau
of Justice Statistics which is a big
policy think-tank that is out of the
United States Department of Justice
looks at approximately in a five year
period when people come out of the
penitentiary z– roughly three-quarters
of them go back within a five year
period so that’s a lot so that’s
basically just again this endless cycle
incarceration as a cycle it affects
people’s families it affects their
children children who have incarcerated
parents are much more likely to become
justice involved whether it be juvenile
justice or adult criminal justice
systems so this is very cyclical it
affects communities it affects everybody
and a very strong basis so what do I do
and how do I try to impact mass
incarceration I’m a professor here of
criminology and criminal justice at the
University of Michigan Dearborn and I
love my job it’s an incredible
opportunity for me to be able to speak
about the injustice of our criminal
justice system and also empower my
students to do something about it
my great-grandfather told me once that
you don’t really have a right in this
country to bitch about a problem unless
you’re willing to stand up and do
something about it and he’s a 90 year
old disabled vet who is one of the last
World War two veterans and I have a lot
of respect for Lisbeth and it’s it’s
really it’s great advice like we have to
think about things that we can do as
we can’t just say that you know we’re
not directly affected by something this
is all of our problems we are all
culpable in a sense for the things that
are having through mass incarceration so
some of the things that I do as a part
of my profession I my research looks at
the phenomenon of incarceration so I
look at lived experiences of people who
have been through the justice system and
instead of really an interpretation or
analysis of that content I just want to
be able to describe that experience so I
interview people who are formerly
incarcerated or maybe talk to people who
are in the juvenile prison systems and
what does that weigh
what does that experience like there’s a
lot of trauma that comes out of these
experiences and that trauma can be
brought out of the prison system as well
and then that traumatic experience that
people have faced gets put off on to
their families get sparked off into the
community as you’ve seen for previous
lives with the recidivism rates it is
actually enhancing criminogenic factors
so people are becoming more likely to
find problems because of these
experiences that they’ve faced in the
institutions so here’s a picture of some
of my colleagues and I say colleagues
these are actually students here at the
University of Michigan Dearborn but I
see them as my colleagues because as a
professor I try to put myself on the
same page with my students I don’t want
to have this hierarchical structure
where I’m above them or below them I
want them to collaborate with me and I
want them to understand and work with
them in ways so I take them on lots of
different experience trips here’s an
example of the Ohio State Penitentiary
where we’ve done different field trips
this is actually where the Shawshank
Redemption was filmed so students
actually got to go into an empty prison
block and an entire facility and kind of
feel like what it’s like to be
incarcerated so they’re actually having
that lived experience and then I have
myself and other speakers kind of like
walk them through that process
what’s it like to be trapped in solitary
confinement 23 hours a day 24 hours a
day with limited food with isolation and
and in fact solitary confinement been
shown to like create all kinds of mental
health problems and in fact it even can
make people insane being in that type
fire here’s another example out in the
community I want my students to be able
to connect with law-enforcement agencies
as well I’m kind of selfish in that I
want to stack the deck a little bit so I
have the students that are going into
whether it be law enforcement the
judiciary or corrections field I want
them to kind of humanize people who’ve
been in the system and I also want them
to better understand the needs and
responsibilities of someone who is in
law enforcement for instance so this is
a field trip that we did the Monroe
County Jail which was an incredible
experience for them to talk to different
law enforcement officials people that
run the county jail and they were able
to see some people that are getting put
in and out of the system as well why am
I so passionate about this issue so on
the left you see a antique recognition
of myself a little bit thinner as well
too
Here I am 19 years old my first year in
the penitentiary and I’m the right as
you can see I’m dressed up but I’m a
faculty member now so my journey into
the penitentiary was a very long lived
experience in which as a child I was
exposed to so many different negative
elements I grew up in poverty I never
knew my father my mother was bouncing
around two different men in the
community who were some of the most
violent criminals out in the streets and
as a child I became exposed to violence
violence was pushed on me I was abused
as a child tortured I’ve seen murders my
stepfather almost killed me once when I
was an eight-year-old kid and that has a
way of transforming people I became in
my early teens what I kind of hated as a
young child and that was I became
involved in criminality very heavily I
became hyper masculine I became
aggressive I became angry and I actually
committed violent acts against others
not to excuse my behavior but to explain
it in a certain sense is that my
experiences early on in life helped to
transform me into that I didn’t have
opportunities where a lot of people
where they come from privileged families
are able to get access to
a home and I don’t buy home I mean
actually owning a home not renting a
property or going to different housing
projects or apartments I didn’t
experience these things I went hungry as
a child my mother again bounced around
to different places and we never had a
solidified experience where college to
me all I knew about the University of
Michigan as a young man was that we hate
the Ohio State University and anybody
that’s a Buckeye that is my complete
understanding of the university
experience so I never thought in a
million years one that I would even go
to college let alone become a professor
so my journey has been really profound
and I’m excited that I’m at this point
in my life so my journey as a teenager
very violent in and out of juvenile
facilities at the age of 18 was a
pivotal moment that kind of brought me
on the penitentiary journey I was on a
trip in Maine I was actually on felony
probation at that time I get pulled over
by law enforcement with my young
girlfriend we’re both teenagers I’m 18
years old and a state trooper pulls up
to my left and me being the aggressive
violent man that I was and everything
that I’m used to I felt threatened I
have a cop that’s right over here on my
left coming up to my vehicle and I react
in a way that kind of changes my life
forever
I pull out a gun I fire out the window
and the trooper drops and within seconds
to the right bullets start flying into
my vehicle and I feel like I’m in the
matrix time kind of stops the back
windshield gets blown out bullets going
the gas tank bullets go through my seat
lodging the dash in different parts of
the radio we had tape decks back then
and this was 1997 somehow miraculously I
was not harmed and all this happens
within a few seconds it’s all on
videotape I take off on a high-speed
chase
later thankfully I find out also that
the officer that I shot at was not
harmed as well nobody was harmed in this
incident I didn’t get shot
girlfriend and good shot and neither of
the troopers that were there were harmed
as well so I go on a high-speed chase I
end up getting a roadblock set up where
a spike mat was thrown out and end up
stopping my vehicle it’s not like you
see in the Fast and the Furious movies
where you know the tires blow out and
the car flips upside down and goes in
slow motion and we kind of do this weird
maneuver but the tire slowly deflated
and went down and started sparking and I
jumped a closed field where I was at in
the state of Maine went towards the
border of Canada where I seen a tree
line so me and my girlfriend are running
and I still have my gun on me we’re
going through the woods at night and
long story short the next day we come
out my girlfriend walks up to a row
thinking that everything is good peachy
keen we’re you know so it’s over now and
I’m like yeah I find out later 100
different law enforcement personnel
we’re searching for us during this
manhunt military Canadian Mounties local
state police everybody
planes helicopters dogs and they end up
I’m mark Cruiser comes out me and my
girlfriend are staying in there and I’m
at another moment in my life what am I
gonna do what’s my decision now I have a
loaded firearm in my pocket and my
girlfriend’s right next to me and I’ve
got an officer under a shotgun at me
point-blank range I did the right thing
I gave up put my hands up they took me
into custody I end up going to the
County Jail and now I’m facing life in
prison for the attempted murder of a
state trooper and to fast forward like
the the experience of incarceration is
extremely difficult
I spent time probably half my time in
solitary confinement and this was just a
horrific experience these this time I
had in the system made me more violent
program is extremely limited isolation
is a detriment to your mental health
status and eventually I went to trial
I lost a trial I spent a year and a half
in the county jail I ended up getting a
19 year sentence off to a State
Penitentiary
so my acclimation to prison was kind of
easy because I already had a crime that
was perceived as
thing that is honorable in the system I
was very violent and that was able to
make my transition easier so I was more
of a predator as opposed to prey and a
lot of the prisoners who were lifers
immediately came up to me and gave me
respect and started to mentor me and the
irony there is that I learned how to
become nonviolent through people who
have committed some of the most violent
acts in society many of these men that
mentored me were in there for a murder
and these men taught me the profound
purpose of finding my way in life and
looking at nonviolent ways to kind of
contribute to society as opposed to take
from us so I started learning about law
public policy and instead of fighting
the system with physical violence I
filed all kinds of grievances different
types of litigation against the system
where I felt there were injustice is
being held against myself or my
daughters I actually helped to start
different religious groups inside I
started a Native American group that I
was able to learn which ties into the
title of my presentation restoration
through incarceration I learned about
restorative practices I learned to
become accountable for what I have done
to society and try to repair that hard
way and I helped to get other prisoners
access to religious activities and group
work we started a group for his LOM
Buddhism we created an environment that
was more inclusive while we’re inside
fast forward as I came home my last year
in the penitentiary I took a college
course this changed my life forever and
as I was released I jumped right out I
only had to do approximately half my
time in prison so I did almost ten years
from the age of 18 to 28 I was paroled
under a mandatory statute that allowed
me to get release and I went right into
a community college I did an awesome job
when I got my bachelor’s degree my
masters all this time I struggled to
find employment but then I was given an
opportunity not too long ago was I got
into a doctoral program where I started
to teach at Western Michigan University
and eventually I was brought here by my
boss to walk plug right now judge Donna
Shelton who recruited me to teach here
at the University of Michigan do so now
I’m a professor I go out and do public
policy speaking I do things to
contribute to society I work with people
who’ve been formerly incarcerated and I
want to create safer neighborhoods I
want safe smart policy I want things
that are able to improve everything for
everyone not just people who’ve been
inside but we need to have opportunities
for people or we’re gonna end up just
continuing this endless cycle so I’ll
stop it there and thank you very much
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: