
[Music]
in the spring of 2015 I gave a talk at
Johns Hopkins University on the topic of
women and gaming after it finished a
bunch of students gathered their chairs
into a circle and continued to talk
about the things we had just discussed
they expressed frustration over things
like a lack of diversity in games
rampant misogyny and racism and online
gaming spaces and the lack of women
involved in games production eventually
one male student asked so if people
don’t like video games the way they are
why don’t they just make their own to be
fair his question points to a common
misunderstanding about the accessibility
of video game design something that’s
been perpetuated by movements like the
idea that everybody can make games do a
quick google search for teach yourself
game design or how to code your own
games and I guarantee you’ll find
thousands of results that promise to do
just that teach you how to make your own
video game usually for free the
abundance of these kinds of websites
along with workshops and summer camps
many of them targeting young girls and
people of color to encourage them to
pursue careers in game design have
helped create the narrative that now
literally everybody can make video games
now while these are important
initiatives and calling attention to
gender inequity within games
developments today I want to challenge
the use of the everyone can make games
movements or as I like to call it ECM GM
as a sole solution to gaming’s diversity
concerns now while more diversity in
games development promises to bring
fresh perspectives to a community that
has long privileged select voices I’m
afraid that things like ECM GM may
actually obscure forms of oppression
faced by women LGBTQ individuals and
people of color looking for a career in
game design so today I want to talk
about ECM GM both the promise and perils
and then talk about how we can ensure
that these in
Civet II projects are actually setting
up aspiring developers for long and
fruitful careers in game design one of
the main motivations behind ICI MGM
projects is calling attention to and
attempting to resolve gender and racial
inequalities and game design it
accomplishes this through a variety of
initiatives so on one hand there are
training based organizations like girls
make games an organization that offers
workshops and summer camps and tutorials
to spark an interest in game design
among young women then there’s the
internet-based DIY approaches for
example game developer Zoe Quinn runs a
curated list of websites that teach
individuals how to program games do
their own game arts and other relevant
game making skills
well helpful I see these DIY kinds of
approaches as distinct from things like
girls make games or women in games
international an organization that
offers lecture series workshops and
mentorship programs for women seeking
long-term careers in the games industry
these types of initiatives offer more
long-term support for people looking for
a career in games as opposed to
initiatives that ask you to kind of find
your own way therefore I feel that EC
MGM may perpetuate the idea that a road
to a career in games is quick and
effortless to be fair there are plenty
of reasons why feminist gamers and game
designers should support EC MGM
initiatives for one thing despite the
fact that more women than ever are
pursuing careers in game design they
remain vastly outnumbered by men
according to a recent survey conducted
by the International Game Developers
Association which surveyed over 3,000
industry employees from around the globe
75% of the global games workforce
identify as male compared to 22% female
1% transgender and about 2% non-binary
similar disparities are also reflected
in terms of race according to that same
survey 76% of the global games
force identifies as white Caucasian
European the real irony of it though is
that this lack of diversity in games
development is not at all reflective of
the people who actually play video games
a recent study published out of
Northwestern University for example
reveals that black and Latino
individuals actually spend more time
playing games than whites or Asian
individuals one of the hopes of EC MGM
initiatives is that more diversity among
people creating games will engender more
diversity in the term of games that are
offered to an increasingly more diverse
audience of the people who play them so
to be fair I can’t emphasize enough how
much the idea that anybody can go out
and make a game as an important nudge of
encouragement to young girls and
children of color who’ve spent their
whole lives playing games but never felt
that they had the means to make them
themselves EC MGM however may actually
obscure forms oppression that these
individuals face and moreover places the
burden of shifting gaming’s culture of
misogyny and racism and homophobia on
the precise individuals marginalized by
it rather than asking the industry to
change from within additionally I
worried that the rhetoric of everyone
can make games makes it seem as if
everyone does have the equal opportunity
to produce games in the first place my
concern is that individuals may adopt
the rhetoric of EC MGM initiatives as an
unquestioned truth and enter into a
career in game design both unaware and
unprepared to deal with misogyny racism
and homophobia that they may encounter
during their careers the promise of the
independent games market a booming
sector of game development that
privileges new types of game design and
storytelling and game mechanics further
augments the illusion that its
individual developers who should be
responsible for scaling institutional
barriers this is something that
unfortunately oftentimes gets prepared
she waited so for those who aren’t
familiar indie-games kind of like their
film counterparts our small budget
programs often produced by a team of
maybe one to developers on a shoestring
budget the key is they don’t have the
backing from a large gaming studio
behind them so on one hand this is nice
because it frees them up to really
experiment with different kinds of
storytelling and gameplay and bring
fresh perspectives to mainstream gaming
culture giving us more variety in what
we’re given the trade-off however is
because they’re not backed by a large
game studio the onus of publishing and
marketing their products falls squarely
on developers shoulders and even in the
era of digital distribution platforms
like Steam for example independent
developers compete with thousands of
other independent developers not to
mention established franchises with
loyal fan bases additionally it’s become
increasingly hard to subsist on an indie
developer salary according to a 2014
Indian report which surveyed workers
from around the world about how much
money they make in a year in 2013 the
average salary for an independent games
developer was eleven thousand one
hundred eighty two dollars which I might
add is a 49 percent decrease from just
the previous year so a lot of
self-taught game developers get their
first experiences with programs like
twine or game maker these programs are
really accessible game design software
because they require little to no
programming knowledge whatsoever so
while these two programs are awesome for
learning how game code functions they do
come with limitations twine for instance
restricts users to creating text-based
adventure stories like interactive
fiction kind of like a choose your own
adventure story game maker allows for
slightly more complex game making
instead relying on things like visual
scripting and programming but these
programs will only take one so far in
the industry in order to really remain
competitive more advanced skills will
eventually be required
the Popular Unity engine is low costs
and a nice alternative especially for
college students who are aspiring
designers but it does require
significantly more technical knowledge
and has a very steep learning curve in
an era where we’re told that anyone can
make a game the independent market
becomes saturated with inexperienced
developers competing against established
franchises and full-time professionals
not to mention they’re much larger
marketing budgets but this is a reality
that sometimes gets obscured in ECM GM
initiatives in order to truly be the
success that it can be ICI MGM must call
for structural and cultural changes
within the games industry itself
attitudes about who plays games and who
can even make a game in the first place
have to change before hiring practices
in the games industry can be free of
things like gender and racial biases the
general work culture of the games
industry must shift as well to become
more amenable to people of diverse needs
whether it’s childcare where a person
with a disability that might preclude
them from working 70 hours long work
weeks fortunately I think we’re already
starting to see some of this shift in
parts due to the work of initiatives
like ICI MGM male game developers have
begun speaking out against harassment
against their female colleagues as well
as calling for more diversity
initiatives in games hiring practices
but until we see structural overarching
change from games culture itself the
overall progress of ICI MGM will be
stymied one of the ways that ICI MGM can
bolster its intended effects then is to
better focus on efforts that prepare
these individuals to enter into work
climates that frankly speaking can be a
little Postol to their presence at times
earlier I mentioned the organization
women and games International it’s a
professional organization that helps
socialize women and other individuals
looking for careers and games
in addition to their tech based
workshops that teach people saying like
audio design or coding your own games
they also equip them with tools and
resources to help navigate many of the
hurdles that I’ve talked about today
moreover their online mentorship program
can be an indispensable resource for a
new aspiring developer looking to
navigate the industry and because WI Gi
is an established organization with
connections throughout gaming culture
they’re in a better position to help
guide individuals towards game studios
that are known to have more welcoming
work climates something that a solo
developer going about it themselves
would have a much harder time figuring
out and if you’re an independent games
developer looking to launch your first
game having an experienced mentor to
help guide you through that process can
literally be the difference between a
success story and the all-too-common
indie game failure now that’s not to say
that we want developers operating in
isolation from each other either to
really truly be effective ECM GM should
encourage strategic partnerships
throughout the games industry recently
the organization girls who code which
teaches young girls programming skills
partnered with 20 leading firms from the
tech industry who have then agreed to
give graduates of this program both paid
internships and other opportunities now
although it’s not game design specific
their hire me campaign serves as an
ideal model that could easily be
replicated by the games industry as well
unfortunately we are already starting to
see commitments towards boosting
diversity from some sectors in gaming
culture including the heavily
male-dominated eSports scene in 2015
Intel announced a partnership with the
electronic sports league making a pledge
to boost diversity among their ranks ICI
MGM is a rallying cry for individuals
who have grown up with games feeling
unspoken for so finally have a voice for
them
selves but if the gaming industry isn’t
willing to hear those voices then how
much change can we truly expect yeah it
may be true that everybody can now make
a game but can we yet honestly say that
everybody has the equal opportunity to
make a career in games this is the
reality that ICI MGM initiatives must
reconcile with in order to make sure
they’re ensuring aspiring developers
will have long and successful careers in
game design the late game development
legend Satoru Iwata is often quoted as
saying above all video games are meant
to just be one thing fun for everyone
it’s going to take a whole lot of change
from the gaming industry and a great
deal of social pressure to make it all
happen but it is my sincerest hope that
sometime in the very near future the
idea that everyone can make games will
not just be a truism but will in fact be
the reality for gaming as a whole thank
you
[Applause]
in the spring of 2015 I gave a talk at
Johns Hopkins University on the topic of
women and gaming after it finished a
bunch of students gathered their chairs
into a circle and continued to talk
about the things we had just discussed
they expressed frustration over things
like a lack of diversity in games
rampant misogyny and racism and online
gaming spaces and the lack of women
involved in games production eventually
one male student asked so if people
don’t like video games the way they are
why don’t they just make their own to be
fair his question points to a common
misunderstanding about the accessibility
of video game design something that’s
been perpetuated by movements like the
idea that everybody can make games do a
quick google search for teach yourself
game design or how to code your own
games and I guarantee you’ll find
thousands of results that promise to do
just that teach you how to make your own
video game usually for free the
abundance of these kinds of websites
along with workshops and summer camps
many of them targeting young girls and
people of color to encourage them to
pursue careers in game design have
helped create the narrative that now
literally everybody can make video games
now while these are important
initiatives and calling attention to
gender inequity within games
developments today I want to challenge
the use of the everyone can make games
movements or as I like to call it ECM GM
as a sole solution to gaming’s diversity
concerns now while more diversity in
games development promises to bring
fresh perspectives to a community that
has long privileged select voices I’m
afraid that things like ECM GM may
actually obscure forms of oppression
faced by women LGBTQ individuals and
people of color looking for a career in
game design so today I want to talk
about ECM GM both the promise and perils
and then talk about how we can ensure
that these in
Civet II projects are actually setting
up aspiring developers for long and
fruitful careers in game design one of
the main motivations behind ICI MGM
projects is calling attention to and
attempting to resolve gender and racial
inequalities and game design it
accomplishes this through a variety of
initiatives so on one hand there are
training based organizations like girls
make games an organization that offers
workshops and summer camps and tutorials
to spark an interest in game design
among young women then there’s the
internet-based DIY approaches for
example game developer Zoe Quinn runs a
curated list of websites that teach
individuals how to program games do
their own game arts and other relevant
game making skills
well helpful I see these DIY kinds of
approaches as distinct from things like
girls make games or women in games
international an organization that
offers lecture series workshops and
mentorship programs for women seeking
long-term careers in the games industry
these types of initiatives offer more
long-term support for people looking for
a career in games as opposed to
initiatives that ask you to kind of find
your own way therefore I feel that EC
MGM may perpetuate the idea that a road
to a career in games is quick and
effortless to be fair there are plenty
of reasons why feminist gamers and game
designers should support EC MGM
initiatives for one thing despite the
fact that more women than ever are
pursuing careers in game design they
remain vastly outnumbered by men
according to a recent survey conducted
by the International Game Developers
Association which surveyed over 3,000
industry employees from around the globe
75% of the global games workforce
identify as male compared to 22% female
1% transgender and about 2% non-binary
similar disparities are also reflected
in terms of race according to that same
survey 76% of the global games
force identifies as white Caucasian
European the real irony of it though is
that this lack of diversity in games
development is not at all reflective of
the people who actually play video games
a recent study published out of
Northwestern University for example
reveals that black and Latino
individuals actually spend more time
playing games than whites or Asian
individuals one of the hopes of EC MGM
initiatives is that more diversity among
people creating games will engender more
diversity in the term of games that are
offered to an increasingly more diverse
audience of the people who play them so
to be fair I can’t emphasize enough how
much the idea that anybody can go out
and make a game as an important nudge of
encouragement to young girls and
children of color who’ve spent their
whole lives playing games but never felt
that they had the means to make them
themselves EC MGM however may actually
obscure forms oppression that these
individuals face and moreover places the
burden of shifting gaming’s culture of
misogyny and racism and homophobia on
the precise individuals marginalized by
it rather than asking the industry to
change from within additionally I
worried that the rhetoric of everyone
can make games makes it seem as if
everyone does have the equal opportunity
to produce games in the first place my
concern is that individuals may adopt
the rhetoric of EC MGM initiatives as an
unquestioned truth and enter into a
career in game design both unaware and
unprepared to deal with misogyny racism
and homophobia that they may encounter
during their careers the promise of the
independent games market a booming
sector of game development that
privileges new types of game design and
storytelling and game mechanics further
augments the illusion that its
individual developers who should be
responsible for scaling institutional
barriers this is something that
unfortunately oftentimes gets prepared
she waited so for those who aren’t
familiar indie-games kind of like their
film counterparts our small budget
programs often produced by a team of
maybe one to developers on a shoestring
budget the key is they don’t have the
backing from a large gaming studio
behind them so on one hand this is nice
because it frees them up to really
experiment with different kinds of
storytelling and gameplay and bring
fresh perspectives to mainstream gaming
culture giving us more variety in what
we’re given the trade-off however is
because they’re not backed by a large
game studio the onus of publishing and
marketing their products falls squarely
on developers shoulders and even in the
era of digital distribution platforms
like Steam for example independent
developers compete with thousands of
other independent developers not to
mention established franchises with
loyal fan bases additionally it’s become
increasingly hard to subsist on an indie
developer salary according to a 2014
Indian report which surveyed workers
from around the world about how much
money they make in a year in 2013 the
average salary for an independent games
developer was eleven thousand one
hundred eighty two dollars which I might
add is a 49 percent decrease from just
the previous year so a lot of
self-taught game developers get their
first experiences with programs like
twine or game maker these programs are
really accessible game design software
because they require little to no
programming knowledge whatsoever so
while these two programs are awesome for
learning how game code functions they do
come with limitations twine for instance
restricts users to creating text-based
adventure stories like interactive
fiction kind of like a choose your own
adventure story game maker allows for
slightly more complex game making
instead relying on things like visual
scripting and programming but these
programs will only take one so far in
the industry in order to really remain
competitive more advanced skills will
eventually be required
the Popular Unity engine is low costs
and a nice alternative especially for
college students who are aspiring
designers but it does require
significantly more technical knowledge
and has a very steep learning curve in
an era where we’re told that anyone can
make a game the independent market
becomes saturated with inexperienced
developers competing against established
franchises and full-time professionals
not to mention they’re much larger
marketing budgets but this is a reality
that sometimes gets obscured in ECM GM
initiatives in order to truly be the
success that it can be ICI MGM must call
for structural and cultural changes
within the games industry itself
attitudes about who plays games and who
can even make a game in the first place
have to change before hiring practices
in the games industry can be free of
things like gender and racial biases the
general work culture of the games
industry must shift as well to become
more amenable to people of diverse needs
whether it’s childcare where a person
with a disability that might preclude
them from working 70 hours long work
weeks fortunately I think we’re already
starting to see some of this shift in
parts due to the work of initiatives
like ICI MGM male game developers have
begun speaking out against harassment
against their female colleagues as well
as calling for more diversity
initiatives in games hiring practices
but until we see structural overarching
change from games culture itself the
overall progress of ICI MGM will be
stymied one of the ways that ICI MGM can
bolster its intended effects then is to
better focus on efforts that prepare
these individuals to enter into work
climates that frankly speaking can be a
little Postol to their presence at times
earlier I mentioned the organization
women and games International it’s a
professional organization that helps
socialize women and other individuals
looking for careers and games
in addition to their tech based
workshops that teach people saying like
audio design or coding your own games
they also equip them with tools and
resources to help navigate many of the
hurdles that I’ve talked about today
moreover their online mentorship program
can be an indispensable resource for a
new aspiring developer looking to
navigate the industry and because WI Gi
is an established organization with
connections throughout gaming culture
they’re in a better position to help
guide individuals towards game studios
that are known to have more welcoming
work climates something that a solo
developer going about it themselves
would have a much harder time figuring
out and if you’re an independent games
developer looking to launch your first
game having an experienced mentor to
help guide you through that process can
literally be the difference between a
success story and the all-too-common
indie game failure now that’s not to say
that we want developers operating in
isolation from each other either to
really truly be effective ECM GM should
encourage strategic partnerships
throughout the games industry recently
the organization girls who code which
teaches young girls programming skills
partnered with 20 leading firms from the
tech industry who have then agreed to
give graduates of this program both paid
internships and other opportunities now
although it’s not game design specific
their hire me campaign serves as an
ideal model that could easily be
replicated by the games industry as well
unfortunately we are already starting to
see commitments towards boosting
diversity from some sectors in gaming
culture including the heavily
male-dominated eSports scene in 2015
Intel announced a partnership with the
electronic sports league making a pledge
to boost diversity among their ranks ICI
MGM is a rallying cry for individuals
who have grown up with games feeling
unspoken for so finally have a voice for
them
selves but if the gaming industry isn’t
willing to hear those voices then how
much change can we truly expect yeah it
may be true that everybody can now make
a game but can we yet honestly say that
everybody has the equal opportunity to
make a career in games this is the
reality that ICI MGM initiatives must
reconcile with in order to make sure
they’re ensuring aspiring developers
will have long and successful careers in
game design the late game development
legend Satoru Iwata is often quoted as
saying above all video games are meant
to just be one thing fun for everyone
it’s going to take a whole lot of change
from the gaming industry and a great
deal of social pressure to make it all
happen but it is my sincerest hope that
sometime in the very near future the
idea that everyone can make games will
not just be a truism but will in fact be
the reality for gaming as a whole thank
you
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: