
okay so here we are this is about
unlearning deconstructing innovating
usually this is associated with younger
people business people and people
outside large institutions so when my
students who is here Sophia invited not
only a teacher but also someone who
spent her entire life in in the Masha as
the girl called it the United Nations
system he will admit there is a paradox
I’m not the immediate candidate you
could think of for innovation
deconstructing and unlearning right well
so it’s going to be my impossible task
today to demonstrate to you the opposite
okay what has been my gerbil all my life
for the last 32 years Wow building peace
in the minds of men and women this is
the motto and the Constitution of UNESCO
it’s quite a wide program wouldn’t you
say but also quite a relevant one one
because peace as we could see from the
South North Korean element is still a
common good that is far from achieved in
many parts of the world and we see that
every day P war and intolerance seems to
be spreading and to because building
peace in the minds of men and women at
UNESCO means doing it through education
culture science and communication not
money not infrastructure not big guns
not even the Internet so this is what
I’m trying to tell you here is keep
faith in some of the institutions
if the institutions you have fought for
governance do not satisfy you then
innovate and build different ones the
urban biosphere
the motto of this project which was a UN
project was reconnecting people through
and to their natural environment we have
seen just before
a perfect example of what it is to
reconnect to your natural environment
through urban agriculture but don’t you
think there is also that there is also a
need to reconnect people to each other
today and this day and where we’re
building walls as opposed to bridges
where we’re trying to say that
foreigners that you know women should be
excluded for some some public places
that my grandson does and desirable
people there is a need for reconnect or
reconnection and why why do that in the
city okay
the world is moving to town more than 50
percent of the world today lives in
cities and by 2100 it would be 90
percent so the city is our playground
and the days we’re at the UN we were
talking about stemming the rural Exodus
are gone we know all know that we are
all more or banning coasts the urban
creature why cities because cities today
IQ if you pitch cities against the
environment you say cities produce 70%
of the carbon emission of the world
cities pollute the air and breathable as
we speak of today in Beijing or Delhi so
cities pollutes cities produce co2 and
also cities produce waste produce waste
that has to go somewhere else right so
we there’s a huge iko iko lot what we
call the ecological footprint of cities
today we we now say with this new cool
tool called the ecological footprint
that if all of us lived and consumed and
produce waste like New Yorkers we would
need seven planets and we don’t have
seven planets even for those of you who
think that we’ve just discovered nine
new planets I think the time by you know
by which we we can all go and happily
live together there is a bit far okay so
why city is also fine because cities are
places of innovation urban agriculture
the green roofs common gardens and the
city is also the place of reconnection
between people people are different
pluses people of different colors people
of different genders mixed together just
in the subway you know in New York
subway you see people from countries who
are war with each other
Serbs and Bosniaks and Arabs and Jews
and they all go happily together in the
subway they go to work they talk to each
other so cities are places of
reconnection and don’t forget that the
metropolis police was invented in Athens
in 200 or so BC in order to create
politics you know create politics and
institution and this is what we are
talking about today the need to
reintroduce politics and all of this
ecosystem services and biodiversity in
unlikely places this is this is my
contribution to the unlearning and
deconstructing part of this talk ok do
you really think there is thriving
nature on the roof of Chicago’s City
Hall well yes there is why because
cities do not most of the cities do not
use pesticides for example for their
garden so the bees on the roof of
Chicago’s City Hall are more prosperous
than outside and outside what you have
outside Chicago you have monoculture
exactly as the previous speaker
explained the Great Plain monoculture
pesticides no no no biodiversity so it’s
been documented that the biodiversity
inside the city of Chicago is bigger
than than outside plus we’re talking
today about ecosystem services ok you
think of services like the subway is a
service so electricity is a service but
think of all the service that nature
gives us clean air clean water
biodiversity food fuel fiber I mean can
anyone of you think could think of
living without these services we’ve lost
this notion of reconnection to
nature birds we have not lost the basic
necessity of having access to these
resources so you know we are in the
Anthropocene
we’ve changed you are the first
generation in 10,000 years to change
your logical era did you know that it’s
sort of pretty cool the geologists
change their minds about something like
every ten thousand years and now they
have declared that we are in the
Anthropocene the Anthropocene means the
planet is entirely dominated by humans
so some people will lament that in
particular the hard core ecologies I say
oh where is pristine nature
I grew up professionally in Asia and for
me nature is always full of people I’ve
never seen pristine nature in my entire
life and I’m fine with that you know I’m
fine with people living together with
with natural and and nature depending on
humans for management because this is
where we are we are in the entrepot
scene we’ve dominated every planetary
system so it means we’re in charge with
great power comes great responsibilities
right so now we’re responsible for
managing all these services not just the
infrastructure but also the natural ones
and this is what I find exciting about
about cities is that cities gather
people they gather ecosystem services
they gather resources they gather
information and they also gather
government and money which is useful and
businesses and innovators of all sorts
okay deconstructing part – when you see
– the green cities okay what comes to
mind Vancouver in France notice the sort
of greener City and then okay those
cities have matured for a long time what
it is to be green but they still think
of themselves first you know it’s still
urban gardens for urban people and then
you have green washing green washing is
all over the place and you have two
examples here
come to mind one is in Nigeria Lagos the
one of the largest city in Nigeria over
10 million people 80% of them live in
slums this is also the financial capital
of Nigeria which is an oil-producing
economy so what do they do
what are they proposing to do they are
proposing to build an offshore gated
community ecosystem eco city for
business people where the poor won’t
have access to the city of course
because poor messy and dirty and they
pollute we all know that know that you
know environmental services and poverty
do not go hand-in-hand
and yet justice an amount of what
managing the planet is sort of
imperative so this is what I call
brainwashing is throwing a huge amount
of concrete in the sea closing closing
it to other people reserving it for rich
people and putting solar panels on the
roof of buildings so that it can be
called the green city that doesn’t work
guys I mean an inequitable green city is
not going to work because you cannot be
I learned of prosperity in a sea of
misery forget that and this is what
we’re building islands of prosperity in
the sea of misery if you look at what
we’re doing around the world
plus the solutions for tomorrow’s world
may very well be found here this is the
Dharavi slum in India in Bombay one of
the largest slum in the world why are
the solutions here in my view first of
all because the world already looks like
this
the oceans are already a giant garbage
bin within a ten years or so in the
méditerranée there will be more
plastic than fish
we already using our oceans and coastal
area as garbage bins second the floods
yes I’m not you know I’m not predicting
the big flood
you can see everywhere big floods are
coming the coastal the coastal areas are
on the front lines of climate
vulnerabilities and we all know that
flood and drought succeed each other at
more frequent like speed right now so
these guys what do they know they know
how to live in environment in like this
and they still live you know it’s not as
many urban planners would like to tell
us misery
dejection millions of people live like
this an urbanization of tomorrow
80% of urbanization in the next 25 years
will take place in Africa in unplanned
cities and will be in the form of
informal settlements which take
different kind of form and shape but
certainly do not like like do not look
like Washington DC you know with the
center and nice avenues coming from the
center this is a completely different
form of urban planning that’s coming so
these people will know how to adapt
before before before we do and we better
take our cues from them the way they
organize the way they they manage to
survive in such environments okay let me
come to this project first of all what
do you need when you are the UN you’re
stuck in a huge administration and
innovation is not part of your DNA okay
if innovation is not part of the DNA of
UN organization why because our
shareholders if you like our 193
countries ranging from Vanuatu to the
United States and most of them are rogue
countries you know that’s your sort of
number of countries in in that group
that are really responsible stewards of
their people and their environment is
very limited and I would say shrinking
certainly with the advent of the new
administration in the u.s. we’ve lost
the sort of large shareholder who had
before upheld the principles of the
United Nations and today’s trampling
them clearly
it’s like rejecting them completely okay
so what do you do when you want to do
this an innovation about negating
project that reconnects people to nature
and through nature first of all you
don’t rely on your colleagues on your
bosses let me tell you that you rely on
interns the modern form of indentured
servitude the interns free labor while
spirits willing to work for free until
midnight so this is what I did I got a
fantastic group of interns I think five
or six from one Siberian guy to sue to
an American to a Colombian girl and we
had a time of her life you know that’s
also what and we we never did anything
dishonest or but we certainly were
walking on the lines of rules at the UN
we didn’t ask
I didn’t ask my bosses too many
permission before starting that second
of all what what you need what you need
for a successful innovation when you
want to create a successful innovative
institution within the UN okay so first
you recognize that you’re building
something on the shoulders of other
giants okay so UNESCO where I was
working had created this worldwide
network of biosphere reserves
I think there’s 700 of them now so
biosphere reserves are places where they
were there was a revolutionary idea when
it came up in the 70s because ecologists
have always been anti-development you
had conservation or development for the
longest time and these guys said no
there are places where conservation can
be going on with development so let’s
say for ten blow is the biosphere
reserve Yellowstone is the biosphere
reserve many unlike
places you know our biosphere and this
was a progress certainly a progress in
the notion of conserving in trying to
align the progress the conservation and
development do these places exist in
real life yes they do and the Christians
done biosphere reserve in Sweden is a
good example of that so what did these
guys do you know Swedes are innovative
people we all know that in ranking of
sustainability you constantly have the
Scandinavia Zone on top of the food
chain but I don’t exactly have an
explanation for that but this is the way
it is so what these guys you know they
are surrounded by wetlands and at first
they did what many cities do they turn
their back to the wetland hostile full
of mosquitoes disgusting so what did
they do they put their industry there
which created more pollution and at some
point they said no we wouldn’t want to
reconnect to the natural system that
made up make up our city and the history
of our city and those are wetlands so
they remove the industrial
infrastructure and restore the wetlands
so this was ecological engineering and
you understand that but you destroy
something and you need to rebuild it
it’s no longer you don’t let nature
operate by itself it’s ecological
engineering it requires engineers money
political will so they did that and they
did that by establishing that the value
of healthy wetland is higher than the
value the profit they would get from
having industries and that’s a very
smart move and that’s called valuation
of natural capital and now you have many
economies jumping into this okay
the Obie’s project built on this urban
biosphere project but wanted to go
further and that brings us back to
places like Korea for example where you
have wounds that you need to heal pieces
that outer piece building means
re-establishing trust you would you
would give me that
captain the wounds of apartheid the
wounds of apartheid do not disappear
just because the apartheid regime
disappears color than African people did
not have access to Cape Town they also
did not have access to the Natural Park
the Table Mountain Park that is so
charismatic knew they were simply
excluded from it so when apartheid
collapsed what happened when I bought I
collapsed these people had to read they
were they were allowed to move again and
what the Cape Town groupies projected
was to try and Riaan tower people who
had no access to Cape Town to become
good stewardship of the natural good
stewards of the natural areas by owning
them and that was a long painful process
but sometimes music sometimes natural
spaces can be places of healing and
reconciliation and in this case this is
what the municipality and the University
of Cape Town did within this project
okay when when you do a project at the
UN
you better have a big patron in this guy
in the shape of Ban ki-moon the
secretary-general because UNESCO was not
very friendly to the idea of turning
biosphere reserve into urban biosphere
fear of losing influence long story made
short but ban ki-moon was starting to
understand the importance of cities the
importance of mayors who were more
nimble in many ways in governance
systems and so we found a friend we
found a friend in ban ki-moon and we
also found a friend in the Convention on
Biological Diversity this is an
international treaty but this is also a
very important institutions and those
guys organize the parallel meeting of
mayors parallel to the conference of the
parties what they do and they issue the
resolution saying one there is valuable
nature in cities to cities
to reconnect to rural area to recognize
their sort of death and dependencies and
three we should acknowledge and use the
level of governance at the municipal
level mayor’s so this was groundbreaking
in our kind of world you know where we
work through resolution friends again
you know networks of organizations and
these are all the allies that I had if
you like not including science Tulane
University Columbia University Stockholm
University institutions legal treaties
so semi NGOs IUCN Diversity us science
policy networks and of course you let’s
go who paid my salary not inconsistent
okay so in conclusion I just want to say
don’t listen to any politician do not
vote for any politicians who will tell
you that he or she wants to build walls
walls don’t work they don’t work again
they cost money they are made of
concrete they emit co2 not good for the
environment
they don’t stop people forget it they
don’t stop people they also don’t stop
floods just look at New Orleans if you
don’t believe me and they cost too much
taxpayer money so hiding ourselves
behind wall is not going to do it so
don’t listen to these guys build bridges
through music through through a green
line through through a bet through music
through through a better of urban
agriculture but create connections and
thank you so much
[Applause]
unlearning deconstructing innovating
usually this is associated with younger
people business people and people
outside large institutions so when my
students who is here Sophia invited not
only a teacher but also someone who
spent her entire life in in the Masha as
the girl called it the United Nations
system he will admit there is a paradox
I’m not the immediate candidate you
could think of for innovation
deconstructing and unlearning right well
so it’s going to be my impossible task
today to demonstrate to you the opposite
okay what has been my gerbil all my life
for the last 32 years Wow building peace
in the minds of men and women this is
the motto and the Constitution of UNESCO
it’s quite a wide program wouldn’t you
say but also quite a relevant one one
because peace as we could see from the
South North Korean element is still a
common good that is far from achieved in
many parts of the world and we see that
every day P war and intolerance seems to
be spreading and to because building
peace in the minds of men and women at
UNESCO means doing it through education
culture science and communication not
money not infrastructure not big guns
not even the Internet so this is what
I’m trying to tell you here is keep
faith in some of the institutions
if the institutions you have fought for
governance do not satisfy you then
innovate and build different ones the
urban biosphere
the motto of this project which was a UN
project was reconnecting people through
and to their natural environment we have
seen just before
a perfect example of what it is to
reconnect to your natural environment
through urban agriculture but don’t you
think there is also that there is also a
need to reconnect people to each other
today and this day and where we’re
building walls as opposed to bridges
where we’re trying to say that
foreigners that you know women should be
excluded for some some public places
that my grandson does and desirable
people there is a need for reconnect or
reconnection and why why do that in the
city okay
the world is moving to town more than 50
percent of the world today lives in
cities and by 2100 it would be 90
percent so the city is our playground
and the days we’re at the UN we were
talking about stemming the rural Exodus
are gone we know all know that we are
all more or banning coasts the urban
creature why cities because cities today
IQ if you pitch cities against the
environment you say cities produce 70%
of the carbon emission of the world
cities pollute the air and breathable as
we speak of today in Beijing or Delhi so
cities pollutes cities produce co2 and
also cities produce waste produce waste
that has to go somewhere else right so
we there’s a huge iko iko lot what we
call the ecological footprint of cities
today we we now say with this new cool
tool called the ecological footprint
that if all of us lived and consumed and
produce waste like New Yorkers we would
need seven planets and we don’t have
seven planets even for those of you who
think that we’ve just discovered nine
new planets I think the time by you know
by which we we can all go and happily
live together there is a bit far okay so
why city is also fine because cities are
places of innovation urban agriculture
the green roofs common gardens and the
city is also the place of reconnection
between people people are different
pluses people of different colors people
of different genders mixed together just
in the subway you know in New York
subway you see people from countries who
are war with each other
Serbs and Bosniaks and Arabs and Jews
and they all go happily together in the
subway they go to work they talk to each
other so cities are places of
reconnection and don’t forget that the
metropolis police was invented in Athens
in 200 or so BC in order to create
politics you know create politics and
institution and this is what we are
talking about today the need to
reintroduce politics and all of this
ecosystem services and biodiversity in
unlikely places this is this is my
contribution to the unlearning and
deconstructing part of this talk ok do
you really think there is thriving
nature on the roof of Chicago’s City
Hall well yes there is why because
cities do not most of the cities do not
use pesticides for example for their
garden so the bees on the roof of
Chicago’s City Hall are more prosperous
than outside and outside what you have
outside Chicago you have monoculture
exactly as the previous speaker
explained the Great Plain monoculture
pesticides no no no biodiversity so it’s
been documented that the biodiversity
inside the city of Chicago is bigger
than than outside plus we’re talking
today about ecosystem services ok you
think of services like the subway is a
service so electricity is a service but
think of all the service that nature
gives us clean air clean water
biodiversity food fuel fiber I mean can
anyone of you think could think of
living without these services we’ve lost
this notion of reconnection to
nature birds we have not lost the basic
necessity of having access to these
resources so you know we are in the
Anthropocene
we’ve changed you are the first
generation in 10,000 years to change
your logical era did you know that it’s
sort of pretty cool the geologists
change their minds about something like
every ten thousand years and now they
have declared that we are in the
Anthropocene the Anthropocene means the
planet is entirely dominated by humans
so some people will lament that in
particular the hard core ecologies I say
oh where is pristine nature
I grew up professionally in Asia and for
me nature is always full of people I’ve
never seen pristine nature in my entire
life and I’m fine with that you know I’m
fine with people living together with
with natural and and nature depending on
humans for management because this is
where we are we are in the entrepot
scene we’ve dominated every planetary
system so it means we’re in charge with
great power comes great responsibilities
right so now we’re responsible for
managing all these services not just the
infrastructure but also the natural ones
and this is what I find exciting about
about cities is that cities gather
people they gather ecosystem services
they gather resources they gather
information and they also gather
government and money which is useful and
businesses and innovators of all sorts
okay deconstructing part – when you see
– the green cities okay what comes to
mind Vancouver in France notice the sort
of greener City and then okay those
cities have matured for a long time what
it is to be green but they still think
of themselves first you know it’s still
urban gardens for urban people and then
you have green washing green washing is
all over the place and you have two
examples here
come to mind one is in Nigeria Lagos the
one of the largest city in Nigeria over
10 million people 80% of them live in
slums this is also the financial capital
of Nigeria which is an oil-producing
economy so what do they do
what are they proposing to do they are
proposing to build an offshore gated
community ecosystem eco city for
business people where the poor won’t
have access to the city of course
because poor messy and dirty and they
pollute we all know that know that you
know environmental services and poverty
do not go hand-in-hand
and yet justice an amount of what
managing the planet is sort of
imperative so this is what I call
brainwashing is throwing a huge amount
of concrete in the sea closing closing
it to other people reserving it for rich
people and putting solar panels on the
roof of buildings so that it can be
called the green city that doesn’t work
guys I mean an inequitable green city is
not going to work because you cannot be
I learned of prosperity in a sea of
misery forget that and this is what
we’re building islands of prosperity in
the sea of misery if you look at what
we’re doing around the world
plus the solutions for tomorrow’s world
may very well be found here this is the
Dharavi slum in India in Bombay one of
the largest slum in the world why are
the solutions here in my view first of
all because the world already looks like
this
the oceans are already a giant garbage
bin within a ten years or so in the
méditerranée there will be more
plastic than fish
we already using our oceans and coastal
area as garbage bins second the floods
yes I’m not you know I’m not predicting
the big flood
you can see everywhere big floods are
coming the coastal the coastal areas are
on the front lines of climate
vulnerabilities and we all know that
flood and drought succeed each other at
more frequent like speed right now so
these guys what do they know they know
how to live in environment in like this
and they still live you know it’s not as
many urban planners would like to tell
us misery
dejection millions of people live like
this an urbanization of tomorrow
80% of urbanization in the next 25 years
will take place in Africa in unplanned
cities and will be in the form of
informal settlements which take
different kind of form and shape but
certainly do not like like do not look
like Washington DC you know with the
center and nice avenues coming from the
center this is a completely different
form of urban planning that’s coming so
these people will know how to adapt
before before before we do and we better
take our cues from them the way they
organize the way they they manage to
survive in such environments okay let me
come to this project first of all what
do you need when you are the UN you’re
stuck in a huge administration and
innovation is not part of your DNA okay
if innovation is not part of the DNA of
UN organization why because our
shareholders if you like our 193
countries ranging from Vanuatu to the
United States and most of them are rogue
countries you know that’s your sort of
number of countries in in that group
that are really responsible stewards of
their people and their environment is
very limited and I would say shrinking
certainly with the advent of the new
administration in the u.s. we’ve lost
the sort of large shareholder who had
before upheld the principles of the
United Nations and today’s trampling
them clearly
it’s like rejecting them completely okay
so what do you do when you want to do
this an innovation about negating
project that reconnects people to nature
and through nature first of all you
don’t rely on your colleagues on your
bosses let me tell you that you rely on
interns the modern form of indentured
servitude the interns free labor while
spirits willing to work for free until
midnight so this is what I did I got a
fantastic group of interns I think five
or six from one Siberian guy to sue to
an American to a Colombian girl and we
had a time of her life you know that’s
also what and we we never did anything
dishonest or but we certainly were
walking on the lines of rules at the UN
we didn’t ask
I didn’t ask my bosses too many
permission before starting that second
of all what what you need what you need
for a successful innovation when you
want to create a successful innovative
institution within the UN okay so first
you recognize that you’re building
something on the shoulders of other
giants okay so UNESCO where I was
working had created this worldwide
network of biosphere reserves
I think there’s 700 of them now so
biosphere reserves are places where they
were there was a revolutionary idea when
it came up in the 70s because ecologists
have always been anti-development you
had conservation or development for the
longest time and these guys said no
there are places where conservation can
be going on with development so let’s
say for ten blow is the biosphere
reserve Yellowstone is the biosphere
reserve many unlike
places you know our biosphere and this
was a progress certainly a progress in
the notion of conserving in trying to
align the progress the conservation and
development do these places exist in
real life yes they do and the Christians
done biosphere reserve in Sweden is a
good example of that so what did these
guys do you know Swedes are innovative
people we all know that in ranking of
sustainability you constantly have the
Scandinavia Zone on top of the food
chain but I don’t exactly have an
explanation for that but this is the way
it is so what these guys you know they
are surrounded by wetlands and at first
they did what many cities do they turn
their back to the wetland hostile full
of mosquitoes disgusting so what did
they do they put their industry there
which created more pollution and at some
point they said no we wouldn’t want to
reconnect to the natural system that
made up make up our city and the history
of our city and those are wetlands so
they remove the industrial
infrastructure and restore the wetlands
so this was ecological engineering and
you understand that but you destroy
something and you need to rebuild it
it’s no longer you don’t let nature
operate by itself it’s ecological
engineering it requires engineers money
political will so they did that and they
did that by establishing that the value
of healthy wetland is higher than the
value the profit they would get from
having industries and that’s a very
smart move and that’s called valuation
of natural capital and now you have many
economies jumping into this okay
the Obie’s project built on this urban
biosphere project but wanted to go
further and that brings us back to
places like Korea for example where you
have wounds that you need to heal pieces
that outer piece building means
re-establishing trust you would you
would give me that
captain the wounds of apartheid the
wounds of apartheid do not disappear
just because the apartheid regime
disappears color than African people did
not have access to Cape Town they also
did not have access to the Natural Park
the Table Mountain Park that is so
charismatic knew they were simply
excluded from it so when apartheid
collapsed what happened when I bought I
collapsed these people had to read they
were they were allowed to move again and
what the Cape Town groupies projected
was to try and Riaan tower people who
had no access to Cape Town to become
good stewardship of the natural good
stewards of the natural areas by owning
them and that was a long painful process
but sometimes music sometimes natural
spaces can be places of healing and
reconciliation and in this case this is
what the municipality and the University
of Cape Town did within this project
okay when when you do a project at the
UN
you better have a big patron in this guy
in the shape of Ban ki-moon the
secretary-general because UNESCO was not
very friendly to the idea of turning
biosphere reserve into urban biosphere
fear of losing influence long story made
short but ban ki-moon was starting to
understand the importance of cities the
importance of mayors who were more
nimble in many ways in governance
systems and so we found a friend we
found a friend in ban ki-moon and we
also found a friend in the Convention on
Biological Diversity this is an
international treaty but this is also a
very important institutions and those
guys organize the parallel meeting of
mayors parallel to the conference of the
parties what they do and they issue the
resolution saying one there is valuable
nature in cities to cities
to reconnect to rural area to recognize
their sort of death and dependencies and
three we should acknowledge and use the
level of governance at the municipal
level mayor’s so this was groundbreaking
in our kind of world you know where we
work through resolution friends again
you know networks of organizations and
these are all the allies that I had if
you like not including science Tulane
University Columbia University Stockholm
University institutions legal treaties
so semi NGOs IUCN Diversity us science
policy networks and of course you let’s
go who paid my salary not inconsistent
okay so in conclusion I just want to say
don’t listen to any politician do not
vote for any politicians who will tell
you that he or she wants to build walls
walls don’t work they don’t work again
they cost money they are made of
concrete they emit co2 not good for the
environment
they don’t stop people forget it they
don’t stop people they also don’t stop
floods just look at New Orleans if you
don’t believe me and they cost too much
taxpayer money so hiding ourselves
behind wall is not going to do it so
don’t listen to these guys build bridges
through music through through a green
line through through a bet through music
through through a better of urban
agriculture but create connections and
thank you so much
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: