
great pleasure being with you and
essentially in this short 18 minutes
what I’m going to attempt to do is share
with you what some insights we have into
innovation and actually I am sure that
all of you are sitting here it’s become
a big buzzword hasn’t it innovation and
today the reality is no CEO we dare
caught not talking innovation
everybody talks it but very few actually
manage it and even fewer have actually
managed to institutionalize it into the
DNA of an organization so the question
really I am sure that is puzzling all of
us is what makes it so difficult that
why so many people aspire it so few
actually manage it and this is a
question that we have kind of struggled
with through these through these very
many years and the you know the the verb
of the one answer which has struck us
all this time is the single word is
gravity now think about it that said one
force which pulls down no matter how
hard you throw it and the forces
opposing innovation are pretty much the
same and when you think about it the
design of an organization today is still
the remnant of the Industrial Age while
the world has moved on but the design of
the organization has hardly changed so
what at the heart of it what are the key
questions and the myths we need to bust
in order to mobilize the organization to
move Israeli what I am attempting to
share with you today and the one
experience the wit which pulls out the
very heart of this dilemma and the
possibility is really a story out of
Walt Disney’s life you know the one of
the very we just stuck with me through
many years but the very first film that
they made that was very successful an
animated venture was a film about three
pigs I am sure some of you have heard
the story you are seeing the film even
it’s a very popular three little pigs
and this was very successful now the so
Walt Disney got a studio together to
think about what what film should we do
next
you can imagine when one genre film
begins to succeed what would have been
the answer what do you think was the
answer you know unfortunately for
Disney the answer was the same so you
know pigs work pigs hell so pigs to
weather did pigs too and it didn’t work
very well and in a very formalized
review they concluded the idea was good
but the execution was bad and so pigs
three and it went on till pigs four
actually
till finally struck Walt Disney like a
bolt of lightning you can’t beat pigs
with pigs you have to do something else
yeah that was such a little obvious but
a big jolt and that led to Snow White
and the Seven Dwarfs those of you who
know film history it was the first
full-length animated feature film it
actually created the category of
animated feature films the it was far
bigger than pigs could ever be and it is
still a date in the Hall of Fame as the
biggest grosser and when you compare it
to today it still remains there but take
a look
it took that key question right to break
through that but in when you see across
the organization the cross industry even
what happens over a period everybody is
busy making pigs actually when you when
you look at it the whole industry can
become an extended pigs factory and then
they call it getting commoditized but
really there is there is nothing called
a commoditized industry just commoditize
mindsets well nobody asked is asking the
snow-white question at all so when
you’re faced with such a scenario you
can imagine a CEOs challenges and the
the starting point the first myth we
need to bust is it’s all about managing
innovation so we have departments being
created around managing innovation we
have perhaps solving the wrong problem
innovation is not the purpose innovation
is a means transformation is the purpose
once transformation becomes a purpose
innovation is the fuel what which
shifting is the purpose innovation is
the means it’s not an end in itself when
we start managing innovation things
start more completely alright so really
the challenge for an organization in the
first myth we need to break it let’s not
manage innovation you have to lead orbit
shifts it’s not about managing
innovation between lead transformation
and then transformation becomes a
purpose innovation becomes the
few lineage necessary so that’s really
one myth but the second one which goes
almost along with it
which I’m sure you’ve seen this to did
this story bring a life we are all
seduced with the idea of out-of-the-box
thinking I’m sure you’ve heard that
you’ve been also talked about and and
nudged and prodded to do that you know
think out of the box think differently
but the bigger question is how does one
find the box you know the trouble is the
biggest and the most powerful boxes of
the most paralyzing ones are actually
the most invisible recognising that is
the heart of the challenge and you know
to just to a story brings it very alive
in experience that we had well working
with the with a global corporate now
they were talking about what do we do to
transform and to create the next game
changer in laundry now why don’t they
were talking all this they also said you
know all around the world we’ve done
lots of ideation and we have some 4,000
ideas I doubted there’s anything left
you thought about everything possible so
rather than respond to that we just
started mapping those ideas to look for
boxes and they were fascinating they
were just one or two boxes in which all
those 4,000 ideas were well unknowingly
it had paralyzed it and what was the box
no we did in hindsight you notice all
great ideas are very obvious in
hindsight now in this case what it
happened was very unknowingly did you
just think aloud with me that when you
think of laundry what is the war what
comes to mind what’s the purpose of
laundry
I’m sure instinctively it’ll be to clean
to remove surely it is to clean to
remove microbial dirt or physical dirt
but it is to remove so think about it
laundry is a post dirt intervention the
movement this question was framed you
can imagine immediately a blind spot
opened up by post what could be done pre
dirt
what about preventing dirt the whole
questioned opened up that oh there could
be a radically different way of handling
this question and suddenly a whole range
of new possibilities opened up on the
other hand the question was it’s about
removing what would it add the first
thing was
standard core do you mean could add dirt
but not really
we could add health immediately it
followed through but all these
possibilities were striking much later
and when you look back at all those
3,500 ideas since it was all about post
dirt intervention you can imagine those
3,500 ideas were all about cleaning
faster cheaper better unknowingly that
box had maintained and this was around
the world doesn’t matter what cultural
differences were but this is the
paralysis of the box the invisible box
which had limited them completely so the
starting point is not out of the box
thinking is finding the boxes is
actually mapping and breaking through
boundaries and if we do it with the same
force as we think of ideation amazing in
new possibilities open up so that’s the
first myth the the that needs to be
broken and very closely associated with
this is the starting point of an
innovation now all these years have you
know all these I’m sure you’ve heard of
lot of romantic stories around
innovation we started with a big idea
and they almost all seem to start there
but and therefore that the myth which
has cultivated it begins with a big
breakthrough idea and after that you
have to kind of stage manage it but what
we have discovered is if you want to do
it by design not by accident it doesn’t
start with an out-of-the-box idea it
starts with an out-of-the-box challenge
taking on a challenge which cannot be
done by doing more of the same when it
starts there then new things begin to
happen in to do give you another very
interesting illustration of this another
global cooperation that we are working
with now this is a talking to a category
head globally and he was discussing that
you know he was in charge of soaps and
shampoos globally for him the concern
was that you know the water is becoming
a stress issue and our soaps and
shampoos consume a lot of water in usage
a lot of water gets wasted how do we
reduce it because who over this is going
to become a question so I asked him so
what is the challenge he says even if
you can reduce it 25 30 %
now in a little bit of dialogue what
emerged was this is not an orbit
shifting challenge it was orbit it was
actually incremental the dialogue took
shape and we were discussing that you
know if we did it like 25-30 percent
what will the people do this yoke a
pre-shampoo
during shampoo portion take out ten
percent here ten percent job done but
that’s the classical incremental kind of
thinking and and this kind of dialogue
it triggered an out-of-the-box challenge
well how about a range with doubt water
let’s start from scratch
how about creating a range with has no
water at all now that out of the box
challenge provoked them to think
completely differently it took just
three or four months to arrive at the
full new portfolio but the starting
point had changed the ending the now all
this sounds great by but think about it
in management language we have something
called objective setting huh it’s called
good objectives or what challenging but
realistic now that but realistic is the
gravity which did decimates it to doing
more of the same whereas what are.what
obviously what is needed is an
out-of-the-box challenge which will by
design
bust the existing box cannot be done by
doing what are the same and/or if you
look back all of the grand innovations
that have come actually began with an
aspiration which was close to this the
question is how do we do this by design
and not let it happen by incident an
accident within which most of these
stories actually are about and the
almost follow through to this is that we
then ceo’s talk about expanding markets
and growing by innovation for growth is
the big story but the next question
always is but how do we get new insights
into the market I’m sure you heard the
question right new insight into the
market is very wider so how do they go
about it market research okay so senior
guy thinks about it he’ll talk
tu-tu-tu-tu-tu is the the next level guy
who’ll talk to a market research agency
and finally the researcher will be five
times removed from the person who
thought of this idea and he is going
around talking to customers at the end
of it what they are left with is a graph
Peabody with thousands of data points if
you are lucky some useful information
but almost never a breakthrough inside
over these years what we found is just
such an amazing amount of effort goes
into doing incrementally different
things but but what is the problem with
this process now it is great for
incremental improvements but when it
comes to breakthrough innovation it was
short but where does it really fall
short you notice a starting point of a
research is a hypothesis there is an
innovation is not about there’s no
starting with the hypothesis about
discovering a new hypothesis research is
about finding answers to questions
whereas innovation is about finding the
next question which hadn’t which we
haven’t even thought about so far so
this is the starting point in itself is
fundamentally different now how does one
engage with that and the biggest
learning for us in over these years is
insight is the one thing which the
leadership of an organization cannot
outsource to anybody they need to do it
personally because only they have the
capacity to actually ask and discover
the next questions and once the
questions have to be been discovered
they can be validated the other big myth
is we have to go to consumers and
discover and articulated needs of course
that has to be done but they are not the
only source the challenge is to discover
new sources entirely who else who else
understands the consumer but is not a
consumer one very breakthrough insight
about watches actually came from not
talking to the consumer but talking
about to a spa runner who was providing
spa service to those consumers she
understood them far more intimately than
we could ever have and a fascinating new
insight came up another new insight into
wellness actually came from talking to
now hold your breath a traditional
Chinese medicine doctor was a completely
new insight into how wellness could be
conceived occurred from that
conversation and so it’s amazing how
many new insights can come by joining
new dots but here accidents have to be
made to happen by design and not hope to
hope it will pull away will happen so we
have to transform the way we
we explore markets research is great for
maintaining but for do we have to get
into market discovery alongside with
that now these are some of the key myths
but at the heart of the matter is one
fundamental question innovation is
finally the journey into the unknown and
think about it our organization design
is all about making sure unknown doesn’t
happen is about ensuring certainty in
fact what we’ve discovered over these
years that one cultural phenomena which
runs across most organizations is
success equals not failing that almost
becomes an ingrained culture imagine not
failing so what does it actually
translate into the who our heroes in her
in a risk-averse culture heroes are
people who are great at under promising
and overachieving
in fact this becomes an art form at the
beginning of the year when goals are
being set for next year the hero is the
guy who can promise just less than what
he believes he can achieve now think
about it if we had to under promising
and I am talking about out-of-the-box
challenges unthinkable it must be he
must be nuts to be taking on a challenge
like that
but how does so what’s the heart of the
matter it’s not the fear of commercial
risk but the fear of personal risk which
holds back innovation drives how does
one create a safe environment to create
new experiments unless that happens it
will remain me a talk and the other myth
that is another fascinating one is to
take it beyond ideation really biggest
ideas don’t just die they get diluted in
fact if they if they died it may have
been easier but reality reality is we’ve
seen biggest ideas don’t die they just
get compromised slowly what looks like a
Snow White in a boardroom by the time it
reaches the market has become a peak
because at every step a compromise takes
place and how does this happen because
the people who came up with the idea but
two or three but in a large organization
they have to depend upon many other
functions to come together to execute it
now when the execution stage comes up
cross-functional battles take over
what is an excitement and exciting
opportunity for me is a headache for the
other guy I mean he singing as if I
don’t have enough problems already
bugger has come up with yet another one
so what does he do you say well we can
do so much yeah the other it if you
insist it has to be done all the way it
may take another five years this forget
it here at least do what you can do so
10% compromise another 5% compromise one
after the other see real compromises and
by the time it reaches the market it’s a
pale shadow of its original self and
those of you who Ben and I in the
organization you must have painfully see
seen this happen very very frequently
and the heart of the matter is why does
this happen the starting point really is
how an innovation is resourced by
resourced I don’t mean money that’s the
easier part the tougher part is who are
the people leading it now in the one
conversation I’ve seen happen very
frequently with senior leadership is up
to the point of doing great things doing
or betrayed they are very excited the
moment the question comes up so tell me
who will do it then gravity takes over
and then suddenly the conversation
changes – who can be spare who can be
spare but the best people are defending
today
only the ones who can be spared are
available to create tomorrow so imagine
are the people pursuing the new are
spare people in spare time spare people
in spare time don’t create history it’s
almost by design dilution and no wonder
it a pitfalls away in in very very
frequently DVD and the second big source
of delusion is this belief that all the
romance around innovation is coming up
with a big idea executing it anybody can
do it
so the thinkers are in the involved in
the creation stage and then it is handed
over to the so called implementers and
with me forget the one critical thing
that as much innovation will be called
for in executing the idea as was called
for in creating it in fact overcoming
the execution obstacles will call for as
many breakthroughs at virtually every
stage what happens is a new idea goes
into an old pipe and it kills it in the
last mile use a new product will may
need a marketing innovation a business
model innovation in order to
see how will that happen and the Li if
you put the whole thing together the one
key question that I’m sure you heard all
the time is you need to hire new people
to make innovation happen you know the
same people can’t do it
have you heard that you know this is
this is another myth and I’m calling it
a myth because this idea of calling it
superheroes and making great things
happen is easily talked about but in
reality the organization’s mindsets are
far tougher than even the the new people
imagine and the group of new people are
hired and over a period of time they
become very unconsciously and we induct
them bloody well it’s to be inducted
into the existing mindsets on the other
hand what we’ve seen is that when
gravity is broken through the same
people have made the orbit shift happen
have we have in fact across these years
the one thing which stands out is that
the same people led the transformation
it didn’t take a change of teams so this
is a fanciful theoretical question more
or less that it takes a change of team
deep people but what all this is trying
to put together is the six myths that
need to be busted and by through which
we can re architect an organization
which can actually transform and I would
urge you to think that the same
principles can be applied to leapfrog
the development curve of a nation –
thank you very much and I’m going to
leave you with just one thought it’s all
about creating and not following history thank you