
[Music]
[Music] [Applause]
[Music]
[Music] so in November 2016 I was having lunch
so in November 2016 I was having lunch
so in November 2016 I was having lunch with a friend who was dreading
with a friend who was dreading
with a friend who was dreading Thanksgiving the country had just
Thanksgiving the country had just
Thanksgiving the country had just elected a new president and she was
elected a new president and she was
elected a new president and she was concerned that the holiday dinner was
concerned that the holiday dinner was
concerned that the holiday dinner was going to erupt into a political war zone
going to erupt into a political war zone
going to erupt into a political war zone she told me about an article that she
she told me about an article that she
she told me about an article that she had read in The Washington Post I
had read in The Washington Post I
had read in The Washington Post I believe that had a title like surviving
believe that had a title like surviving
believe that had a title like surviving Thanksgiving when you can’t stand how
Thanksgiving when you can’t stand how
Thanksgiving when you can’t stand how your family voted later that day I went
your family voted later that day I went
your family voted later that day I went and looked it up on Google and I found
and looked it up on Google and I found
and looked it up on Google and I found it but I was surprised to find also that
it but I was surprised to find also that
it but I was surprised to find also that an entire genre had emerged on this
an entire genre had emerged on this
an entire genre had emerged on this theme of surviving Thanksgiving dinner a
theme of surviving Thanksgiving dinner a
theme of surviving Thanksgiving dinner a missed political disagreement in the
missed political disagreement in the
missed political disagreement in the intervening year the genre has exploded
intervening year the genre has exploded
intervening year the genre has exploded that’s 21 million hits on Google for
that’s 21 million hits on Google for
that’s 21 million hits on Google for surviving Thanksgiving politics now many
surviving Thanksgiving politics now many
surviving Thanksgiving politics now many of these articles offer pretty solid
of these articles offer pretty solid
of these articles offer pretty solid advice remain calm don’t call names try
advice remain calm don’t call names try
advice remain calm don’t call names try to understand the other person’s
to understand the other person’s
to understand the other person’s perspective however a good portion of
perspective however a good portion of
perspective however a good portion of them close with the following message
them close with the following message
them close with the following message hey sometimes it’s just too hard
hey sometimes it’s just too hard
hey sometimes it’s just too hard sometimes it’s not even worth the
sometimes it’s not even worth the
sometimes it’s not even worth the attempt to get along with your family
attempt to get along with your family
attempt to get along with your family and in those cases stay home
and in those cases stay home
and in those cases stay home skip Thanksgiving so what to make of
skip Thanksgiving so what to make of
skip Thanksgiving so what to make of this
this
this now I’m a political philosopher and my
now I’m a political philosopher and my
now I’m a political philosopher and my work focuses mainly on moral and
work focuses mainly on moral and
work focuses mainly on moral and political disagreement and the role of
political disagreement and the role of
political disagreement and the role of disagreement in democratic society you
disagreement in democratic society you
disagreement in democratic society you can judge those books by their covers
can judge those books by their covers
can judge those books by their covers and in this work I’ve taken a view that
and in this work I’ve taken a view that
and in this work I’ve taken a view that is pretty popular among political
is pretty popular among political
is pretty popular among political philosophers and that view is that
philosophers and that view is that
philosophers and that view is that democracy is a 24/7 job the way to do
democracy is a 24/7 job the way to do
democracy is a 24/7 job the way to do democracy well is to do it perpetually
democracy well is to do it perpetually
democracy well is to do it perpetually and if we find that democracy has any
and if we find that democracy has any
and if we find that democracy has any troubles or problems there’s always the
troubles or problems there’s always the
troubles or problems there’s always the solution of more democracy I’ve since
solution of more democracy I’ve since
solution of more democracy I’ve since changed my mind about that and I want to
changed my mind about that and I want to
changed my mind about that and I want to talk to you a little bit today about why
talk to you a little bit today about why
talk to you a little bit today about why my mind has changed and how my view now
my mind has changed and how my view now
my mind has changed and how my view now is that there are some problems that
is that there are some problems that
is that there are some problems that democracy faces where the solution is
democracy faces where the solution is
democracy faces where the solution is not to do more democracy but in fact
not to do more democracy but in fact
not to do more democracy but in fact sometimes we need to do less democracy
sometimes we need to do less democracy
sometimes we need to do less democracy now that might sound heretical to you so
now that might sound heretical to you so
now that might sound heretical to you so let me explain what I mean there are
let me explain what I mean there are
let me explain what I mean there are some goods that can be realized only
some goods that can be realized only
some goods that can be realized only when we pursue something else if you
when we pursue something else if you
when we pursue something else if you want a simple example consider fun it’s
want a simple example consider fun it’s
want a simple example consider fun it’s good to have fun right however the
good to have fun right however the
good to have fun right however the surest way to fail at fun is to make
surest way to fail at fun is to make
surest way to fail at fun is to make having fun the point of your activity
having fun the point of your activity
having fun the point of your activity when you make fun the object of what
when you make fun the object of what
when you make fun the object of what you’re doing you bore yourself
you’re doing you bore yourself
you’re doing you bore yourself that’s because fun is a byproduct it’s a
that’s because fun is a byproduct it’s a
that’s because fun is a byproduct it’s a good that comes and emerges out of
good that comes and emerges out of
good that comes and emerges out of activities that have something else as
activities that have something else as
activities that have something else as their point feeling the plunge of the
their point feeling the plunge of the
their point feeling the plunge of the roller coaster telling the story dancing
roller coaster telling the story dancing
roller coaster telling the story dancing to the song listening to the music if
to the song listening to the music if
to the song listening to the music if you want another example consider
you want another example consider
you want another example consider something else that seems to be going on
something else that seems to be going on
something else that seems to be going on in this picture friendship it’s good to
in this picture friendship it’s good to
in this picture friendship it’s good to have friends
have friends
have friends we need friends however again
we need friends however again
we need friends however again the surest way to fail at friendship is
the surest way to fail at friendship is
the surest way to fail at friendship is to make friendship the point of all of
to make friendship the point of all of
to make friendship the point of all of your interpersonal interactions when you
your interpersonal interactions when you
your interpersonal interactions when you set out in engaging with others to make
set out in engaging with others to make
set out in engaging with others to make friends when that becomes the point of
friends when that becomes the point of
friends when that becomes the point of what you do with others all the time you
what you do with others all the time you
what you do with others all the time you wind up alienating people you seem
wind up alienating people you seem
wind up alienating people you seem creepy to them you try too hard and you
creepy to them you try too hard and you
creepy to them you try too hard and you wind up alone now I want to suggest that
wind up alone now I want to suggest that
wind up alone now I want to suggest that democracy has a similar structure that
democracy has a similar structure that
democracy has a similar structure that doesn’t want to suggest to you that
doesn’t want to suggest to you that
doesn’t want to suggest to you that democracy like fun and
democracy like fun and
democracy like fun and friendship is the kind of thing that can
friendship is the kind of thing that can
friendship is the kind of thing that can flourish only when sometimes we do
flourish only when sometimes we do
flourish only when sometimes we do things together that have no political
things together that have no political
things together that have no political dimension to them at all in a slogan
dimension to them at all in a slogan
dimension to them at all in a slogan that by now will be familiar to you in
that by now will be familiar to you in
that by now will be familiar to you in order to do democracy well we need to
order to do democracy well we need to
order to do democracy well we need to put politics in its place now putting
put politics in its place now putting
put politics in its place now putting politics in its place is very very
politics in its place is very very
politics in its place is very very difficult because after all our social
difficult because after all our social
difficult because after all our social world is saturated with calls to our
world is saturated with calls to our
world is saturated with calls to our political allegiances and loyalties and
political allegiances and loyalties and
political allegiances and loyalties and more than that in ways that are not
more than that in ways that are not
more than that in ways that are not always obvious to us our everyday
always obvious to us our everyday
always obvious to us our everyday activities for example where you buy
activities for example where you buy
activities for example where you buy your coffee the last time you went to a
your coffee the last time you went to a
your coffee the last time you went to a local park what movies you watch what
local park what movies you watch what
local park what movies you watch what radio stations you listen to how you get
radio stations you listen to how you get
radio stations you listen to how you get to work these are all features that are
to work these are all features that are
to work these are all features that are largely conditioned by your political
largely conditioned by your political
largely conditioned by your political profile and what that means is that your
profile and what that means is that your
profile and what that means is that your casual encounters with others online for
casual encounters with others online for
casual encounters with others online for example when you’re buying your coffee
example when you’re buying your coffee
example when you’re buying your coffee are increasingly likely to occur only
are increasingly likely to occur only
are increasingly likely to occur only among people who politically are just
among people who politically are just
among people who politically are just like you now there’s all kinds of
like you now there’s all kinds of
like you now there’s all kinds of reasons which I’ll go through in a
reasons which I’ll go through in a
reasons which I’ll go through in a moment to suggest that or which suggest
moment to suggest that or which suggest
moment to suggest that or which suggest that ongoing social interactions among
that ongoing social interactions among
that ongoing social interactions among like-minded people creates problems for
like-minded people creates problems for
like-minded people creates problems for democracy in order to see it though I
democracy in order to see it though I
democracy in order to see it though I want to start with something that’s kind
want to start with something that’s kind
want to start with something that’s kind of familiar to us political polarization
of familiar to us political polarization
of familiar to us political polarization it’s not hard to find people complaining
it’s not hard to find people complaining
it’s not hard to find people complaining about this on the news every night and
about this on the news every night and
about this on the news every night and it’s a familiar phenomenon it’s the
it’s a familiar phenomenon it’s the
it’s a familiar phenomenon it’s the dropping out of the middle ground
dropping out of the middle ground
dropping out of the middle ground between people it’s to oppose political
between people it’s to oppose political
between people it’s to oppose political or ideological groups that have nothing
or ideological groups that have nothing
or ideological groups that have nothing in common and so therefore are not able
in common and so therefore are not able
in common and so therefore are not able to cooperate and often not even able to
to cooperate and often not even able to
to cooperate and often not even able to productively communicate we know that
productively communicate we know that
productively communicate we know that disagreement of this kind is bad for
disagreement of this kind is bad for
disagreement of this kind is bad for democracy because it creates deadlock
democracy because it creates deadlock
democracy because it creates deadlock and we know that one of the things that
and we know that one of the things that
and we know that one of the things that democracy
democracy
democracy to do in order to be successful is do
to do in order to be successful is do
to do in order to be successful is do things get stuff done but there’s
things get stuff done but there’s
things get stuff done but there’s another phenomenon that’s also called
another phenomenon that’s also called
another phenomenon that’s also called polarization which might be not familiar
polarization which might be not familiar
polarization which might be not familiar to you
to you
to you but I think is in some ways more
but I think is in some ways more
but I think is in some ways more disconcerting this is a phenomenon that
disconcerting this is a phenomenon that
disconcerting this is a phenomenon that occurs not among two different
occurs not among two different
occurs not among two different politically opposed groups but inside
politically opposed groups but inside
politically opposed groups but inside like-minded groups that is to say if we
like-minded groups that is to say if we
like-minded groups that is to say if we think that disagreement is a problem for
think that disagreement is a problem for
think that disagreement is a problem for democracy agreement might be even worse
democracy agreement might be even worse
democracy agreement might be even worse here’s why a phenomenon called group
here’s why a phenomenon called group
here’s why a phenomenon called group polarization is the statistical
polarization is the statistical
polarization is the statistical regularity which has been found across
regularity which has been found across
regularity which has been found across groups of all kinds not just political
groups of all kinds not just political
groups of all kinds not just political groups it is the phenomenon according to
groups it is the phenomenon according to
groups it is the phenomenon according to which like-minded people when they get
which like-minded people when they get
which like-minded people when they get together to talk about the issues that
together to talk about the issues that
together to talk about the issues that they agree about in the course of their
they agree about in the course of their
they agree about in the course of their discussion each member of the group
discussion each member of the group
discussion each member of the group comes to hold a more extreme version of
comes to hold a more extreme version of
comes to hold a more extreme version of the view that he or she held before the
the view that he or she held before the
the view that he or she held before the conversation began in a nutshell group
conversation began in a nutshell group
conversation began in a nutshell group polarization is the regularity that
polarization is the regularity that
polarization is the regularity that discussion among like-minded others
discussion among like-minded others
discussion among like-minded others turns us into more extreme versions of
turns us into more extreme versions of
turns us into more extreme versions of ourselves
ourselves
ourselves now that might strike you as
now that might strike you as
now that might strike you as disconcerting because it looks like it’s
disconcerting because it looks like it’s
disconcerting because it looks like it’s well it’s often imperceptible we don’t
well it’s often imperceptible we don’t
well it’s often imperceptible we don’t see it happening to ourselves however
see it happening to ourselves however
see it happening to ourselves however what’s even more disconcerting is that
what’s even more disconcerting is that
what’s even more disconcerting is that the Group polarization phenomenon is not
the Group polarization phenomenon is not
the Group polarization phenomenon is not driven by the introduction of new
driven by the introduction of new
driven by the introduction of new reasons or evidence or arguments we
reasons or evidence or arguments we
reasons or evidence or arguments we become more extreme versions of
become more extreme versions of
become more extreme versions of ourselves simply due to social pressures
ourselves simply due to social pressures
ourselves simply due to social pressures what’s problematic about that for
what’s problematic about that for
what’s problematic about that for democracy is that Group polarization
democracy is that Group polarization
democracy is that Group polarization kicks into gear a broader dynamic as we
kicks into gear a broader dynamic as we
kicks into gear a broader dynamic as we talk to like-minded people are only two
talk to like-minded people are only two
talk to like-minded people are only two like-minded people we become more
like-minded people we become more
like-minded people we become more extreme versions of ourselves and as we
extreme versions of ourselves and as we
extreme versions of ourselves and as we become more extreme versions of
become more extreme versions of
become more extreme versions of ourselves we also come to increasingly D
ourselves we also come to increasingly D
ourselves we also come to increasingly D personalized and demonize the people
personalized and demonize the people
personalized and demonize the people with whom we disagree as we demonize and
with whom we disagree as we demonize and
with whom we disagree as we demonize and D personalize the people with whom we
D personalize the people with whom we
D personalize the people with whom we disagree moreover we become increasingly
disagree moreover we become increasingly
disagree moreover we become increasingly unable to hear new on
unable to hear new on
unable to hear new on in the other sides views that is as we
in the other sides views that is as we
in the other sides views that is as we become more extreme versions of
become more extreme versions of
become more extreme versions of ourselves we come more inclined to see
ourselves we come more inclined to see
ourselves we come more inclined to see the people with whom we disagree as the
the people with whom we disagree as the
the people with whom we disagree as the extremists and because we start seeing
extremists and because we start seeing
extremists and because we start seeing the people with whom we disagree as
the people with whom we disagree as
the people with whom we disagree as extremists we become increasingly unable
extremists we become increasingly unable
extremists we become increasingly unable to see those people as the kind of
to see those people as the kind of
to see those people as the kind of people it makes sense to even try to
people it makes sense to even try to
people it makes sense to even try to have a civil rational conversation with
have a civil rational conversation with
have a civil rational conversation with that is to say the saturation of our
that is to say the saturation of our
that is to say the saturation of our social lives with politics sets us up
social lives with politics sets us up
social lives with politics sets us up for group polarization and Group
for group polarization and Group
for group polarization and Group polarization sets us up for political
polarization sets us up for political
polarization sets us up for political polarization with a disconcerting add-on
polarization with a disconcerting add-on
polarization with a disconcerting add-on not only do we have opposed political
not only do we have opposed political
not only do we have opposed political groups that can’t talk to each other
groups that can’t talk to each other
groups that can’t talk to each other because there’s no common ground we also
because there’s no common ground we also
because there’s no common ground we also have opposed political groups that can’t
have opposed political groups that can’t
have opposed political groups that can’t talk to each other each of whom is
talk to each other each of whom is
talk to each other each of whom is convinced that the people on the other
convinced that the people on the other
convinced that the people on the other side are not worth talking to so that’s
side are not worth talking to so that’s
side are not worth talking to so that’s not only deadlock that’s a recipe for a
not only deadlock that’s a recipe for a
not only deadlock that’s a recipe for a politics based in animosity distrust and
politics based in animosity distrust and
politics based in animosity distrust and antagonism it’s a huge problem for
antagonism it’s a huge problem for
antagonism it’s a huge problem for democracy when democracy can’t get
democracy when democracy can’t get
democracy when democracy can’t get anything done and moreover is driven by
anything done and moreover is driven by
anything done and moreover is driven by distrust animosity and animosity what
distrust animosity and animosity what
distrust animosity and animosity what can be done well let’s think for a
can be done well let’s think for a
can be done well let’s think for a moment about what democracy is now we
moment about what democracy is now we
moment about what democracy is now we tend to think that democracy is simply a
tend to think that democracy is simply a
tend to think that democracy is simply a system of government where we each get a
system of government where we each get a
system of government where we each get a vote each one gets one vote and the
vote each one gets one vote and the
vote each one gets one vote and the majority rules and democracy is that but
majority rules and democracy is that but
majority rules and democracy is that but it’s more than that democracy is the
it’s more than that democracy is the
it’s more than that democracy is the ideal of self-government among political
ideal of self-government among political
ideal of self-government among political equals that is to say democracy doesn’t
equals that is to say democracy doesn’t
equals that is to say democracy doesn’t happen merely in the voting booth
happen merely in the voting booth
happen merely in the voting booth democracy happens in the moments before
democracy happens in the moments before
democracy happens in the moments before you go to cast your vote when you talk
you go to cast your vote when you talk
you go to cast your vote when you talk to other people about how you might cast
to other people about how you might cast
to other people about how you might cast your vote when you enter into
your vote when you enter into
your vote when you enter into conversations with them about the
conversations with them about the
conversations with them about the political structure of the will of the
political structure of the will of the
political structure of the will of the the country at the moment democracy
the country at the moment democracy
the country at the moment democracy exists in conversations and
exists in conversations and
exists in conversations and disagreements and arguments with your
disagreements and arguments with your
disagreements and arguments with your fellow citizens about the structure of
fellow citizens about the structure of
fellow citizens about the structure of our shared political
our shared political
our shared political world now what that means is that if
world now what that means is that if
world now what that means is that if we’re going to see democracy as this
we’re going to see democracy as this
we’re going to see democracy as this ideal of self-government among equals
ideal of self-government among equals
ideal of self-government among equals there’s going to be disagreement and
there’s going to be disagreement and
there’s going to be disagreement and where there’s disagreement there’s the
where there’s disagreement there’s the
where there’s disagreement there’s the challenge of disagreeing respectfully
challenge of disagreeing respectfully
challenge of disagreeing respectfully and civilly the Group polarization
and civilly the Group polarization
and civilly the Group polarization phenomenon erodes that ability the
phenomenon erodes that ability the
phenomenon erodes that ability the ability to disagree civilly and
ability to disagree civilly and
ability to disagree civilly and respectfully together
respectfully together
respectfully together how can it be built well I want to
how can it be built well I want to
how can it be built well I want to suggest that democracy understood is
suggest that democracy understood is
suggest that democracy understood is this ideal of self-government among
this ideal of self-government among
this ideal of self-government among equals requires in us not merely to
equals requires in us not merely to
equals requires in us not merely to inform ourselves about the issues to
inform ourselves about the issues to
inform ourselves about the issues to think hard about the political questions
think hard about the political questions
think hard about the political questions of the day but also to cultivate within
of the day but also to cultivate within
of the day but also to cultivate within ourselves a series of skills and
ourselves a series of skills and
ourselves a series of skills and dispositions and habits that will enable
dispositions and habits that will enable
dispositions and habits that will enable us to regard even those with whom we
us to regard even those with whom we
us to regard even those with whom we disagree about the most important things
disagree about the most important things
disagree about the most important things to regard those people nonetheless as
to regard those people nonetheless as
to regard those people nonetheless as our fellow citizens as equal sharers in
our fellow citizens as equal sharers in
our fellow citizens as equal sharers in political power I want to call this set
political power I want to call this set
political power I want to call this set of dispositions and skills civic
of dispositions and skills civic
of dispositions and skills civic friendship civic friendship is different
friendship civic friendship is different
friendship civic friendship is different from ordinary friendship in many
from ordinary friendship in many
from ordinary friendship in many respects but I think it has a similar
respects but I think it has a similar
respects but I think it has a similar structure to ordinary friendship that is
structure to ordinary friendship that is
structure to ordinary friendship that is I want to suggest to you that civic
I want to suggest to you that civic
I want to suggest to you that civic friendship is is the kind of relation
friendship is is the kind of relation
friendship is is the kind of relation that is smothered when all we do
that is smothered when all we do
that is smothered when all we do together is civics civic friendship is
together is civics civic friendship is
together is civics civic friendship is the kind of thing that’s derailed when
the kind of thing that’s derailed when
the kind of thing that’s derailed when every social interaction is tinged with
every social interaction is tinged with
every social interaction is tinged with or aimed at the pad something political
or aimed at the pad something political
or aimed at the pad something political if we want the cultivate civic
if we want the cultivate civic
if we want the cultivate civic friendship that is we have to cultivate
friendship that is we have to cultivate
friendship that is we have to cultivate within ourselves or we have to engage
within ourselves or we have to engage
within ourselves or we have to engage with others in activities that have some
with others in activities that have some
with others in activities that have some other point than self-government now you
other point than self-government now you
other point than self-government now you might think that it’s difficult to
might think that it’s difficult to
might think that it’s difficult to cultivate civic friendship and you’re
cultivate civic friendship and you’re
cultivate civic friendship and you’re right because go back to a couple of
right because go back to a couple of
right because go back to a couple of slides ago our worlds are already
slides ago our worlds are already
slides ago our worlds are already structured by our political allegiances
structured by our political allegiances
structured by our political allegiances how can we find some things to do
how can we find some things to do
how can we find some things to do together that don’t already have
together that don’t already have
together that don’t already have politics as a pollutant with
politics as a pollutant with
politics as a pollutant with in them well it’s a big problem
in them well it’s a big problem
in them well it’s a big problem sometimes big problems call for big
sometimes big problems call for big
sometimes big problems call for big solutions but not always sometimes the
solutions but not always sometimes the
solutions but not always sometimes the right approach to take when you’re
right approach to take when you’re
right approach to take when you’re confronting a big problem is to start
confronting a big problem is to start
confronting a big problem is to start with something small let’s go back to
with something small let’s go back to
with something small let’s go back to Thanksgiving dinner around the country
Thanksgiving dinner around the country
Thanksgiving dinner around the country Thanksgiving dinners are governed by a
Thanksgiving dinners are governed by a
Thanksgiving dinners are governed by a rule of etiquette that I’ll call mom’s
rule of etiquette that I’ll call mom’s
rule of etiquette that I’ll call mom’s Maxim don’t argue politics at the dinner
Maxim don’t argue politics at the dinner
Maxim don’t argue politics at the dinner table it’s a good rule it tells us
table it’s a good rule it tells us
table it’s a good rule it tells us suppress political differences so that
suppress political differences so that
suppress political differences so that you can make it through a holiday dinner
you can make it through a holiday dinner
you can make it through a holiday dinner here’s a slightly different conception
here’s a slightly different conception
here’s a slightly different conception though and note been thinking small what
though and note been thinking small what
though and note been thinking small what I’m suggesting is not that we do
I’m suggesting is not that we do
I’m suggesting is not that we do something different but that we think
something different but that we think
something different but that we think about what we’re doing in a slightly
about what we’re doing in a slightly
about what we’re doing in a slightly different way here’s an alternative
different way here’s an alternative
different way here’s an alternative Maxim and you won’t find this in any of
Maxim and you won’t find this in any of
Maxim and you won’t find this in any of the 21 million Google hits something is
the 21 million Google hits something is
the 21 million Google hits something is more important than politics like family
more important than politics like family
more important than politics like family dinner know that elicits from us the
dinner know that elicits from us the
dinner know that elicits from us the same kind of behavior as mom’s Maxim but
same kind of behavior as mom’s Maxim but
same kind of behavior as mom’s Maxim but it’s a value judgment it doesn’t tell us
it’s a value judgment it doesn’t tell us
it’s a value judgment it doesn’t tell us to suppress our political differences it
to suppress our political differences it
to suppress our political differences it tells us to rise above them and that’s
tells us to rise above them and that’s
tells us to rise above them and that’s an important difference even if the
an important difference even if the
an important difference even if the behavior might be the same now the very
behavior might be the same now the very
behavior might be the same now the very thought that there could be something
thought that there could be something
thought that there could be something more important than politics is oddly
more important than politics is oddly
more important than politics is oddly foreign to us but ask yourself what is
foreign to us but ask yourself what is
foreign to us but ask yourself what is politics for because if politics is for
politics for because if politics is for
politics for because if politics is for something the idea that something is
something the idea that something is
something the idea that something is more important than politics shouldn’t
more important than politics shouldn’t
more important than politics shouldn’t be so far in that’s what politics is for
be so far in that’s what politics is for
be so far in that’s what politics is for valuable human relationships caring
valuable human relationships caring
valuable human relationships caring relationships loving relationships
relationships loving relationships
relationships loving relationships neighborly relationships relationships
neighborly relationships relationships
neighborly relationships relationships of friendship support vulnerability
of friendship support vulnerability
of friendship support vulnerability dependency solidarity we’re interested
dependency solidarity we’re interested
dependency solidarity we’re interested in getting politics right because we’re
in getting politics right because we’re
in getting politics right because we’re interested in what’s going on in this
interested in what’s going on in this
interested in what’s going on in this picture people living lives of value
picture people living lives of value
picture people living lives of value together devoted to aims
together devoted to aims
together devoted to aims spiration x’ and projects that are not
spiration x’ and projects that are not
spiration x’ and projects that are not about politics but are about other
about politics but are about other
about politics but are about other things living well together if we can’t
things living well together if we can’t
things living well together if we can’t get politics right we lose this and the
get politics right we lose this and the
get politics right we lose this and the idea that politics is all that matters
idea that politics is all that matters
idea that politics is all that matters or is always the most important thing is
or is always the most important thing is
or is always the most important thing is destroying what’s in this picture that’s
destroying what’s in this picture that’s
destroying what’s in this picture that’s why we have to put politics in its place
why we have to put politics in its place
why we have to put politics in its place because politics has a place it serves
because politics has a place it serves
because politics has a place it serves other human goods take away
other human goods take away
other human goods take away I have not denied that democracy
I have not denied that democracy
I have not denied that democracy democratic politics are really important
democratic politics are really important
democratic politics are really important that hasn’t been my message
that hasn’t been my message
that hasn’t been my message I haven’t said get out of politics
I haven’t said get out of politics
I haven’t said get out of politics forget about it it’s a waste of your
forget about it it’s a waste of your
forget about it it’s a waste of your time
time
time democracy is important justice is
democracy is important justice is
democracy is important justice is important equality and freedom and
important equality and freedom and
important equality and freedom and autonomy these are all important things
autonomy these are all important things
autonomy these are all important things I haven’t been denying that what I’ve
I haven’t been denying that what I’ve
I haven’t been denying that what I’ve been trying to convince you of is that
been trying to convince you of is that
been trying to convince you of is that democracy makes it possible for us to
democracy makes it possible for us to
democracy makes it possible for us to live together well and that’s what
live together well and that’s what
live together well and that’s what explains its importance
explains its importance
explains its importance then I’ve tried to convince you that in
then I’ve tried to convince you that in
then I’ve tried to convince you that in order to do democracy well we have to
order to do democracy well we have to
order to do democracy well we have to sometimes do things together that aren’t
sometimes do things together that aren’t
sometimes do things together that aren’t about democracy now what those things
about democracy now what those things
about democracy now what those things are is hard to have hard to get our mind
are is hard to have hard to get our mind
are is hard to have hard to get our mind around I’ve suggested starting something
around I’ve suggested starting something
around I’ve suggested starting something starting very small with a reminder to
starting very small with a reminder to
starting very small with a reminder to yourself with an affirmation to yourself
yourself with an affirmation to yourself
yourself with an affirmation to yourself and then ultimately to with an
and then ultimately to with an
and then ultimately to with an affirmation to your friends and family
affirmation to your friends and family
affirmation to your friends and family say to yourself now before we get
say to yourself now before we get
say to yourself now before we get embroiled in another contentious
embroiled in another contentious
embroiled in another contentious political season before we have to start
political season before we have to start
political season before we have to start arguing with each other over
arguing with each other over
arguing with each other over Thanksgiving about who to vote for for
Thanksgiving about who to vote for for
Thanksgiving about who to vote for for president do it now say to yourself and
president do it now say to yourself and
president do it now say to yourself and to your loved ones family and friends
to your loved ones family and friends
to your loved ones family and friends are more important than what politically
are more important than what politically
are more important than what politically divides us
divides us
divides us the end of the day if you do that I
the end of the day if you do that I
the end of the day if you do that I think that’s all that there’s left to do
think that’s all that there’s left to do
think that’s all that there’s left to do is to hope for the best thank you
is to hope for the best thank you
is to hope for the best thank you [Applause]
[Music] [Applause]
[Music]
[Music] so in November 2016 I was having lunch
so in November 2016 I was having lunch
so in November 2016 I was having lunch with a friend who was dreading
with a friend who was dreading
with a friend who was dreading Thanksgiving the country had just
Thanksgiving the country had just
Thanksgiving the country had just elected a new president and she was
elected a new president and she was
elected a new president and she was concerned that the holiday dinner was
concerned that the holiday dinner was
concerned that the holiday dinner was going to erupt into a political war zone
going to erupt into a political war zone
going to erupt into a political war zone she told me about an article that she
she told me about an article that she
she told me about an article that she had read in The Washington Post I
had read in The Washington Post I
had read in The Washington Post I believe that had a title like surviving
believe that had a title like surviving
believe that had a title like surviving Thanksgiving when you can’t stand how
Thanksgiving when you can’t stand how
Thanksgiving when you can’t stand how your family voted later that day I went
your family voted later that day I went
your family voted later that day I went and looked it up on Google and I found
and looked it up on Google and I found
and looked it up on Google and I found it but I was surprised to find also that
it but I was surprised to find also that
it but I was surprised to find also that an entire genre had emerged on this
an entire genre had emerged on this
an entire genre had emerged on this theme of surviving Thanksgiving dinner a
theme of surviving Thanksgiving dinner a
theme of surviving Thanksgiving dinner a missed political disagreement in the
missed political disagreement in the
missed political disagreement in the intervening year the genre has exploded
intervening year the genre has exploded
intervening year the genre has exploded that’s 21 million hits on Google for
that’s 21 million hits on Google for
that’s 21 million hits on Google for surviving Thanksgiving politics now many
surviving Thanksgiving politics now many
surviving Thanksgiving politics now many of these articles offer pretty solid
of these articles offer pretty solid
of these articles offer pretty solid advice remain calm don’t call names try
advice remain calm don’t call names try
advice remain calm don’t call names try to understand the other person’s
to understand the other person’s
to understand the other person’s perspective however a good portion of
perspective however a good portion of
perspective however a good portion of them close with the following message
them close with the following message
them close with the following message hey sometimes it’s just too hard
hey sometimes it’s just too hard
hey sometimes it’s just too hard sometimes it’s not even worth the
sometimes it’s not even worth the
sometimes it’s not even worth the attempt to get along with your family
attempt to get along with your family
attempt to get along with your family and in those cases stay home
and in those cases stay home
and in those cases stay home skip Thanksgiving so what to make of
skip Thanksgiving so what to make of
skip Thanksgiving so what to make of this
this
this now I’m a political philosopher and my
now I’m a political philosopher and my
now I’m a political philosopher and my work focuses mainly on moral and
work focuses mainly on moral and
work focuses mainly on moral and political disagreement and the role of
political disagreement and the role of
political disagreement and the role of disagreement in democratic society you
disagreement in democratic society you
disagreement in democratic society you can judge those books by their covers
can judge those books by their covers
can judge those books by their covers and in this work I’ve taken a view that
and in this work I’ve taken a view that
and in this work I’ve taken a view that is pretty popular among political
is pretty popular among political
is pretty popular among political philosophers and that view is that
philosophers and that view is that
philosophers and that view is that democracy is a 24/7 job the way to do
democracy is a 24/7 job the way to do
democracy is a 24/7 job the way to do democracy well is to do it perpetually
democracy well is to do it perpetually
democracy well is to do it perpetually and if we find that democracy has any
and if we find that democracy has any
and if we find that democracy has any troubles or problems there’s always the
troubles or problems there’s always the
troubles or problems there’s always the solution of more democracy I’ve since
solution of more democracy I’ve since
solution of more democracy I’ve since changed my mind about that and I want to
changed my mind about that and I want to
changed my mind about that and I want to talk to you a little bit today about why
talk to you a little bit today about why
talk to you a little bit today about why my mind has changed and how my view now
my mind has changed and how my view now
my mind has changed and how my view now is that there are some problems that
is that there are some problems that
is that there are some problems that democracy faces where the solution is
democracy faces where the solution is
democracy faces where the solution is not to do more democracy but in fact
not to do more democracy but in fact
not to do more democracy but in fact sometimes we need to do less democracy
sometimes we need to do less democracy
sometimes we need to do less democracy now that might sound heretical to you so
now that might sound heretical to you so
now that might sound heretical to you so let me explain what I mean there are
let me explain what I mean there are
let me explain what I mean there are some goods that can be realized only
some goods that can be realized only
some goods that can be realized only when we pursue something else if you
when we pursue something else if you
when we pursue something else if you want a simple example consider fun it’s
want a simple example consider fun it’s
want a simple example consider fun it’s good to have fun right however the
good to have fun right however the
good to have fun right however the surest way to fail at fun is to make
surest way to fail at fun is to make
surest way to fail at fun is to make having fun the point of your activity
having fun the point of your activity
having fun the point of your activity when you make fun the object of what
when you make fun the object of what
when you make fun the object of what you’re doing you bore yourself
you’re doing you bore yourself
you’re doing you bore yourself that’s because fun is a byproduct it’s a
that’s because fun is a byproduct it’s a
that’s because fun is a byproduct it’s a good that comes and emerges out of
good that comes and emerges out of
good that comes and emerges out of activities that have something else as
activities that have something else as
activities that have something else as their point feeling the plunge of the
their point feeling the plunge of the
their point feeling the plunge of the roller coaster telling the story dancing
roller coaster telling the story dancing
roller coaster telling the story dancing to the song listening to the music if
to the song listening to the music if
to the song listening to the music if you want another example consider
you want another example consider
you want another example consider something else that seems to be going on
something else that seems to be going on
something else that seems to be going on in this picture friendship it’s good to
in this picture friendship it’s good to
in this picture friendship it’s good to have friends
have friends
have friends we need friends however again
we need friends however again
we need friends however again the surest way to fail at friendship is
the surest way to fail at friendship is
the surest way to fail at friendship is to make friendship the point of all of
to make friendship the point of all of
to make friendship the point of all of your interpersonal interactions when you
your interpersonal interactions when you
your interpersonal interactions when you set out in engaging with others to make
set out in engaging with others to make
set out in engaging with others to make friends when that becomes the point of
friends when that becomes the point of
friends when that becomes the point of what you do with others all the time you
what you do with others all the time you
what you do with others all the time you wind up alienating people you seem
wind up alienating people you seem
wind up alienating people you seem creepy to them you try too hard and you
creepy to them you try too hard and you
creepy to them you try too hard and you wind up alone now I want to suggest that
wind up alone now I want to suggest that
wind up alone now I want to suggest that democracy has a similar structure that
democracy has a similar structure that
democracy has a similar structure that doesn’t want to suggest to you that
doesn’t want to suggest to you that
doesn’t want to suggest to you that democracy like fun and
democracy like fun and
democracy like fun and friendship is the kind of thing that can
friendship is the kind of thing that can
friendship is the kind of thing that can flourish only when sometimes we do
flourish only when sometimes we do
flourish only when sometimes we do things together that have no political
things together that have no political
things together that have no political dimension to them at all in a slogan
dimension to them at all in a slogan
dimension to them at all in a slogan that by now will be familiar to you in
that by now will be familiar to you in
that by now will be familiar to you in order to do democracy well we need to
order to do democracy well we need to
order to do democracy well we need to put politics in its place now putting
put politics in its place now putting
put politics in its place now putting politics in its place is very very
politics in its place is very very
politics in its place is very very difficult because after all our social
difficult because after all our social
difficult because after all our social world is saturated with calls to our
world is saturated with calls to our
world is saturated with calls to our political allegiances and loyalties and
political allegiances and loyalties and
political allegiances and loyalties and more than that in ways that are not
more than that in ways that are not
more than that in ways that are not always obvious to us our everyday
always obvious to us our everyday
always obvious to us our everyday activities for example where you buy
activities for example where you buy
activities for example where you buy your coffee the last time you went to a
your coffee the last time you went to a
your coffee the last time you went to a local park what movies you watch what
local park what movies you watch what
local park what movies you watch what radio stations you listen to how you get
radio stations you listen to how you get
radio stations you listen to how you get to work these are all features that are
to work these are all features that are
to work these are all features that are largely conditioned by your political
largely conditioned by your political
largely conditioned by your political profile and what that means is that your
profile and what that means is that your
profile and what that means is that your casual encounters with others online for
casual encounters with others online for
casual encounters with others online for example when you’re buying your coffee
example when you’re buying your coffee
example when you’re buying your coffee are increasingly likely to occur only
are increasingly likely to occur only
are increasingly likely to occur only among people who politically are just
among people who politically are just
among people who politically are just like you now there’s all kinds of
like you now there’s all kinds of
like you now there’s all kinds of reasons which I’ll go through in a
reasons which I’ll go through in a
reasons which I’ll go through in a moment to suggest that or which suggest
moment to suggest that or which suggest
moment to suggest that or which suggest that ongoing social interactions among
that ongoing social interactions among
that ongoing social interactions among like-minded people creates problems for
like-minded people creates problems for
like-minded people creates problems for democracy in order to see it though I
democracy in order to see it though I
democracy in order to see it though I want to start with something that’s kind
want to start with something that’s kind
want to start with something that’s kind of familiar to us political polarization
of familiar to us political polarization
of familiar to us political polarization it’s not hard to find people complaining
it’s not hard to find people complaining
it’s not hard to find people complaining about this on the news every night and
about this on the news every night and
about this on the news every night and it’s a familiar phenomenon it’s the
it’s a familiar phenomenon it’s the
it’s a familiar phenomenon it’s the dropping out of the middle ground
dropping out of the middle ground
dropping out of the middle ground between people it’s to oppose political
between people it’s to oppose political
between people it’s to oppose political or ideological groups that have nothing
or ideological groups that have nothing
or ideological groups that have nothing in common and so therefore are not able
in common and so therefore are not able
in common and so therefore are not able to cooperate and often not even able to
to cooperate and often not even able to
to cooperate and often not even able to productively communicate we know that
productively communicate we know that
productively communicate we know that disagreement of this kind is bad for
disagreement of this kind is bad for
disagreement of this kind is bad for democracy because it creates deadlock
democracy because it creates deadlock
democracy because it creates deadlock and we know that one of the things that
and we know that one of the things that
and we know that one of the things that democracy
democracy
democracy to do in order to be successful is do
to do in order to be successful is do
to do in order to be successful is do things get stuff done but there’s
things get stuff done but there’s
things get stuff done but there’s another phenomenon that’s also called
another phenomenon that’s also called
another phenomenon that’s also called polarization which might be not familiar
polarization which might be not familiar
polarization which might be not familiar to you
to you
to you but I think is in some ways more
but I think is in some ways more
but I think is in some ways more disconcerting this is a phenomenon that
disconcerting this is a phenomenon that
disconcerting this is a phenomenon that occurs not among two different
occurs not among two different
occurs not among two different politically opposed groups but inside
politically opposed groups but inside
politically opposed groups but inside like-minded groups that is to say if we
like-minded groups that is to say if we
like-minded groups that is to say if we think that disagreement is a problem for
think that disagreement is a problem for
think that disagreement is a problem for democracy agreement might be even worse
democracy agreement might be even worse
democracy agreement might be even worse here’s why a phenomenon called group
here’s why a phenomenon called group
here’s why a phenomenon called group polarization is the statistical
polarization is the statistical
polarization is the statistical regularity which has been found across
regularity which has been found across
regularity which has been found across groups of all kinds not just political
groups of all kinds not just political
groups of all kinds not just political groups it is the phenomenon according to
groups it is the phenomenon according to
groups it is the phenomenon according to which like-minded people when they get
which like-minded people when they get
which like-minded people when they get together to talk about the issues that
together to talk about the issues that
together to talk about the issues that they agree about in the course of their
they agree about in the course of their
they agree about in the course of their discussion each member of the group
discussion each member of the group
discussion each member of the group comes to hold a more extreme version of
comes to hold a more extreme version of
comes to hold a more extreme version of the view that he or she held before the
the view that he or she held before the
the view that he or she held before the conversation began in a nutshell group
conversation began in a nutshell group
conversation began in a nutshell group polarization is the regularity that
polarization is the regularity that
polarization is the regularity that discussion among like-minded others
discussion among like-minded others
discussion among like-minded others turns us into more extreme versions of
turns us into more extreme versions of
turns us into more extreme versions of ourselves
ourselves
ourselves now that might strike you as
now that might strike you as
now that might strike you as disconcerting because it looks like it’s
disconcerting because it looks like it’s
disconcerting because it looks like it’s well it’s often imperceptible we don’t
well it’s often imperceptible we don’t
well it’s often imperceptible we don’t see it happening to ourselves however
see it happening to ourselves however
see it happening to ourselves however what’s even more disconcerting is that
what’s even more disconcerting is that
what’s even more disconcerting is that the Group polarization phenomenon is not
the Group polarization phenomenon is not
the Group polarization phenomenon is not driven by the introduction of new
driven by the introduction of new
driven by the introduction of new reasons or evidence or arguments we
reasons or evidence or arguments we
reasons or evidence or arguments we become more extreme versions of
become more extreme versions of
become more extreme versions of ourselves simply due to social pressures
ourselves simply due to social pressures
ourselves simply due to social pressures what’s problematic about that for
what’s problematic about that for
what’s problematic about that for democracy is that Group polarization
democracy is that Group polarization
democracy is that Group polarization kicks into gear a broader dynamic as we
kicks into gear a broader dynamic as we
kicks into gear a broader dynamic as we talk to like-minded people are only two
talk to like-minded people are only two
talk to like-minded people are only two like-minded people we become more
like-minded people we become more
like-minded people we become more extreme versions of ourselves and as we
extreme versions of ourselves and as we
extreme versions of ourselves and as we become more extreme versions of
become more extreme versions of
become more extreme versions of ourselves we also come to increasingly D
ourselves we also come to increasingly D
ourselves we also come to increasingly D personalized and demonize the people
personalized and demonize the people
personalized and demonize the people with whom we disagree as we demonize and
with whom we disagree as we demonize and
with whom we disagree as we demonize and D personalize the people with whom we
D personalize the people with whom we
D personalize the people with whom we disagree moreover we become increasingly
disagree moreover we become increasingly
disagree moreover we become increasingly unable to hear new on
unable to hear new on
unable to hear new on in the other sides views that is as we
in the other sides views that is as we
in the other sides views that is as we become more extreme versions of
become more extreme versions of
become more extreme versions of ourselves we come more inclined to see
ourselves we come more inclined to see
ourselves we come more inclined to see the people with whom we disagree as the
the people with whom we disagree as the
the people with whom we disagree as the extremists and because we start seeing
extremists and because we start seeing
extremists and because we start seeing the people with whom we disagree as
the people with whom we disagree as
the people with whom we disagree as extremists we become increasingly unable
extremists we become increasingly unable
extremists we become increasingly unable to see those people as the kind of
to see those people as the kind of
to see those people as the kind of people it makes sense to even try to
people it makes sense to even try to
people it makes sense to even try to have a civil rational conversation with
have a civil rational conversation with
have a civil rational conversation with that is to say the saturation of our
that is to say the saturation of our
that is to say the saturation of our social lives with politics sets us up
social lives with politics sets us up
social lives with politics sets us up for group polarization and Group
for group polarization and Group
for group polarization and Group polarization sets us up for political
polarization sets us up for political
polarization sets us up for political polarization with a disconcerting add-on
polarization with a disconcerting add-on
polarization with a disconcerting add-on not only do we have opposed political
not only do we have opposed political
not only do we have opposed political groups that can’t talk to each other
groups that can’t talk to each other
groups that can’t talk to each other because there’s no common ground we also
because there’s no common ground we also
because there’s no common ground we also have opposed political groups that can’t
have opposed political groups that can’t
have opposed political groups that can’t talk to each other each of whom is
talk to each other each of whom is
talk to each other each of whom is convinced that the people on the other
convinced that the people on the other
convinced that the people on the other side are not worth talking to so that’s
side are not worth talking to so that’s
side are not worth talking to so that’s not only deadlock that’s a recipe for a
not only deadlock that’s a recipe for a
not only deadlock that’s a recipe for a politics based in animosity distrust and
politics based in animosity distrust and
politics based in animosity distrust and antagonism it’s a huge problem for
antagonism it’s a huge problem for
antagonism it’s a huge problem for democracy when democracy can’t get
democracy when democracy can’t get
democracy when democracy can’t get anything done and moreover is driven by
anything done and moreover is driven by
anything done and moreover is driven by distrust animosity and animosity what
distrust animosity and animosity what
distrust animosity and animosity what can be done well let’s think for a
can be done well let’s think for a
can be done well let’s think for a moment about what democracy is now we
moment about what democracy is now we
moment about what democracy is now we tend to think that democracy is simply a
tend to think that democracy is simply a
tend to think that democracy is simply a system of government where we each get a
system of government where we each get a
system of government where we each get a vote each one gets one vote and the
vote each one gets one vote and the
vote each one gets one vote and the majority rules and democracy is that but
majority rules and democracy is that but
majority rules and democracy is that but it’s more than that democracy is the
it’s more than that democracy is the
it’s more than that democracy is the ideal of self-government among political
ideal of self-government among political
ideal of self-government among political equals that is to say democracy doesn’t
equals that is to say democracy doesn’t
equals that is to say democracy doesn’t happen merely in the voting booth
happen merely in the voting booth
happen merely in the voting booth democracy happens in the moments before
democracy happens in the moments before
democracy happens in the moments before you go to cast your vote when you talk
you go to cast your vote when you talk
you go to cast your vote when you talk to other people about how you might cast
to other people about how you might cast
to other people about how you might cast your vote when you enter into
your vote when you enter into
your vote when you enter into conversations with them about the
conversations with them about the
conversations with them about the political structure of the will of the
political structure of the will of the
political structure of the will of the the country at the moment democracy
the country at the moment democracy
the country at the moment democracy exists in conversations and
exists in conversations and
exists in conversations and disagreements and arguments with your
disagreements and arguments with your
disagreements and arguments with your fellow citizens about the structure of
fellow citizens about the structure of
fellow citizens about the structure of our shared political
our shared political
our shared political world now what that means is that if
world now what that means is that if
world now what that means is that if we’re going to see democracy as this
we’re going to see democracy as this
we’re going to see democracy as this ideal of self-government among equals
ideal of self-government among equals
ideal of self-government among equals there’s going to be disagreement and
there’s going to be disagreement and
there’s going to be disagreement and where there’s disagreement there’s the
where there’s disagreement there’s the
where there’s disagreement there’s the challenge of disagreeing respectfully
challenge of disagreeing respectfully
challenge of disagreeing respectfully and civilly the Group polarization
and civilly the Group polarization
and civilly the Group polarization phenomenon erodes that ability the
phenomenon erodes that ability the
phenomenon erodes that ability the ability to disagree civilly and
ability to disagree civilly and
ability to disagree civilly and respectfully together
respectfully together
respectfully together how can it be built well I want to
how can it be built well I want to
how can it be built well I want to suggest that democracy understood is
suggest that democracy understood is
suggest that democracy understood is this ideal of self-government among
this ideal of self-government among
this ideal of self-government among equals requires in us not merely to
equals requires in us not merely to
equals requires in us not merely to inform ourselves about the issues to
inform ourselves about the issues to
inform ourselves about the issues to think hard about the political questions
think hard about the political questions
think hard about the political questions of the day but also to cultivate within
of the day but also to cultivate within
of the day but also to cultivate within ourselves a series of skills and
ourselves a series of skills and
ourselves a series of skills and dispositions and habits that will enable
dispositions and habits that will enable
dispositions and habits that will enable us to regard even those with whom we
us to regard even those with whom we
us to regard even those with whom we disagree about the most important things
disagree about the most important things
disagree about the most important things to regard those people nonetheless as
to regard those people nonetheless as
to regard those people nonetheless as our fellow citizens as equal sharers in
our fellow citizens as equal sharers in
our fellow citizens as equal sharers in political power I want to call this set
political power I want to call this set
political power I want to call this set of dispositions and skills civic
of dispositions and skills civic
of dispositions and skills civic friendship civic friendship is different
friendship civic friendship is different
friendship civic friendship is different from ordinary friendship in many
from ordinary friendship in many
from ordinary friendship in many respects but I think it has a similar
respects but I think it has a similar
respects but I think it has a similar structure to ordinary friendship that is
structure to ordinary friendship that is
structure to ordinary friendship that is I want to suggest to you that civic
I want to suggest to you that civic
I want to suggest to you that civic friendship is is the kind of relation
friendship is is the kind of relation
friendship is is the kind of relation that is smothered when all we do
that is smothered when all we do
that is smothered when all we do together is civics civic friendship is
together is civics civic friendship is
together is civics civic friendship is the kind of thing that’s derailed when
the kind of thing that’s derailed when
the kind of thing that’s derailed when every social interaction is tinged with
every social interaction is tinged with
every social interaction is tinged with or aimed at the pad something political
or aimed at the pad something political
or aimed at the pad something political if we want the cultivate civic
if we want the cultivate civic
if we want the cultivate civic friendship that is we have to cultivate
friendship that is we have to cultivate
friendship that is we have to cultivate within ourselves or we have to engage
within ourselves or we have to engage
within ourselves or we have to engage with others in activities that have some
with others in activities that have some
with others in activities that have some other point than self-government now you
other point than self-government now you
other point than self-government now you might think that it’s difficult to
might think that it’s difficult to
might think that it’s difficult to cultivate civic friendship and you’re
cultivate civic friendship and you’re
cultivate civic friendship and you’re right because go back to a couple of
right because go back to a couple of
right because go back to a couple of slides ago our worlds are already
slides ago our worlds are already
slides ago our worlds are already structured by our political allegiances
structured by our political allegiances
structured by our political allegiances how can we find some things to do
how can we find some things to do
how can we find some things to do together that don’t already have
together that don’t already have
together that don’t already have politics as a pollutant with
politics as a pollutant with
politics as a pollutant with in them well it’s a big problem
in them well it’s a big problem
in them well it’s a big problem sometimes big problems call for big
sometimes big problems call for big
sometimes big problems call for big solutions but not always sometimes the
solutions but not always sometimes the
solutions but not always sometimes the right approach to take when you’re
right approach to take when you’re
right approach to take when you’re confronting a big problem is to start
confronting a big problem is to start
confronting a big problem is to start with something small let’s go back to
with something small let’s go back to
with something small let’s go back to Thanksgiving dinner around the country
Thanksgiving dinner around the country
Thanksgiving dinner around the country Thanksgiving dinners are governed by a
Thanksgiving dinners are governed by a
Thanksgiving dinners are governed by a rule of etiquette that I’ll call mom’s
rule of etiquette that I’ll call mom’s
rule of etiquette that I’ll call mom’s Maxim don’t argue politics at the dinner
Maxim don’t argue politics at the dinner
Maxim don’t argue politics at the dinner table it’s a good rule it tells us
table it’s a good rule it tells us
table it’s a good rule it tells us suppress political differences so that
suppress political differences so that
suppress political differences so that you can make it through a holiday dinner
you can make it through a holiday dinner
you can make it through a holiday dinner here’s a slightly different conception
here’s a slightly different conception
here’s a slightly different conception though and note been thinking small what
though and note been thinking small what
though and note been thinking small what I’m suggesting is not that we do
I’m suggesting is not that we do
I’m suggesting is not that we do something different but that we think
something different but that we think
something different but that we think about what we’re doing in a slightly
about what we’re doing in a slightly
about what we’re doing in a slightly different way here’s an alternative
different way here’s an alternative
different way here’s an alternative Maxim and you won’t find this in any of
Maxim and you won’t find this in any of
Maxim and you won’t find this in any of the 21 million Google hits something is
the 21 million Google hits something is
the 21 million Google hits something is more important than politics like family
more important than politics like family
more important than politics like family dinner know that elicits from us the
dinner know that elicits from us the
dinner know that elicits from us the same kind of behavior as mom’s Maxim but
same kind of behavior as mom’s Maxim but
same kind of behavior as mom’s Maxim but it’s a value judgment it doesn’t tell us
it’s a value judgment it doesn’t tell us
it’s a value judgment it doesn’t tell us to suppress our political differences it
to suppress our political differences it
to suppress our political differences it tells us to rise above them and that’s
tells us to rise above them and that’s
tells us to rise above them and that’s an important difference even if the
an important difference even if the
an important difference even if the behavior might be the same now the very
behavior might be the same now the very
behavior might be the same now the very thought that there could be something
thought that there could be something
thought that there could be something more important than politics is oddly
more important than politics is oddly
more important than politics is oddly foreign to us but ask yourself what is
foreign to us but ask yourself what is
foreign to us but ask yourself what is politics for because if politics is for
politics for because if politics is for
politics for because if politics is for something the idea that something is
something the idea that something is
something the idea that something is more important than politics shouldn’t
more important than politics shouldn’t
more important than politics shouldn’t be so far in that’s what politics is for
be so far in that’s what politics is for
be so far in that’s what politics is for valuable human relationships caring
valuable human relationships caring
valuable human relationships caring relationships loving relationships
relationships loving relationships
relationships loving relationships neighborly relationships relationships
neighborly relationships relationships
neighborly relationships relationships of friendship support vulnerability
of friendship support vulnerability
of friendship support vulnerability dependency solidarity we’re interested
dependency solidarity we’re interested
dependency solidarity we’re interested in getting politics right because we’re
in getting politics right because we’re
in getting politics right because we’re interested in what’s going on in this
interested in what’s going on in this
interested in what’s going on in this picture people living lives of value
picture people living lives of value
picture people living lives of value together devoted to aims
together devoted to aims
together devoted to aims spiration x’ and projects that are not
spiration x’ and projects that are not
spiration x’ and projects that are not about politics but are about other
about politics but are about other
about politics but are about other things living well together if we can’t
things living well together if we can’t
things living well together if we can’t get politics right we lose this and the
get politics right we lose this and the
get politics right we lose this and the idea that politics is all that matters
idea that politics is all that matters
idea that politics is all that matters or is always the most important thing is
or is always the most important thing is
or is always the most important thing is destroying what’s in this picture that’s
destroying what’s in this picture that’s
destroying what’s in this picture that’s why we have to put politics in its place
why we have to put politics in its place
why we have to put politics in its place because politics has a place it serves
because politics has a place it serves
because politics has a place it serves other human goods take away
other human goods take away
other human goods take away I have not denied that democracy
I have not denied that democracy
I have not denied that democracy democratic politics are really important
democratic politics are really important
democratic politics are really important that hasn’t been my message
that hasn’t been my message
that hasn’t been my message I haven’t said get out of politics
I haven’t said get out of politics
I haven’t said get out of politics forget about it it’s a waste of your
forget about it it’s a waste of your
forget about it it’s a waste of your time
time
time democracy is important justice is
democracy is important justice is
democracy is important justice is important equality and freedom and
important equality and freedom and
important equality and freedom and autonomy these are all important things
autonomy these are all important things
autonomy these are all important things I haven’t been denying that what I’ve
I haven’t been denying that what I’ve
I haven’t been denying that what I’ve been trying to convince you of is that
been trying to convince you of is that
been trying to convince you of is that democracy makes it possible for us to
democracy makes it possible for us to
democracy makes it possible for us to live together well and that’s what
live together well and that’s what
live together well and that’s what explains its importance
explains its importance
explains its importance then I’ve tried to convince you that in
then I’ve tried to convince you that in
then I’ve tried to convince you that in order to do democracy well we have to
order to do democracy well we have to
order to do democracy well we have to sometimes do things together that aren’t
sometimes do things together that aren’t
sometimes do things together that aren’t about democracy now what those things
about democracy now what those things
about democracy now what those things are is hard to have hard to get our mind
are is hard to have hard to get our mind
are is hard to have hard to get our mind around I’ve suggested starting something
around I’ve suggested starting something
around I’ve suggested starting something starting very small with a reminder to
starting very small with a reminder to
starting very small with a reminder to yourself with an affirmation to yourself
yourself with an affirmation to yourself
yourself with an affirmation to yourself and then ultimately to with an
and then ultimately to with an
and then ultimately to with an affirmation to your friends and family
affirmation to your friends and family
affirmation to your friends and family say to yourself now before we get
say to yourself now before we get
say to yourself now before we get embroiled in another contentious
embroiled in another contentious
embroiled in another contentious political season before we have to start
political season before we have to start
political season before we have to start arguing with each other over
arguing with each other over
arguing with each other over Thanksgiving about who to vote for for
Thanksgiving about who to vote for for
Thanksgiving about who to vote for for president do it now say to yourself and
president do it now say to yourself and
president do it now say to yourself and to your loved ones family and friends
to your loved ones family and friends
to your loved ones family and friends are more important than what politically
are more important than what politically
are more important than what politically divides us
divides us
divides us the end of the day if you do that I
the end of the day if you do that I
the end of the day if you do that I think that’s all that there’s left to do
think that’s all that there’s left to do
think that’s all that there’s left to do is to hope for the best thank you
is to hope for the best thank you
is to hope for the best thank you [Applause]
Please follow and like us: