Press "Enter" to skip to content

Preventing Terrorism: a Millennial Challenge | Sondre Lindahl | TEDxSOAS


good evening
nothing has perhaps caused more terror
fear anxiety paranoia than terrorism
since 2001 when do you have experienced
terrorism or not our lives are shaped by
it on a daily basis there is in fact not
a universal definition of terrorism
there are approximately 300 of them and
many often refer to the old cliche that
terrorism is like pornography you know
what it is when you see it but the most
obvious place to start perhaps when
talking about terrorism is the 9/11
attack in 2001 and this attack has
become emblematic of terrorism in which
terrorists attack civilians in a
seemingly indiscriminate manner and so
for a terrorism scholar I want to
understand how such acts become possible
but also what are we doing to prevent
them so today I want to make the case
that preventing terrorism is a
millennial challenge but perhaps not for
the reason that most of you might expect
to prevent terrorism after 9/11 the
United States and its partners declared
a war on terror and in that war on
terror there was a key narrative namely
that we were now faced with a new
terrorism so whereas the good old
terrorists wanted to set off a bomb to
get the seat at the negotiation table
the new terrorists wanted to blow up the
negotiation table and everyone around it
the new terrorists did not value life
and they did not seek ordinary political
goals it was only a matter of when and
not if the West would suffer its first
WMD attack we had horrifying images and
scenarios of a mushroom cloud rising
above Manhattan in addition we had
estimates in 2002 that there were
between 2000 and 4000 al-qaeda
operatives on the
in America this made terrorism seem like
an existential threat is supported by a
culture of fear now 17 years later it
seems reasonable to evaluate the war on
terror and ask has it made us any safer
importantly has it prevented terrorism
and I believe the short answer is no so
if you look at the war on terror it has
included two large games large-scale
military campaigns and these campaigns
have led to almost over a million
civilian casualties it has led to
millions more being internally displaced
almost 10,000 coalition soldiers have
died and for the US alone we’re talking
a price tag of three trillion dollar
dollars when everything is said and done
in addition we can speak of the chaos
that the war in Iraq created that helped
Isis establish itself and spread its
misery in addition to the war the worst
and the military campaigns we’ve had
widespread government surveillance we’ve
had cases of torture and human rights
abuse we had a rampant drone program and
we had a great many security enhancing
efforts at airports schools universities
and in city centers as I’m sure most of
you are aware of and yet we seem to be
living in an age with increasing
terrorism and political violence for
instance in Europe so what I want to say
is that despite all these efforts and
governments are asking our 9 stating
that we need to devote more resources to
countering terrorism it is tempting to
conclude that so far the only thing
contemporary counter turn has done is
that has made terrorism into a
self-fulfilling prophecy now of course
there could be stream of terrorists
coming to attack us or maybe extremists
have become really good at radicalizing
vulnerable young people in addition
there are some who say that the civil
war in Syria and the rise
yeah the higher levels of immigration to
Europe are a cause of terrorism but what
is conspicuously missing from the
mainstream debate is that the potential
cause that may be violence creates more
violence tonight therefore I want to
appoint your or draw your attention to
one reason in particular for why the war
on terror has failed and why it will
continue to fail underlying contemporary
counterterrorism is an assumption a
belief that violence can be good this
assumption is deeply rooted in Western
countries so much so that we often take
it for granted we don’t even question it
or find it weird that it can always be
used as a tool to resolve a conflict or
a situation for instance in movies it
has become what John Stuart Mill would
call a dead dogma in movies depicting
life in the Old West it was the
gunslinger who were rid of the bad guys
while the nonviolent town-folks too
passive and idly by or consider a case
of a modern gunslinger perhaps most of
the media and the Democratic Party may
not like what President Trump is doing
politically at home but they all seem to
agree that he acts presidential when he
sends drones and missiles to faraway
countries or when he talks about
torturing the families of alleged
terrorists suddenly President Trump is
being Bigley presidential another aspect
of this assumption is that the violence
is neutral it’s like hammer you can pick
it up whenever you want to and it stops
and begins whenever you want to this
line of thinking is perhaps best
summarized by former President Jimmy
Carter at a press conference in 1980 he
was asked whether the US and the U
okay back coup in Iran in 1953 which
helped bring the Shah back to power
whether those events helped lead to the
revolution in 78 79
bear in mind Jimmy Carter was speaking
in 1980 Jimmy Carter then said well 1953
those events were ancient history well
maybe to Jimmy Carter those events were
ancient history but for the people of
Iran who had to endure massive violence
and repression from the shall security
forces they lived the events viscerally
and corporally every day and Carter’s
belittling of the Iranian situation is
similar to contemporary counterterrorism
failure to understand that it has a
similar impact on the countries in which
it operates in contrast Robert Young
argues that violence is a phenomenon
with a history it is always a double act
of violence and counter violence acts of
violence do not cancel each other out
they simply accumulate add new layers of
meaning to a context creating the
violent debris of history as such acts
of violence can often see him senseless
but they are rarely without any kind of
meaning for example to most people here
I guess 9/11 came out of the blue but a
report from the Cato Institute a
libertarian think-tank in America from
98 shows a bit more difficult complex
story this Cairo report sought to
investigate a claim made by the
Pentagon’s
defense Science Board that there was a
strong correlation between us into a
military involvement abroad and and
terrorist attacks against US interest
and the report did indeed find evidence
to support this claim and they labeled
u.s. military intervention abroad a
lightning-rod of terrorism but what’s
really interesting in this report
because it is examines terrorist attack
scenes
in hundreds is that from 93 95 96 97 98
there are numerous mentions are one
Osama bin Laden organizing and
perpetrating attacks against the US
because of US presence in Saudi Arabia
and US support of Israel and we have
this going on throughout the whole 90s
and then in 1998 after bin Laden has
organized attack on US embassies in
Kenya and Tanzania the Clinton
administration attacks a bin Laden’s
training camp in Afghanistan with cruise
missiles now of course bin Laden
responded a couple a couple of years
later on an event that interpolated even
more people into this violent repetition
effect of violence and counter violence
now what happened also between bin Laden
al Qaeda and United States was that they
were trapped in this repetition effect
of violence and they could not free
themselves from this repetition effect
by using more violence indeed this I
believe is the crux of the matter today
the illusion of good violence prevents
us from seeing that violence begets
violence
now we may think we only need better
weapons perhaps we need better
technology and someday we will get it
right but if violence is part of the
lived experiences of people if it shapes
people in a dialectic manner then
violence should be rejected as a means
to create now to prevent terrorism in
the future the question then becomes
what we do to prevent terrorism well the
first thing I want to suggest is
actually an old enlightenment principle
there to know this is exactly what
contemporary counterterrorism won’t do
but something that we all must do for
example on a personal level it might
involve reflecting on the use of
violence notice next time you watch a
movie how easy effective and seemingly
obvious violence can be to resolve a
situation or problem conversely notice
how
nonviolent alternatives are rendered
passive weak ineffective or just simply
ignored second study or study and
explore the literature on non violence
for instance Maria Stephan and Erica
Chenoweth has conducted a extensive
study on violence versus non violent
campaigns and they find that the
likelihood of a country being a
democracy five years after that campaign
ends is 57% for nonviolent campaigns and
less than 6% for violent campaigns thus
if you’re dare to know and look you will
find research that challenges the
utility and effectiveness of violence
and provide empirical evidence for a
while
nonviolent alternatives are better third
several resistance works even in the
face of a brutal enemies such as Isis we
know of cases where civil resistance has
prevented Isis from arresting people and
destroying local infrastructure but the
point areas as many scholars have argued
groups like Isis requires territory to
exert its political and religious
control thus its power base is fluid and
it depends on the active and passive
cooperation of a great number of social
groups thus civil resistance strategies
and techniques can work to weaken
contain and perhaps also defeat
searching groups while there are no
silver bullet of counterterrorism civil
resistance and non-violence does one
very important thing by not using
violence we are not interpolating more
people into a repetition effect of
violence and counter violence for
example to get rid of the threat that
was saddam hussein in iraq the point was
to use military force remove Saddam
Hussein and once he was gone Iraq will
be ready for free-market capitalism and
democracy but what the use of violence
did was that it closed down the space
for ordinary Iraqis to come together
engage in politics and carve out a
meaning
full existence for themselves the means
we use have to be commensurate with the
ends we want to achieve and as Gandhi
once pointed out you cannot get a
beautiful rose by planting and noxious
weed to conclude an preventing terrorism
is not a millennial challenge because
it’s all about how to capture or kill
terrorists that’s easy enough well we
have to get rid of the illusion that
violence is good and at the very least
recognize the fact that if we use
violence we will create more violence in
the future so to prevent terrorism in
the future requires that we all
challenge rethink and ultimately replace
violence as a means to create peace and
stability and thereby prevent terrorism
preventing terrorism is truly a
millennial challenge that I hope you are
all ready for it is possible but only if
we dare to know and if we dare to act
thank you [Applause]

Please follow and like us: