
[Music]
how can a medical exams office offer
comfort to the families in the aftermath
of the worst mass shooting in American
history
my name is dr. Joshua Stephanie and the
chief medical examiner for orange and
Osceola counties I was on call that
tragic morning of Sunday June 12 2016 at
approximate 2 a.m. nine-one-one operas
began as you’ve called a mass shooter at
the pulse nightclub near downtown
Orlando surely they’re out there our
office was notified at the time we
didn’t know how many individuals were
killed or injured it was until hours
later when we realized the total number
of lives taken was 49 as a medical
examiner my job as defined by state
statute is to identify the deceased
document and in all injuries and
determine the cause and manner of death
but another service that we provide that
is not a state statute is that we also
offer comfort to the families how do we
do this I always tell my staff that
anytime we interact with someone it’s
the worst day of their lives
mothers fathers brothers sisters
husbands wives children of the deceased
it’s always the worst day of their lives
can you imagine that can you imagine any
other job that every time you talk to
somebody it’s the worst day of their
lives and as such we have to treat them
with compassion respect and yes offer
them a sense of comfort
I knew that during those initial hours
of the tragedy we had to accomplish
three goals to come help comfort their
families our first goal was to transport
all 49 individuals to our secure
facility we don’t want anyone to ever
think of their loved ones in the same
building with that shooter one second
longer than necessary
our second goal was identify other
individuals in collaboration with the
Florida Department of Law Enforcement
there was they began to be identified
the moment they came to our facility the
sooner we could identify them
the sooner we could notify their
families and there would be no delay in
the process of grieving our third goal
was to complete the autopsies with our
staff of seven doctors and about thirty
more forensic staff we accomplished that
goal by 4:30 Tuesday afternoon so within
72 hours of those initial shots fired
all 49 individuals were transported
secured identified in autopsy
in fact by 4:30 Tuesday afternoon many
of them had already been released and
we’re being reunited with their families
well we could prevent anyone from being
taken that night we hope that our
efforts offer some sense of healing and
comfort to the families we weren’t
allowed at the nightclub
actually until later Sunday afternoon as
law enforcement was still securing it
and making sure it was safe for us to go
in it was at that time when I when I
first got into the scene to assess the
situation and see what we were dealing
with that I made a decision it was a
decision I made in the fly and I think
actually a visceral decision I didn’t
really put much thought into at the time
but the decision was to completely
isolate the shooter from his victims I
instructed my office to transport him
separately store him separately and that
I would talk to him separately the very
next day in a completely different
building you know we didn’t know that
decision would ever be made public like
I said I made it on the fly I instructed
in my office and honestly why did I make
that I think for anyone intimately
involved in what we were doing my staff
any of these state aid that came any
other first responders I didn’t want
them to ever have the thought or picture
of that shooter in the same room with
his victims ever again
I know for me I didn’t want to think of
that individual in the same place with
the 49 lives that he just took and at
that moment it seemed like a simple
choice again one which I didn’t think
will be made public but it wasn’t really
until days later that we found out that
the rest of the country found out about
it and not only did they find out about
it but it seemed to resonate with them
sort of some kind of sense of humanity
that we offered we received countless
letters and emails of support and
including just that decision focusing on
that decision I’d like to read you if I
could one such letter from Selma Alabama
dear ladies and gentlemen I wanted to
write and thank you all for your hard
work in helping the victims of the
recent shooting at pulse I read about
how the shooter was kept separate from
the victims and was so touched at the
care and thoughtfulness you gave while
handling this horrific task I cannot
imagine how hard your job is I want to
say thank you for all that you do I will
keep your community in my thoughts as it
tries to heal up until now I’ve been
talking about how my office tried to
comfort the community and the families
of the deceased but as chief medical
examiner I also have to be cognizant of
my staff and what their feelings are the
pulse nightclub had 49 victims that
large number just increased the
potential that any one of my staff could
have some kind of personal attachment
did they know anybody in the club did
they have children the same age as
anyone in the club or had they ever been
in the club themselves from the very
beginning I told them if they ever felt
overwhelmed by what were they doing or
what they were seeing – please take a
step back focus on what they were doing
take the time that you have themselves
and then they can come back to work I’m
sure many of them did I don’t know the
exact number or how many but I’m sure
they did take advantage of it so when my
team is interacting with families and
loved ones on
worst day of their lives how can that
not affect them how can them not affect
us as doctors the answer to that is that
we have to somewhat disassociate our
emotions from what we’re doing so in
concentrate at the task at hand on an
average day our office handles fired the
six cases but that weekend of pulse was
no average day I asked my staff to
handle the 49 individuals along with the
horrific shooting of Christina Grimmie
that Saturday night the tragic loss of
two you’re laying graves by an alligator
attack on Tuesday as well as our normal
five to six cases per day it was a
monumental task and I’m sure always
asking a lot
following the POE strategy days weeks my
staff and myself we took the time sit
down with one another and so I’ve talked
about what we have done what we have
seen it was good for us to be in talking
in communicating each other about our
feelings
after all we were the only ones who
could really experience what we had just
done it turns out that that talking the
banana with one another and sharing our
feelings our emotions a vote we had done
in those few days was a great place to
start but sometimes you need is someone
or something to sit down sit next to you
beside you to just be with you you don’t
without speaking or talking but just
sitting there and listening to you and
maybe just sitting next to you and
feeling your grief it turns out that
animals can be the perfect prescription
for comfort my entire staff are animal
lovers if not dog lovers we had the
opportunity to be visited by 12 golden
retriever therapy dogs now if any of you
ever seen I firstly have two golden
tears at home so I’m used to a but if
any of you have ever seen them come to
your office when they came to our office
that day just the sight of them and the
touch of them they didn’t ask anything
of us they just came in lay down
let us pet them let us touch him and
just let us be with them
just watching my staff their eyes light
up the tension disappear from their face
if like a weight was lifted off their
shoulders I can’t thank those dogs
enough so I brought a friend here today
everybody this is Sasha
in her handler Phil Sasha along with 11
of her friends not only visited our
office but went around the community in
the city visiting other first responders
as well as survivors they were the
perfect prescription for comfort for us
and survivors looking back on that week
what surprised me most was not just a
love and support that was given to the
families of the victims and survivors
but the love and support that was given
to our office normally as medical
examiners none of you know what we do
none of you fortunately probably never
heard of us
we probably prefer it that way we do not
like the limelight so if you think about
previous mass shootings in American
history Sandy Hook Columbine Aurora and
unfortunately many more you never hear
about what we do so it was a very
unusual and unique that we got this much
attention and it was our privilege to in
some way hopefully comfort the families
I’ll always remember the events or that
week as something that was so horrific
which could have really torn our
community in our city apart but if you
had just the opposite effect it actually
made a committee stronger made us all
unified and I was glad that our office
could be a small part of that thank you
Oh Sasha
you
how can a medical exams office offer
comfort to the families in the aftermath
of the worst mass shooting in American
history
my name is dr. Joshua Stephanie and the
chief medical examiner for orange and
Osceola counties I was on call that
tragic morning of Sunday June 12 2016 at
approximate 2 a.m. nine-one-one operas
began as you’ve called a mass shooter at
the pulse nightclub near downtown
Orlando surely they’re out there our
office was notified at the time we
didn’t know how many individuals were
killed or injured it was until hours
later when we realized the total number
of lives taken was 49 as a medical
examiner my job as defined by state
statute is to identify the deceased
document and in all injuries and
determine the cause and manner of death
but another service that we provide that
is not a state statute is that we also
offer comfort to the families how do we
do this I always tell my staff that
anytime we interact with someone it’s
the worst day of their lives
mothers fathers brothers sisters
husbands wives children of the deceased
it’s always the worst day of their lives
can you imagine that can you imagine any
other job that every time you talk to
somebody it’s the worst day of their
lives and as such we have to treat them
with compassion respect and yes offer
them a sense of comfort
I knew that during those initial hours
of the tragedy we had to accomplish
three goals to come help comfort their
families our first goal was to transport
all 49 individuals to our secure
facility we don’t want anyone to ever
think of their loved ones in the same
building with that shooter one second
longer than necessary
our second goal was identify other
individuals in collaboration with the
Florida Department of Law Enforcement
there was they began to be identified
the moment they came to our facility the
sooner we could identify them
the sooner we could notify their
families and there would be no delay in
the process of grieving our third goal
was to complete the autopsies with our
staff of seven doctors and about thirty
more forensic staff we accomplished that
goal by 4:30 Tuesday afternoon so within
72 hours of those initial shots fired
all 49 individuals were transported
secured identified in autopsy
in fact by 4:30 Tuesday afternoon many
of them had already been released and
we’re being reunited with their families
well we could prevent anyone from being
taken that night we hope that our
efforts offer some sense of healing and
comfort to the families we weren’t
allowed at the nightclub
actually until later Sunday afternoon as
law enforcement was still securing it
and making sure it was safe for us to go
in it was at that time when I when I
first got into the scene to assess the
situation and see what we were dealing
with that I made a decision it was a
decision I made in the fly and I think
actually a visceral decision I didn’t
really put much thought into at the time
but the decision was to completely
isolate the shooter from his victims I
instructed my office to transport him
separately store him separately and that
I would talk to him separately the very
next day in a completely different
building you know we didn’t know that
decision would ever be made public like
I said I made it on the fly I instructed
in my office and honestly why did I make
that I think for anyone intimately
involved in what we were doing my staff
any of these state aid that came any
other first responders I didn’t want
them to ever have the thought or picture
of that shooter in the same room with
his victims ever again
I know for me I didn’t want to think of
that individual in the same place with
the 49 lives that he just took and at
that moment it seemed like a simple
choice again one which I didn’t think
will be made public but it wasn’t really
until days later that we found out that
the rest of the country found out about
it and not only did they find out about
it but it seemed to resonate with them
sort of some kind of sense of humanity
that we offered we received countless
letters and emails of support and
including just that decision focusing on
that decision I’d like to read you if I
could one such letter from Selma Alabama
dear ladies and gentlemen I wanted to
write and thank you all for your hard
work in helping the victims of the
recent shooting at pulse I read about
how the shooter was kept separate from
the victims and was so touched at the
care and thoughtfulness you gave while
handling this horrific task I cannot
imagine how hard your job is I want to
say thank you for all that you do I will
keep your community in my thoughts as it
tries to heal up until now I’ve been
talking about how my office tried to
comfort the community and the families
of the deceased but as chief medical
examiner I also have to be cognizant of
my staff and what their feelings are the
pulse nightclub had 49 victims that
large number just increased the
potential that any one of my staff could
have some kind of personal attachment
did they know anybody in the club did
they have children the same age as
anyone in the club or had they ever been
in the club themselves from the very
beginning I told them if they ever felt
overwhelmed by what were they doing or
what they were seeing – please take a
step back focus on what they were doing
take the time that you have themselves
and then they can come back to work I’m
sure many of them did I don’t know the
exact number or how many but I’m sure
they did take advantage of it so when my
team is interacting with families and
loved ones on
worst day of their lives how can that
not affect them how can them not affect
us as doctors the answer to that is that
we have to somewhat disassociate our
emotions from what we’re doing so in
concentrate at the task at hand on an
average day our office handles fired the
six cases but that weekend of pulse was
no average day I asked my staff to
handle the 49 individuals along with the
horrific shooting of Christina Grimmie
that Saturday night the tragic loss of
two you’re laying graves by an alligator
attack on Tuesday as well as our normal
five to six cases per day it was a
monumental task and I’m sure always
asking a lot
following the POE strategy days weeks my
staff and myself we took the time sit
down with one another and so I’ve talked
about what we have done what we have
seen it was good for us to be in talking
in communicating each other about our
feelings
after all we were the only ones who
could really experience what we had just
done it turns out that that talking the
banana with one another and sharing our
feelings our emotions a vote we had done
in those few days was a great place to
start but sometimes you need is someone
or something to sit down sit next to you
beside you to just be with you you don’t
without speaking or talking but just
sitting there and listening to you and
maybe just sitting next to you and
feeling your grief it turns out that
animals can be the perfect prescription
for comfort my entire staff are animal
lovers if not dog lovers we had the
opportunity to be visited by 12 golden
retriever therapy dogs now if any of you
ever seen I firstly have two golden
tears at home so I’m used to a but if
any of you have ever seen them come to
your office when they came to our office
that day just the sight of them and the
touch of them they didn’t ask anything
of us they just came in lay down
let us pet them let us touch him and
just let us be with them
just watching my staff their eyes light
up the tension disappear from their face
if like a weight was lifted off their
shoulders I can’t thank those dogs
enough so I brought a friend here today
everybody this is Sasha
in her handler Phil Sasha along with 11
of her friends not only visited our
office but went around the community in
the city visiting other first responders
as well as survivors they were the
perfect prescription for comfort for us
and survivors looking back on that week
what surprised me most was not just a
love and support that was given to the
families of the victims and survivors
but the love and support that was given
to our office normally as medical
examiners none of you know what we do
none of you fortunately probably never
heard of us
we probably prefer it that way we do not
like the limelight so if you think about
previous mass shootings in American
history Sandy Hook Columbine Aurora and
unfortunately many more you never hear
about what we do so it was a very
unusual and unique that we got this much
attention and it was our privilege to in
some way hopefully comfort the families
I’ll always remember the events or that
week as something that was so horrific
which could have really torn our
community in our city apart but if you
had just the opposite effect it actually
made a committee stronger made us all
unified and I was glad that our office
could be a small part of that thank you
Oh Sasha
you
Please follow and like us: