Press "Enter" to skip to content

Pourquoi ce nutritionniste déteste parler des nutriments | Bernard Lavallée | TEDxUmontreal


good evening everyone
yes my name is good in the valley I
am a nutritionist and i hate talking
nutrients and calories that’s
that today we talk a lot
more of a trimant than food
as such and I mean by
example we will tell you so that your
supportive meal it must contain a
minimum of 15 g of protein or
example we will tell you
Omega-3s it’s really important
for the brain to eat fish or
hyogo low in fat will do good to
your size or country
a commitment without gluten thank you we are
under the dictatorship of the nutritionist
a concept that is invented by die hard
disk bring together a professor of
food policy at the University of
Melbourne in Australia
the nutritionist is our propensity
to break down the food in their
components like vitamins the
minerals antioxidants carbohydrates
and lipids and the calories that them
accompany and the nutritionist even
with the sense of nutrition because
that officially nutrition
it’s a sense that’s about links
between food and health but in
reality nutrition was born the day
it has been discovered that in food
were there components and what are the
quantities that we ate it could
have an influence on our health and
so the more we integrated the science of
nutrition to our diet
but the more we started to accept that
to be healthy to eat well
had to eat the right amounts of
nutrients and calais so the day we
accept that we accepted that for good
eating had to eat things that
can see that we can not feel
can not taste that we can not measure
we as a consumer we can not
tools have not the sense to know
what in my apple that
I train to eat I do not know then
we became dependent on
nutrition specialists
we need specialists who will
tell us that it’s good for you eat the
that’s not good eat bread because
me as a simple consumer
I do not know because I do not have the
tools to find out and so a big
problematic because talk about
nutrients that puts the focus on it
but it does not work in real life
would not be so bad if it worked but
the reality is that it does not work and the
purpose of my lecture tonight is to
you
very much that we should stop forever
put the focus so on the nutrients
and hugs first one must understand
that we do not live in a laboratory
worse in health studies that are
considered to be the most
credible and the most believable talk about
call it clinical trials
randomized double-blind controlled
what is it for example when we
develops drugs but we will
give a group of passers-by the
new drug
another group we will give the placebo
and the purpose of giving the placebo is that
we do not understand exactly why
but people feel better soon
that they receive a treatment even if
the treatment is phony so that’s
important because when we test a
drug but there has to be more
of people who heal when we give the
drug than when we give the placebo
but in food
it’s extremely difficult
impossible to use a placebo how
want to hide from someone who is
eating a banana
how do you want to hide someone who
want to eat five fruits and vegetables
per day
it’s impossible so what it gave
his instructions to be more and more
studying the components of the
foods therefore in the form of extracts
antioxidants and then fruit powders
small fish deals and less
fewer studies that studied foods
as a whole but we say little
in a laboratory
we eat anti food and so
results that speak of an excerpt
sexy nantes in lab ben that
not work for us because we
we eat lots of food together in
same time then I want to make a
exercise with you ok sorry a little
of interactions the bank firstly I
want you to raise your hand if you
know someone and that can be
yourself who are suffering or who has
suffered from a disease like diabetes
as a heart disease
or as the cancer lift your but
flexible the majority of people are raising their
but now let’s go back there
repeat the same exercise
wash your hand if you know
someone who suffers from an illness
like lust scrapped the beriberi or the
rickets people the science of
nutrition has been developed in a
food and health context
public that was very different
present-day
at the time the nutritional deficiencies
was much more
frequent than today and so heal
a nutritional deficiency it’s great
easy goal score for example there is
a cause and a solution the person
is sick
if you give vitamin c can
is cured it’s super easy a cause
a solution and like nutrition has been
developed in this context we started
to his believe that to cure the
health problems we had to find the
nutrient who was going to be the savior where
the nutrient what be the cause of our
problems but today it’s more
nutritional deficiencies that are
our main issues
today the diseases that kill the
more people in canada
but here he is sick of the heart the
cancer diabetes
but these diseases are caused by a
package of different factors that are going
even beyond food but one
continues to think in the same way in
looking for who is the culprit nutrient
of all our problems there that we say
these grains no it’s sugar no it’s
the no it’s the goal is no it’s the
big no these sugars we search all the
time to point the finger one we
must eliminate from our diet for
heal but the reality is we can
more think that way because
that we will never find the culprit to
all of our diseases today because
that they are caused by a lot of things
different so we have to change our
way of thinking
another exercise that I want to do with
you I show you 5 foods here that
is bananas from the oranges of the milk of
spinach and eggs
I name you nutrients that just
the world together you will tell me
in which foods we find this
nutrient so time what food is this
which one finds the potassium in which
food is what is found calcium
what food is what we find
vitamin C
in what foods do we find the
make
very good it’s just in our head
ben nan equals potassium the equals
equal calcium and pinard make orange
equal vitamin c
how come we created these
associations between a food is a
nutrient I could barely but
the majority of the foods I watch
here contain many other nutrients
so those who are there but well
other nutrients also every food
contains hundreds of molecules
different and yet we as being
human we decided that banana is
the potassium that
so it’s the most nutrient
important but a banana is not the
potassium a banana it’s a banana in
makes a band years and 99% not the
potassium and yet in our head
banana equals potassium and why it’s
dangerous to think that way there
is that we associate the role of a
nutrient to the whole food and
the agri-food industry used
this strategy to sell us
products for example if we decide that
in flaxseeds but what is
beneficial it’s the omega 3 ben
the agri-food industry that decided
by a chocolate biscuit then
put omega-3 flaxseed that
we like cookies is going to be really
better for you because I put
omega-3 flaxseed
then we know that flaxseed is
good because there are omega-3s to
inside but realistically so
you eat a chocolate cookie or
seeds of rainsars not the same
impact on your health
no food is much more than the
sum of these nutrients
then you have to understand that a food
if they live while growing an apple tree
for example according to the variety of apple
according to the only one in which we fly
grown according to look on we will water according to
fertilizers according to the teaching according to
the climate during the summer near mates but
it’s going to change the nutritional value of
apples summoned who to go further
let’s take the same first the same branch
from the same first mail app a little poucet
at the end of the branch flat dots that
pushes his middle of the tree will not have
the same nutrient content so wanted
we want to eat an apple
you do not know how many nutrients
exactly the inside is impossible
to start calculating is aged 23 mg of
6 pts 32 mg of that impossible name that
besides, even the lines
agribusiness is not capable of
make
so when you saw the picture of the
nutritional value where there are numbers
who are registered but the industry has
right to 20% margin of error on the
figure that will be inscribed because
it’s almost impossible to get to
exact figure because the foods
are alive so we can not
control what one swallows exactly and
even if we were able to
control is what we swallow is the
reality is that once we have it
valley we are not able to
control what will be absorbed by
our body an example that I like you
given in relation that I gave myself by
report to that is that of the fines
let’s take exactly the same amount
of almond are the sleeves in form
complete
in the form of almond butter or under
almond oil form
we will not absorb exactly the same
amount of calories
why is it that you all already
ate fines in life when we
crunches including neither respect for a small
goat are not born in the water in the
bath is the same thing in our
stomach in our stomach this not become
completely ground almond butter
like that our stomach is not there
as effective as a machine
uses to make almond butter and
it’s okay so what does it mean
is that these odd jobs have passed
all right because our chest
able to digest them but our body
evolved there for thousands of years
to absorb certain things and not
absorb certain things and that’s
correct
it’s like those we’ve evolved with
real foods so even if we could
control what have swallowed what is
not the case we do not know exactly what
will be absorbed once one laval
the other thing that is important to
to understand is that transformation
more totally changed foods
the effect of an instrument for example here
we know very well now that if we
we drink the same sugar that comes
of an orange are the wood in a juice
orange or if you eat it in their
whole angels this same sugar will not be
absorb the same way by our body
it will not have the same effect on our
health but another example that I like
a lot given in relation to that it’s
that of butter and margarine because
that in the 60’s we discovered
that the butter contained saturated fat
which could have a detrimental impact on
heart health so we started to
tell the people attention stop
to eat butter is really
dangerous
you are going to die we have a crisis
heart is to eat butter
stopped to eat it instead eat from
the margarine the margarine it was with
vegetable oils that contain
polyunsaturated fat that’s great it’s
fat there without having a beneficial effect
about heart health but there is a
problem with the oils was created his
liquid at room temperature
so we had to find a way to
that it becomes solid at that moment
we use a process we called
hydrogenation hydrogenation that
makes these oils liquid
they become ground and of the
room temperature and can be of
sandwiches and like butter so that
became the proper replacement of the bottom that
suited the good polyunsaturated fats
calais good for our heart so during
a long time our people are eating and the
margarine it’s really better for
until you realize
that obs hydrogenation cause a
change
at the level of fatty acids and transform
these polyunsaturated fats have what we
calls trans fats from the greeks are
so bad for the health that
are now banned
in Canada we can not use them anymore
and so what that means is that we
can not know at that moment so much
that we had not studied these facts
did not know but who is
now they are banished
because we did studies that entrusted
that it has an impact that is harmful harmless
on heart health
but today in Quebec a food
on two a gallery on two facings
we consume comes from food
to transform like margarine the
soft drinks the meals ready to
eat the bars time cookies the
cakes etc all these foods are undergoing
tons of different transformation
when we do not necessarily know
still the impacts of these
transformations on the nutrients that
these foods will contain then for
push further thinking I’ll you
said earlier that trans fats actually
partially hydrogenated oils
are the main source of trans fat
are now banned in canada
gave us new you can
still spread your margarine is
still solid
do you already have the
question why am I
still able to spread mama
margarine if you’re not allowed to talk anymore
of resignation is that the industry has
found new ways of new
processes including so- called
the inter esterification this process the
changes the structure of fatty acids so
there the languages ​​the components of the oil
for paul and fits precisely that of
the temperature of the room
but if new molecules that are
created exists anywhere else in
our environment which my goal for
tell you where were created by the man
so it’s necessarily harmful
no, but we hardly have any studies on
the facts of these new molecules
who has never been exposed to health
but yet right now we’re saying
more trans fat people in the
margarine eat in eat let’s say it’s
super good for you who in addition we go
you put some avocado oil in
you’ll see it’s going better
because in ten years offered oops
so if puts the focus on nutrients
it’s not the right solution for good
to eat what is the solution first
to eat what is the five stuff based
on science to stop thinking
so reduced reductionist to
food first you have to eat a
variety of foods
because if you eat full
of different foods you are going to eat
full of different nutrients
it does not matter if you know them
does it matter what we know
exactly the stop made on the body this
serious pot
the more you eat a variety more your
body is going to be able to fetch
everything he needs
secondly you eat less
ultra processed food that is one
do not know exactly why this
food category and nefarious but this
we know that the more we consume
the higher the quality of our food
degrades and more associated with different
health issues like obesity the
cardiovascular diseases and diabetes
then you have to bet on plants
because where we have the most studies in
this moment it’s on the diet
Mediterranean and on the diet
vegetarian
so the people who fill their
plate of vegetables fruits of
cereal grain legumes
antilles and nuts but are in
better health than others and they
suffer from least of all
diseases that kill the most Canadians
every year then we have to listen to
signals from our body because
that today we are constantly
connected or notifying our
cellular but we are no longer connected
or notification that our body we
send
and yet he has an arsenal of
message to tell us when this is the
time consultant who stop eating
but often as we get older we stopped
of the listened but nevertheless it would be
really simpler there would be less
of problems if people followed the
simple rule of eating when they have
hungry who stop eating when they have
have done and then finally I did myself
last but stop it could have been
the first one must make a place
to pleasure because today the
food we talk about under the magnifying glass of the
science under the magnifying glass of nutrients
because we live under the dictatorship of a
nutritionist even but the reality is
that food is much more
that a pack of nutrients the foods
it’s ours our culture its new to
our family that should a source
constant pleasure in our lives but
it became a source of anxiety because
that we have intellectualized it too much
and then I guarantee you that if you follow
these five tips there not only you
are going to be healthier than the
majority of people who live in the
industrialized countries
but in addition you can stop like
me to talk about nutrients and
calories
thank you so much
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: