
when each of us was born our parents
played genetic roulette when my wife and
I had our two boys we played genetic
roulette
and when any of you in the audience have
children in the future
you too will play genetic roulette
unless the Health System changes so what
do I mean when I say genetic roulette
well one of the two major forms of
genetic or inherited diseases is
recessive disease and in recessive
disease you have to inherit two bad
copies of the same gene one bad copy
from your mom and one bad copy from your
dad and then you have the disease your
mum and dad only have one bad copy of
the gene so they’re called carriers and
they are unaffected so in recessive
human disease two unaffected people have
an affected child the recessive disease
that’s usually talked about in schools
is cystic fibrosis so a lot of you may
have heard about that but there are
hundreds of recessive diseases that we
humans can have and many of them have a
much more severe effect on the child
than cystic fibrosis one of these is
called spinal muscular atrophy in spinal
muscular atrophy the nerves that make
our muscles move die and disappear so an
affected child has great difficulty in
actually moving the most severe form of
spinal muscular atrophy are babies born
almost incapable of moving now the
carrier frequency for spinal muscular
atrophy is 1 in 40 people so that means
that in this room
right now it’s highly likely that three
of us are carriers of spinal muscular
atrophy and if two of those carriers get
together because they fancy each other
their students at UWA and that sort of
thing happens then they have a one in
four chance of having a child with
spinal muscular atrophy now what happens
to a couple to a family when we have a
child with one of these severe genetic
disorders so to illustrate that for you
I want to try and take us all back in
history to early 1995 now now this is
what I want some audience participation
all of those of you who weren’t born in
1995 can you put your hands up farming
there’s no need to be shy path leads so
if you weren’t born in 1995 it’s really
but but to try and help you with this
1995 was before Facebook it was before
Twitter it was before snapchat it was
so you’re talking about moments that
change our lives
so I’m sitting in my office early 1995
the gene for a spinal muscular atrophy
had not been phoned then the telephone
calls at the other end of the line is
one of the West Australian mothers who’d
had a child died from spinal muscular
atrophy and she said to me Nigel
we hear our gene has been found now
finding genes finding disease genes is
what I do for a living we still do it on
the seventh floor of this building
I had heard nothing from the science
science community but she was right a
few weeks later the disease gene that’s
mutated in spinal muscular atrophy was
published by a group in France so
somehow free social media the news had
got from France to the families in
Western Australia that were at risk and
I’ve always felt that somehow the news
had got from the families that have
participated in the study in France it
had got ran the world to here now if
you’re a couple who’ve had one child
with a severe genetic disease what you
most want is not to have another
child with that disease and we can’t
help couples with that until we know the
precise gene that’s the problem in that
family so the gene for spinal muscular
actually have been discovered to help
couples avoid having another affected
child you do prenatal diagnosis you test
the unborn child and you do that at 12
weeks and basically it felt like 12
weeks after the gene was published in
France we were doing pre mental
diagnosis for the families in Western
Australia basically they had a put off
having any further children until their
gene had been found and we could help
them avoid having further affected kids
so spinal muscular atrophy is just one
of these severe recessive disorders
there’s hundreds of them and the numbers
are worked out in the mid 1950s by one
of the godfathers of Human Genetics
Newton Morton each single one of us is a
carrier of three to five lethal
recessive diseases so that means each of
us is a carrier of a disease which if we
get together with someone who’s carrying
one of those three to five we will have
a child who will not live long enough to
have children of their own and that’s
why I say whenever any of us have
children we play genetic roulette
because basically most of us have no
idea which three to five lethal
recessive diseases we are carrying so
well one of the things we can try and do
is we can try and find the carriers of
these recessive diseases before they
find out their carriers but having an
effective child and finding carriers is
called pre conception carrier screening
and in Australia we are way behind
world’s best practice in preconception
carrier screening for certain specific
communities that have high incidence of
recessive diseases preconception
carriers screening programs have been in
place for decades and what always
happens is that the incidence of those
recessive diseases goes down hugely so
diseases in the Ashkenazi community
fellows Semien Mediterranean countries
the incidence has dropped way down the
most comprehensive an amazing carrier
screening program in the world is in
Israel
it’s government-funded is freely
available to everybody they screen for
over 90 different recessive diseases
they’re screening 60 to 70 thousand
people a year who wish to be screened in
Australia we don’t have that so there
are a number of us around this chair who
are interested in preconception carrier
screening and what we could do here in
this country and last year we thought
we’d hold a conference here in Western
Australia but we decided we instead we’d
have a satellite meeting of a meeting in
Europe because it’s quite expensive to
bring people all the way to Westminster
and being Scottish we like to do things
on the cheap Helen
so we decided the thing to do was to
hold the satellite meaning of a meeting
in Europe where everyone is going to be
anyway so we held this meeting in
Glasgow and scope works well it’s my
and we brought together people from
North America from Europe and my
favorite guy the guy in Israel would put
their programme together we locked
ourselves in a room for a day and we
talked and I was amazed that at the end
of the day we had a consensus and the
consensus that we came to was that for
recessive diseases that were lethal by
age 4 people felt there was no ethical
or disability rights impediment booting
such a program in place so what I would
like to see in the future in Australia
is preconception of carries being
available to everybody the people that
will benefit the most probably are those
of you who put up your hands to say that
you weren’t born in 1995 it’s a bit late
for my wife and life so my vision for
the future is that no couple in
Australia should have a child with a
severe recessive disease unless they want to thank you very much
played genetic roulette when my wife and
I had our two boys we played genetic
roulette
and when any of you in the audience have
children in the future
you too will play genetic roulette
unless the Health System changes so what
do I mean when I say genetic roulette
well one of the two major forms of
genetic or inherited diseases is
recessive disease and in recessive
disease you have to inherit two bad
copies of the same gene one bad copy
from your mom and one bad copy from your
dad and then you have the disease your
mum and dad only have one bad copy of
the gene so they’re called carriers and
they are unaffected so in recessive
human disease two unaffected people have
an affected child the recessive disease
that’s usually talked about in schools
is cystic fibrosis so a lot of you may
have heard about that but there are
hundreds of recessive diseases that we
humans can have and many of them have a
much more severe effect on the child
than cystic fibrosis one of these is
called spinal muscular atrophy in spinal
muscular atrophy the nerves that make
our muscles move die and disappear so an
affected child has great difficulty in
actually moving the most severe form of
spinal muscular atrophy are babies born
almost incapable of moving now the
carrier frequency for spinal muscular
atrophy is 1 in 40 people so that means
that in this room
right now it’s highly likely that three
of us are carriers of spinal muscular
atrophy and if two of those carriers get
together because they fancy each other
their students at UWA and that sort of
thing happens then they have a one in
four chance of having a child with
spinal muscular atrophy now what happens
to a couple to a family when we have a
child with one of these severe genetic
disorders so to illustrate that for you
I want to try and take us all back in
history to early 1995 now now this is
what I want some audience participation
all of those of you who weren’t born in
1995 can you put your hands up farming
there’s no need to be shy path leads so
if you weren’t born in 1995 it’s really
but but to try and help you with this
1995 was before Facebook it was before
Twitter it was before snapchat it was
so you’re talking about moments that
change our lives
so I’m sitting in my office early 1995
the gene for a spinal muscular atrophy
had not been phoned then the telephone
calls at the other end of the line is
one of the West Australian mothers who’d
had a child died from spinal muscular
atrophy and she said to me Nigel
we hear our gene has been found now
finding genes finding disease genes is
what I do for a living we still do it on
the seventh floor of this building
I had heard nothing from the science
science community but she was right a
few weeks later the disease gene that’s
mutated in spinal muscular atrophy was
published by a group in France so
somehow free social media the news had
got from France to the families in
Western Australia that were at risk and
I’ve always felt that somehow the news
had got from the families that have
participated in the study in France it
had got ran the world to here now if
you’re a couple who’ve had one child
with a severe genetic disease what you
most want is not to have another
child with that disease and we can’t
help couples with that until we know the
precise gene that’s the problem in that
family so the gene for spinal muscular
actually have been discovered to help
couples avoid having another affected
child you do prenatal diagnosis you test
the unborn child and you do that at 12
weeks and basically it felt like 12
weeks after the gene was published in
France we were doing pre mental
diagnosis for the families in Western
Australia basically they had a put off
having any further children until their
gene had been found and we could help
them avoid having further affected kids
so spinal muscular atrophy is just one
of these severe recessive disorders
there’s hundreds of them and the numbers
are worked out in the mid 1950s by one
of the godfathers of Human Genetics
Newton Morton each single one of us is a
carrier of three to five lethal
recessive diseases so that means each of
us is a carrier of a disease which if we
get together with someone who’s carrying
one of those three to five we will have
a child who will not live long enough to
have children of their own and that’s
why I say whenever any of us have
children we play genetic roulette
because basically most of us have no
idea which three to five lethal
recessive diseases we are carrying so
well one of the things we can try and do
is we can try and find the carriers of
these recessive diseases before they
find out their carriers but having an
effective child and finding carriers is
called pre conception carrier screening
and in Australia we are way behind
world’s best practice in preconception
carrier screening for certain specific
communities that have high incidence of
recessive diseases preconception
carriers screening programs have been in
place for decades and what always
happens is that the incidence of those
recessive diseases goes down hugely so
diseases in the Ashkenazi community
fellows Semien Mediterranean countries
the incidence has dropped way down the
most comprehensive an amazing carrier
screening program in the world is in
Israel
it’s government-funded is freely
available to everybody they screen for
over 90 different recessive diseases
they’re screening 60 to 70 thousand
people a year who wish to be screened in
Australia we don’t have that so there
are a number of us around this chair who
are interested in preconception carrier
screening and what we could do here in
this country and last year we thought
we’d hold a conference here in Western
Australia but we decided we instead we’d
have a satellite meeting of a meeting in
Europe because it’s quite expensive to
bring people all the way to Westminster
and being Scottish we like to do things
on the cheap Helen
so we decided the thing to do was to
hold the satellite meaning of a meeting
in Europe where everyone is going to be
anyway so we held this meeting in
Glasgow and scope works well it’s my
and we brought together people from
North America from Europe and my
favorite guy the guy in Israel would put
their programme together we locked
ourselves in a room for a day and we
talked and I was amazed that at the end
of the day we had a consensus and the
consensus that we came to was that for
recessive diseases that were lethal by
age 4 people felt there was no ethical
or disability rights impediment booting
such a program in place so what I would
like to see in the future in Australia
is preconception of carries being
available to everybody the people that
will benefit the most probably are those
of you who put up your hands to say that
you weren’t born in 1995 it’s a bit late
for my wife and life so my vision for
the future is that no couple in
Australia should have a child with a
severe recessive disease unless they want to thank you very much
Please follow and like us: