Press "Enter" to skip to content

Perfectly normal | Jan Grue | TEDxOslo


so about a year ago I became a father

and I thought I knew more or less how

that was going to happen a few weeks

before the due date my wife and I went

to one of those soon-to-be parents

classes at the hospital where they tell

you what to expect in some detail there

were 11 people in the room when we

arrived five other couples and one woman

by herself that long woman looked at us

noticed the wheelchair and became

extremely relieved she was no longer the

most unusual person in the room we were

all very anxious and for the next few

hours they walked us through the

birthing process in some detail they

showed us the room we were going to be

in with the double bed and the pool and

the big rubber ball they showed us a

model of a pelvis and a very realistic

looking baby doll and by the end of it

we thought okay well now now we know

our son was born a week after his due

date that was the longest week of our

lives everything became unreal once we’d

passed the due dates everything seemed

very strange it seemed like the

pregnancy wasn’t real that we weren’t

going to have a baby but of course we

did and of course what happened during

the birth was nothing like what we

expected we thought we knew something

but we knew nothing still on the 5th of

May 2016 we were back home we were in

our apartment we had our baby with us

and he was perfect

or was he we were first-time parents so

we panicked we didn’t plan to but we did

regularly several times a day it’s the

baby breathing it’s the baby feeding

properly is the baby crying because it’s

in pain should we be doing something

we’re not doing those questions seemed

very reasonable to us during the first

few weeks and of course in a way they

they were reasonable they’re the kind of

questions that help keep babies alive

and the baby kept being alive and loud

but we kept asking questions of course

there were more experienced people we

could ask more experienced parents but

they didn’t have our baby so we looked

everywhere for for answers

this included the internet yeah that

that is not always a good idea

here’s the thing the Internet may not

have the right answers but it does have

a lot of them and the Internet is very

sure of itself it does not hesitate

there are apps for instance that that

have been downloaded millions of times

because they can tell you exactly what’s

wrong with your baby they can tell you

that your baby is now crying because he

is in the middle of his second

developmental leap and it’s going to be

another five days until he comes down

there are even little icons showing

stormy weather and sunny weather so

you’ll know what to look for when the

weather is going to change but what if

the weather doesn’t change well then

there are two options either there is

something wrong with the app or there’s

something wrong with the baby and this

is what the insanity of

early Parenthood is like in a certain

sleep-deprived state of mind it is

easier to believe that there is

something wrong with the baby and with

yourself than with the app because the

app does not question itself the app

does not have moments of doubt the app

just has its little sunny icon so the

clearly the baby must be crying for no

reason at all and also you’re a horrible

parent this went on for some time

sometimes the baby was happy sometimes

the baby was unhappy and as far as my

wife and I could tell there was no

correlation at all between the icons on

the app and the babies actual moods but

he was feeding and he was growing and

slowly we became used to our new life

slowly we began to regain our minds and

having regained my mind I remembered

something I’m an academic it’s part of

my job to be critical and when presented

with new information I always ask a few

questions like how do we know this

what’s the source of this information

so I put those questions to the app and

that’s where things got interesting it

presented me with a very scientific

looking surface solid developmental

psychology distinct developmental stages

and and so on but when I looked at the

studies that have been carried out the

the actual studies it turned out that

they had been done on very small sets of

some of the earliest studies were

carried out on baby chimpanzees this was

good to know there was another fact

about the app which was even more

obvious it was just that we had been too

sleep-deprived to notice all of the

predicted developmental stages all of

the stormy periods and sunny periods

were laid out based on one source of

information which was the baby’s due

date one single data point so we had to

ask ourselves who knows the baby best

this this app which knows one single

thing about him and a few more things

about baby chimpanzees or or us his his

parents who have spent 24 hours a day

with him since he was born we asked

ourselves that question and then we

deleted the app we like to monitor

ourselves just not we like to monitor

our babies we use our Fit beds and

phones and tracking sites to monitor our

financial behavior and our browsing

habits and perhaps most importantly our

health and I’m as fascinated by the

opportunities we have as anyone I’ve

downloaded an app for instance which

uses the accelerometer on my phone to

count the number of steps I take per day

as it turns out it’s it’s fewer than

that things I should take

well I do walk as it happens just not that much the recommended number of

that much the recommended number of steps per day is 10,000 and I average

steps per day is 10,000 and I average about 2,000 well after the baby was born

about 2,000 well after the baby was born I walked back and forth quite a bit and

I walked back and forth quite a bit and bringing my wife food and snacks and

bringing my wife food and snacks and water while she was breastfeeding taking

water while she was breastfeeding taking out the garbage doing the laundry doing

out the garbage doing the laundry doing pretty much everything I could do to

pretty much everything I could do to help while she did the thing that only

help while she did the thing that only she could do so make it three thousand

she could do so make it three thousand steps a day although I didn’t have time

steps a day although I didn’t have time to count them and after about six months

to count them and after about six months of this I’d lost ten pounds so in my

of this I’d lost ten pounds so in my case it seems like three thousand steps

case it seems like three thousand steps was quite a lot now I can hear the app

was quite a lot now I can hear the app developer giving the only logical

developer giving the only logical response which is that we did not build

response which is that we did not build this for wheelchair users who can walk a

this for wheelchair users who can walk a little and that’s a fair point I’m not

little and that’s a fair point I’m not the average user and if average means

the average user and if average means the same thing is normal and I’m not

the same thing is normal and I’m not normal either but how many of us are

normal either but how many of us are really the the health apps to tracking

really the the health apps to tracking sites they present us with a very

sites they present us with a very confident surface and they don’t often

confident surface and they don’t often let us look under the hood so in using

let us look under the hood so in using them we surrender some of our judgments

them we surrender some of our judgments we do this for the best possible

we do this for the best possible recently we want to be better we want to

recently we want to be better we want to be perfect versions of ourselves but the

be perfect versions of ourselves but the question I keep returning to is do these

question I keep returning to is do these tools help us become perfect versions of

tools help us become perfect versions of ourselves or of somebody else

ourselves or of somebody else the perfect baby has perfectly

the perfect baby has perfectly predictable stormy spells and sunny

predictable stormy spells and sunny spells the perfect baby has perfectly

spells the perfect baby has perfectly predictable developmental stages the

predictable developmental stages the perfect baby also doesn’t exist Leo

perfect baby also doesn’t exist Leo Tolstoy wrote in omekata Anna that all

Tolstoy wrote in omekata Anna that all unhappy families are unhappy in their

unhappy families are unhappy in their own way and I think we can go a bit

own way and I think we can go a bit further than that every actually

further than that every actually existing baby is a baby in its own way

for years now I’ve worked in an academic field called disability studies and

field called disability studies and disability studies began as the study of

disability studies began as the study of people who were different from others in

people who were different from others in their bodies in their minds but over

their bodies in their minds but over time disability scholars became more

time disability scholars became more interested in the reasons why people are

interested in the reasons why people are seen as being very different from others

seen as being very different from others why is it for instance that we attach so

why is it for instance that we attach so much more importance to having an extra

much more importance to having an extra finger or missing a finger than we do to

finger or missing a finger than we do to variations in eye color well one answer

variations in eye color well one answer has to do with how gloves are made it’s

has to do with how gloves are made it’s not that easy to find gloves

not that easy to find gloves for hands with six fingers for the same

for hands with six fingers for the same reason that they don’t make step

reason that they don’t make step counting apps for wheelchair users who

counting apps for wheelchair users who can walk a little disability studies

can walk a little disability studies also questions the ideals that would

also questions the ideals that would make for ourselves for our bodies and

make for ourselves for our bodies and for our minds we all want to be better

for our minds we all want to be better healthier more productively we want to

healthier more productively we want to be perfect but real perfection lies

be perfect but real perfection lies beyond us we remain mortal we have a

beyond us we remain mortal we have a limited amount of time on this planet

limited amount of time on this planet that makes it important to choose our

that makes it important to choose our goals carefully to not surrender our

goals carefully to not surrender our judgments because there are some goals

judgments because there are some goals that we shouldn’t try to reach in my

that we shouldn’t try to reach in my case I couldn’t walk 10,000 steps every

case I couldn’t walk 10,000 steps every day I could manage it possibly for a day

day I could manage it possibly for a day or two but I would damage myself in the

or two but I would damage myself in the process because my equilibrium lies at a

process because my equilibrium lies at a different level

my son didn’t follow his developmental stages exactly as the app had predicted

stages exactly as the app had predicted but he’s a little over a year now and

but he’s a little over a year now and he’s helping and he’s happy except when

he’s helping and he’s happy except when he isn’t

during our first year as parents that there were a lot of things that my wife

there were a lot of things that my wife and I didn’t do we didn’t stick to

and I didn’t do we didn’t stick to strict snapping schedules we didn’t

strict snapping schedules we didn’t stick to strict feeding schedules during

stick to strict feeding schedules during those first most vulnerable months we

those first most vulnerable months we didn’t try to Train our baby we didn’t

didn’t try to Train our baby we didn’t try to build a better baby we tried to

try to build a better baby we tried to get to know the one we had II may not be

get to know the one we had II may not be perfect we may not even be perfectly

perfect we may not even be perfectly normal but he is himself and that is

normal but he is himself and that is more than enough thank

Please follow and like us: