Press "Enter" to skip to content

Patterning Culture | Marie-Therese Shortt | TEDxHamburg


thanks very much so before I start I

want to put the focus on all of you for

a few moments so I’d like everyone to

stand up so just ignore the previous

warning and I want everyone to face a

person next to you so make sure everyone

and now I want everyone in your own way

to give the person you’re facing are

okay very good you my you may sit down

again so I saw a few kind of awkward

greeting moments in the audience and

that’s what I’m talking about today so

my earliest kind of memory of a really

awkward greasing was when I was around

16 years old and I was on a family

holiday in Norway and I remember being

introduced to these guys they were in

their 20s and like I was used to in

Norway I put out my hand to greet them

and they just looked at me no no no

that’s not how we greet in Portugal and

one after the other they approached me

and embrace me with two or three kisses

on the cheeks and I was so embarrassed I

felt that they had completely intruded

on my personal space and this is a

memory I really I’ll never forget how I

felt in that moment so this is what my

research is about and um as the SEC said

I’m em my background is Norwegian and

Irish so I’ve always been interested in

cultural related communication and also

how I was interpreted in Norway and

which was quite different and how people

experience me in Ireland whereas my

behavior didn’t necessarily change so

since the greeting in Portugal and I’ve

traveled a lot and lived in different

cultures and countries and I’ve noticed

that my own greeting habits have also

changed quite a lot so actually nowadays

I’m often the one that creates this

awkward situation where I’m like hugging

someone and then I realized mid-air that

this is really not appropriate so I kind

of make other people feel awkward in

these moments and there are other

moments as well you know in with

business meetings when you go to shake

the hand of the person and it’s like

it’s either too hard or too loose or

sometimes they squeeze your hands so

much that it hurts and then

oh yeah sometimes I go a bit too forward

and I touched their shoulder and I

realized and that wasn’t really

appropriate and then it’s the kissing

greasing so it’s like should I give one

two kisses is it three four or even five

and then it’s always the same question

do I go right or left first and recently

I had a really awkward nose crash with

the French friend of mine I was so

enthusiastic to greet him the French way

so I really went for it and then we just

banged our noses and it was really

painful and quite awkward so I was

interested to study this greetings

basically in a more in my PhD but also

in the area where i grew up in norway

and close to the city of stavanger so i

did a field work for my PhD study which

included six different cultures and

norwegian turkish Vietnamese and Golan

Somali and Chilean participants and I

wanted to have quite wide ranging

cultures from different parts of the

world but also that included different

religions because our religious

backgrounds also kind of influence our

behavior so what I found was the people

really enthusiastic to join the study

because they wanted to represent their

own culture from a firsthand perspective

which you don’t often get a chance to do

so they were very enthusiastic and here

are some of the stills from some of the

videos that I documented and this was

kind of the base the core work that I

used to create my visualizations so just

to show you a few examples of some

visualizations so here are three

greetings between a male and a female

and there are all strangers to each

other so on the left you have a greeting

between an a Norwegian male and then an

Angolan female and then in the middle

it’s two Norwegians and to the right two

Chilean people so I wanted to look at

gestures but also how in different

cultures we use the space between us

quite differently and then I was very

interested in how much touch is

appropriate in the greeting so you can

start to compare and then this overhead

view shows the use of personal space

which i think is really interesting and

using color coding you can start to kind

of compare in different situations but

also in different cultures what is kind

of the appropriate use of personal space

or people’s comfort levels so if you

look at the Norwegian Angolan greasing

and he was not it was actually a really

funny moment because it was kind of like

migrating in Portugal where she was

going in for the kiss and he wanted to

do a handshake and then you can see he’s

not completely in her zone so he’s

keeping a bit more distant where she’s

really going in for a lot of physical

contact so I was interested in how in

many cultures you perceive touch and

close proximity to another person as

warm friendly behavior but what also

became quite obvious and interesting was

that in many cultures there are other

ways to kind of display warm behavior so

this is an example from Vietnamese

squeezing where they said that in their

culture it’s very important to show

respect to elderly people so usually the

younger person boughs a bit further than

the older person to show respect and to

them this is very warm behavior so you

can see in contrast to the kiss

increasing they have a lot of personal

space and a lot of space between them

but it’s still a very warm breathing so

when we were discussing this with the

Vietnamese participants one of the

ladies said we do not use a lot of

physical contact when we greet but that

does not mean that we do not care about

each other smiling is very important not

hugging but eye contact and smiling

shows a lot of respect so the more I got

to know the people involved in my study

the more

are interested I got in how they

experience the greeting so the other

visualizations showed what’s happening

the space the touch but it doesn’t show

their experience of the greeting so I

started working with graphic patterns to

to start to visualize the subjective

experiences so if we go back to

migrating in Portugal for example you

can see that I I perceive the other

person as being intrusive they’re

intruding on myspace whereas they

perceive me as being distant so this it

became very obvious working with these

patterns and the greetings that in

different cultures it’s easy to see how

you can kind of clash across cultures

because of our different backgrounds but

then it was also quite interesting

because one of the one of the greetings

within the Turkish culture and they had

very different religious backgrounds and

they were from different regions in

Turkey so you can also find a lot of

cultural difference within the broader

national cultures so this one was

particularly interesting because the

male was from he was a non practicing

Muslim and the female was a quite

religious Muslim and so he said that he

usually greets his or of the other

females with either a handshake or three

kisses on the cheek where she prefers to

not great other men than her husband she

wouldn’t touch them then so there was a

similar situation in Switzerland

recently which was all over the media

where two teenage Syrian refugee boys

they refused to shake the hand of their

female teacher and this really kind of

went all over the media and it kind of

sparked this conversation about

integration about cultural difference

religious difference sexual equality so

it just shows that a greeting or a

simple handshake can carry so much

meaning it to different cultures and and

that it’s really important to be aware

that the other person

experience is the greeting quite

differently to you so working with these

participants and cultures I learned a

lot I learned that people are not either

warm or cold friendly or rude respectful

or disrespectful it’s just that we’ve

been patterned differently by our

cultural backgrounds and I think

sometimes if tension arises it’s good to

keep this in mind and so just consider

that they’ve been brought up differently

to you so maybe next time when you’re

traveling or if you’re in a business

meeting or maybe you made a refugee who

has come a long way from a very

different cultural background to you

just keep in mind that these are the

reasons why they’re greasing might be

different and this also extends to other

areas of life and other types of

behavior and interaction so i encourage

you to reflect on your greasing that you

did at the beginning of the talk and

maybe consider how you felt in that

moment and then how the other person

felt thank you [Applause]

Please follow and like us: