Press "Enter" to skip to content

Out of the Box Thinking for Technology Transfer | Kirsten Leute | TEDxTucsonSalon


[Music]
hello I am so glad to be here tonight
among all of you and especially among my
fellow speakers who were talking about
technology transfer something I’ve been
very passionate about for over 20 years
now obviously we’ve all been doing this
a long time we just look still so young
I know but also just the broader the
broader topic of advancing academic
innovations and I want to talk
particularly about if I could get my
slides up that would probably be good
but I’m going to talk about one
particular point of advancing academic
innovations and that is traversing the
valley of innovation death or as I call
it the void so I call this the void and
it’s also kind of known as the Bermuda
Triangle of academic innovation so this
is a traditional representation of the
void of the value of innovation of death
and that is that academic innovations
are brought to a certain point in
academic research and basic research at
academic institutions but before
industry is willing to take them on
they’re usually looking for some other
things to happen with the technology
before they’re willing to do so so a lot
of things end up perishing in this void
and a lot of the reasons that these
things perish are because of resource
constraints that are associated with it
be it cash Vietnam power and other
things but what I’m going to talk about
tonight are some attributes I see
associated with these technologies that
may also make them perish in this void
so another way to look at it is this all
over the world thousands of academic
researchers each year are creating
innovations now a certain number of
those are disclosed to the technology
transfer offices through invention
disclosures another fraction of those
about 15 to 25 percent of those are
licensed to industry but only a few of
those end up making it actually to be
products that are sold and hope
benefiting all of us so why is this so
important because one of those
innovations that’s not making it could
be a cure for pancreatic cancer another
one could be as simple as the better
battery life for your cell phone imagine
not having to charge your cell phone for
a whole month not worrying about it and
one of those innovations could be a
solution to our current dependence on
fossil fuels so I’m going to talk about
tonight these attributes that I
mentioned tonight from my experience at
Stanford University’s office of
technology licensing where I was for
almost 20 years now a lot of people
think that if you birth a technology at
Stanford basically you haven’t made as
exemplified in this this quote from a
recent article that says if a researcher
at Stanford University wants to create a
spin-out all he or she needs to do is
print the license scrunch it into a ball
and check it out the window to the rabid
pack of entrepreneurs and venture
capitalists waiting below
if only my job had been that easy it
would have been so simple but believe me
there was no rabid pack of entrepreneurs
and venture capitalists waiting below my
window a lot of technologies that
Stanford struggled just like they do in
other places in order to make it out of
the void and into actual industry and
then into commercial products and so I’m
gonna talk about this the void and some
attributes I saw in the void at Stanford
particularly with regards to startups
which are often a mechanism for making
it out of the void so I’m going to give
two examples and these are made up of
different things I saw while I was at
Stanford University so this is the first
example and this it’s a dimension
discovered from the laboratory of
Professor close so professor close and
some of the researchers are her
laboratory find a really interesting
innovation and they disclose it to the
technology transfer office I read it
over I’m really excited about this so I
set up a meeting with them and we meet
at the end of the meeting I’m even more
excited about this particular innovation
it’s a promising cancer therapeutic and
I think wow this could really go
somewhere
at the end of the at the very end of the
meeting professor close to ask the other
researchers to leave and to her me to
stay behind she closes the door and says
I want to do a start-up around this
technology not only that but I don’t
want you to talk about the technology
with anyone else I I really just want to
take this myself
I want to keep this secret for now and I
want to take this for it and so now I’m
starting to have some concerns she’s
never done a start-up before and so I
offer to introduce her to some different
people around campus that potentially
could help her with this there are
different programs around campus that
could help her she could meet advisers
and potentially network to meet some
individuals that will give her some
advice about what to do she accepts some
of the meetings but she doesn’t get much
out of them because she’s not willing to
talk much about what it is that she’s
done she decides to go and hit to start
pitching to entrepreneurs to start to
different investors for to get capital
for her venture but here she’s also she
runs into some roadblocks because she
wants them to sign confidentiality
agreements again because she’s very
being very secretive about what the
invention is and investors are sometimes
very reluctant to sign confidentiality
agreements without knowing much about
the invention and how it might interfere
with other things that they’re looking
at and so as often happens in this
situations she gets frustrated and
nothing ends up happening with the
technology and with the startup and the
innovation dies in this valley of
innovation death so he now has a
different story and that’s the story of
Professor possibility in a recent and
very similar situation where there is a
technology that she and some of the
graduates researchers in her lab
discover I submit an invention
disclosure tour office I read it over
and once again I’m like yes this is
something that’s really promising and I
go and meet with them and I say I love
this and and I learn about it and they
say to me we want to start a company we
want to start a company together around
this technology not only that but we
actually know someone who we think
actually could help us with this as if
a student from the lab who’s actually
already gone on to a startup and knows a
little bit about the field I offer again
to introduce them to different resources
around campus different advisors who
potentially could help them with this
they take those meetings and through
those meetings they actually meet some
potential funders so now they’re
traveling down this road and they’re
getting a lot of go signals they have a
potential funder they’ve talked with
this person at the company they’ve
agreed to come as an intern CEO so they
actually are looking like they might
make it through this valley of
innovation death but I don’t want to
make it seem too rosy because even if
something ends up making it out of the
value of an of innovation death and into
industry it doesn’t necessarily mean
something is going to end up happening
with it and being a product that
benefits you and me but there’s a
possibility that it will and that’s what
you and I and all the investors and the
world are counting on is that some of
those are going to make it so I’ve given
two stories here and I’ve given you some
examples about what I think sometimes
are the attributes that help these
innovations through the valley of death
valley of innovation death so one is
obviously putting aside your paranoia
and this can be very hard for
researchers they want to keep things in
because they don’t want something to
steal their idea so that is very
understandable but there has to be a
certain amount of sharing that happens
particularly after a patent application
is filed and some of the protections are
around the intellectual property that
they’ve created at the university and so
a part of a putting aside your paranoia
is admitting that you need help
academic researchers in general are
wonderful at academic research but it
doesn’t necessarily mean that they’re
great at other things that are
associated with getting the technology
out of the void and that goes for
fundraising being ceos of startup
companies or other things that are
associated with getting out at the void
so admitting you need help and off your
go getting going to get that help from
your networks and relationships so
another thing that you need to do
as getting things out of the void is
build your networks and relationships
and that’s from the start of the in
finding the innovation to doing take
your technology to develop development
building your business planned around
getting the technology developed to
pitching that to other other people and
building those networks and
relationships is often associated with
your having a really good team around
you this was talked about earlier as
well your team is critical for these
technologies to make it out of the void
there was a recent survey that was done
of hundreds of venture capitalists that
talked about that asked the venture
capitalist about what were the most
important things that were associated
with your successful investments and as
you can see from this slide the most
important thing associated with their
successful investments were the team
associated with that investment it was
also the most important factor for their
failed investments so having a good team
around your technology is critical for
it actually making it to success and
again one of the things that can help
these technologies get out of the void
is obviously funds and programs the cash
and the resources that we talked about
earlier to get them out of the void and
these are just some of the examples but
there are hundreds around the of these
around the United States of these
programs that are allowing these
technologies also to make it through the
void so why is this so important again
because there are hundreds examples of
technologies and spinouts from
universities and these are just some of
them that you know of that are helping
our society today but if you think about
that first slide this first couple of
slides where I show you the number of
innovations that are happening at
universities and that are not making it
through that’s what’s really critical is
that there are a bunch of these that
aren’t making it that could be those
things that are helping us so I hope
I’ve given you some ideas that we can
actually help make this void a fertile
Oasis
and I think that there are things that
all of us can potentially do to help
that happen be it from making
introductions helping people overcome
their paranoia knowing successful
startup stories that can help provide
examples for people to make it and
understand how they could take their
technologies through the void and I
think this is so important because we
are facing a lot of critical issues in
the world today and these innovations
are potential answers to all of those
thank you very much
[Applause]
[Music]
Please follow and like us: