Press "Enter" to skip to content

Our Obsession with Growth and the Power of Dormant Markets | Mark Esposito | TEDxHultAshridge


back in the fall of 2000
we’re having dinner with friends and
they happen to be also Business School
professor and we were actually talking
and contemplating why the economy was
not recovering now when you consider
that we all come from a train in
economics and we have no answer for that
question
it’s quite disarming you ask yourself
the question why can’t we not figure
this out and the answer to this is that
because somehow we’ve been trained to
think about the same old story and the
story somehow the one related to growth
we are indeed obsessed with growth our
entire economy our design about growth
our entire economic policy is designed
around growth and we get extremely happy
when we get marginal growth so if you
have a country saying that their GDP
will grow by 1.2 percent or 2%
we have reasons to celebrate if a
company says that their projected sales
next year will be a compound of 3
percent this actually company will
imagine that this is actually something
to embrace because it means we are in
good standing but where is this
obsession of growth coming from well
it’s not historical it would actually be
interesting to think that we have always
been the case but when we actually go
into the numbers we run it and this
actually the most up-to-date information
we could find about historical GDP we
weren’t really aggregating that much for
most of history we were not really too
worried about growth we had a much more
distributed system it was definitely a
lack of structure but we were not
creating this compound elements that
creates growth in the first place
so we were extremely busy in leaving a
life necessarily in building a life that
could be measured at the aggregate so
what does it mean look at the difference
between growth before and growth now
they’re uncomfortable anyone that tells
me that I can learn from the past the
lesson of what occurred to try to
project them into the future is somehow
statistically wrong you can compare
something that has an entirely different
composition in the first place you can’t
compare the GDP of the world for
historical reasons up to the 1900 with
what we actually did right now yes the
Industrial Revolution has changed
everything but you also changed the fact
that he spoiled us and he really limit
us to think about growth all in one
dimension the one that we can measure at
the aggregate level to tell in a
different sense
is when we can actually measure at the
macro level the growth happens so most
of our system our social economic
complex our social welfare is driven
primarily with the assumption the growth
has to happen and that assumption has
become obsessive for most of us but in
recessive time when everybody is asking
the same question where is growth of
course we can’t find the answer because
if the only way we have to define growth
is at the aggregate level and the
aggregate of the macro level is somehow
decreasing its volume when we’ll find
always very micro percentage of growth
so we were frustrated and we decided
what if is the way we asked him the
question that is wrong in the first
place
we expecting growth to happen the macro
level but what if growth is actually not
in the macro level but a much lower
level the grassroots growth as we call
it so we started to think maybe there
are forces right now in the 21st century
who are changing dramatically the way
society operates you see in an
industrial model where the society is
driven by the production clearly growth
can only grow or do grow but it’s not
something that will happen on a
proportional level in some time
incremental but in a world in which so
many large scale forces are shaping
everything we do clearly growth can not
only be found at the top it can also be
found somewhere else
so we started a really exciting
experiment we flipped the question what
if growth is to be found at the micro
level NOC macro and can we find any
evidence into this so we started with a
large question mark that was actually
puzzling our minds and we actually ran
pilots the interesting part about the
story I’m about to tell you is that we
ran PI low since 2013 we’ve been doing
this now for almost four years and it’s
been fascinating to discover that all of
the training we got in economics were
actually wrong yes I said it as an
economist I can tell you right now
everything I learned in school was
formally correct but in a firm a
practice perspective is now helping me
to find any growth right now why if
growth is shifting from macro to micro
it’s become a notice from most of our
macroeconomic instruments so if this is
wise
times we are forcing the process to give
us a sense of growth when actually is
only marginal growth it’s not real
growth but when we started as inquiry
and we started to walk around we were
really noticing that yes our current
model are not designed to allow us to
find the growth so what can we do
we started to imagine what if we could
have proxies that help us to define
growth in a different way now most of
the growth is happening in elements that
we can measure after they happen but we
hardly have a way to measure it while
it’s happening so we decided to go old
school and go into observation so we
thought what if we observe something
that is changing our normal perception
of reality the first thing that happened
is that in 2012 13 ki Noah was rising in
our diets and we start saying all in a
second what if I’m asking the question
in a different way
it’s kino-eye market there’s now
actually rising but because he hasn’t
aggregated yet
I can’t measure it so we actually ran
the numbers and we discovered that ki
Noah produced primarily in Bolivia at
the time was rising at 25% per year now
for all of you at 25% growth is
exceptional for most business or country
there’s no country ever reached that so
imagine what it means for a business to
actually grow at 25% so we said well
maybe this was a lucky shot we have more
work to be done we have to discover
whether this is actually the case in a
systematic manner so we continue to run
we ran 40 pilots around the world we had
a little bit of a grant from a
consulting firm who said go out there
and tell me what you find and we
discover so many different things to put
it in a perspective of what we discover
we discovered that when this large scale
forces are shaping our environments
they’re also allowing social phenomena
to really appear so most of this market
don’t happen because we have large
capital moving in they happen because
our people are and we call this the
dormant demands these are demands they
are in the market out there they’re
ready to be activated but they tend to
be invisible to most of us why because
our instruments are not calibrated to
measure them they’re calibrated to
measure somewhere else
a perfect example I’m always making when
I’m teaching this in the classroom is
always to say
it’s like having a torch if you’re
pointing to the sky you’ll never see
what’s actually right there at your
grass field right at the grassroots
level it’s the same principle how do we
think about growth not from a
perspective of macro but from the
perspective of micro so over time we
because we are academic so we have to
justify yourself that we are important
as solely justification we’re not
important we decided to develop a
framework the framework was called Drive
and it’s a framework that we still use
today to detect this large scale forces
we then talked about the fascist pending
market the macro then we developed the
proxies we decided to go into pain
points field witnesses and certain
futures is a way for us to think about
that there are ways like a GPS system
that helped us to find our way through
this entirely new formulated question
and as we were doing this we discovered
fantastic stories first of all we
discovered that yes our hypothesis was
correct if you are reversing the
question and you’re not searching for
growth marker but you’re going micro you
find plenty of this now most of this
growth will never follow the traditional
trajectory it will never follow the
trajectory the most economy expected to
follow therefore most of the time they
remain very distinct Radek very much on
the ground they hardly become more than
what they are but if we could discover
them how would our economic policy our
social policy and our our Economic
Opportunity really change we discovered
that what is magical about this dormant
demands is that when we activate the
demand with a business model you can
actually really spin off you can create
spillover effect you can create market
out of market and all of this never
really go or ascend to the financial
economy he always stays at the real
economy guess what the real economy
needs to grow now more than ever because
the tendencies for most of our capital
to be created by the real economy and
transfer over the financial economy I’m
gonna give you numbers the real economy
which is all of you every day when you
go to work when you’re sending your kids
to school when you’re basically engaging
into a new effort when you go into a new
degree when you are showing up in a
classroom and meeting your students when
you drive in when you’re buying a
property everything you do every day
define the really
economy and this real economy is
accounted for about sixty trillions
right now so it’s 99.9% of all of us and
the financial economy is three hundred
trillions now interesting the financial
economy is only a micro proportion of
the entire economy we can argue that the
financial economy counts for now 15%
versus eighty five percent of the
economy that is powered by people like
us so why do we still have this
imbalance between macro and micro
primarily because we are empowering the
macro to be the only way of defining
engage growth so the way I like to share
with you some story with you is that
what we discovery was phenomenal we
discovered growth everywhere
we discovered growth in believe as I
mentioned before rising at 25 percent we
then discovered growth in Spain it was
the time where Spain was struggling
because the real-estate bubble because
the banks were actually being
restructure and consolidated and it
wasn’t easy for a Spaniard to thanedars
actually brighter future and guess what
we found growth in organic production of
Agriculture growing a 430 percent per
year now if I even tell you four hundred
percent growth is exponential by the way
I’m sharing this with you and it means
the growth is everywhere if we are able
to tap into the growth happening through
the social drivers that really happened
primarily by habits trends or the way
people simply are to share with you some
of the story chia seeds is another one
that really completely fascinated us we
discovered the chia is rising every
every year by 1,000% growth and who
could imagine this is a millennial food
this is a food that happened to be part
of the diet the Latin America for so
long and when it was discovered being an
integrator of healthy food suddenly grew
rapidly so anyone that has an
agricultural activity around chia right
now is enjoying a lot to growth 1,000%
which financial market give you growth
to one thousand percent per year
none of them why because if we’re
observing the macro we hardly know this
what’s happening in the background which
is where we actually really are Fran
Chia we decided to go in a different
part so chia was discovered primarily in
the US but is connected to the
production of food in of course in Latin
America then we start noticing and the
stories that I was teaching in the
Sanford
skoo campus and I noticed that there was
ill Fornaio which is a beautiful bakery
and pizza place and now they have a food
truck so I noticed the food trucks in
America have been rising exponentially
since I was a kid and I was spending
time between Canada and the United
States now food truck three Americans
are the ten every week goes twice to a
food truck now this is unprecedented we
used to have this food truck but they
tend to be low low level so it was
actually straight food now food truck
are becoming a trend in some place
places you have lines for people they
really want to go to a food truck
because it’s considered to be the place
to be now this is growing right now at
30 percent per year
power primarily from restaurant that
figure out that if I can have people
coming to me I can bring the food to
them and from there we also discover the
next one which is peek game this is
company out of Turkey they decide to
take some of the crumbs from a
production of a German company was
producing video games but they figure
out that in the Middle East there is too
much over stereotyping of the Western
type of characters in the game and very
little about the eastern type and so
what they did they design video games
differently they are actually really
characterized in the car to the game
looking much closer to another part of
the world
now peek game which is a small start-up
is currently growing at twenty five
point six percent growth throughout the
time of the beginning to the end when we
studied them they had an accrued growth
at two hundred and twenty five percent
and this happened because they
understood at the social level there was
a need for a different level of demand
and this was a dormant demand that was
activated with a business model the
final example I want to share with you
is the one that was still teaching class
that we is fascinating many of us and is
really applicable across the globe this
will happen with m-pesa in Kenya now
Kenya is not the country you would
expect that will have a growth 172
percent in banking and yes they had the
growth 172 percent in banking because we
have bypassed the banks and we allowed
millions of people to have access to a
bank account without having a bank
account isn’t that smart what was the
demand millions of people that were
never qualifying to have a bank account
and now we’re gonna give them an option
to remove all application to have
bank account and pairs that transform
everything is one of the example that we
can use multiple with multipolarity on
one hand he has changed a lot the way we
think about banking he has created a
space for FinTech to go in that
direction he allows many people to think
that being digitally digitally present
and having a literacy in finance it does
not have to requires a degree and he has
really taught us a lesson that if you
are not able to participate at the
aggregate level you can still find a way
to participate at the micro level and
find growth with this my takeaway for
you as we’re trying to move towards the
end of this conversation is really to
say where are the large scale events
they’re shaping your reality right now
how do I recognize them that matters to
me how do I understand that while in the
past inside out was the way strategy was
speaking outside in now is shaping a
much greater deal of the type of society
we’re going to have in which way can we
think about the strands being applicable
to us how do I discover proxies that
will allow me to navigate through the
complexity so I can say yes this matters
to me because I’m a food company and
maybe waters matters to me and now I
know that a specific problem might
become a demand in the making and I will
be able to recognize that my
actionability doesn’t stay at the
aggregate level but it stays of the
micro one how do we empower this
grassroots movement to be part of a
growth model how do we change the
question how do we teach our students in
economics the growth hardly can be found
at the macro level it has to be found
where people really are and now do we
understand that by bringing
entrepreneurship and business model
innovation is where we’re going to tap
growth you see guys what I learn is that
it’s not true that we are in a low
growth period we are in a low growth
period according to the 20th century
jargon but according to the 21st century
jargon we’re still prospering which is
prosper in a way that hasn’t been
measured yet so my invite for you as
you’re thinking about this conversation
is find where is the dormant event
around you activate it talk about this
make sure a capital can go there and we
actually won’t be able to be obsessed
with growth in the same way will
perceive growth that’s been a normal
process of our human
thank you very much
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: