
[Music]
here’s a true confession from a
practicing historian I spend way more
time than I should thinking about what
my colleagues in the future are going to
say about the history of right now I
spend a lot of time thinking about what
is that chapter and the textbook gonna
look like where it explains lyric
leadership in the 2010s and I get this
kind of fever dream combination of
presidents past and present and some
members of Congress and a few pop stars
and then some social movement leaders
and then I start calculating my years
till retirement to see if I’m gonna
actually be out of here by the time it’s
my job to make that make sense to
anybody now it was in one of these modes
not too long ago that I tweeted the
question what is the first thing that
comes to mind when you hear the words
American leadership and I got mostly
crickets but five answers three were
some variation on it’s a thing of the
past one wealth the other was a lovely
constellation of qualities and
contradictions that seem to express more
frustration than exhilaration
now I take in my dataset all of the
probably dozens of people who saw the
tweet but they didn’t respond because
the question didn’t move them they drew
a blank when they thought of American
leadership or they felt uncomfortable
talking about it for some reason or
another this led me to believe that our
current politics our high velocity
politics of disruption has lent a lot of
energy to our political conversation and
it has sapped our political imagination
it was a sad thing to think about but as
I sat there with that I did what
historians or want to do and start sort
of rifling through the past the past the
past the past the past and suddenly came
to mind one person this person this
image of this person an Omaha area Irish
Catholic priest with a steadfast concern
for child welfare weak lungs here
holding the Oscar statuette that was
awarded to
tracie for portraying this man in the
film Boys Town in 1938 I am talking
about the one and only father Edward J
Flanagan who I got to know well writing
part of his biography for his cause for
canonization and the saint as a saint in
the Catholic Church now you may know him
perhaps as the person who revolutionized
child welfare in the United States by
convincing people that there are no bad
boys as he would say but rather a world
of adults who failed to provide children
with the love and the guidance that they
need and deserve or maybe you know him
as the person who didn’t build an
institution but a home for every boy who
lived there you may have seen the famous
statue with an older boy carrying a
younger one in his shoulders and the
inscription says he ain’t heavy he’s my
brother
regardless of his race creed or religion
you might know him as President Truman’s
envoy to Germany and Japan in 1945 to
develop orphanages for the many children
in the former axis nations who no longer
had parents to love and to guide them
after the war and I’m not going to talk
to you about even one of those things
I’m not even going to talk to you about
child welfare I’m gonna take you off
roading into the land of so called
extraneous
historical detail why because history
does two things one it makes the past
visible it illuminates the past but it
also at the same time obscures it the
idea here is one that historical
sociologist aviators are Abbeville has
called our norms of historical focusing
it’s our system for determining what
parts of the past become history and
what shape that history takes because
the past is absolutely everything that
happens which is more than our little
human minds can even begin to contain or
process let alone make meaning of so
history is the edited and condensed and
sorted out version of the past
that we adapt and adopt to make mind
sized and informative to get a sense of
what I’m talking about let me show you
the painting parson Weems fable which
anyone who’s ever taken a class from me
almost ever and all of my career has
seen at one point or another so here it
is again students if I ask my students
to tell me what this painting is about
they will tell me it’s George Washington
the cherry tree and truth as a
foundational American virtue and that
makes very good sense because our norms
of historical focusing tell us to attend
to what is largest what is in the front
what is most familiar and where symbols
of power are concentrated and certainly
we get the familiar because we’ve got
George Washington’s $1.00 head stuck on
his like five-year-old body for whatever
reason now I’m not arguing here for
dispensing with our conventional means
of organizing the past because
truthfully I don’t know where I would be
professionally or even personally if I
didn’t have these great things like
chronologies to measure change over time
or decades to contain a bunch of years
in or Wars so that we have common
markers right to kind of relate to but
what I am saying is that by accepting
these organizing structures as natural
and beyond question we lose sight of the
fact that years that end in two or
prolonged periods of peace are also
consequential they’re just off the
narrative beat often with low and slow
indirect impacts so behind these
structures of history is an entire past
available to us and hiding in plain
sight because if I were to ask you to
look at parson Weems again and this time
don’t focus on George Washington focus
on the people in the very back
harvesting the cherries from the tree
that hasn’t been cut now we have a past
that is a very different narrative about
race invisibility
and the historical construction of
American virtue so there’s more pass
there’s more story to tell than meets
the eye and when we shift our focus we
find things like this in 1942 President
Franklin Roosevelt publicly congratulate
Addabbo Flanagan for 25 years of
constructive service to American
citizenship it is also the year that
Franklin Roosevelt authorized the mass
incarceration of 120,000 Americans of
Japanese descent from the West Coast
without any evidence of espionage or
sabotage now this was not the biggest
story in Nebraska Nebraska did not have
an evacuation there wasn’t even a very
large japanese-american population but
this initiative was not without its
effects an Episcopal minister was
arrested from the front steps of his
church after giving a Sunday sermon and
held in detention without charges for
two years for the very fact of being a
japanese-american man the state of
Nebraska refused a request from the
federal government to build a camp in
the state the governor was very clear
the people of Nebraska will not take
members of this so-called enemy race
within its borders unless they could get
in on the work program that actually
would release a few prisoners to help
bring in the harvest now Nebraska also
had these kinds of ambivalent feelings
from time to time about Boys Town it was
a beloved place but there were people
who said that there were just junior
criminals out there and requested that
father Flanagan build a fence and
contain those boys in their place to
which father Flanagan always replied I
am NOT building a prison I’m building a
home you do not wall in members of your
family which means that if you think
about it in 1942 Franklin Roosevelt was
building structures of segregation and
father Flanagan had built one of the
first integrated communities in the
United States meanwhile back in one of
those incarceration camps two
japanese-american men
– father Flanagan and asked if he might
sponsor them to come to Boys Town to
live and to work for the duration of the
war under father Flanagan supervision
rather than the federal government’s now
father Flanagan if nothing else is a
practical person and if you were running
a village of boys at least I know if I
were I would take all the help I could
get so he not only wrote for these two
men to come to Boys Town to teach the
boys how to do agricultural work he
negotiated the release of ten
japanese-american families to come to
Boys Town and these adults were
supervised within a city of children but
they could live there as members of
communities and not as prisoners among
the 200 people the father Flanagan
brought to Omaha or to Boys Town was
Patrick okura this in spite of enormous
national controversy that came to father
Flanagan into Boys Town right all of
this not in the standard father Flanagan
story here’s what happened in 1939 this
man Patrick okura was the
highest-ranking japanese-american civil
servant for the city of Los Angeles and
he was enormous ly successful in two
years he got two promotions he brought
in a lot of talented japanese-american
and civil servants because he helped
people break their stereotypes and and
that excluded them and his Caucasian
co-workers liked him so much that they
jokingly referred to him as their Irish
friend Patrick Oh ‘ Cora which was
really lovely and sweet until the
syndicated columnist Drew Pearson took
that fact and twisted it into fake news
and reported that the Empire of Japan
had an agent in the Los Angeles City
government posing as an Irishman who is
going to bring down the water and the
electrical grid the mayor of Los Angeles
of course had to kind of perform this
outrage he demanded that okura resigned
not once but twice and Patrick Ofer
ocurro refused to resign his job not
once but twice
so the
city of Los Angeles granted Patrick
Okura a leave of absence so he would be
on time for his new life in
incarceration at the Santa Anita
racetrack a horse had been living there
just prior to he and his wife Lily the
mayor of Los Angeles was incensed that
father Flanagan would bring okura to
Boys Town and testified before a
congressional committee on unamerican
propaganda activities that father
Flanagan had brought the most dangerous
Japanese where he could influence the
philosophy of citizens of the future the
FBI came out and said that the charges
against Patrick okura were completely
false and father Flanagan still
continued to get letters of condemnation
from the public which he answered 201 I
don’t think that we should be a party to
condemning people until they are proven
guilty and I am sure that this is your
attitude also blue didn’t say blue
uh-huh although if you had emojis I
don’t know
the Oh core is for their part didn’t
listen to the noise they started a
reception committee to help other
Japanese American families settle into
Boys Town because they had never been to
Omaha Nebraska and they had just been
through a civil rights atrocity their
reception committee though was so
successful that it became a model for
the federal government which means that
the okras jailers came back to them and
said now help us lead the way and
emptying these camps because by the way
it wasn’t too long before the camps were
filled that they were an access
propaganda gift and unconstitutional yo
Cora’s helped with this and in 1947 when
everyone was resettled they
reconstituted to found the Omaha chapter
of the japanese-american Citizens League
which is the oldest and largest Asian
civil rights organization in the United
States after 17 years at Boys Town
Patrick okura went to the National
Institutes of Health where he innovated
specialized health care to meet the
needs of underserved and
underrepresented minority communities
in 1962 based on that national profile
Patrick Okura
was elected the national president of
the japanese-american Citizens League
which made him a major civil rights
leader and as such he was invited to
stand on the dais with dr. Martin Luther
King in 1963 when he delivered his I
have a dream speech
Patrick okura is a sort of little-known
civil rights leader continued the
struggle for civil rights for everyone
all the way through the 1980s when he
got his $20,000 check which most people
did to make up for having been wrongly
incarcerated and used that $20,000 to
found the okura mental health Leadership
Foundation to Train mental health
specialists in Asian American
communities continuing dr. King’s effort
and father Flanagan’s and his own to
speed up that day when all of God’s
children black men and white men Jews
and Gentiles Protestants and Catholics
will be able to join hands and sing in
the words of the old Negro spiritual
free at last free at last thank God
Almighty we are free at last now our
offbeat history our trip off roading
into history reveals four things this is
for you and this is for my friends in
the Twitterverse who didn’t know what to
do with that question about American
leadership it shows us that leaders
don’t have to have followers and if they
do they don’t have to focus on who’s
following them because what they need to
lead are a set of values that they
believe in and that they don’t stray
from they live them they show them they
share them they don’t care what anyone
does in response to them and they invite
people along in fact leaders need that
consistent value system far more than
they need affiliations and sort of these
steadfast allegiances to establish two
political ideologies leaders don’t have
to disrupt and
destroy to start a revolution father
Flanagan did not change one thing about
what he was doing at Boys Town to make
Boys Town this Center for civil right is
a sort of incubator for civil rights
activity he just kept doing the same
thing according to his values and made
the sensible decision to bring the
japanese-americans to Boys Town and to
defend the innocent finally we can
redefine success for our leaders in
terms of what we know is possible from
what we can see in the past so by
thinking about this maybe we can ask our
leaders we can measure their success
about how much space they create for the
next leader to rise to go beyond where
they can go or to lead into places that
they cannot maybe what we are looking
for our leaders who can stick to values
and grow and build and not bludgeon one
another with ideological positions to
get the big win and catch all of us in
the crossfire so I’m calling on you to
look into the past at what may be hidden
behind these frameworks that we usually
use to make history visible and useful
that’s what I’ll be doing and that’s
what I’m going to do when I’m called
upon to put this era in perspective for
my students of the future thank you [Applause]
here’s a true confession from a
practicing historian I spend way more
time than I should thinking about what
my colleagues in the future are going to
say about the history of right now I
spend a lot of time thinking about what
is that chapter and the textbook gonna
look like where it explains lyric
leadership in the 2010s and I get this
kind of fever dream combination of
presidents past and present and some
members of Congress and a few pop stars
and then some social movement leaders
and then I start calculating my years
till retirement to see if I’m gonna
actually be out of here by the time it’s
my job to make that make sense to
anybody now it was in one of these modes
not too long ago that I tweeted the
question what is the first thing that
comes to mind when you hear the words
American leadership and I got mostly
crickets but five answers three were
some variation on it’s a thing of the
past one wealth the other was a lovely
constellation of qualities and
contradictions that seem to express more
frustration than exhilaration
now I take in my dataset all of the
probably dozens of people who saw the
tweet but they didn’t respond because
the question didn’t move them they drew
a blank when they thought of American
leadership or they felt uncomfortable
talking about it for some reason or
another this led me to believe that our
current politics our high velocity
politics of disruption has lent a lot of
energy to our political conversation and
it has sapped our political imagination
it was a sad thing to think about but as
I sat there with that I did what
historians or want to do and start sort
of rifling through the past the past the
past the past the past and suddenly came
to mind one person this person this
image of this person an Omaha area Irish
Catholic priest with a steadfast concern
for child welfare weak lungs here
holding the Oscar statuette that was
awarded to
tracie for portraying this man in the
film Boys Town in 1938 I am talking
about the one and only father Edward J
Flanagan who I got to know well writing
part of his biography for his cause for
canonization and the saint as a saint in
the Catholic Church now you may know him
perhaps as the person who revolutionized
child welfare in the United States by
convincing people that there are no bad
boys as he would say but rather a world
of adults who failed to provide children
with the love and the guidance that they
need and deserve or maybe you know him
as the person who didn’t build an
institution but a home for every boy who
lived there you may have seen the famous
statue with an older boy carrying a
younger one in his shoulders and the
inscription says he ain’t heavy he’s my
brother
regardless of his race creed or religion
you might know him as President Truman’s
envoy to Germany and Japan in 1945 to
develop orphanages for the many children
in the former axis nations who no longer
had parents to love and to guide them
after the war and I’m not going to talk
to you about even one of those things
I’m not even going to talk to you about
child welfare I’m gonna take you off
roading into the land of so called
extraneous
historical detail why because history
does two things one it makes the past
visible it illuminates the past but it
also at the same time obscures it the
idea here is one that historical
sociologist aviators are Abbeville has
called our norms of historical focusing
it’s our system for determining what
parts of the past become history and
what shape that history takes because
the past is absolutely everything that
happens which is more than our little
human minds can even begin to contain or
process let alone make meaning of so
history is the edited and condensed and
sorted out version of the past
that we adapt and adopt to make mind
sized and informative to get a sense of
what I’m talking about let me show you
the painting parson Weems fable which
anyone who’s ever taken a class from me
almost ever and all of my career has
seen at one point or another so here it
is again students if I ask my students
to tell me what this painting is about
they will tell me it’s George Washington
the cherry tree and truth as a
foundational American virtue and that
makes very good sense because our norms
of historical focusing tell us to attend
to what is largest what is in the front
what is most familiar and where symbols
of power are concentrated and certainly
we get the familiar because we’ve got
George Washington’s $1.00 head stuck on
his like five-year-old body for whatever
reason now I’m not arguing here for
dispensing with our conventional means
of organizing the past because
truthfully I don’t know where I would be
professionally or even personally if I
didn’t have these great things like
chronologies to measure change over time
or decades to contain a bunch of years
in or Wars so that we have common
markers right to kind of relate to but
what I am saying is that by accepting
these organizing structures as natural
and beyond question we lose sight of the
fact that years that end in two or
prolonged periods of peace are also
consequential they’re just off the
narrative beat often with low and slow
indirect impacts so behind these
structures of history is an entire past
available to us and hiding in plain
sight because if I were to ask you to
look at parson Weems again and this time
don’t focus on George Washington focus
on the people in the very back
harvesting the cherries from the tree
that hasn’t been cut now we have a past
that is a very different narrative about
race invisibility
and the historical construction of
American virtue so there’s more pass
there’s more story to tell than meets
the eye and when we shift our focus we
find things like this in 1942 President
Franklin Roosevelt publicly congratulate
Addabbo Flanagan for 25 years of
constructive service to American
citizenship it is also the year that
Franklin Roosevelt authorized the mass
incarceration of 120,000 Americans of
Japanese descent from the West Coast
without any evidence of espionage or
sabotage now this was not the biggest
story in Nebraska Nebraska did not have
an evacuation there wasn’t even a very
large japanese-american population but
this initiative was not without its
effects an Episcopal minister was
arrested from the front steps of his
church after giving a Sunday sermon and
held in detention without charges for
two years for the very fact of being a
japanese-american man the state of
Nebraska refused a request from the
federal government to build a camp in
the state the governor was very clear
the people of Nebraska will not take
members of this so-called enemy race
within its borders unless they could get
in on the work program that actually
would release a few prisoners to help
bring in the harvest now Nebraska also
had these kinds of ambivalent feelings
from time to time about Boys Town it was
a beloved place but there were people
who said that there were just junior
criminals out there and requested that
father Flanagan build a fence and
contain those boys in their place to
which father Flanagan always replied I
am NOT building a prison I’m building a
home you do not wall in members of your
family which means that if you think
about it in 1942 Franklin Roosevelt was
building structures of segregation and
father Flanagan had built one of the
first integrated communities in the
United States meanwhile back in one of
those incarceration camps two
japanese-american men
– father Flanagan and asked if he might
sponsor them to come to Boys Town to
live and to work for the duration of the
war under father Flanagan supervision
rather than the federal government’s now
father Flanagan if nothing else is a
practical person and if you were running
a village of boys at least I know if I
were I would take all the help I could
get so he not only wrote for these two
men to come to Boys Town to teach the
boys how to do agricultural work he
negotiated the release of ten
japanese-american families to come to
Boys Town and these adults were
supervised within a city of children but
they could live there as members of
communities and not as prisoners among
the 200 people the father Flanagan
brought to Omaha or to Boys Town was
Patrick okura this in spite of enormous
national controversy that came to father
Flanagan into Boys Town right all of
this not in the standard father Flanagan
story here’s what happened in 1939 this
man Patrick okura was the
highest-ranking japanese-american civil
servant for the city of Los Angeles and
he was enormous ly successful in two
years he got two promotions he brought
in a lot of talented japanese-american
and civil servants because he helped
people break their stereotypes and and
that excluded them and his Caucasian
co-workers liked him so much that they
jokingly referred to him as their Irish
friend Patrick Oh ‘ Cora which was
really lovely and sweet until the
syndicated columnist Drew Pearson took
that fact and twisted it into fake news
and reported that the Empire of Japan
had an agent in the Los Angeles City
government posing as an Irishman who is
going to bring down the water and the
electrical grid the mayor of Los Angeles
of course had to kind of perform this
outrage he demanded that okura resigned
not once but twice and Patrick Ofer
ocurro refused to resign his job not
once but twice
so the
city of Los Angeles granted Patrick
Okura a leave of absence so he would be
on time for his new life in
incarceration at the Santa Anita
racetrack a horse had been living there
just prior to he and his wife Lily the
mayor of Los Angeles was incensed that
father Flanagan would bring okura to
Boys Town and testified before a
congressional committee on unamerican
propaganda activities that father
Flanagan had brought the most dangerous
Japanese where he could influence the
philosophy of citizens of the future the
FBI came out and said that the charges
against Patrick okura were completely
false and father Flanagan still
continued to get letters of condemnation
from the public which he answered 201 I
don’t think that we should be a party to
condemning people until they are proven
guilty and I am sure that this is your
attitude also blue didn’t say blue
uh-huh although if you had emojis I
don’t know
the Oh core is for their part didn’t
listen to the noise they started a
reception committee to help other
Japanese American families settle into
Boys Town because they had never been to
Omaha Nebraska and they had just been
through a civil rights atrocity their
reception committee though was so
successful that it became a model for
the federal government which means that
the okras jailers came back to them and
said now help us lead the way and
emptying these camps because by the way
it wasn’t too long before the camps were
filled that they were an access
propaganda gift and unconstitutional yo
Cora’s helped with this and in 1947 when
everyone was resettled they
reconstituted to found the Omaha chapter
of the japanese-american Citizens League
which is the oldest and largest Asian
civil rights organization in the United
States after 17 years at Boys Town
Patrick okura went to the National
Institutes of Health where he innovated
specialized health care to meet the
needs of underserved and
underrepresented minority communities
in 1962 based on that national profile
Patrick Okura
was elected the national president of
the japanese-american Citizens League
which made him a major civil rights
leader and as such he was invited to
stand on the dais with dr. Martin Luther
King in 1963 when he delivered his I
have a dream speech
Patrick okura is a sort of little-known
civil rights leader continued the
struggle for civil rights for everyone
all the way through the 1980s when he
got his $20,000 check which most people
did to make up for having been wrongly
incarcerated and used that $20,000 to
found the okura mental health Leadership
Foundation to Train mental health
specialists in Asian American
communities continuing dr. King’s effort
and father Flanagan’s and his own to
speed up that day when all of God’s
children black men and white men Jews
and Gentiles Protestants and Catholics
will be able to join hands and sing in
the words of the old Negro spiritual
free at last free at last thank God
Almighty we are free at last now our
offbeat history our trip off roading
into history reveals four things this is
for you and this is for my friends in
the Twitterverse who didn’t know what to
do with that question about American
leadership it shows us that leaders
don’t have to have followers and if they
do they don’t have to focus on who’s
following them because what they need to
lead are a set of values that they
believe in and that they don’t stray
from they live them they show them they
share them they don’t care what anyone
does in response to them and they invite
people along in fact leaders need that
consistent value system far more than
they need affiliations and sort of these
steadfast allegiances to establish two
political ideologies leaders don’t have
to disrupt and
destroy to start a revolution father
Flanagan did not change one thing about
what he was doing at Boys Town to make
Boys Town this Center for civil right is
a sort of incubator for civil rights
activity he just kept doing the same
thing according to his values and made
the sensible decision to bring the
japanese-americans to Boys Town and to
defend the innocent finally we can
redefine success for our leaders in
terms of what we know is possible from
what we can see in the past so by
thinking about this maybe we can ask our
leaders we can measure their success
about how much space they create for the
next leader to rise to go beyond where
they can go or to lead into places that
they cannot maybe what we are looking
for our leaders who can stick to values
and grow and build and not bludgeon one
another with ideological positions to
get the big win and catch all of us in
the crossfire so I’m calling on you to
look into the past at what may be hidden
behind these frameworks that we usually
use to make history visible and useful
that’s what I’ll be doing and that’s
what I’m going to do when I’m called
upon to put this era in perspective for
my students of the future thank you [Applause]
Please follow and like us: