
how’s everyone today thanks for being
here I have notes I apologize I’m gonna
have to not read but I have to reference
can art and storytelling express our
shared humanity of who we are and where
we came from how do we learn to
incorporate life experiences into our
art and how we tell our stories what
would happen if we accepted perspectives
different from our own as valid and
important in their own right eight years
ago I lost my best friend my little
brother Mike he died from a gunshot
wound to the chest it was self-inflicted
his death shocked us all he had
colleagues he had friends he had a close
family
he had me yet none of us saw it coming
to say I had a difficult time adjusting
to life without him would be an
understatement as the weeks passed after
his death I struggled to vocalize my
feelings I felt I had lost my own voice
when his was silenced in that time I
found myself aimlessly driving and
listening to his favorite bands the
voices of Chris Cornell Scott Weiland
and Layne Staley echoed in the clunky
Nissan he helped me purchase just two
years prior one late afternoon as I
drove through the tree-lined streets of
suburban Philadelphia the voice of
Mike’s Idol Eddie Vedder flowed through
the speakers yes I understand that every
life must end as we sit alone I know
someday we must go stay with me you’re
all I see did I say that I need you did
I say that I want you well if I didn’t
I’m a fool you see no one knows this
more than me I was stunned
Eddie better found the words to say what
I was struggling to say about Mike did I
say that I need you did I say that I
want to you this song just breathed was
from Pearl Jam’s 2009 albums backspacer
an album Mike would never hear it’s
funny because all I wanted to do was
talk to him about it I wonder if he
would have liked the album I think he
would Eddie Vedder didn’t write that
song for me or even to express the
feelings of loss many people interpret
the lyrics differently in fact the song
is quite popular
as a first dance song in wedding
celebrations the line stay with me
you’re all I see means something quite
different when sung by two people in
love we don’t really know why Eddie
better throat just breathe
in Pearl Jam fandom there’s much debate
about the meaning of the song think
about it what does that song mean to you
as with all forms of art once
interpretation of it is quite personal
Mike’s death redefined my worldview and
continues to shape what I bring to every
new experience I encounter and I’m not
alone each of us brings our own life
experience to our understanding of the
world I work in a museum in fact I work
in an incredible Museum in Philadelphia
called the Penn Museum it is the largest
university museum in all of North
America we have over 1 million objects
in our collection from around the world
and through those objects we strive to
tell stories of universal importance
stories that everyone can relate to
understand and care about in 1888 the
museum excited excavated the site of new
poor in modern-day Iraq the
archaeologists found over 330 thousand
cuneiform tablets they’re hidden beneath
the surface given the volume of the fine
they thought they had found the world’s
first library upon further evidence they
translated and researched the tablets
and they realized that that was not true
they hadn’t found the first library but
what they did find was a repository of a
different kind it did contain literature
but the tablets also contain evidence of
daily life of receipts for livestock for
grains for dyes and for people it even
contain example examples of how children
learned how to write
we are currently rethinking the stories
we tell with objects from the Middle
East those Canadian form tablets
included in a current exhibition at our
museum called cultures in the crossfire
stories from Syria and Iraq we present
objects from that collection to explore
the destruction of cultural heritage
sites in the Middle East you’ve all seen
footage of objects being destroyed in
Palmyra and Aleppo and other sites in
the region how do we deal with this
unprecedented loss what happens when our
shared history vanishes how do we
understand it then
we would like you to understand and
appreciate those questions but as
museums storytellers we cannot predict
what the audience will bring to their
understanding of our work we don’t
innately know if you are a refugee from
Syria or a resident of the United States
when you visit our museum we don’t know
if you’re a man or a woman if you’re
Roman Catholic or Sunni Muslim or who
you voted for in the last election we
couldn’t possibly know that
but even if we did understand how you
self-identify we wouldn’t know the
experience you bring to the stories that
were telling you topics and stories that
resonate strongly with one person may be
found offensive element to another and
that’s okay that’s part of what it means
to be human last autumn I visited the
van Gogh Museum in Amsterdam for the
first time this museum as you might
guess highlights the work of Vincent van
Gogh the infamous post impressionistic
painter who cut off his left ear and
creative madness his work is popular he
created over 2,000 paintings in his
lifetime I’m sure you all know it he
painted starry nights and sunflowers two
of the most notable paintings in history
he used bold colors and painted with
thick brush strokes and in mesmerizing
swirling patterns his work is typically
presented as important art we are told
to appreciate his technique his focused
his aggressive brushstrokes and the
serene landscapes he created recently
that museum organized a special
exhibition called on the verge of
insanity Van Gogh and his illness and it
took a different approach the labels
next to the X the paintings in this
exhibition told the story of his mental
illness they had flipped the traditional
narrative and a visitor was asked to
experience his art through his suffering
incorporated into the labels for the
stories of his days and asylums of his
suicide attempts of his altercations
with people unlike any other of its kind
in this exhibit you could read the pain
Laden words of helpless friends and
family in archival letters and you saw
the suffering in his paintings
this changed narrative laid bare his
humanity it was remarkable and to this
the best exhibition I’ve ever seen with
his new understanding of his life
experience I experienced his paintings
differently the same can be said for the
songs that we encounter throughout our
lifetimes
sometimes our personal experience
changes the songs meaning as Pearl Jam’s
just Bri that did for me but the meaning
of art can be altered by presenting and
representing it and interpreting it
differently in 1967 Bob Dylan wrote all
along the watchtower while recovering
from a motorcycle accident Dylan’s
version didn’t make it onto the charts
with the following year Jimi Hendrix
covered the song using tone and effects
that hadn’t been heard before and with a
guitar solo that was unstoppable
Hendrix version becomes one of the
greatest cover songs of all time and
produced the raw unfiltered sound of a
generation around the same time Otis
Redding released a song about a
desperate man pleading with his woman to
give him a little respect at the end of
the day his song was popular on the
black singles chart and had crossover
appeal two years later a producer
brought the same song to the attention
of a little-known gospel singer named
Aretha Franklin he thought that the song
would bring attention to her vocal
ability and he was right Arif his
rendition of respect turned her into a
feminist icon she did not ask for a
little respect from her man
she demanded it so much so that she
spelled it out literally RESP ECT this
context changed the meaning of that song
as artists we share the story of our
human experience in many ways in
painting drama sculpture poetry
literature hip-hop and rap we interpret
and interpret as humans we make content
we take content we shape and reshape it
we borrow from each other we steal from
one another we make that content reflect
our times we look to keep you invested
in our work from the connect form
tablets to the art of Van Gogh to the
songs of Pearl Jam we create with intent
I hurt myself today to see if I still
feel those words were written and sung
by Trent Reznor of
Nine Inch Nails he was waiting through
severe depression and riddled with drug
addiction when it was released in 1995
shortly after its release Spin Magazine
named Dresner the most vital artist to
music the song hurt became an instant
1990s classic but not nearly as classic
as it would become when country music
legend Johnny Cash covered it towards
the end of his career in 2003 Reznor’s
version excellent in its own right was
the expression of a twenty-something
experienced pain for the first time
perhaps but when the 70s something man
in black sang the same lyrics a
profoundly deeper and more Universal
meaning was exposed I hurt myself today
to see if I still feel Cash died seven
months after the song was released art
in all forms can take on a life of its
own it is created out of a sense of
obligation a passion of a need to
express but it can be remixed reused and
reinterpreted it is not limited to the
lifetime of its creator it can be
reincarnated and I think it should be
but the question remains can we instill
in our audiences a universal
understanding and appreciation of the
art and the stories we tell of course
not nor should we we must embrace the
perspectives and points of view and
experiences each person brings to their
understanding of the work we produce but
we cannot predict it what resonates for
you may not be what resonates for me
that’s why we need Bob Dylan’s version
with Jimi Hendrix version we need o2
sweating and Aretha Franklin both Trent
Reznor and Johnny Cash Cash’s music
video for hurt was filmed in his home
and museum called the house of cash at
the time of the filming the museum had
been closed for a long time the video
shows dusty memorabilia broken platinum
records and once curated photographs
documenting a remarkable career piled up
in the corner on the floor his wife June
looks on in the distance there’s a
closed to the public sign on the door
Kash died within a year of its filming
and the museum burnt down several years
later but it was rebuilt in 2013 and his
story was retold walking through the
galleries you see his guitars
bits of his black wardrobe his
handwritten song lyrics and other bits
of personal memorabilia including the
Grammy that he won for the video of hurt
in fact if the last thing that you see
when you walk through the museum Reznor
said regarding Cash’s version of his
song I wrote some words in music in my
bedroom as a way of staying sane about a
bleak and desperate place I was in
totally isolated and alone somehow that
winds up reinterpreted by a music legend
from a radically different era and still
retains sincerity and meeting different
but every bit is cure it really made me
think about how powerful music is as a
medium and an art form my brother’s
death redefined my understanding of the
world what experiences have shaped your
understanding of it what experiences
will shape your future understanding of
it the truth is you don’t know we don’t
know what the future holds but we do
know that new experiences will shape us
just as past experiences already have we
all have that in common
that’s humanity
[Applause]
here I have notes I apologize I’m gonna
have to not read but I have to reference
can art and storytelling express our
shared humanity of who we are and where
we came from how do we learn to
incorporate life experiences into our
art and how we tell our stories what
would happen if we accepted perspectives
different from our own as valid and
important in their own right eight years
ago I lost my best friend my little
brother Mike he died from a gunshot
wound to the chest it was self-inflicted
his death shocked us all he had
colleagues he had friends he had a close
family
he had me yet none of us saw it coming
to say I had a difficult time adjusting
to life without him would be an
understatement as the weeks passed after
his death I struggled to vocalize my
feelings I felt I had lost my own voice
when his was silenced in that time I
found myself aimlessly driving and
listening to his favorite bands the
voices of Chris Cornell Scott Weiland
and Layne Staley echoed in the clunky
Nissan he helped me purchase just two
years prior one late afternoon as I
drove through the tree-lined streets of
suburban Philadelphia the voice of
Mike’s Idol Eddie Vedder flowed through
the speakers yes I understand that every
life must end as we sit alone I know
someday we must go stay with me you’re
all I see did I say that I need you did
I say that I want you well if I didn’t
I’m a fool you see no one knows this
more than me I was stunned
Eddie better found the words to say what
I was struggling to say about Mike did I
say that I need you did I say that I
want to you this song just breathed was
from Pearl Jam’s 2009 albums backspacer
an album Mike would never hear it’s
funny because all I wanted to do was
talk to him about it I wonder if he
would have liked the album I think he
would Eddie Vedder didn’t write that
song for me or even to express the
feelings of loss many people interpret
the lyrics differently in fact the song
is quite popular
as a first dance song in wedding
celebrations the line stay with me
you’re all I see means something quite
different when sung by two people in
love we don’t really know why Eddie
better throat just breathe
in Pearl Jam fandom there’s much debate
about the meaning of the song think
about it what does that song mean to you
as with all forms of art once
interpretation of it is quite personal
Mike’s death redefined my worldview and
continues to shape what I bring to every
new experience I encounter and I’m not
alone each of us brings our own life
experience to our understanding of the
world I work in a museum in fact I work
in an incredible Museum in Philadelphia
called the Penn Museum it is the largest
university museum in all of North
America we have over 1 million objects
in our collection from around the world
and through those objects we strive to
tell stories of universal importance
stories that everyone can relate to
understand and care about in 1888 the
museum excited excavated the site of new
poor in modern-day Iraq the
archaeologists found over 330 thousand
cuneiform tablets they’re hidden beneath
the surface given the volume of the fine
they thought they had found the world’s
first library upon further evidence they
translated and researched the tablets
and they realized that that was not true
they hadn’t found the first library but
what they did find was a repository of a
different kind it did contain literature
but the tablets also contain evidence of
daily life of receipts for livestock for
grains for dyes and for people it even
contain example examples of how children
learned how to write
we are currently rethinking the stories
we tell with objects from the Middle
East those Canadian form tablets
included in a current exhibition at our
museum called cultures in the crossfire
stories from Syria and Iraq we present
objects from that collection to explore
the destruction of cultural heritage
sites in the Middle East you’ve all seen
footage of objects being destroyed in
Palmyra and Aleppo and other sites in
the region how do we deal with this
unprecedented loss what happens when our
shared history vanishes how do we
understand it then
we would like you to understand and
appreciate those questions but as
museums storytellers we cannot predict
what the audience will bring to their
understanding of our work we don’t
innately know if you are a refugee from
Syria or a resident of the United States
when you visit our museum we don’t know
if you’re a man or a woman if you’re
Roman Catholic or Sunni Muslim or who
you voted for in the last election we
couldn’t possibly know that
but even if we did understand how you
self-identify we wouldn’t know the
experience you bring to the stories that
were telling you topics and stories that
resonate strongly with one person may be
found offensive element to another and
that’s okay that’s part of what it means
to be human last autumn I visited the
van Gogh Museum in Amsterdam for the
first time this museum as you might
guess highlights the work of Vincent van
Gogh the infamous post impressionistic
painter who cut off his left ear and
creative madness his work is popular he
created over 2,000 paintings in his
lifetime I’m sure you all know it he
painted starry nights and sunflowers two
of the most notable paintings in history
he used bold colors and painted with
thick brush strokes and in mesmerizing
swirling patterns his work is typically
presented as important art we are told
to appreciate his technique his focused
his aggressive brushstrokes and the
serene landscapes he created recently
that museum organized a special
exhibition called on the verge of
insanity Van Gogh and his illness and it
took a different approach the labels
next to the X the paintings in this
exhibition told the story of his mental
illness they had flipped the traditional
narrative and a visitor was asked to
experience his art through his suffering
incorporated into the labels for the
stories of his days and asylums of his
suicide attempts of his altercations
with people unlike any other of its kind
in this exhibit you could read the pain
Laden words of helpless friends and
family in archival letters and you saw
the suffering in his paintings
this changed narrative laid bare his
humanity it was remarkable and to this
the best exhibition I’ve ever seen with
his new understanding of his life
experience I experienced his paintings
differently the same can be said for the
songs that we encounter throughout our
lifetimes
sometimes our personal experience
changes the songs meaning as Pearl Jam’s
just Bri that did for me but the meaning
of art can be altered by presenting and
representing it and interpreting it
differently in 1967 Bob Dylan wrote all
along the watchtower while recovering
from a motorcycle accident Dylan’s
version didn’t make it onto the charts
with the following year Jimi Hendrix
covered the song using tone and effects
that hadn’t been heard before and with a
guitar solo that was unstoppable
Hendrix version becomes one of the
greatest cover songs of all time and
produced the raw unfiltered sound of a
generation around the same time Otis
Redding released a song about a
desperate man pleading with his woman to
give him a little respect at the end of
the day his song was popular on the
black singles chart and had crossover
appeal two years later a producer
brought the same song to the attention
of a little-known gospel singer named
Aretha Franklin he thought that the song
would bring attention to her vocal
ability and he was right Arif his
rendition of respect turned her into a
feminist icon she did not ask for a
little respect from her man
she demanded it so much so that she
spelled it out literally RESP ECT this
context changed the meaning of that song
as artists we share the story of our
human experience in many ways in
painting drama sculpture poetry
literature hip-hop and rap we interpret
and interpret as humans we make content
we take content we shape and reshape it
we borrow from each other we steal from
one another we make that content reflect
our times we look to keep you invested
in our work from the connect form
tablets to the art of Van Gogh to the
songs of Pearl Jam we create with intent
I hurt myself today to see if I still
feel those words were written and sung
by Trent Reznor of
Nine Inch Nails he was waiting through
severe depression and riddled with drug
addiction when it was released in 1995
shortly after its release Spin Magazine
named Dresner the most vital artist to
music the song hurt became an instant
1990s classic but not nearly as classic
as it would become when country music
legend Johnny Cash covered it towards
the end of his career in 2003 Reznor’s
version excellent in its own right was
the expression of a twenty-something
experienced pain for the first time
perhaps but when the 70s something man
in black sang the same lyrics a
profoundly deeper and more Universal
meaning was exposed I hurt myself today
to see if I still feel Cash died seven
months after the song was released art
in all forms can take on a life of its
own it is created out of a sense of
obligation a passion of a need to
express but it can be remixed reused and
reinterpreted it is not limited to the
lifetime of its creator it can be
reincarnated and I think it should be
but the question remains can we instill
in our audiences a universal
understanding and appreciation of the
art and the stories we tell of course
not nor should we we must embrace the
perspectives and points of view and
experiences each person brings to their
understanding of the work we produce but
we cannot predict it what resonates for
you may not be what resonates for me
that’s why we need Bob Dylan’s version
with Jimi Hendrix version we need o2
sweating and Aretha Franklin both Trent
Reznor and Johnny Cash Cash’s music
video for hurt was filmed in his home
and museum called the house of cash at
the time of the filming the museum had
been closed for a long time the video
shows dusty memorabilia broken platinum
records and once curated photographs
documenting a remarkable career piled up
in the corner on the floor his wife June
looks on in the distance there’s a
closed to the public sign on the door
Kash died within a year of its filming
and the museum burnt down several years
later but it was rebuilt in 2013 and his
story was retold walking through the
galleries you see his guitars
bits of his black wardrobe his
handwritten song lyrics and other bits
of personal memorabilia including the
Grammy that he won for the video of hurt
in fact if the last thing that you see
when you walk through the museum Reznor
said regarding Cash’s version of his
song I wrote some words in music in my
bedroom as a way of staying sane about a
bleak and desperate place I was in
totally isolated and alone somehow that
winds up reinterpreted by a music legend
from a radically different era and still
retains sincerity and meeting different
but every bit is cure it really made me
think about how powerful music is as a
medium and an art form my brother’s
death redefined my understanding of the
world what experiences have shaped your
understanding of it what experiences
will shape your future understanding of
it the truth is you don’t know we don’t
know what the future holds but we do
know that new experiences will shape us
just as past experiences already have we
all have that in common
that’s humanity
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: