Press "Enter" to skip to content

Non gioco più, me ne vado – TEDxPisa 2015 -Chiara Lalli | Chiara Lalli | TEDxPisa


he failed he came back
at home
father cia brakes while
he died peacefully he turned off I could
continue the list for a long time but it is
the point is clear that we do everything
not to say he died or died
we do not want on any occasion
talk about death and it is also clear the
reason why we do not want to do it but a
sometimes it becomes risky becomes
risky because we facilitate them
inequality and discrimination has
missed the affection of his loved ones perhaps
one of the most widely used and the most widely used idioms
the most equivocal is gone , not only
in obituaries because necrologists do not
we risk not understanding what we are
talking about a death but in all
our conversations in the titles of the
newspapers on anniversaries as I said it is
clear why we do not want to
talk about death often even among adults
we have a tendency to think also that
be something that leads badly
it is not rare to see gestures almost in short
between corn and other forms in which it is
he wants to remove this thought, however
as I told you, we’ll talk about it
we can not avoid dying
of course, but we can talk about it
try to decide how not always
of course because there are cases of
accidents and sudden deaths but in all
those conditions in which there is one
chronic disease a disease that yes
therefore prolongs a disease condition
terminal
we can at least decide how we can
decide not to suffer for example
we can decide not to extend one
condition that is truly one
survival we can decide why
the medical decision
all medical decisions naturally
they are far more than technical decisions and
especially in the final stages of the
our life
I’m almost sure that even in one
obituary perhaps more than it concerned
my father someone did write if
he went there I did not pay much attention to it
I did not care because the thing anymore
important that my father is dead
that is, he chose he could decide he has
I could choose
my father was definitely a
privileged it was for many reasons
first of all he was a doctor and therefore he was in
able to understand he was able to understand
what they were saying was in
able to understand what he was
going on and they were listening too
for this reason because it was a
really like interlocutor
they had health insurance on
I will come back because of course it is a
privilege and ours to have
a public health service but there
they are aspects that should be
undoubtedly improved and some of these
they still concern the how again
having health insurance brought
choose for example the community of one
clinic in which he had a room alone
in which the schedules and appointments
they were respected not postponed in which
whoever went to visit it was not necessary
hear after a few minutes
the invitation to sit out because
out of the room of someone who
he’s dying, he’s not comfortable either
inside of course but out
certainly you are not comfortable you could
even to sleep with him and this
certainly changes the dying of
a person and also changes the life of
those who are close to those who are dying
but what happens to other people
what happens to the choices of the others
people how to handle the pain talking
of death as I told you could
work or it could be less than one
attempt to decrease inequality
to reduce the difference compared to whom
we are in front of us
we could for example be very afraid
to die in the hospital
it is right to know that we can ask and
claim to die at home
we could be very scared of the
pain and therefore it is right that we know
that there are ways to soothe
pain and it is our right
but often we do not know this is the
map of hospices that there are in
Italy a map edited by the
federation palliative care onlus e
probably many of you
me before I have directly
occasion I did not know almost what they were
few hospices also know i
doctors often do not know and do not know that
you can be assisted to
domicile it is not known that in a hospice you
it is treated and treated differently
from what happens in a hospital
because everything is built at least
in the idea around the person who is
to die the attempt is to give to
these people a better quality
the highest possible the first
discrimination of course as it is clear
it’s information
so know not only about hospices but
also as I mentioned before the drugs
for pain at palliative care
home care know that
all this is our right and
know that we can ask for it not only
this discrimination or this
inequality on information is a lot
deeper invisible concerns how
we can understand what is there
what they are telling us though
we are conscientious and we have taken
information and what could be
say the myth of informed consent as
let us understand what is there
they are saying
in the second report on
social inequalities in health care in
2014 we read in the health system i
points more sensitive to
social inequalities are different
demand control mechanisms
ticket exemptions lists of expected criteria
of priority those of control
of the resource allocation offer
definition of the essential levels of
assistance and management
of the appropriateness of quality and continuity
of the procedures of the state of the
assistance routes only to read
these lines is a bit remains a confused
species of information black hole
but if we want to do something else
example
let’s think about the debate on my that
maybe you’ll have heard of mine is a
acronym that stands for nutrition and
artificial hydration and it came
out as a very chronicle
heavy almost wild when it is
he was discussing a bill of one
possible law on the living will
or advance treatment directives in
that case there was someone is more than
someone who said is not a
medical treatment nutrition
artificial and therefore you can not
choose a perfect example of one
false premise and an inference
completely unpacked
I have here two drawings that, in short, not
require comments
I have not brought video photos because they can
also make an impression but if you want
you can search for belis and it is
obvious that a tube and a hole in the
our body is something that in short
something very invasive and a lot
intrusive and it is also very difficult not
consider it a medical treatment
doctor
apart from the fact that a consensus is needed
informed and need doctors to do
something like that but again if not
you know that
you can easily find them in the
condition in which someone will decide to
your place
and this is not just about a hole in it
belly concerns any other technique
and any other medical treatment
this is for giorgio welby ve lo
you will remember the tracheostomy or the
mechanical fan any technique
or treatment that you need
have our will and ours
authorization because as I told you
before
every element every question in medicine
it’s not just a technical question but
it concerns our will
the second inequality naturally
the law what allows us to do the
Law here in Italy is forbidden to diet
such tommasi is prohibited suicide
assisted the dates of the assets
anticipated treatment are not
fortunately recognized it was not done
none of those bills in which
there was that horror I told you about
before that is nutrition as something
not a doctor and therefore not
we could have decided, however, for example
it is possible to ask for total sedation
this could be another one
subspecies of inequality we could
we can choose to be
if you are massively total data then
completely lose ours
conscience until death but not
we can ask, in short, to exercise
to the bottom of ours
self-determination
a very interesting example of which
we should take into account that
of Holland the holland is one of the countries that
it is a more liberal law but beyond
this element
what’s important is interesting
know what happened before the
law
the holland has done a survey on the
phenomenon difficult to photograph that
the tanasi is clandestine then gone to
see what happened in the hospitals
and they realized that not only
Naturally it happened then age either
Assisted suicide happened but often
they happened without the consent of the direct
interested in that it happened in the way
worst possible
like that hole in the belly like others
in short, someone else had treatments
the ardor of deciding for us begins
and this is really the only violation
that we must not accept or that
main
directives in fact
they should serve this should
serve to ensure that what we
we want we do not want today to be worth
even in the future
the third inequality naturally
it is money who has possibilities
economic can go to switzerland can
go to another country where the right
it is more guaranteed and where there is
possibility of having death
there is often this way of saying death
with dignity
naturally dignity and that which we
we decide is a subjective value is not
that someone comes to say that the
our life is no longer dignified
this and bethanie mainarda maybe there
you will remember is a woman to whom she is
a brain tumor was diagnosed
who decided to die according to fact
his will or rather to die a little
first not letting the disease the
condemned to a symptomatology
very heavy as often in the cases of
cancer patients and especially in the case
in his case of a brain tumor is
the oregon went from california
the oregon is another of the states that
allows you to die with dignity and few
days before he died he said mine
dream that for all there will be
this possibility to choose is one
foundation in your name that you see that
try to carry on this his
desire
the fourth inequality is the service
I mentioned the question before the health
of the public health service
of course not everyone in all of us in
all countries there is a health service
public
but there are other other faces less
let’s say coarse inequality
like the fact of capital a hospital in
another to happen with a doctor
or another to happen with someone
that you know
in short, a true map of inequalities
and a map of different access also to
as treated pain for example not
it is rare that even today compared to the
pain to the request to soothe the
pain you look at it a bit like saying but
you are not brave enough by
dealing with pain is a strange idea
of courage above all for pain
that of terminal illnesses which is a
pain absolutely useless the fifth
the fifth inequality is the expectation that
it is not fatal to wait is not mortal but
it is certainly unnerving and it is
especially when our time is a
deadline is almost over we have been told
that we are going to die so imagine
that wants one can have to wait
chemotherapy appointments or services
here too money can of course
make the difference between a timetable
respected and one not
the sixth is that you are a doctor
for example they die differently they tend
to plan and to refuse treatments
aggressive useless maybe that
they would require us or patients to die
in peace they die the better the difference is
often also due to what
they can understand as I said before e
these data that I show you
only briefly because the question
of the enormous difference of this has us
spoken giuseppe costa first so it is
just a data that is added
further to the inequalities that
what is our socio-cultural profile
it affects a lot in general
let alone in a terminal condition
the seventh is between conscious and non-conscious people
at least in Italy and in all others
places where the living will
advance directives are not
perhaps the most cruel or the most difficult
to understand
that is, if I am conscious I can
refuse any treatment
lifesaving life- saving I can decide
if if compared to any offer
medical and also take the opportunity to say that
we should get rid of that of
that silly expression that useless
therapeutic fury and divide it into
two aspects of our will that I repeat
it is the hinge the compass and what is from the
useful technical medical point of view
so the questions we have to ask ourselves
I want this treatment is this
treatment is useful or futile serves no
I need
let’s get rid of this expression because
if I do not want anything
even minimally invasive treatment is a
fierce form of fury
therapeutic a violation a violence
true but this happens if I
I am conscious if I can defend myself if
I am no longer conscious what happens if
precisely the living will not me
guarantees the continuity of mine
will it happen that I lose consciousness and
typically a doctor can decide to do
what up until a few minutes before
I had refused
then I feel bamby revives me yes
puts some tools to prolong
a survival that is often merely
biological there was a lot of other episodes
but in short this one in particular
episode of house in which it was called
own prohibited resuscitation in which
house but a doctor is a very strange
as well as fiction but is a doctor who
It always creates reason and this is a bit
difficult to find it in reality but
in short, a certain point he violates the
request for non-resuscitation by part
of a patient despite the happy ending
wonderful because then in the end that
patient not only survives but exits
better than how he had come in because
that opportunity is also discovered that
there had been a wrong diagnosis and
so in reality he comes in
walking out almost healthy
Well, the reason ends up in court
is that luckily in short in some
systems that is a series of bombs
in short and in some systems ours
decision therefore self-determination is
considered the most important thing
even
of life itself so if I said
no something even if then it makes me better than
as I had thought
this does not change the general principle
the last one declared the last one
inequality and how we talk about death
how to say death do not know how to do if
you dealt with doctors
you probably had an experience
direct this the difficulty of
speak
it increases naturally when it comes to
communicate a deadly diagnosis or when
it must be communicated that the attempts
maybe it comes to who it is but therapy
experiments have not been successful
well it is not only important to talk and
know how to speak but it is also important
let the patient talk leave us
talk explain this interesting
also because generally we tend to
stop the patient after 18 seconds
to be discovered there are so many studies in
merit a famous one from there it started
in short, in the 80s where it was understood
that under 13 minutes of conversation
the number of complaints of malpractice was
very tall with an increasing number
of conversation between doctor and patient
from 18 onwards this number will decrease
very much but it’s not just important
because it reduces cases of complaint or or
try to solve the so-called
defensive medicine but of course the
main point that reduces errors and
facilitates a set-up of one
diagnosis and even a path
so it is strawy talk
very important and clinical empathy is
a tool is a medical tool one
tool that allows us to make
a discipline that medical is
become more and more technically
functional, in short, improved better
but that humanly it is often still
lacking and therefore the instrument
of clinical empathy can try to
fill in this hole, among other things
teach and learn in some
US universities are taught the
Narrative medicine and clinical empathy e
this is one of many cases and in this
case
the attempt is to make one more human
condition that is perhaps inhumane but not
for human reasons but because it is there
gets sick
in short, in short, if we can not
avoid or at least we can not yet
we can at least stay alive
try to die better and die better
it generally means to die as we want
we
[Music]
[Applause]
[Music]
Please follow and like us: