Press "Enter" to skip to content

Myths About Violence Against Women | Nicole Westmarland | TEDxDurhamUniversity


I

[Music]

[Applause]

it takes two to tango it’s six of one

and half a dozen of the other you can’t

thread a movie needle these are just

some of the myths the stereotypes the

misogynistic statements which are given

examples of statements which serve to

excuse cook to condone violence against

women to suggest that somehow people who

are victimized through violence as

somehow equally to blame for their

victimization we can see this through

history we see examples of judges in one

case saying that a victim of rape and

being negligent and had somehow

contributed towards her rape why because

she had been hitchhiking in another case

a man who had killed his wife wat free

from the courts with the judge saying

that woman would have tried the patience

of a saint assuming that six of one half

a dozen of another it takes two to tango

violence against women and I’m saying

violence against women rather than

against men because today what I’m

talking about is a structural inequality

that affects women the world over it is

not to suggest that violence does not

happen towards men or the women are

sometimes violent towards men which they

undoubtedly are but today I’m talking

about violence against women something

which kills women all over the world

every single day last year just in the

UK 118 women at least were killed but at

and that’s an extreme example house I’m

talking about homicide about femicide

I’m talking about sometimes the ultimate

acts of control murder suicide where a

man kills his partner his children and

then kills himself but there are other

forms of violence as well that can that

can leave women feeling restricted in

their life for years for decades in some

cases so what does a domestic violence

perpetrator look like well he looks

exactly like some of the people in this

audience actually he looks like person

who’s standing behind you in the

supermarket q he looks like the police

officer he looks like the taxi driver

who looks like the barman he looks just

like we all do as a criminologist we do

a lot of research with domestic violence

and we do some research interviewing

perpetrators of domestic violence and as

part of that we need to as everybody

does who does primary research we need

to fill in ethics forms and as part of

the ethical requirement we think about

what the risks are to our participants

but we also think about what the risks

and the sorts of things we put down when

we’re interviewing violent man well

we’ll we’ll telephone somebody when we

got in and out of the interview so that

people know that we serve we say we’ll

do the interviews in a in a public

building where there are people next

door in case we get into any

difficulties but in reality these are

not the main risks to the researchers

doing interviews with violent mode when

they come out of the interviews they

feel odd they say he seemed quite nice

he seemed really normal I could imagine

having a drink with him in the fall I

was sat next to him on a long train

journey I would have quite happily

spoken to him all the time they don’t

appear as monsters they don’t appear as

the Hulk they certainly don’t have

perpetrator stamped across their

forehead in my own interviews with

domestic violence perpetrators I’m

reminded of the first domestic violence

perpetrator that I ever interviewed

about 15 years ago and he told me he was

on a domestic violence perpetrated

program a course that tries to

re-educate men and try to help them to

stop using violence to choose to change

to choose to not use violence in their

relationships and he said to me do you

want my friends thinks it’s funny I’m on

this class even my GP says I don’t know

why you’re doing it you’re merely placid

person and that’s how perpetrators often

come across to other people they’re not

a threat they can be the person who is

the life and soul of the party they can

be the person who is in other words

fighting for social justice for social

equality as an outward person there can

be what one of the most service people

for you to be with but within the

relationship it’s different alcohol does

even a larger this has a nickname of

wife beater alcohol drugs bereavement

stress testosterone these are all some

of the reasons which are given for wide

men’s violence against women happens

being unemployed being overworked having

children not having children

and then too many childcare

responsibilities not being able to look

after the children because of work

responsibilities whatever the situation

there is a sit there was a myth about

why violence against women happens and

if it doesn’t work for the man hippie

work the other way around as a

criminologist I often spend time in

courts watching magistrates and judges

listen to domestic violence cases in one

of the most most recent cases dares that

I spent in court I heard time after time

alcohol being blend as the number one

reason why violence against women was

happening man who will work working

aware and not able to drink came back

and somehow i went on a big drink Fink

drink binge drinking binge and then came

back for a violent towards their partner

and sometimes their children as well if

it worked the other way around it was

because of the woollens drinking in one

care sir I heard which attempt which

involved an attempted rare physical

violence and violence against his

children one evening it had been New

Year’s Eve they’ve both been out the man

had not been drinking he had been

driving the woman had insisted on going

out for more drinks he didn’t want to he

wanted to stand he was the good guy here

she had insisted on going out the

defense in this case continued to make a

point about how much she had drunk even

to the extent of saying what she had

been drinking all night and what was

this terrible hi alcoholic drink that

she’d been drinking all night archers

and lemonade whatever happens and there

is an another reason that is often given

for why men’s violence against women

to use and violence isn’t always

physical either in fact the worst

violence often isn’t physical now

whenever somebody is killed within a

part intimate partner relationship we do

domestic violence homicide reviews we

look at who knew what who could have

helped how could we intervene sooner and

what we often find us for that that for

the domestic violence homicides there

hasn’t been any recent history of

physical violence there hasn’t

necessarily been call out to the place

and that is because in the most

controlling relationships in the worst

cases of domestic violence in the cases

that end up in death there hasn’t had to

be any violence fines were not being

used for years for decades even the

threat of violence the threat of what

could happen to herself to her children

to her pets to her family these things

ten years ago Evan stark an American

academic wrote a book called coercive

control the entrapment of women in

everyday life and in this book he

reminded us even just through the title

the entrapment of women in everyday life

he reminded us how close gender

inequality within our day-to-day lives

within our lived relationships within

our everyday interactions with each

other agenda and that it is Thor’s not

violence that links to that links gender

inequality to violence against women and

the continuing violence against women we

now have a new law came out last year

pod coercive and controlling behavior

this is about that constant checking of

facebook messages what was needing to

know where somebody years of being half

an hour legend having ninety missed

calls on your phone I’m not having the

freedom to stop off at the shop on the

way back because you’ll be accused of

what you clearly did have you been with

another man why have you got your hair

done why did you buy those shoes one of

the women we interviewed talked about

how she wanted to he wanted her to look

beautiful and have her hair done and

we’re short skirt and heels whenever he

was out with her but forbid her from

doing that the rest of the time she told

us I felt like a dog it was turned on

but hey it’s 2017 surely violence

against women then is illegal we have

laws against it surely in the Western

world this is new still happening surely

they’re imprison these domestic violence

perpetrators I wish I could say that is

the case but my extensive research over

15 years on this topic tells me not only

that it isn’t true but also that it

possibly isn’t going to happen at least

anytime soon in fact most of the men in

prison who are domestic violence

perpetrators will be in for a different

crime we know that policing is a problem

we know that the courts are a problem I

gave the examples earlier of how women

were seen as somehow contributing

towards their offends the idea that in

violence it takes two to tango even this

morning driving into durham i heard on

the radio of a judge telling women but

they shouldn’t drink alcohol they

shouldn’t get so drunk if they don’t

want to be weird so what do we do then

we look at the building blocks of gender

inequality and we look at them at the

very basic level we look at then when

people start playing building blocks we

look at them as babies and toddlers I

was like a mummy’s facebook group last

week and often people offer things for

sale or they offer things for free if

anybody wants them kind of

think things on this children grow so

fast there things one minute and then

they don’t the next somebody was

offering for free anybody who can

collect free tiny v do you think that

five hooded there be towels lovely offer

and then somebody had commented

underneath are these for boys or girls

babies towels we are gendering bear

these towels for the minute they come

out of the room are these for boys and

girl or girls when I was looking at our

tips for this TED talk I typed into

Google the question what mix are and

then I typed in the word gee I was going

to take him what makes a good 10 talk

and by accident a Titan I after gym and

three top options it gave me worth what

makes a girl good in bed second option

what makes a girl pretty third option

what makes a girl

and I just thought how depressing but it

is the third one down that comes to what

makes a girl happy and unfortunately I

think that tells us a lot about gender

inequality within our world so if we

want to end violence against women we

have to remember that it is gender

inequality and other forms of inequality

that intersect with gender inequality

amount of disability around sexuality

around rarest ethnicity it’s not alcohol

it’s not drugs it’s not mental illness

it’s gender inequality and we need to

think about the ways in which we tackle

that within our everyday life this isn’t

just about the big gestures it’s not

just about the changing of laws so not

just about the judges or the police

officers it’s about us in our everyday

life and this really is where it does

take two to tango when you think about

equality within your day-to-day

interactions in your relationships in

your workplaces in volunteering think

about the acts which you do and think

about how they can be gendered and

refuse to comply with those gender norms

try to resist actively resist those

gender norms in your everyday life dress

your girls in blue dress your boys in

pink think about who takes the minutes

at work think about who tidies up after

meetings who washes the cups after the

coffee morning who takes responsibility

for organizing collections when somebody

has a baby who takes responsibility for

going to get the leaving present if

somebody’s leaving think about it within

your household who does the emotional

level who buys grandma’s present who

books the table for Mother’s Day lunch

who takes time off when the kids are

sick and think about these things and

think about how you enact gender in your

relationship and let’s try to put these

gender norms and stereotypes in the bin

for good because it is only about

changing one generation

but we are going to change gender

inequality and state an end to violence

against women thank you [Applause]

Please follow and like us: