Press "Enter" to skip to content

Moi, j’écoute de tout | Stéphane Dorin | TEDxBordeaux


[Music]
my research focuses on the love of
music
I work as a sociologist on this
particular relationship that binds us to
music and our musical tastes
for my part I started to
work there is more than 20 years on
the underground velvet and its relations
with andy warhol in the factory
to new york in the 60s then
I investigated the audiences of the
Eastern music of jazz and music
of jazz and rock in india at calcutta
especially and since about ten
of years I work on the public
classical music music
contemporary with among others a
survey on the whole
intercontemporary stone then buckle
in my investigations
I often ask a question that is
what kind of music do you listen to a
simple question to which I would like
that each and every one of you
to try to think the answer that
you could give me in my
investigations
the most common answer that
I get it’s me I listen to everything I
see to the laughter in the room that this is the
talk to a lot of people actually
so this simple answer actually
has a lot of ideas
the first is that we are a little
little besides me I listen to all that
means listen to others have
maybe limited tastes but me
you understand it’s different the
second idea is that we want
thus show a form of openness to
musical diversity then the
diversity that can be understood
different ways a diversity in
terms of musical genres of a
diversity also in terms of time in
terms of place or in terms
of different artists within a
same kind
however, this openness to
diversity can remain abstract
if we do not put it concretely into
work then that’s why in my
investigations when I discuss with the
interviewees I try to
know a little bit more and sometimes he
there is some difficulty in expressing
concretely this opening and the
ask but you listen to all
really you can give examples
so frozen I do not have here but it’s
it is displayed very well so you all
the world sees the rolling stones you
listen to rolling stones and tino
rossi listen to you miles davis
and patrick sébastien
you listen to master gims men and
stone really buckle you’re on the
time obviously smiles or
laughter in the room that show us
right away that these mixtures in
somehow do not go without saying or in
consciousness intuitively and we say to ourselves
that there is a form of incongruities in
this juxtaposition then we can get
also say that we can
know how to appreciate each other one can
listen without loving but if you listen
without loving but that means we
excluded and that one may not be
so open and that’s why
that a common answer as well as
I get it’s me I listen to everything
except rap
I listen to everything except metal me
I listen to everything except classical
moreover about this the sncf has
successfully experimented with diffusion
of classical music in railway stations for
scare away the groups of young people who
would linger a little too long and
finish you that it works and that
also works in the centers
commercials in britain swiss
so the sociologist Pierre Bourdieu
said the tastes are primarily
disgusts and yes it’s easier to
to define oneself probably because one
do not like that because we love and the
musical disgust finally this is the
disgust of the musical tastes of people to
who does not want to look like the old
maybe for classical music
but this is only an assumption
sociological and 7
this idea actually shows us that
the musical tastes not work
as symbolic boundaries between
individuals and social groups
so why continue to believe that
we are open and why
continue to make others believe that
we are very open about
music an essential reason is to
our belief we have the freedom of our
choice
in fact we have a pretty design
romantic love of music
it’s a type of love that looks like
the one who unites us to our lover
our lover a love without constraint
without requiring a pure love
freedom that is based on passion and
this love of music that builds
our musical musical tastes contribute
to also create our personality
our personal identity and we are there
firmly hold the rochefoucauld of
is already dense and maxim that we
more to our tastes than to our
opinions
that is, we are more
easily on our opinions as on our
tastes so there is a shape
personal identification through
musical tastes and adherence to the
music can be very strong
so she is particularly very
strong among the youngest who can
love music passionately
but obviously this adherence to the
music is also spreading in the
company and so in our many
age classes
but among the youngest, it’s going to go
for example with a style
dress that is suitable adequate
with the musical taste if we think of the
funk music to rap or metal to
Gothic and that’s when we end
obviously to a contradiction since
on one side we will display an opening
to the most diverse musical tastes and
on the other side we will define ourselves by
a limited number of musical genres
a small number or even a genre
unique that will contribute to us
personally define then on 7 out
this idea of ​​self-definition and
well to resolve this contradiction
between self-definition and openness
must understand that we keep the
musical tastes that we have wrought
during our youth
I showed in my works by
example that one forges its musical taste
between 15 and 25 years old and then
continues to keep the same differently
says if we discovered jazz at 20
we will continue to like it at 60 then
I will show you a graph
here is the median age of audiences
so on this graph
I put two investigations from the Ministry of
the culture of 1981 and 88 in blue and
red
and I added a third column
orange which is my own investigation on
the audiences of classical music in
2014
when you see it is that first
the median age of audiences is more
high for classical music and
the opera only for jazz, which itself
higher than for rock
so that’s a first element
can be quite known the second who
is less known is more interesting
is that this median age is increasing with
the weather
that is, we see that between 80 and
2008 all audiences of all genres
musicals have aged and we have
that a succession of generations that
corresponds to the succession of the genera
musical in the history of music
so does this mean that there is no
young lovers of classical music
jazz or opera well of course no he
this is not a strict determinism
but constraints
so we can find these young amateurs
and in my investigations but I was able
show that these young lovers of
classical music presents
quite distinct features id
they have attended the
conservatory for quite a long time
several years and they have
benefited from what sociologists
call a musical socialization
early is long enough and
intense to counterbalance the effects
the massive diffusion of music
popular on the mass media or
on the Internet
if you look at for example the tube of
summer 2010 is soon to spas
exceeded 4 billion views on
Youtube
so it’s not hard smith necessarily
of great diversity
so does this mean that the
openness to the musical taste of others
would be reserved for those children who have
benefited from the conservatory and that
Generally, it would only be
that an illusion
I do not think so I do not think so because
in this in this light in this
optically there well it must be considered
another fact of our belief that
is that of the freedom of our choices
precisely we are maybe not
as free as we think in our
musical choices we like to believe that
we are very open and probably
because of the fact that the genres
Musicians are today very
easily accessible thanks to
digital there is internet on deezer
spotify or youtube
anyone can listen to the full
of master gims and the integral of stone
snap and instantly
obviously it’s not quite what
that we do every day but
we like to believe also a second
something that is perhaps more important
that equals dignity of all its
musical forms ie the idea
that they all have the same value and
that we have come to some sort of
democracy of musical tastes
everyone does what he wants this belief
in reality is not shared by any
the world in society
it is actually reserved instead
reserved for the middle classes and
superior is to the categories
the most graduates and maybe
precisely to those categories that have
benefited from a musical education
attendance at the conservatory or
from an opening to sensitivity to
various forms of music
so much so that we have the sociologists
of culture say today that
openness to musical diversity
it became the new distinctive sign
modern elites
in other words to be a member of
the modern elite it takes both to
know his classics and at the same
time be very open to the
novelty
we would have gone from a distinction
who went through exclusion to a
distinction by opening so far
in our observable behaviors of
music consumption
we continue to consider that our
musical tastes are the best that’s
normal these are ours so these are
they are the best
so that and we say we must hold
account of the fact that our report to the
culture has changed profoundly during
recent decades and this in
precisely because of the internet and
digital technologies that we
allow to have access technically
very easily to forms that
cultural musical very diverse and very
varied and also because of the
rise of cultural globalization
ie putting in contact
generalized of all the cultures of the
world and today the idea that has
prevailed up to during a strict
hierarchy of musical tastes
a hierarchy at the top of which is
would find classical music
Western and the idea of ​​a definition
unique taste of music we are
today almost unbearable
denigrate popular music
despise music from elsewhere
these are attitudes that we
no longer really accept
we sincerely want to be open
to the music of others we want
sincerely be open and
of tolerance
but that first recognizes
that this opening is not self-evident
that it is not so easy and that it does not
suffice to proclaim it
to make it exist otherwise well we
would have to deal with a kind
of social hypocrisy that would consist of
display a facade tolerance while
by continuing to operate
distinctions of the selections is then
and to distinguish between what is
good taste according to us and what does not
do not then obviously rise this
willingness to open
and ubf tolerance data
ask how to make it
more effective and well we can imagine
that the key lies in the
democratization precisely of
music and artistic education
that is, we must accept
the idea that we have to disseminate for
all categories of the population
but especially obviously for the most
youth
this access to a musical education
diversified where one could have
access precisely musical forms
more demanding where different
in any case different from that which
simply pass on networks
social video sharing sites
or on streaming platforms
to go a little further through
educate
this musical and artistic education
which would no longer be reserved as
this is still the case too often
today to the most categories
favored
then at that moment the hierarchies
cultures we talk about is contempt
popular music
the dictatorship of good taste and monopoly
good taste may belong to the
past
in other words we still have some
efforts to provide
so after thinking about it more
carefully I want to ask you
again the question and you you
listen to all of you really I you
thank
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: