Press "Enter" to skip to content

Military Veteran Dialogues on Belonging | Douglas McGetchin | TEDxFAUJupiter


hello I’m here to introduce you to a few
of my friends some veterans and veterans
who have lived through Wars of the 20th
century I’d like to start with Erich
Maria Remarque who is probably the most
well known for writing the novel of all
Quiet on the Western Front in this he
has a character named Paul this is the
German army he comes back from lead and
the experiences that he has back home in
his old familiar place is in his bedroom
he sees his Butterfly Collection his mom
is right there he sees the piano and yet
after having been at the front he
describes it as if there’s a veil in
front of him that he can’t quite connect
with his old life now remember also
wrote the road map and this is a book
about what happens after the war ends
and they come back and try to be
integrated with society and the
difficulties the trials and tribulations
that the veterans go through to give you
just one example there’s a dinner party
and one of these veterans in the front
is there the family is assembled they
bring in the main course such as pork
chops and he goes into a little rubber
ad he forgets where he is and
he thinks he’s back at the front again
he grabs the pork chops puts his arms on
the table starts chewing away and just
loses himself in the memories and
suddenly he snaps back and he realizes
that these people have all stopped
around him and they’re kind of
snickering and laughing at him and he
realizes that there’s as he distracted a
stone wall in between his experience and
the civilian experience now there are
students about these veterans returning
from the first world war that showed
that those that stuck together
particularly in the German army
there were units they came from
particular regions and so they had time
coming back from the war to spend time
with each other for over several weeks
to discuss what had happened to them
it’s kind of a decompress but there were
other units that just dispelled at the
front and they came back individually
and this is similar to say during the
Vietnam War era where people would just
end their term of service and then come
right back now the ones who did not have
that dialogue and that connection with
other veterans were more alienated they
tended to be more frustrated and they
joined Luke was known as the fry Corps
or as one author historian Arthur Wade
calls it the vanguard of Nazism so these
were the paramilitary groups that formed
the backbone of the Nazi movement
another entity – is Paul Fussell he
wrote two books he was a World War two
veteran and he fired on the European
campaign into Germany but he wrote a
book on the first world war and he
describes the gap or the the lack of
connection that many veterans had in
describing their war experiences part of
this
argues looking at cases of World War one
that party describes how there’s so much
of war it’s very physical digging and
doing physical activity and when it
comes to words to describing those
activities it’s very hard to do that so
he hoppers had this one example but he
also says that people back home really
don’t want to hear it and in veterans
themselves particularly this generation
World War two generation are we’re very
sad they did not want to talk about it
in part because they wanted to shield
the people back home from hearing the
words within went through his other book
is wartime where he describes World War
two excellent but so he’s someone
definitely to look at another friend I’d
like to call him veteran I’ve learned a
lot from his Eugene sledge he was a
corporal in the marine corps in the
Pacific campaign and he has written a
memoir with the old breed and in this
memoir he describes his love for his
commanding officer the company commander
captain Hall named and he describes how
they is a
square-jawed five degree or five o’clock
shadow all the time and yet he admired
this commanding officer because he
demanded discipline and yet he did it in
a respectful compassionate way he never
yelled and he got the respect of the
troops unfortunately captain Haldane
died in the fighting but sledge in with
the old breed describes the the
connection that he had with his captain
and sledge also describes the connection
that he had
the troops in Company K his fellows in
the foxholes fighting across the Pacific
campaign he had the opportunity because
he had some college experience to go to
Oxford Kennedy School and he could have
left the fighting that Pacific done back
to the states and had a more sane
existence but he specifically chose not
to do that and to stay with his fellows
and this is why your belongings so
important to soldiers now as far as the
connection there’s often this as I’ve
described it from mark this block in
between the works great send people back
home and instead circles book the good
war he describes Peggy Henderson who was
a nurse who cared for extremely wounded
casualties and she had a friendly bill
whatever patience he was she was caring
for he is an aviator he had been
severely wounded he lost half of his
face and he was able to connect with
other severely wounded soldiers and
aviators in the club that was set aside
for them particularly shocking for Peggy
and for Bill was when she was taken from
Marx out in the streets of Pasadena this
is a very affluent area of Los Angeles
she we go out to the streets and she was
familiar with bill bill had other
friends who were similarly named but
there were finely dressed women in the
community who were horrified they would
get this stare and she describes it how
he dosent describes that how they they
were horrified they would write letters
to the editors
didn’t want to see this monstrosity this
thing as they called it they didn’t like
to see the war coming home to them in
Pasadena
another veteran who I’ve actually
physically met is a thread Tomasello he
was a Vietnam he has been a war veteran
and he’s written a memoir called
the walking wounded and I want to share
one story he relates in that memoir
after he got back from the war in
Vietnam he served what was called a
casualty casualty calls are something
that the rancor does other services
they’ll send a telegram if someone is
wounded or if there’s a death in the
fighting but the rancor sends a
representative and he was the person to
do this a chaplain would go out with him
but anytime marine was wounded her died
you have to go visit their family and he
relates this the person who trained him
relates a story that happened one time
this marine in Vietnam had triggered a
mine and it had wounded him so they went
up to the house told the family I was
obviously very upset and worried that
call was over few days later they found
out they had amputated foot so any
change of condition means they have to
go back and do another
so they went out to the house again went
through the same sort of emotional
turmoil crying the horror
engaging with his family went back he
continued to deteriorate then he lost so
they attempted his foot then they had to
amputate his arm back out to the house
it was his eye he went out five times
the last time they went out he had died
that scarring experience of interacting
with bereaved family members was
something that Thomas Sullivan could not
forget and he went through that percival
with his own casualty calls over the
next year however this is 50 years later
Fredman right now is in Vietnam he’s
just finishing this trip he went on
published back to some of those sites in
Vietnam he met some of the former
opponents here in person that North
Vietnamese Army veterans and so he was
able to reconcile with some of the
people who were shooting at him and in
fact this is a bullet that went into
Fred’s leg
he was an aerial observer so he was a
bird dog aircraft with radios he looked
down called in air attacks and artillery
against enemy positions and while he was
up in this observer aircraft ground fire
this bullet came up shot through the
plane went entered his ankle and went up
threw his hat into his knee he came back
and was operated on and then the doctors
gave him this foot so fred has been
carrying around this bullet for 50 years
on this trip yes
he just went back he went to a bridge in
Vietnam and he dropped it from the
bridge symbolizing the healing
symbolizing let him go the whore of
Vietnam it shows his ability to work
through some of these amazing encounters
and events that he lived I met Fred at a
retreat a veteran sentry that cloud I’m
Jim Thomas who is also the has helped
he’s now as a Zen monk he’s written and
kelskiy and he holds these veterans
retreats over several days he had it’s
very structured so people write their
stories and they also get together in a
talking circle now this is a Native
American tradition of coming together in
small groups about 10 people and there’s
an object in the middle of the circle
whoever has that object speaks and
others just listen so it’s a space for
dialogue or and for expressing and then
those stories are written out at the end
of the whole the tree everyone writes
but the best stories are the people who
want to then present to a whole group at
the end of it dr. lair is a nursing
professor at FAU she and I have put a
grant in to national identity manatees
to facilitate some discussion groups
with veterans in the local area veterans
their families and people
community because we’re very interested
in promoting this kind of dialogue so
it’s called dialogues and experience of
war and what I’ll tell you a little bit
about what we want to do but what some
of dr. Blair’s work involves working as
a nurse with survivors of both Pearl
Harbor and parotia and she is gathered
there accounts of these survivors and
she’s published them in a playful form
this is called what their voices raised
and the Hibakusha
just to give you one of these stories
one of that box is a ferocious victim he
like the pilot was maimed by the blast
he lost it and I faced and he was
talking with his father his father said
you should be lucky
you should think how lucky you are and
you’ve got instantly very mad he was
very frustrated with this what think
I’ve been made by this atomic bomb it
took a little while but he began to
realize oh well at least I can’t see
with my other eye and he works through
those initial feelings and felt better
about it
so the course involves there’s two
phases to it one his preparatory course
we’re going to pick some FA College of
veterans and then lead them through
discussions and studying of literature
from the first and second world war and
then later so worse than the 20th
century and there’s a lot of practical
activities involved at this and once
these this small group is trained out
then we’ll do phase two which involves
working with
so we’re going to have three different
groups from Davie Delray Beach and up
here in Jupiter and these veterans that
we’ve trained in phase one are going to
then leave the discussion sections and
part of it to us and we hope that
veterans from any living conflict are
going to be involved in that but also
found the members and people in the
community as well so that’s our goal you
know include care by letting you know
about this other resource dr. Shay is a
Veterans Administration psychiatrist and
he works with veterans group sees toxic
touch with his dialogues and facilitates
working with individual deference but he
also draws upon the Humanities tradition
and he has looked at the parallels
between the Homeric epics and then the
clientele that he works with and in the
VA he sees a lot of parallels he’s
written these two books about Achilles
in Vietnam in the Iliad and then
Odysseus in America so looking at the
Homeric epics and looking at them
through the lens of that transit so
there’s a tremendous amount of really
interesting material out there and I
encourage you to connect to people
dialogue with them in invite veterans to
connect with you and I hope that you’re able to share that so thank you
Please follow and like us: