
[Music]
I’ll tell you something about stories
you said they’re not just entertainment
and don’t be fooled they’re all we have
you see all we have to protect ourselves
from illness and death you don’t have
anything if you don’t have the stories
evil is mighty evil is mighty but not in
the shadow of our stories some would
choose to destroy the stories confuse
them forget them or simply say that they
just don’t matter if we would let that
happen if we would let that happen we
would be defenseless
Margaret was 54 years old and dying of
one of the worst metastatic breast
cancers that the dana-farber cancer
doctors in Boston had ever seen it was a
superficial tumor that was enveloping
her and she had severe pain from her
cancer and wounds on her chest I walked
into her room to help as best I could
during my training as a pain and
palliative care physician her devoted
husband sat quietly just behind her bed
I made some changes in the medications
to help her be more comfortable and I
and I came back the next day with a
medical intern who was training with me
to be sure that she was doing better as
we quietly entered the room we could see
that Margaret was much more comfortable
much closer to dying and
husband was right by her side after a
few moments I edged a little closer to
her and I softly said Margaret you’re 54
years old and she said yes I am and then
I said so Margaret you’ve lived 54 years
of stories and she said yes I have and
then I asked so Margaret of all the
stories you’ve lived what was one of the
best and she said without hesitation and
with one foot in both worlds when I met
him so I said how did you meet and she
said that I was a single mother working
at a cash register and a local grocery
store when he came through the line and
asked me out I wasn’t that interested
but he persisted and he wore me down and
eventually I said okay so then I said
what did you do and she said oh we just
went down the street to a local bar for
a drink and then I said what did you
order and she said a Guinness and as
she’s telling this story as she’s
sharing this story there is a palpable
change in the energy of the room such
that that in turn standing right next to
me
leans over and unprompted whispers in my
ear you know this is better than any
morphine we’ve given her all day so the
next thing that intern and I did was
race out of the hospital and down the
street
to find the closest liquor store we
could and find the coldest Guinness and
the nicest pint glasses and we ran back
to that hospital and up the stairs and
down the ward and into their room to
build them one last Guinness to share
together she died peacefully two days
later her husband right next to her I’ll
never forget that moment it was a moment
that began with a question about a story
and I thought to myself that was a
pretty good question
I should ask it more often I also
thought what if what if that in turn was
right
what if stories could be better than
morphine at the end of life I also
thought that I was an intern once I was
never right but what if that intern was
right
what if stories can really protect us
from illness and death what an absurd
idea but I’d love absurd ideas and I
thought that I should check it out so
what I did was that I found a group of
patients dying of cancer and I asked
them of all the stories you’ve lived
what was one of the best and I looked at
their ratings of sense of well-being as
well as sense of pain and I compared
that to another group of patients dying
of cancer where I did not engage with
their story I did not ask them of all
their stories he lived what was one of
the best and what I found was
interesting as far as well-being and
each of these lines represents one
patient during the time they were with
me you can see that ratings for the
controls the patients where we didn’t
engage in stories their sense of
well-being did not change but if you
engage with patients where you engage
with their story their sense of
well-being their ratings change
significantly
well what about pain what about pain for
the controls the same thing nothing much
happened but if you engaged the best
story of their lives and deepen that
story what we saw was that pain scores
changed significantly even what we say
is neuropathic pain neuropathic pain
very difficult from tumor invading
nerves themselves there was significant
changes and so you might ask well if
these stories could account for those
changes if those stories could account
for those changes well what were the
stories they told what what are the best
stories of dying patients and so what I
did was that I kept track and I titled
each of the stories told to me and these
are some of the examples
of what was shared title themes when we
first met cheese and crackers with
mother piano concert series in Boston
family vacations and Cape Cod wedding
day and daughter success with
schizophrenia
the day I got married stories of my five
children infant son dancing mtv-style
who’s now in Berkeley adoption of twins
after 12 years instant family singing
with children my wedding day
snowmobiling in Canada made the list
marrying my wife when we first met
well these stories really fall into four
categories they fall in two categories
of activities they fall in two
categories of family spouse spouse and
activities but for the most part all of
these stories are about one thing in
general they’re about one thing they’re
really about reaching through sacred
space to find the magic of connection
with those we love when not much more
matters when not much more matters
that’s what matters most that space that
sacred space between
a while back I assured some sacred space
with a stoic Irishman with a great sense
of humor and his family in exam room 14
of her Cancer Centre mr. Udall we get
met when he was in the hospital weeks
before with severe pain from his
pancreatic stage for cancer
mr. O’Donnell and I we had a deal I
would help him with his pain and he
would help me perfect my Irish accent
thankfully his pain got better quite
quickly
sadly my Irish accent he didn’t but he
turned to me and he said in the only way
that an Irishman could he said you know
lad you gave it your best try and that’s
the most important thing
he’d be happy to hear that mr. O’Donnell
was much weaker now and time was getting
short he was reflective of his life and
the love of his family
we now talked about how hospice could be
of great benefit to him and his family
as well the mood was somber but at
clarity in the moment for mr. O’Donnell
he even hummed a little Irish tune from
his childhood and his eyes brightened a
bit at the end I waited a moment or two
and then I turned to him and the best
Irish that I could muster and I said and
so mr. O’Donnell would you be so kind
and willingness to share with us a wee
bit of a song and he looked at me and he
looked at his family smiled took a
breath and began to say Oh Danny Boy the
pipes the pipes are calling from Glen to
Glen
and I’m sorry I have to stop for a
minute I have to tell you a secret I’m
not a very good singer
just ask my 10 year old daughter and my
7 year old son you know the ones with
the rolling eyes dad are you singing but
they also teach me what they learn in
school important lessons and they’ve
said to me dad if you ever need some
help or what you have to do is ask
so perhaps perhaps we all could give it
our best try together because that’s the
most important thing and we might just
conjure up a wee bit of magic such as
would bring a smile to the face of a
stoic Irishman and honour and memory of
his story are you all with me and this
is your moment this is your moment let’s
just find a note together
ooh Danny Boy the pipes the pipes are
calling from when Duke went down the
mountainside
[Music]
and the summer is gone and all the Roses
falling it’s you it’s you
must go and I must buy
but come ye back when summers in the man
[Music]
or when the valleys hushed and white
with snow and I’ll be
in sunshine Horace child
Oh Oh Danny Boy Oh Danny Boy I love you
so
[Music]
[Applause]
as he finished as he finished his voice
hung in the air and echoed throughout
the examination room as tears streamed
down the faces of all present and
spilled over into the cancer center
itself nurses and staff paused in the
midst of his singing mr. O’Donnell got
up slowly came over to me reached out
his hand and shook mine hard and long
and then let go he said goodbye
turned and left with his family hard to
find words for moments like that
I believe those moments like the ones
with mr. O’Donnell and Margaret lie
beyond the constructs of medicine and
healthcare it’s really about how we
choose to approach life there are
windows available to us to open if we
pay attention to our shared humanity and
the secret spaces between one another
perhaps we could even consider it the
creative space of performance art that
we have the opportunity to engage with
each other each day on the grand stage
of what matters most encounters that
always contain elements of the unknown
opportunities to shape-shift experience
and creative process that finds its own
way in the midst of life’s mystery and
in the magic of our stories I will tell
you something about stories he said
they’re not just entertainment and don’t
be fooled
[Applause]
I’ll tell you something about stories
you said they’re not just entertainment
and don’t be fooled they’re all we have
you see all we have to protect ourselves
from illness and death you don’t have
anything if you don’t have the stories
evil is mighty evil is mighty but not in
the shadow of our stories some would
choose to destroy the stories confuse
them forget them or simply say that they
just don’t matter if we would let that
happen if we would let that happen we
would be defenseless
Margaret was 54 years old and dying of
one of the worst metastatic breast
cancers that the dana-farber cancer
doctors in Boston had ever seen it was a
superficial tumor that was enveloping
her and she had severe pain from her
cancer and wounds on her chest I walked
into her room to help as best I could
during my training as a pain and
palliative care physician her devoted
husband sat quietly just behind her bed
I made some changes in the medications
to help her be more comfortable and I
and I came back the next day with a
medical intern who was training with me
to be sure that she was doing better as
we quietly entered the room we could see
that Margaret was much more comfortable
much closer to dying and
husband was right by her side after a
few moments I edged a little closer to
her and I softly said Margaret you’re 54
years old and she said yes I am and then
I said so Margaret you’ve lived 54 years
of stories and she said yes I have and
then I asked so Margaret of all the
stories you’ve lived what was one of the
best and she said without hesitation and
with one foot in both worlds when I met
him so I said how did you meet and she
said that I was a single mother working
at a cash register and a local grocery
store when he came through the line and
asked me out I wasn’t that interested
but he persisted and he wore me down and
eventually I said okay so then I said
what did you do and she said oh we just
went down the street to a local bar for
a drink and then I said what did you
order and she said a Guinness and as
she’s telling this story as she’s
sharing this story there is a palpable
change in the energy of the room such
that that in turn standing right next to
me
leans over and unprompted whispers in my
ear you know this is better than any
morphine we’ve given her all day so the
next thing that intern and I did was
race out of the hospital and down the
street
to find the closest liquor store we
could and find the coldest Guinness and
the nicest pint glasses and we ran back
to that hospital and up the stairs and
down the ward and into their room to
build them one last Guinness to share
together she died peacefully two days
later her husband right next to her I’ll
never forget that moment it was a moment
that began with a question about a story
and I thought to myself that was a
pretty good question
I should ask it more often I also
thought what if what if that in turn was
right
what if stories could be better than
morphine at the end of life I also
thought that I was an intern once I was
never right but what if that intern was
right
what if stories can really protect us
from illness and death what an absurd
idea but I’d love absurd ideas and I
thought that I should check it out so
what I did was that I found a group of
patients dying of cancer and I asked
them of all the stories you’ve lived
what was one of the best and I looked at
their ratings of sense of well-being as
well as sense of pain and I compared
that to another group of patients dying
of cancer where I did not engage with
their story I did not ask them of all
their stories he lived what was one of
the best and what I found was
interesting as far as well-being and
each of these lines represents one
patient during the time they were with
me you can see that ratings for the
controls the patients where we didn’t
engage in stories their sense of
well-being did not change but if you
engage with patients where you engage
with their story their sense of
well-being their ratings change
significantly
well what about pain what about pain for
the controls the same thing nothing much
happened but if you engaged the best
story of their lives and deepen that
story what we saw was that pain scores
changed significantly even what we say
is neuropathic pain neuropathic pain
very difficult from tumor invading
nerves themselves there was significant
changes and so you might ask well if
these stories could account for those
changes if those stories could account
for those changes well what were the
stories they told what what are the best
stories of dying patients and so what I
did was that I kept track and I titled
each of the stories told to me and these
are some of the examples
of what was shared title themes when we
first met cheese and crackers with
mother piano concert series in Boston
family vacations and Cape Cod wedding
day and daughter success with
schizophrenia
the day I got married stories of my five
children infant son dancing mtv-style
who’s now in Berkeley adoption of twins
after 12 years instant family singing
with children my wedding day
snowmobiling in Canada made the list
marrying my wife when we first met
well these stories really fall into four
categories they fall in two categories
of activities they fall in two
categories of family spouse spouse and
activities but for the most part all of
these stories are about one thing in
general they’re about one thing they’re
really about reaching through sacred
space to find the magic of connection
with those we love when not much more
matters when not much more matters
that’s what matters most that space that
sacred space between
a while back I assured some sacred space
with a stoic Irishman with a great sense
of humor and his family in exam room 14
of her Cancer Centre mr. Udall we get
met when he was in the hospital weeks
before with severe pain from his
pancreatic stage for cancer
mr. O’Donnell and I we had a deal I
would help him with his pain and he
would help me perfect my Irish accent
thankfully his pain got better quite
quickly
sadly my Irish accent he didn’t but he
turned to me and he said in the only way
that an Irishman could he said you know
lad you gave it your best try and that’s
the most important thing
he’d be happy to hear that mr. O’Donnell
was much weaker now and time was getting
short he was reflective of his life and
the love of his family
we now talked about how hospice could be
of great benefit to him and his family
as well the mood was somber but at
clarity in the moment for mr. O’Donnell
he even hummed a little Irish tune from
his childhood and his eyes brightened a
bit at the end I waited a moment or two
and then I turned to him and the best
Irish that I could muster and I said and
so mr. O’Donnell would you be so kind
and willingness to share with us a wee
bit of a song and he looked at me and he
looked at his family smiled took a
breath and began to say Oh Danny Boy the
pipes the pipes are calling from Glen to
Glen
and I’m sorry I have to stop for a
minute I have to tell you a secret I’m
not a very good singer
just ask my 10 year old daughter and my
7 year old son you know the ones with
the rolling eyes dad are you singing but
they also teach me what they learn in
school important lessons and they’ve
said to me dad if you ever need some
help or what you have to do is ask
so perhaps perhaps we all could give it
our best try together because that’s the
most important thing and we might just
conjure up a wee bit of magic such as
would bring a smile to the face of a
stoic Irishman and honour and memory of
his story are you all with me and this
is your moment this is your moment let’s
just find a note together
ooh Danny Boy the pipes the pipes are
calling from when Duke went down the
mountainside
[Music]
and the summer is gone and all the Roses
falling it’s you it’s you
must go and I must buy
but come ye back when summers in the man
[Music]
or when the valleys hushed and white
with snow and I’ll be
in sunshine Horace child
Oh Oh Danny Boy Oh Danny Boy I love you
so
[Music]
[Applause]
as he finished as he finished his voice
hung in the air and echoed throughout
the examination room as tears streamed
down the faces of all present and
spilled over into the cancer center
itself nurses and staff paused in the
midst of his singing mr. O’Donnell got
up slowly came over to me reached out
his hand and shook mine hard and long
and then let go he said goodbye
turned and left with his family hard to
find words for moments like that
I believe those moments like the ones
with mr. O’Donnell and Margaret lie
beyond the constructs of medicine and
healthcare it’s really about how we
choose to approach life there are
windows available to us to open if we
pay attention to our shared humanity and
the secret spaces between one another
perhaps we could even consider it the
creative space of performance art that
we have the opportunity to engage with
each other each day on the grand stage
of what matters most encounters that
always contain elements of the unknown
opportunities to shape-shift experience
and creative process that finds its own
way in the midst of life’s mystery and
in the magic of our stories I will tell
you something about stories he said
they’re not just entertainment and don’t
be fooled
[Applause]
Please follow and like us: