
pharmaceutical company Merck announced
that they were stopping the phase 3
clinical trials of a new drug targeting
Alzheimer’s disease the trials were
stopped because the drug did not seem to
have any positive effect it did not help
against the disease and it’s far from
the first time this has happened in the
in the last 14 years no new major drugs
have been approved for the treatment of
Alzheimer’s lack of a cure is not by
lack of research efforts but really the
first time I read a medical research
paper in detail
I realized two things about experimental
medical research now this was a paper
studying brain activity during sleep and
they were studying sleeping mice in
particular and the main author of this
study had spent two years of her life
teaching mice to fall asleep under a
microscope
just imagine that two years teaching
mice for one study but until then I
don’t think I’d realized how practically
difficult experimental medical research
can be now the second thing I realized
was a bit more let’s say sinister now
these types of papers sometimes state
that the mice were sacrificed after so
in so many hours after so in so many
minutes and it dawned on me then that
medical research can be ethically
difficult and I understood how it can be
today that there are even fundamental
things that we do not know about the
mouse brain and much more so about the
human brain this complexity of
traditional experimental and clinical
approaches to medical research just begs
the question could there be a different
way to gain medical insight could there
be an approach that could transcend
these practical and ethical limitations
and it really was well then now you
imagine that you’re in this situation
where you have something something
precious think of a crystal vas a really
expensive crystal vas and you need to
experiment a bit on this but you’re
terrified
oh it’s shattering into a million pieces
what do you do well one thing you can do
is to make a dummy or a model a model is
a representation of a person or a thing
or a phenomenon the model may not have
all the features of the original it may
not be as detailed it may not be as
elaborate it may not be as perfect but
the model must capture the essence of
the original the key features that make
the original what it is mobiles are in
use everywhere for instance the car
industry they’ve been using crash-test
dummies since the 1950s because the
beauty of having a model you see is that
once you have it you can practice on it
you can experiment on it with a crash
test dummy they can test the effects of
a car crash without it even happening
and if it’s a good model and the sense
that the model captures enough features
of the original then what happens in the
model will also happen in reality
a crash test dummy without a head or a
neck would probably not be such a good
model for testing whiplash injuries but
it might be a good model even if it
lacks hear or eyelashes or forgot to put
on makeup that in the context of
medicine in the context of human health
and disease that’s something precious
that we ideally would want to experiment
on but can’t afford to break is the
human body and what I want to make model
of what I want to model is how the body
functions when healthy and how it
dysfunctions in the case of disease or
even more precisely I want to make a
mathematical model of a physiological
process
of an action of something that happens
inside your body one example could be
the single beat of a heart which is
driven by tiny electrical sparks
spreaded throughout it or in that
medical study I referred to earlier
where they injected dye into I was
studying sleeping animal eating mice
they very carefully inject dye into the
brains of those sleeping mice in order
to see how it would spread so that would
be an example of another physiological
process the spreading of dye or more
generally the spreading of oxygen or
protein fragments in brain tissue and
this is an interesting interesting
physiological process because we know
that in diseases like Alzheimer’s
protein fragments tend not to spread
nicely but rather lump together and
create havoc mathematical models are not
physical models like a crash-test dummy
mathematical models are abstract models
posed as equations an equation is
relation between something that’s known
as something now it’s not an unknown
when I solve the equation I compute the
unknown from the known information using
a fixed set of rules and operations that
everyone agrees on when creating a
mathematical model of a physiological
process the known bits are the things
that are possible to observe and to
measure
well the unknowns are the things that
work cannot so what are things that are
about relatively easy to measure well
anything exterior on your outside of
your body is pretty easy to access and
generally shapes and sizes even the
shape of your heart and the shape of
your brain can be mapped using medical
imaging what the unknowns are typically
depend on the process if one is modeling
the heart the unknown could be the
electrical signal which is present in
every cell in your heart during every
heartbeat or when modeling the spread of
dye in brain
issue the unknown could be the movement
of water in and around the brain cells
the water will carry the dye but it’s
actually impossible to measure the
movement of water itself this leaves us
with one missing piece the link between
the knowns and the unknowns
unfortunately this is where the basic
laws of physics come to our rescue these
are the laws the state that entity does
not appear out of nowhere that matter
does not vanish in thin air and that
movement does that start or stop without
a fool’s mathematics then provides us
with the language to express these laws
in the form of equations so that is what
a mathematical model is it’s an abstract
representation of a process or a
phenomenon which couples nature is
governing laws on the one hand with
known information on the other this is a
mathematical model of dye spreading in
brain tissue it’s called the diffusion
there’s just seven simple symbols there
but those seven simple symbols can
represent this incredibly complex
physiological process this is a computer
simulation of the same mathematical
model which you can think of as a
realization of the model or as the
output from the model with given
much in the same way as crash test
dummies allow us the experiment with
different car crash scenarios
mathematical models allow us to
experiment with and make predictions for
changing conditions for instance this
mathematical model would allow us to
experiment with different brain
scenarios by changing properties of the
tissue on the brain within the model we
can ask and answer what if type
questions what if the brain is not an
average brain but the younger brain the
brain of a child what if it’s an older
brain what if it’s an older brain with
Alzheimer’s symptoms but much unlike
crash test dummies mathematical models
have no physical limitations so this
means that we can create an experiment
with scenarios that are not even
possible to create in real life and in
contrast to crash test dummies which may
cost hundreds of thousands of US dollars
and in contrast to clinical trials which
may cost tens of millions of US dollars
this mathematical model is free it’s
available to all and the only cost to
realize it is the cost of the computer
power needed let’s look at the different
mathematical models so this is a model
of the electrical signal propagating
through your heart roughly every second
every day every year of your life and in
a study published last year researchers
from Johns Hopkins University combined
computer simulations of precisely this
model with medical images of individual
patients hearts and their results showed
that the model could predict each
individual patients risk of future heart
rhythm disturbances better than any
existing clinical metric so perhaps in
the next 14 years this mathematical
approach will give us new therapies for
so to me the appeal of mathematics is
not in number magic or tricky puzzles in
the newspaper to me the real beauty of
mathematics is how it provides us with
this simple language but with endless
possibilities for describing for
understanding and for improving the
world around us and the world within us thank you